Is this offer too good to refuse?

Question:
I turned down an attractive offer from a company a few months back. They're desperate for more IT people and tried to sweeten the offer by matching my option equity at my current company (the numbers of shares and strike price) in order to get me sooner, which amounts to about five times my salary, in addition to salary, bonus, and equity in the new company. My first response was to say, "Hurray! My ship has come in!"

But I'm concerned that down the road I may be viewed differently�for example, during the review process�and that the execs might question what I have done to justify this compensation.

It's a great position, working on new technology at a company I respect highly and working for a person I've known for years. The company is near my wife's family, and she would really like that. My current company is also fine, and it affords plenty of opportunities to grow into different fields that interest me.

Any advice on how to decide whether this is a real concern? If I were an executive, it might be a different story, but I'm a good software developer who happens to be at the right place at the right time.

Reply:
I would talk to the person you'd be working for. Lay out your concerns openly and honestly, and ask for his or her opinion and advice.

There's a chance the big package will create a whiplash later, but bear in mind that what the company spends to get you is up to the company. They feel you're worth it. If they're giving you cash for the options, it's a one-time payment/expense, not part of your salary (thus not a recurring cost).

If they're substituting options or stock in their company for your old options, to some degree or another that's speculative: You may never see the full value of the paper, so it's a risk for you, too. They're not paying you five times your old salary; that would be another story. You may find that the stock and/or options are worthless in three years. Then who's left holding the bag?

I think your best bet is to talk with your future boss. You might even ask to talk with someone higher up, to address the very question you're asking. Some might say you're looking a gift horse in the mouth, but I think it's a legitimate, honest concern and it ought to be discussed.

By the way, congrats on the fine offer!

Best,
Nick Corcodilos
Ask The Headhunter

Nick Corcodilos is a nationally recognized headhunter, speaker, and authority on job hunting, hiring, and career success. Nick started headhunting in 1979 in Silicon Valley and has been featured in The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, Fast Company, and on CNNfn, CNBC, and MSNBC. Check out his book, Ask The Headhunter: Reinventing the Interview to Win the Job (Penguin/Plume, 1997).

The Croc's got teeth
Each week, Nick Corcodilos shares his iconoclastic perspective on job hunting in The Crocodile�, his column on TechRepublic.com. This week, Nick says call before an interview to make sure the manager has read your resume

att-2   att-4

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1