| Boise | Minnesota | Mercury | Sacramento | Bedford | Iowa | |
| SKYHAWKS | MUSKIES | COMETS | GOLD SOX | BLUES | EASY RIDERS | |
| Chris Howell | Tom Fish | Joe Brown | J.G. Preston | Reg Awalt | Wayne Anderson | |
| 1 | Willie Mays | Sandy Koufax | Harmon Killebrew | Tony Oliva | Juan Marichal | Richie Allen |
| 2 | Chris Short | Gary Peters | Don Drysdale | Jim Bunning | Joe Horlen | Bob Gibson |
| 3 | Johnny Callison | Jim Ray Hart | Lou Brock | Willie McCovey | Orlando Cepeda | Willie Davis |
| 4 | Juan Pizarro | Tony Gonzalez | Rocky Colavito | Jim Kaat | Curt Flood | Gaylord Perry |
| 5 | Hoyt Wilhelm | Bob Allison | Bill White | Mike Cuellar | Ron Hansen | Matty Alou |
| 6 | Tommy Davis | Floyd Robinson | Bert Campaneris | Frank Howard | Ron Perranoski | Jim Perry |
| 7 | Curt Simmons | Johnny Roseboro | Tony Taylor | Tim McCarver | Ken Boyer | Tom Haller |
| 8 | Pete Ward | Camilo Pascual | Earl Battey | Don Buford | Clay Dalrymple | Maury Wills |
| 9 | Wayne Causey | Dick Groat | Rich Rollins | Dave Boswell | Julian Javier | Dick Green |
| 10 | Hal Lanier | Mudcat Grant | Ray Sadecki | Moe Drabowsky | Bobby Bolin | Don Mincher |
| 11 | Jimmie Hall | Mike Hershberger | Rick Wise | Cookie Rojas | John Buzhardt | Ron Fairly |
| 12 | Roger Craig | Jim Gentile | Ruben Amaro | Phil Ortega | Jesus Alou | Mike Shannon |
| 13 | Bobby Wine | Bob Miller | Ray Washburn | Al Worthington | Frank Thomas | Jim Brewer |
| 14 | Wes Stock | Ron Herbel | Alex Johnson | Zoilo Versalles | Pete Richert | Eddie Fisher |
| 15 | Barney Schultz | Ed Roebuck | Dennis Bennett | Bruce Howard | Bob Humphreys | Bob Hendley |
| 16 | Bill Skowron | Bobby Shantz | John O'Donoghue | Jim Davenport | Wes Covington | Dave Nicholson |
| 17 | Jack Sanford | Al Weis | Howie Reed | Nelson Mathews | Dick Stigman | Jose Santiago |
| 18 | Gus Triandos | Johnny Klippstein | Jack Baldschun | Wes Parker | John Wyatt | Johnny Briggs |
| 19 | Billy Bryan | Dick Tracewski | Jose Pagan | Ron Taylor | Del Crandall | Billy O'Dell |
| 20 | Billy Pierce | Jerry McNertney | Bob Shaw | Diego Segui | Jim Roland | Ken McMullen |
| 21 | Ed Charles | Harvey Kuenn | J.C. Martin | John Herrnstein | Tommy McCraw | Ken Sanders |
| 22 | Gordie Richardson | Ken Berry | Don Mossi | Bernie Allen | Danny Cater | Larry Miller |
| 23 | Orlando Pena | Ted Bowsfield | Gene Stephens | Bob Uecker | Jim Duffalo | Nate Oliver |
| 24 | Cam Carreon | Fred Talbot | Bill Pleis | Gerry Arrigo | Joe Grzenda | Derrell Griffith |
| 25 | Jerry Zimmerman | Johnny Lewis | Ray Culp | Jim Landis | Tommie Reynolds | Bob Meyer |
| 26 | Dick Estelle | Vic Power | Ken Harrelson | Joe Moeller | Chuck Hiller | Frank Kreutzer |
| 27 | Larry Stahl | Ray Herbert | John Boozer | Frank Kostro | Nick Willhite | Art Mahaffey |
| 28 | Carl Warwick | George Alusik | Duke Snider | Jose Tartabull | Jerry Kindall | Bob Skinner |
| 29 | Bobby Locke | Manny Jimenez | Dave Duncan | Doug Camilli | Bart Shirley | Charlie James |
| 30 | Jim Snyder | Johnny Goryl | Glen Hobbie | Roy Sievers | Phil Gagliano | Doc Edwards |
| 31 | Minnie Minoso | Ron Henry | Jim Gilliam | Jay Ward | Smoky Burgess | Jerry Buchek |
| 32 | Bill Bethea | Cap Peterson | Rick Joseph | Dallas Green | Wally Moon | Frank Baumann |