WR2 Problem Solving:  Domain Specific vs. Content Specific
Assessment and Accommodation

 

Objective -  By the end of the lesson given instructions and Web sites, scholars will:

·         Access and read the 12 theories described in "About Learning" from Funderstanding.com (follow all links)

·         Access and explore "The Personality Page" at ChartPlanet.com (follow all links)

·         Take the "Keirsey Temperament Sorter" test provided by Keirsey.com

·         Draw conclusions about the theories described as they apply to adult vocational courses

·         Discuss how the articles apply to the class you teach

·         Discuss how your class could be improved by these concepts

·         Write and submit a report in memo format to the class-at-large via e-mail by the due date syllabus


Assignment Description

Theories on how adults learn abound.  Some support content specific learning.  For example Problem-Based Learning (PBL) suggests that critical thinking can be taught using real life scenarios or situations.  Others support domain specific learning.  For example Bloom's taxonomy theorist suggest that problem-solving is based on a domain preference, i.e. an information processing [cognitive domain (thinking)], perceptual [psychomotor domain (trial and error)], or personality [affective domain (emotion, what feels right)] approach. 

The plethora of theories have given rise to many evaluation tools for identify a learners problem-solving preference and/or method of information processing.  Two of these have been provided for you to take and discuss.  Many more can be found on-line, in books, or through professional services.  Some are available at a fee while others are free.  Please take the two that have been provided as you will be asked to reference the results in your report. 

I have used the Kiersey Temperament Sorter for my students and most have reported a better understanding of themselves and their approach to problem-solving and communication strategies.  Although I have used others, the Kiersey has yielded consistent results when repeated at different life stages while others yield different results based on the stage of life or current state of tester.  Does this mean that some tests are more valid than others or does it indicate out preferences change over time.  Perhaps it means that preferences situational-based.  It is left to you to draw your own conclusions from these readings and activities.

Access and read the 12 theories described in "About Learning" from Funderstanding.com and the Myers-Briggs approach exemplified by the Keirsey Temperament Sorter at "The Personality Page" at ChartPlanet.com.  Be sure to follow all links to ensure addressing the material comprehensively.  Take the Keirsey Temperament Sorter self-evaluation.  Then write a report following the memo format described in the first assignment.  The report will be e-mailed to the class-at-large using the "Send mail" feature in NiceNet.  Reports should include all the following elements.

Drawing upon your experience as both an educator and a student, draw conclusions about how the various theories apply to teaching adult learners in vocational education.  Discuss the merits and demerits of these theories from a pragmatic point of view.  For example, how practical is the implementation in real-time classrooms?  Are some theories more effective than others? Which are best and describe why?  Be specific and support your conclusion with examples from your classroom or personal experience.

Next, which, if any, of these concepts are in practice in your classrooms in total or in part.  Be specific and site examples.  Do not use vague references.  Always avoid names and identifying information to preserve your students' privacy but explain the details of the example you are using.

Finally, discuss whether or not your class could be improved by implementing additional concepts from these articles.  Site the article and specific theory.  Explain how you would apply the concept and the expected outcome.  Reference your Keirsey Temperament Sorter results to support your conclusions.

 

Grading Criteria

This assignment is worth 10% of your grade. 

Reports meeting the following criteria will receive an "A." 

·         Take the "Keirsey Temperament Sorter" test provided by Keirsey.com (2 point)

·         Draw conclusions about the theories described as they apply to adult vocational courses (2 points)

·         Discuss how the articles apply to the class you teach (2 points)

·         Discuss how your class could be improved by these concepts (2 points)

·         Write and submit a report in memo format to the class-at-large via e-mail by the due date (2 point)

Extra Credit

Read the article on Problem-Based Learning (PBL) learning and reference it in your report along with the mandatory theories listed above.  (2 points)

 

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1