Adams/McCutchen - Bair/Mehrer Genealogy

as presented by Michelle Adams


Taliaferro Craig Family History

First it must be said that there are several different versions of the origins of Taliaferro  Craig. I have listed the different stories below.

A Brief Overview of Taliaferro Craig
Taliaferro was born most likely in 1705 in Spotsylvania County, Virginia. His name is often spelt Toliver, which apparently is the phonetic way of saying his name. Taliaferro (meaning cut with iron) seems to be an Italian surname from long ago. Originally Normans, who were Scandinavians who settled in Northern Gaul then Italy. There were some Taliaferros who left Italy and settled in Scotland. It is believed that this Taliaferro Craig line is Scottish.

This is a list of events in his life. I have copied these from books about Craig and Hawkins families. I do not claim to have looked at any official court records.

1730 resided in Botetourt County, VA
1730 He married Mary Hawkins in Spotsylvania Co, VA
1747 April 17 They sold 200 acres of land in St George Parish, Spotsylvania Co, VA that Mary inherited from her father John Hawkins to her brother Joseph Hawkins.
1760 June 2
Spotsylvania Co, VA they gave 276 acres to son Lewis and 87 acres to son John
1781 June 30 They sold 500 acres for 20,000 Pounds in Berkeley Parrish, Spotsylvania County, Virginia to William Wiatt
1781 September, they moved from Orange Co, V
A to Woodford Co, KY (most likely this should be Fayette Co, KY which later Woodford Co was formed from). They came with the Traveling Church.
1782 August 15 They were in Fayette Co, KY at a fort called Bryant's Station when it was attached by Indians. (
See Bryan's Station - Its Heroes and Heroines. Toliver and Mary Craig were the oldest defenders of Bryan's Station.)
1795 He died in Woodford Co, KY. Will filed in Woodford Co, KY.

Taliaferro's wife is Mary "Polly" Hawkins (19 Sep 1716 - 6 Jan 1804). She was buried at the Great Crossing Church, near Georgetown, KY. Her tomb is marked "The Mother of Many Faithful." (Hawkins of Virginia, The Carolinas, and Kentucky pg42) Some reports say that Taliaferro is buried there as well but this is not commonly written. Also, I have seen reports that this cemetery has been paved over for a parking lot. Her parents are John Hawkins and Mary unknown. There is a whole other debate over which specific John and Mary Hawkins this is. As of now, I haven't made a specific decision on this and choose not to publish what is most commonly found on the internet.

Taliaferro and Mary had eleven children.

  1. John Craig m. Sally Page. He was the first representative sent by Kentucky to the Virginia Assembly. Was in command of the garrison at Bryan's Station when it was attacked by the Indians under Girty in August, 1782.
  2. Lewis Craig, b ca 1737, d 1828, Bracken Co, KY, m. Elizabeth Sanders. Lewis, born in Orange County, Virginia  was the pastor of a Baptist Church in Spotsylvania County, Virginia. This church, known as The Traveling Church, moved in the Fall of 1781 to Kentucky. He died in Bracken County, aged eighty-seven; his wife was Elizabeth Sanders; their daughter, Mary, married General Philemon Thomas, her cousin.
  3. Toliver Craig Jr, m. Elizabeth Johnson. He came to Kentucky with the "Traveling Church," and was of the garrison of Bryan's Station when it was besieged.
  4. Elijah Craig, b. ca 1743, m. Frances Smith. Frances probably a cousin, daughter of George Smith and Elizabeth Hawkins. Elijah was a celebrated Baptist preacher. He moved from Virginia to Scott County, Kentucky, in 1786, where he laid out the town of Georgetown, named after George Washington; he was zealous and enterprising in business as well as in preaching; established the first fulling and paper mills in Kentucky, and also the first schools in which the classics were taught.
  5. Jane Craig m. John Sanders. Jane was the grandmother of George N. Sanders, a noted politician during the Presidency of James Buchanan.
  6. Benjamin Craig m. Nancy Sturman. Benjamin, born in Culpeper County, Virginia, March 30, 1751. Among his descendants are A. G. Craig, Vevay, Ind., and George C. and Edward Eggleston, well-known writers of essays and some books.
  7. Jeremiah Craig m. Lucy Hawkins, his cousin, dau. of Philemon and Sarah (Smith) Hawkins. Lucy was one of the noted women at the defense of Bryan's Station (Jeremiah was also of the garrison); also her four children, Elijah, Polly, Franky, and Hawkins.
  8. Elizabeth Hawkins m. Richard Cave, a Baptist minister who died in Woodford Co, KY. 
  9. Joseph Craig b 1742, d 1819, m. Sally Wisdom. He was an eccentric man and was a preacher for the Separatist Baptist Church.
  10. Sally Craig m. Manoah Singleton.
  11. Joyce Craig m. JOHN FOULCONER.(Faulkner)

According to Winchell McKendree in The Craig Family, all the children where born and reared in Virginia. Most, if not all, married in Virginia. Some of them moved to Kentucky with their parents and others followed later. The families settled in Fayette County, Kentucky which later split so that the Craig families can be found in Fayette, Woodford, Scott, and Jassamine counties.

Bryan's Station (also known as Bryant's Station)
See
Bryant’s Station Notes written by the Filson Club of Louisville, KY. I found a copy on HeritageQuestOnline. This is a compilation of sources.

There was a fort of about 40 homes built in Lexington, Kentucky on the road to Paris, KY by a Bryan or Bryant. Many people moved in and out of the fort due to the Indian attaches. There was one particularly long siege by the Indians from May 15 to August 18, in 1782 (Bryant's Station Notes states it started Aug 17) that made its mark in history.

The Indians had surrounded the fort. As the story goes, there was no water source inside the fort. It was decided that for anyone to survive inside they needed water and that the women and children would be sent out of the fort to a creek to collect water. They believed the Indians would not show themselves by attacking the women and children. This was the case. A memorial was erected near the site by the DAR. John P. Morton & Co., Louisville, Ky. published a memorial proceedings of Bryan's Station in honor of the defenders of the Station. The names of those in the fort are stated, among them Toliver Craig and his wife, Polly Hawkins (who had arrived in Kentucky with "The Traveling Church" in the previous mid-winter, after enduring great hardships); also Toliver Craig, Jr., and many others of Craig and Hawkins connections.

Who was Taliaferro Craig's parents?

First Story (this is the most repeated)
Basically, there where these two Taliaferro brothers. One brother was named Robert. Other brother has un
known first name but is always referred to as Capt. Taliaferro or Capt Toliver. Some accounts have them as being Italian and some as being Scottish. This Capt Toliver was a ship captain traveling between Virginia and Scotland. 

On one of Capt Toliver's trips, he brought a woman to Virginia. Some people just have her last name of Craig and other say her name is Jane Craig. As the story goes, Capt Toliver got Jane Craig pregnant but didn't marry her. (He probably had ladies in every port.) For some unnamed reason he just left her to raise the child. This was in 1704.

To follow the story, Jane had the baby and named him Taliaferro Craig. Much emphasis is put on the fact that he is illegitimate.

Lewis Sanders' (a grandson of Taliaferro Craig Sr) seems to be the main source of this story. "Two brothers, named Taliaferro, supposed to be Italians, came to Virginia in the beginning of the 18th Century. One of the brothers was a seafaring man, engaged in the trade from Virginia to Scotland, this brother brought over on one of his trips a young woman named Craig-- this young woman had a son by Capt. Toliver, which she named Toliver Craig. This is the head and origin of the numerous Craig family, now spread out through Kentucky and adjoining states."

A little on Robert Taliaferro who lived 112 years old. Robert Taliaferro was married twice. By his first wife he had a son, Samuel Taliaferro, and a daughter who married a Mr. Bowler. By his second wife, he had five daughters and two sons. One daughter named Nancy Taliaferro.

What is odd about this story to me is that there are many records about Robert Taliaferro and his life. His descendants can be traced today. But this "Capt. Taliaferro" brother of Robert is so elusive that no one can find his first name? He had no other children than Taliaferro Craig? And no one can seem to find his ship records? If anything, I would think that there would be many official records of a ship going to and from Virginia and Scotland.

Second Story
Three Taliaferro brothers came to Virginia from England. One died young, never having married. Second brother married a widow Craig and took her name for reasons satisfactory to himself and his elder brother, Robert Taliaferro. These two brothers were not friendly, their families having no communication with one another and when they separated they divided some family jewels. One ring, which they considered a valuable heirloom, each wanted. They decided the dispute by cutting the ring, making two complete circles, each taking one.

In Historical Sketches of the Campbell, Pilcher and Kindred Families on page 394, it states: Robert's [Taliaferro] brother, who, tradition says, took the name of Craig, was lost sight of by Robert's descendants, and only a few members of the family knew that they were related.

This story has holes in it to me. Once again we never get the name of Robert's brother. So if he did marry a widow Craig woman, why wouldn't we know their names?

Third Story
This and the two previous stories are told by Bill Davis on Ancestry.com in 2003. Davis offers these stories as possible origins of the Taliaferro Craig line. The previous two stories I have read in other places. This is the only place I have seen this story. Taliaferro Craig's father could be Captain Richard Taliaferro who was known as "The Pirate." This Richard was a sea captain who served the Court of the Colony of Barbados. He married a Sarah Wingfield of Barbados. Richard died in 1715.

I guess if this is the right story to believe then it would explain why Taliaferro Craig's father didn't married his mother.

Forth Story (the more acceptable one to me)
Memoranda Concerning Some Branches of the Hawkins Family and Connections by John Parker Hawkins 1913; page 52-53; "THE CRAIG FAMILY: Among the descendants of my great, great grandfather, John Hawkins, King William County, Virginia, is the distinguished Craig family of Virginia and Kentucky, descended from Taliaferro Craig and Mary Hawkins (born 1716). This Taliaferro Craig (born 1710) was the son of John Craig, emigrant, who by tradition was descended from John Craig, of Edinburg, Scotland, a colleague of John Knox, minister of Holy Rood in 1562, and in 1567 proclaimed the banns of matrimony between Queen Mary of Bothwell. The name Taliaferro is pronounced as if spelled "Toliver," and is sometimes written the latter way."

The Craig Family, 1956 by Winchell McKendree Craig
The first quote from the book on page 123: Taliaferro Craig was the posthumous child of John Craig, who died in Scotland in 1704. This John Craig was the great-grandson of John Craig, 1st, who was born in 1512 and died in 1600. John Craig married Jane Taliaferro, who after the death of her husband, came to America with her brothers, Robert and William Taliaferro. They came to Virginia. John Craig died in Scotland in November, 1704, and his son, Taliaferro Craig was born in Virginia four months after the death of his father. Taliaferro Craig married Mary Hawkins in 1730. Taliaferro Craig died in Kentucky in 1795 . His wife, Mary Hawkins, died in 1804.

The second quote from the book on page 123: The father of Talliver Craig, or Taliaferro Craig, as the name is correctly spelled, was John Craig, Jr. of Scotland, who died in 1704, and who's wife was Jane Taliaferro. After his death, his widow came to America with her two brothers, Robert and John Taliaferro, where his posthumous son, Talliver, was born in Spotsylvania County, Virginia, in 1705. He married Mary Hawkins in 1730, and they were the parents of Lewis, Elijah and Joseph, the three preachers, who led the famous church in 1781. John Craig, the father of Tolliver, was either the son or grandson of John Craig, the Friar, mentioned in the "Sketch of the Parishes." (Authority: Kentucky State Historical Society Register, Vol. 19, page 119, Year 1921.)

My Conclusions
The most plausible story of Taliaferro Craig's parents is the Forth Story I offered above. John Craig married Jane Taliaferro in Scotland some time before or in 1704. Jane gets pregnant and John dies of unknown causes around November 1704. Jane's two brothers, Robert and John (or William) Taliaferro, were moving to America. Jane, recently widowed and probably having no family left, decided to go to America with her brothers. Maybe John Craig had already planned on moving to America but died abruptly. I don't know. I haven't gotten to Scotland to track him down.

It was very common for parents to name a child by taking the mother's surname and making it the child's first name. In this case Taliaferro became a first name. (I have found many examples in my family tree.)

What I find interesting is that the second quote from The Craig Family book (listed above under "Forth Story") goes on farther talking about Taliaferro Craig and it is often quoted by people who are also quoting the story I have in "First Story" above. How is it that these two parts started being quoted together when the origins of Taliaferro Craig's parents is so different?

Home


My Family Tree

Descendant View

Adams Line
Adams

Bailey
Bates

Crafton
Ellis

Hood
Landom
Morgan

McCutchen Line
Boggs
Craig
Davis
Ferguson
Kinder
McCutchen
McLaughlin/McGlocklin
Reynolds
Richmond
Robins/Robbins

Bair Line
Bair/Bear

Berry
Bice
Demaree/Demarest
Gaddis
Hall
Lawson
Logan
Monroe 
Newkirk/Neukirch

Sebring
Sipe

Mehrer Line
Bohnet

Brosz
Klain
Klukes
Mehrer


Other Information

Family Histories and Stories

Where I Get My Information


If you feel something here is in error or would like me to add someone, you may send me an email.

contact me at:

1