Articles written the first week of December 2000


BOTTLE VS. TAP: THE WATER DEBATE


November 20, 2000 (Akron Beacon Journal) �
The bottled water industry has exploded in the last 16 years. But consumer advocates warn that bottled water drinkers often have a false sense about the product they�re buying, thinking it�s cleaner or safer than tap water.

People shouldn't fool themselves into believing that just because they have spent a lot of money and pulled the water off the grocery store shelf that it's any better or purer than the stuff coming out of their tap, said Erik Olson, co-author of a study last year by the National Resources Defense Council.

The research and advocacy group concluded after a four-year study that about one-third of the 1,000 bottles of 103 brands tested contained levels of contamination that exceeded allowable limits under either state or bottled water industry standards. In some cases, the bottled water samples had more bacteria than tap water. And one-fourth of bottled water is repackaged tap water that�s been treated.

The National Resources Defense Council�s study can be found at
http://www.nrdc.org/water/drinking.

Return to Article Index
Click here to return to homepage.
Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

************************************************************************************************* OLD WATER TESTS, NEW POLLUTANTS WORRY SCIENTISTS


BIRMINGHAM, AL, November 19, 2000 (Birmingham News) � Many of the nation�s leaders in drinking water technology say it�s time for even the best water plants to get tougher.

�We�re still using the same kinds of tests we�ve used since the �60s,� said Jay Grimes, a University of Southern Mississippi professor who sits on a panel of microbiologists working to recommend new tests to the EPA. �They�re not specific. They�re not rapid. They take at least 48 hours. By then, you�ve either drunk the water or you haven�t.�

And there is not a city in the nation testing or treating for what some scientists consider the latest emerging pollutants � prescription and over-the-counter drugs including nicotine, antibiotics, pain relievers and hormones. In a recent EPA report, researchers write that they have no doubt the drugs will be found everywhere drugs are used.

In virtually every city in the nation, the coliform bacteria test is the only way to detect disease carried by human or animal waste. That test has changed little in a century. If coliform bacteria are present, the logic goes, human or animal waste probably is present.

In Milwaukee in 1993, more than 100 people died and 403,000 were sickened when cryptosporidium entered the city water supply. City officials say their water met every legal disinfection standard when the outbreak occurred. The intestinal parasite is not killed by chlorine or other conventional disinfection methods. It must be filtered out of the water.

Chlorine�s job is to kill bacteria and viruses. But it can form something else, too. When chlorine meets organic materials, it creates minute amounts of cancer-causing trihalomethanes. As dirt, leaves and other natural materials, such as nutrients, increase in the water, so do the carcinogenic byproducts.

Scientists agree there�s not a sewage or water treatment plant in the nation equipped to remove the drugs and medicines being found in American waters. More than 50 drugs in various waters lead scientists to believe that every commonly prescribed drug or over-the-counter medication could be found in US waters.

The US Geological Survey (www.usgs.gov) is looking at hundreds of water bodies. The first report is expected out late this year.

*************************************************************************************************
LISLE RESIDENTS� SUIT SAYS PLANT TAINTED WATER

LISLE, IL, November 15, 2000 (Chicago Sun-Times) � Since August, Kitty Murphy hasn�t let her three children drink the tap water in their Lisle home or go near their backyard pool. She even urges them to hurry when they take showers.

Murphy is one of about 40 Lisle residents who filed a federal lawsuit Tuesday against a nearby metal fabricating plant they allege has contaminated their drinking water with a toxic chemical.

The lawsuit contends that Lockformer Co. for more than 20 years spilled an industrial solvent called trichloroethylene, or TCE, into the ground, where it reached the aquifer that supplies neighbors� drinking water.

Recent tests turned up TCE in 13 of 17 residential wells in the area south of the 12-acre plant. Now neighbors worry that years of drinking and bathing with the water may have endangered their health.

�It�s definitely scary. We�re taking quick showers and trying to hold our breaths,� said Murphy whose family, like others in the neighborhood, now drinks only bottled water.

The chemical was routinely spilled into the ground beginning about 1968, but the company didn�t inform residents of problems even after Lockformer officials learned in 1992 that soil around the plant was contaminated with TCE. TCE consumed in high concentrations can cause liver and kidney damage, heart problems, convulsions and even death, experts say.

Special Article

********************************************************************************************
WORKERS URGED TO AVOID CONTAMINATION TALK



NORTH CANTON, OH, November 21, 2000 (Beacon Journal) � A November 17 letter signed by Mayor Daryl Revoldt and Assistant Law Director Thomas Treadon said it would be inappropriate for city officials, employees and council members to talk to reporters. The ban on public comment came after water department workers said they were visited at their homes by a television news crew that asked, �Who poisoned the Dressler Road well field?�

The question refers to year-old allegations that city employees dumped degreasers, paint thinners, cleaning solutions, and pesticides at the site in the 1980s.

In September of 1999, investigators from the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency discovered trichloroethylene (TCE) and tetrachloroethylene (PCE) in water samples taken from monitor wells at the field.

EPA (www.epa.org) reports say investigators were told that up to 20 55-gallon drums of liquid waste were disposed in the area between the monitoring wells and one of the field�s three productions wells.

Discarded substances mentioned in the EPA findings were characterized as a �substantial threat to public safety.� The chemicals were found within a few hundred feet of one of the city�s main sources of drinking water, but the production wells themselves were found to be free of contamination.

Although the investigation into the cause of the contamination continues, a civil charge is unlikely, Revoldt said.

Return to Index of Articles

Return to homepage

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

Links to other sites on the Web

Return to homepage


This page hosted by Yahoo! GeoCities Get your own Free Home Page


Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1