Instructional Interventions for: Passive Resistance
Examples of behavior
· Sleeping in class
· Refusing to work (passive, not disruptive)
· Disengaged
· “Just sits”
· Withdrawn
· Appears depressed (sad, flat affect, lethargic)
Desired alternative behavior(s)
· Actively participates in classroom activities (e.g., stays awake, asks questions, talks when appropriate, participates in small group activities)
· Completes assignments (with a minimum of __% accuracy, on time, turned in)
· Remains on task (e.g., reading or writing, working on assignment) for ____ minutes
· Resumes task within ___ seconds/minutes with no more than 1 prompt
· Use attentive body language (e.g., head up, eye contact, following along)
General instructional strategies that
might be useful in teaching the desired behavior(s)
·
Organization
skills – could be done in each class or in a homeroom or study hall; using
different colored folders for each class, assignment notebooks
·
Social skills –
use small groups, cooperative learning, lab partners, cross-age tutoring,
literature circles (each member has a role such as leader, recorder,
vocabulary, etc. and members rotate roles)
·
Students who are
reluctant to ask questions or speak out - have the students write questions on
a piece of paper and then give them a written response – be sure to compliment
the student (e.g., “Good question” or “Would you ask that question tomorrow in
the large group?”); also you might send another student with the same question
to the target student
·
Give extra credit
(1 point) for a pertinent question asked
·
Have students
develop materials for other students (cross-age or same-age)
·
Catching up –
have buddies, give the student a “snapshot” of the day/activity/lesson they
missed, call the student at home to say you missed him/her, welcome him/her
back
·
Give choices (on
homework, alternative testing options)
·
Plug into the
student’s strengths – start small and build on success
·
Have the student
help in a classroom where he/she has been successful in the past
·
Give student
responsibility you know he or she will want and that will be motivating
·
Passive breaks –
time to relax, put head down, nap (if health or sleep deprivation issue)
Instructional materials that might prove
useful in teaching the desired behavior(s)
·
Managing Passive-Aggressive
Behavior by Nicholas J. Long and Jody E. Long. Pro-Ed,
·
Forms for Helping the Socially
Fearful Child by
· Good Thinking Sopris West, 4093 Specialty Place, Longmont, CO 80504. 1-800-547-6747. www.sopriswest.com
· Changing Behavior by Changing Thinking by John Bemis. [email protected]
· Thinking Mistakes an elementary curriculum by Orv Clark and Wayne Hull, Available from CESA 6. Contact Bunny Boelter at [email protected]
·
Skillstreaming; PREPARE Curriculum. Research
Press,
·
Teaching Social Skills to
·
Esteem Builders, 2nd edition by
Dr. Michele Borba.
Jalmar Press.
·
Seals materials, English Multicolor Emotions Poster, various other materials
and games for developing self esteem.
Wellness Reproductions and Publishing,
|
|
Adult attention |
Escape/avoidance |
Power/control |
Peer affiliation |
Justice/revenge |
||||
|
Teacher: Instructional strategies to
promote desired alternative behavior And/or Instructional
strategies to reduce the target behavior [Note: when alternate behavior is incompatible
with target behavior, the same strategy may work both to promote & to
reduce] |
-
-
Build
relationship with the student -
Greet
student when he/she enters room or is in other school setting -
Have
the student “work” in a school job (library, with computers) -
Review
expectations with student -
Student
has input on appropriate expectations -
Token
economy -
Use
lots of little “hooks” – ways for students to get involved & get
attention -
See note at left |
-
-
Set
clear expectations -
Social
skill instruction on group participation, asking questions -
Work
on improving academic skill deficits -
Set
realistic expectations, meet the student where he/she is “at” -
When
student works for “x” amount of time, he/she earns that amount of free time -
Review
expectations with student -
Student
has input -
Token
economy for participation -
Break
time -
Give
students choices
|
-
Set
clear expectations -
Give
the student choices when possible (example:
use extra credit points on test scores or on daily work; options for
homework) -
Make
the student a leader -
Give
the student some responsibility or a “job” at school -
Flexible
schedule (e.g., do math first or spelling first) -
Set
goals with student -
Student(s)
brainstorm, have input on appropriate expectations -
When
student works for “x” amount of time, he/she earns that amount of free time
|
-
Use
small group counseling or interest groups -
Cue
other students to engage the target student -
Give
the target student opportunities to be the leader, to do classroom or school
“jobs” -
Encourage
peers to compliment each other -
Use
peer modeling
|
-
Acknowledge
that emotions are okay; actions are the problem (e.g., it’s okay to be angry
– how can you better express that) -
Peer
mediation -
Third
party meet with teacher and student to try to work it out -
Counseling
to address issues and redirect anger away from teacher
|
||||
|
Student: Instructional consequences for
alternative appropriate behavior And/or Instructional
consequences for inappropriate target behavior |
-
Praise
for effort -
Special
reward or recognition for engagement -
Note
home and/or to other key adults -
Grade
on improvement and effort (primary goal is to get the student involved) -
Have student identify appropriate ways to get adult attention |
-
Positive
reward for work and engagement -
Grade
on improvement and effort (primary goal is to get the student involved) -
Make up lost time -
Homework Club -
Have to complete essential task to earn grade -
Have the student identify appropriate ways to escape |
-
-
Grade
on improvement and effort (primary goal is to get the student involved) -
Teach student when being “passive” is okay – when is it appropriate
to be more reserved -
Have student identify appropriate ways to get power and control |
-
Group
reward -
Peer modeling -
Reward other students who are engaged -
Have student identify appropriate ways to get power and control |
-
Involve
the student in being a peer mediator -
Teach students when being “passive” is okay
– when is it appropriate to be more reserved. -
Have student identify
appropriate ways to get justice |
||||
|
Avoid the use of |
-
Power struggles -
Arguing,
cajoling -
Going overboard
with praise |
-
Overwhelming
the student -
Expectations
that change (set expectations & stick to them) |
- Power struggles - Going overboard with praise |
- Buddies or group work if that is punishing for the student |
- Power struggles |
||||
|
Special considerations |
From “Managing Passive-Aggressive Behavior”, pages
75-84: Know the characteristics of this type of
behavior so that you can work to avoid responding in kind and/or becoming
visibly upset with the student (that’s what he/she often wants); Avoid using group pressure to get the
student to conform(e.g., “we can’t go out for recess until Mary does her
work”); Use benign confrontation (back off quietly from confrontation and
leave the student with the point you wanted to make); Respond differently to
“temporary deafness”, feigned misunderstanding, delay tactics (e.g., set
clear expectations, time limits and consequences for non-compliance and then
do not argue about it). Are there issues at home – not enough sleep, responsibility for younger siblings, etc.? Are there medical issues? Depression? Is there a need to involve pupil services staff (counselor, school nurse, school psychologist, school social worker) and/or outside agencies? |
||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|