|
West Nile Country
Virus, With New Complications, Rages Across America — But for How Long?
By Michael S. James
Oct. 20
— Experts are unsure if America has seen the worst of the West Nile virus,
even after a summer when, for the first time, thousands of human cases stretched
from coast to coast, and more than 100 people died.
The mosquito-borne virus is here to stay, they said, but the North American
strain's unpredictable nature makes it next to impossible to say with certainty
what will happen next, or whether it will continue to get more widespread and
deadly.
"I don't have a crystal ball," said Dr. Lyle Petersen, an
infectious disease specialist at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
"If I had to predict, I would say there will be continuing outbreaks of
varying size throughout the country, so the incidence of disease could vary
tremendously from year to year."
Thousands of Cases
This year, as of Friday, 3,174 people in the United States tested positive
for West Nile and 173 of them died, the CDC reported. With West Nile established
in warm-weather states where mosquitoes bite year round, Petersen expects the
number of cases to keep rising through the winter months.
The deaths, illnesses and geographical range of the disease — with human or
animal cases in 42 states and the District of Columbia — are up steeply from
prior years, when West Nile was confined to Eastern states and the central part
of the country.
There were only 66 human West Nile cases reported in 2001, when the virus was
detected in 27 states and the nation's capital, Dr. James M. Hughes, director of
the CDC's National Center for Infectious Diseases, told a congressional
subcommittee recently.
West Nile's spread to new areas may have aided its explosion this year, some
believe.
"The ability to respond to the virus is absent or very low in most
animals, especially birds, right now, so those animals, especially birds, are
dying," said Dr. Dawn Wesson, associate professor of tropical medicine at
Tulane University Health Sciences Center in New Orleans, and president of the
Louisiana Mosquito Control Association.
There is hope the disease could fade as immunity gets built up among
Americans and U.S. birds — key carriers of West Nile.
"It's going to settle down," said Dr. Susan L. F. McLellan, an
associate professor of infectious diseases at Tulane. "Whether it's
happened this year, I don't know, but most of the susceptible population will
have been exposed and so will be immune."
"[West Nile] may turn out to be no more of a big deal than any of the
other arboviruses [illnesses spread by insects] whose names nobody can
remember," she added.
West Nile Model?
Some see St. Louis encephalitis, a mosquito-borne virus related to West Nile,
as a model of what the future may hold for West Nile in America. The disease
seems to disappear for stretches of time, then suddenly appear in localized
outbreaks.
But St. Louis encephalitis still presents a danger, Petersen said. He noted
that there have been occasional years when, with little explanation, nationally
reported St. Louis encephalitis cases jumped from a few dozen into the
thousands.
In addition, some health experts are worried newly observed complications —
including polio-like symptoms and paralysis, and apparent transmission through
transplanted organs, blood and breast milk — may send West Nile down a more
complicated path than some other viruses, and could muddy the U.S. prognosis.
Petersen is not among them.
"All these other modes of transmission that have been uncovered have
nothing to do with the maintenance of the virus in nature," Petersen said.
"Ninety-nine percent of the transmissions that occur this year or in any
future year are going to be because of mosquitoes."
Birds Are Key
The West Nile virus mainly spreads via mosquitoes who bite infected birds,
and then bite other birds, people or animals, experts say.
Only birds are believed to start the mosquito-borne transmission cycle
because of higher concentrations of West Nile in their blood, McLellan said, so
people and mammals with West Nile are not significant public health risks.
That includes common household pets, which rarely become ill from the
disease, several West Nile experts said.
However, four dogs with encephalitis-like symptoms in Louisiana — including
three who died — had the West Nile virus, the Associated Press reported
Saturday. The state veterinarian said there is no proof that West Nile caused
the illnesses, but suggested veterinarians should watch more closely for the
disease in dogs.
Infected animals are not believed to represent a threat to the U.S. food
supply because cooking kills the West Nile virus.
Other than birds, humans and horses appear most frequently to get severe
reactions to the virus. For unknown reasons, though, a majority of people only
get flu-like symptoms or no symptoms at all, perhaps not even knowing they have
the virus.
Less than 1 percent of West Nile-infected humans become severely ill with
West Nile encephalitis or meningitis, which involve inflammation of the brain or
nervous system membranes. About 10 percent of those with severe illness die,
with most deaths involving the elderly or victims with compromised immune
systems.
Protect Yourself
Despite the low fatality rates, health experts agree, people in affected
areas should aggressively protect themselves from mosquitoes with long sleeves,
insect repellant containing DEET and other precautions
(see CDC Web link, in the right column of this page, for a detailed list)
.
"As a clinical allergist, I'm not looking to throw chemicals onto people
… but this year West Nile is here and you want to use something," says
Dr. Clifford W. Bassett, an allergist and immunologist who teaches at the New
York University School of Medicine. "When you use insecticide, you use the
smallest amount [as measured by chemical concentration] to get the job
done."
Higher concentrations of DEET do not give added protection, but stay
effective longer, he adds.
West Nile is not a newly discovered disease. It was isolated in Uganda, in
1937, and there have been cases elsewhere in Africa, the Middle East and Eastern
Europe.
The American strain of West Nile that first appeared in New York City in 1999
was "essentially identical to a West Nile virus strain which had been
isolated from geese in Israel in 1998," the CDC's Hughes said.
|