from DEFECTIVE ? DETECTIVE To :.JOHN ST. FRANCIS, Esq.. Chittenden County States Attorney "Costello" Building 32 Cherry Street Burlington, Vermont 05401 :.duckgramz.. Questions of Matt Young, Howard Family Services Confirm or Deny 1. As a matter of practice, policy and procedure; the Defective Detective would confer with you about who he was "working" with in order to see if the "story" remained constant, and as a means of protection from unwarranted complaints of conduct while acting as an armed private detective.. 2. The defective detective had advised you of being retained by a female juvenile, (xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx) to investigate jose rodriques, and was cooperating with Detective Art Cyr. of the Burlington Police Department..(and spectrum out reach workers; xxxxxxx xxxx, and xxxxx xxxx.) This involved efforts to aid m. xxxxxx xxxxxxxx, during the summer and fall of 2000.) 3. The defective detective advised that the states attorney's and law enforcement dropped the ball, jailed the female victims (xxxxxx xxxxxxxx) and allowed rodriques to go free, walking out of court with xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxn. The Defective Detective advised that he had spoke to Burlington Detective Paul Glenn, and States Attorney Carolyn Hanson, and neither one wanted to communicate with the females to get them to cooperate against Rodriques. And when asked by the defective detective, if she (ms. Hanson) had talked to Detective Art Cyr, HER RESPONSE WAS NO.. 4. The defective detective; after the murder of Christal Jones, advised that he had learned of a plot to murder the remaining witness' and had filed this NOTICE; with the Vermont secretary of state, and governors security unit, since the governors son and Jessy Jones were friends, and played hockey together. & that the threat was also being made against several local drug dealers, and was NOT being followed up by police. 5. The defective detective; advised that he was following up on a lead that a threat was being made by xxxxxx xxxxxxg. That a request was made to Burlington Police to provide a picture, and again No Response, TO which you stated that you had also been threatened, and a picture could be found with Burlington Square Mall Security. The defective detective cited past experience with "Mall Security" and when the defective detective attempted to communicate and cooperate with mall security they threw the defective detective out and issued a one year notice of trespass served by Burlington Police Department.. 6. The defective detective advised you that he was working an undercover investigation in cooperation with the Vermont Attorney General's Detective Peter C. Bottino, involving corruption of Police Officers. The names and identities of teenagers involved were provided; and you were asked to keep your ears open, to see if "stories" were remaining consistent, and to report any intel to Burlington Police Detective Art Cyr. Did there come a time when a female juvenile (xxxxxx) runaway with "xxxxxxx".. 7. The defective detective asked you to listen to xxxxxxx xxxxxxt, and help him find work' as he is an important witness involved with the drug trafficking and family members directly involved in the Christal Jones homicide. 8. Explain to the jury the timeline: From when advised by the defective detective, to the time that a law enforcement officer talked to you about xxxxxxx xxxxxxx, and the information being followed up in re (murder of christal jones) to drug dealers, and persons considered a threat to high risk youth, involved with Spectrum Youth Services. 9. Has the Defective Detective ever filed written complaints and communications about persons that were making threats against himself; and that had also made threats against you, with the management, and oversight of Howard Family Services, Sen. James Leddy. 10. Has it been common public knowledge FOR YEARS, and amongst Spectrum Youth Out Reach Workers, xxxxxxx xxxx, and xxxxx xxxx; that the Defective Detective has been smoking pot and playing chess as a matter of civil disobedience; First Amendment Right to Free Speech, while openly and actively campaigning for the Publicly Elected office of Chittenden County Sates Attorney. (while actively hiding in plain view as an undercover operative filing reports for law enforcement safety, (for the prosecution) and intel reports with the Vermont Secretary of State, Attorney Generals' Detective Peter C. Bottino, and Burlington Police Detective Art Cyr. & TO: Spectrum Youth Services.. 11. At the time you witnessed the arrest of the Defective Detective, in City Hall Park, on July 20th. did you ask the question " WHY NOW ? "explain to the jury.. 12. Did the defective detective follow up on the run away of juvenile xxxxxxxx with "xxxxxxx'' and advise you of communications sent to Essex Police Department Chief David Demag.. did any police officer question you about the juvenile runaway, or "xxxxxxx" 13. Where you ever interviewed about past behavior and interaction between the defective detective, and high risk teenagers in city hall park, and the Church Street Marketplace drug activity, prostitution, or any unprofessional conduct while acting in the fiduciary capacity as being the Qualifying Agent of Defective Detective, a private detective agency, regulated for professional conduct by the Vermont Secretary of State.. 14. Was there verbal communication between yourself and the defective detective about the competency and follow up by the States Attorney's Office, Burlington Police, and the behavior of various law enforcement officers. During one conversation about the incompetence of police officers: The statement was made that Walt. Decker was seen on church street: to which the reply was "WHAT WAS HE DOING, SHOPPING!". who made that statement. and do you feel that you can be honest in giving your opinion without fear of reprisal. 15. More recently: Did the defective detective, under the issue of looking for work, introduce you to a female juvenile (A.R.) and advise, she was the most recent victim of gang sexual assault. That she was in FEAR of giving testimony, and that support was being gathered to be with her during court testimony. Were you also told that a reporter for WVNY, Kelly Reardon, wa being briefed about the extent of gang activity, and continuing negligence by police. 16. Were you later advised, and sent copies of confidential communication to Kelly Reardon of WVNY, in re to the Female Victim juvenile being put under pressur to SHUT UP, and not talk about incidents that happened under the care of srs. and Spectrum Youth Services. Were you introduced to Kelly Reardon, by the defective detective, on Church Street. 17. Were you later advised by the defective detective; the female juvenile was arrested and lodged at Woodside Correctional Facility, and that the suspects in the assault were still dealing drugs and soliciting young girls for prostitution, on the corner of Church and Cherry Streets.& Did the defective detective most recently advise you that the suspect xxxx xxxxxxx had beat a male juvenile (x.x.) punching him in the eye's .. Questions of Officer Kenneth Tisdel Burlington Police Department Confirm or Deny 1. The DEFECTIVE ? DETECTIVE.. advised that he had NOT SOLD drugs to a girl, but had purchased $10.00 worth of pot, as a mater of Free Speech;and medical necessity, in civil disobedience for a scheduled 4:20 press conferences.. for the publicly elected office of chittenden county state's attorney.. 2. The response and disclosure of the purchase of a nugget of marijuana was in response to being told by police, that under covers had reported that the Defective Detective had passed a bag to a girl.. 3. You advised the defective detective that he could not use the first amendment right as free speech because, it is not words.. 4. You advised; to Officer Fabiani, he (defective detective) wasn't selling drugs, he (defective detective) was buying! 5. You stated that Vermont does NOT have a marijuana law. The defective detective Insisted that the Vermont Legislature HAD PASSED A LAW, and THAT LAW was signed by Vermont Governor Richard Snelling.. 6. You stated that you were not going to argue with the defective detective. & consent to search be given, and to voluntarily surrender the pot or be subject to arrest. To which the defective detective insisted on arrested, and no authority for search was granted. 7. State the names of the persons also in the immediate vicinity. The name and identity of the female juvenile that returned the defective detectives chess pieces, and her then boy friend. 8. Did you ever file for the crime stoppers tip for the defective detective in re "Timothy & Albert", aggravated assault.. 9. After arrest: Did the defective detective advise both you and Officer Fabiani, that he was working for Detective Peter Bottino, for the Vermont Attorney Generals Office, and that the details could not be discussed, but wanted to have it noted in the report, To which you responded that I (defective detective) couldn't be working for Detective Bottino, because it's against Federal Law to work undercover without a wire. 10 Explain to the jury what you meant when you walked into the processing room at the Police Station and stated " wouldn't you love to turn those cameras off ! ".. Confirm or Deny Questions for Detective Peter C. Bottino Office of the Vermont Attorney General 1. Did you offer to have all private detective agency license fees waived for "renewals" sec# 3178 Ch.59 T.26 VSA. 2. Was that offer rejected by the Defective Detective, stating, the value of the license is in the ability to have a case filed, rather than denied due process, and would rather go to the jury without a license, as a matter of civil disobedience, requiring the state to explain WHY the Detective Agency has REFUSED to pay for Professional Regulation that filed Fraudulent findings by an "investigation". 3. Did you talk about the issues of being denied due process, when the defective detective filed a formal complaint and civil suit against Burlington Square Mall and Censor Security for their behavior in handling an incident of the Defective Detective removing a bomb from the mall and down town Burlington. Case filed S-0133-98Cnc 4. Did you and the Defective Detective discuss the fact that the Secretary of States' Criminal investigator, opened cases filed against IDS/ Amex, as a whistle blower, while acting as a Series 7/ 63 Financial Planner. Termination of all insurance licenses, and loss of real estate investment of disability income, exceeds $500,000. and was bases for suit against the State of Vermont as detailed in Supreme court of Vermont docket # 96-144.. 5 . Did the Defective Detective discuss the suit Filed against the City of Burlington, for unlawful termination of employment when a formal complaint was filed against David Archer, General Manager of Memorial Auditorium. 6. Did the Board of Private Investigators and Security Services, ever hold a hearing.. 7. Did the Defective Detective, state and file that the "City claimed that he was not hired" rather than fired and the BOARD rule that the Defective Detective never worked there, nor was compensated although a W-2 and security reports were filed.. as DOCUMENTED IN Supreme Court docket # 96-143.. 8. Did the Defective Detective Complain that the stalking Charge filed, was by David Archer, mgr. of the auditorium, in an effort to discredit the complaint filed.. 9. Did the Effect of having a "stalking Complaint" have a bearing on the dismissal of the suit against Censor Security, and Burlington Square Mall. 10. Has the Defective Detective continually been campaigning for the Publicly Elected Office of Chittenden County States Attorney, and used the issue of medical marijuana as a means of free speech, as noted in filings with the Secretary of State.. 11. Is it not common knowledge that the Defective Detective has worked undercover narcotics investigations in City Hall Park, by the use of smoking pot as a means of "hiding in plain view" and reporting intel to City Police.. 12. Did the Defective Detective advise you that he had on numerous occasions filed complaint against Lt. Walt Decker, for negligence in the line of duty, including failing to give Notice to Sen. James Jeffords office that a take over of his office was going to occur. After having been given notice of an investigation conducted by the Defective Detective and Notice forwarded by South Burlington Police Lt. Ernie Lemay.. 13. Did the Defective Detective advise you of the complaint against Lt. Decker for negligence in handling assaults against women, drug activity and storage of bombs, as filed in an action to show a pattern of behavior, filed in case file 4, docket # 96-144.. 14. Did the Defective Detective bring forward and aid in an investigation of Police Drug trafficking, and the use of teenagers to distribute the drugs. 15. Did the Defective Detective, file written reports, in re to Police drug trafficking.. 16. Did the Defective Detective, provide intel about a state chapter of the hells angels, to which you stated that "protocol" was to change from notice to Mark Galley, Governors Security Unit, TO: Detective Peter C. Bottino, for the Vermont attorney general. 17. Has the Defective Detective continued to file intel reports while applying to be sworn to the Christal Jones Homicide and interstate gang narcotic traffic. 18. Did the Defective Detective talk to you about the Chittenden county states Attorney's Office and how Attorney Carolyn Hanson, had dropped the ball and Failed to communicate with detective Art Cyr. BPD about Jose' Rodriques, resulting in jailing the female victim on heroin, and allowing Rodriques to walk when the Defective Detective had gained the confidence of several females that would testify. But that was never followed up.. 19. Did you tell the Defective Detective, that you had nothing to do with his arrest for possession of marijuana, and after reviewing the facts, try to get the ag's office to take jurisdiction and dismiss the charges. 20. Did you talk to the Defective Detective, just before arraignment, about poor communication between law enforcement agencies, to which you responded that the charges are probably going to get dropped anyway. Most Respectfully Submitted :.November 19, 2001.. & :.tankz.. Paul Charles Duprat Criminologist & Qualifying Agent DEFECTIVE ?DETECTIVE :.a private detective agency.. defense in 3 issues 1. RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH AS A POLITICAL CANDIDATE STANDING IN CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE IN THE ISSUE OF HEALTH CARE: RIGHT TO SPEAK TO A DOCTOR IN A CONFIDENTIAL setting And the Right and Obligation of a DOCTOR to speak open and honestly and recommend the best prescription for recovery and maintenance of Health Care, in all aspects of prevention, education, and maintenance to treatment for Pain.. 2 Response to unexpected incident is treated as a greater risk than incidents with pre planning and approval. Thus the accusation of being a "DRUG DEALER" to teens in City Hall Park; OVER SHADOWS, and negates the lawful issues raised, to the same extent that a Non-civil Disobedient Protest negates the ISSUES by attention drawn towards the violence.. That is why the anonymous phone call was placed: To discredit the whistle blower that was tracking the corruption within law enforcement that filters down to the streets by use of teenagers.. 3 MOTIONS Arguments For the Defense to Change Jurisdiction of Trial 1 :.Motion..Rule Court Lacks Jurisdiction.. Defendant claims all actions and behavior are under Jurisdiction of the Washington County Superior Court..vsa T. 26 Ch. 59 sec 3183 Remedies Jurisdiction over Authority and Responsibility: Professional regulation Vermont Secretary of State: office of professional Regulation; Board of Private Investigative and Security Services; VSA T.3 Ch.5 sec.122 Subchapter 3. Professional Regulation. (18) Board of Private Investigators and Security Services..and COUNTER CLAIM: AT RISK Private Detective working investigation with state and city police officers subjected to malicious prosecution for not contacting attorney general detective, nor secretary of state criminal investigator; Conflict of Interest between Chittenden County States Attorney's Office and CANDIDATE FOR THE SAME PUBLICLY ELECTED OFFICE.. Canon 9 AVOIDING EVEN THE APPEARANCE OF Impropriety.. Administrative Orders & Rules 2 :.Motion.. for Subpoena TAPE OF ORIGINAL "anonymous" Telephone Complaint to Burlington Department, along with tape of processing by Burlington Police Officers.. 3 :.Motion.. Require Attorney General Detective Peter C. Bottino, to Submit a Certified Copy of the "Confidential" for Law Enforcement Officers Safety; Letter & Envelope, re need to know undercover operation, post marked July 19th. 2001, Note for issue of Jurisdiction review:. Detective Peter Bottino, is a part time police officer for the City of Burlington Vt. HOWEVER, THIS CASE WAS "a need to know, ONLY" UNDER THE EXPRESSED SOLE JURISDICTION OF THE VERMONT ATTORNEY GENERAL.. Detective Bottino; did not want any law enforcement officer advised of the nature of the investigation, including Det. Art Cyr of Burlington Police Department, Informant and operative does not trust police, however was willing to work after Detective Cyr, introduced operative to Detective Bottino.. arrangements made by the Defective ? Detective.. & as a matter of protocol for networking intel / to STATE AUTHORITY established Protocol Change :.FROM.. Notice to Trooper Mark Galley, Governors' Security Unit, :.TO.. DETECTIVE BOTTINO, FOR THE VERMONT ATTORNEY GENERAL.. This Request and Change in protocol has been honored; in addition to NOTICE Filed as Action and record of behavior while acting under the Authority & Responsibility of the Vermont Secretary of State, oversight of Professional Regulation: Board of Private Investigators and Security Services..Attention Criminal Investigator Paul Hutchings..Transcript to be used in defense to undercover narcotics investigation; acting in accordance to experience and training by Federal DEA Academy protocol for :."BUYING DRUGS.." and networking undercover operatives with Law Enforcement Authority.. 4 :.Motion.. To Demand and Acknowledge Jurisdiction for the Possession of Marijuana, in City Hall Park, during a protest and campaign by a political candidate, is a STATE'S RIGHT ISSUE OF FREE SPEECH.. behavior of Candidate using marijuana in a "corn cob" pipe as a trademark expression of free speech. 5 :.Motion..Recognition of the Fiduciary Right of Patient/ Doctor Right to Confidentiality in determining treatment for a patient.. 6 :.MOTION.. ACCEPT MEDICAL NECESSITY DEFENSE; AND ACCEPT AS EVIDENCE CONFIDENTIAL PHYSICIAN PATIENT HEALTH FILE. DETAILING MEDICATIONS THAT WERE REFUSED DUE TO SIDE EFFECTS, LACK OF PERFORMANCE OR INCREASED RISK CONTRARY TO THE HEALTH BENEFITS OF A PLANT CALLED MARIJUANA. Most Respectfully Submitted :.November 12, 2001.. & :.tankz.. Paul Charles Duprat Criminologist & Qualifying Agent DEFECTIVE ?DETECTIVE :.a private detective agency..