Review - Ivy League vs Half A Cow
@ Newtown RSL 1 April 99

The stage had been set for what could rightly been the battle of the century between these two inner-city Indie record labels; a bout even Don King couldn't fix! Punters, supporters, all were in line for a night of six bands, with Sneeze, Bernie Hayes and Smudge in the HAC corner, and Hoolahan, Youth Group and 78 Saab doing it for the Ivy League. Let the fight begin!

Sneeze were the first contestants, and may I say that if it weren't for the fine line up ahead I would have walked out there and then! Emerging from the dark with an early Casio MT65, bongos, and a revolving door behind the main drums, I was stunned, bewildered and aghast (and other entries alongside amazed in the thesaurus) at this band purporting to represent the Half A Cow stable! Two of the singers couldn't (the guitarist/lead vocalist was OK) and no-one save for a couple of the drummers could actually play. The mix and lighting matched this abhorrence, although there seems to be a market for this sort of thing because there was more than polite applause through the set. Set the HAC scoreboard up with a big duck-egg to start!

Hoolahan did what was expected of them and actually raised the level of the evening. It must have been an Ivy League engineer: even the light and sound improved, albeit marginally. Maybe Don King was involved! Hoolahan were bright, punchy and poppy in their inimitable way, with a let down in the tightness department due to the almost-constant audible tuning and other delays between tunes. They showed why they were representatives at the recent PCMC outing and were one of the main reasons for my being there again. Good work, chaps!

A relaxing and kick-backable venue like the Bingo Hall (as Bernie Hayes referred to the venue whose decor has not changed since 1947) needs a kicked-back and relaxed act like Bernie for this next set. As expected, Mr Shout delivered with a smooth but somewhat shortened set, featuring Jess Ciampa of Tokakros on percussion and an exceptional selection of songs from his own, the Shouties and Stevie Punder's catalog. The standout tunes of the night included "Slumber", “a three to four minute song when I play on my own but even longer when I play it with a band”, he warned.

Due to personal reasons, I had to bail out fairly early, but not before seeing Youth Group doing it for the League. Change is a many varied thing in the music business: while the stability (since November) of Hoolahan's act is working wonders for their profile, the support garnered by Youth Group's current direction is pleasing to the Sydney live-scene cynic! While the style is still Custardesque in places (especially in the new single "Country Tour") they have honed and sharpened their indie sound and presentation, complete with the Tim Rogers/Pete Townshend guitar flourish and the super-extended rock & roll finish to the set! Loud, dirty and favoured by the home-ground crowd, with a tad Brit-rock for added depth!

Who knows which label came through this battle tonight? It will probably be written up somewhere else, but the winner was definitely live and independent inner-city music: if it weren't for the innovation and enterprise of a couple of young bands, events such as these would be things of the past (or future) in Sydney.

PG (Jacky) Gleeson

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1