| Most Seasons | 21 | George Armstrong |
| Most Games | 1187 | George Armstrong |
| Most Goals, Career | 389 | Darryl Sittler |
| Most Assists, Career | 620 | Borje Salming |
| Most Points, Career | 916 | Darryl Sittler (389G, 527A) |
| Most PIM, Career | 1777 | Tie Domi |
| Most Shutouts, Career | 62 | Turk Broda |
| Longest Consecutive Games Streak | 486 | Tim Horton Feb 11/61-Feb 4/68 |
| Most Goals, Season | 54 | Rick Vaive (1981-82) |
| Most Assists, Season | 95 | Doug Gilmour (1992-93) |
| Most Points, Season | 127 | Doug Gilmour (1992-93) |
| Most PIM, Season | 365 | Tie Domie (1997-1998) |
| Most Points, Defenseman Season | 79 | Ian Turnbull (1976-77 22G, 57A) |
| Most Points, Center, Season | 127 | Doug Gilmour (1992-93 32G, 95A) |
| Most Points, Right Wing, Season | 97 | Wilf Paiement (1980-81 40G, 57A) |
| Most Points, Left Wing, Season | 99 | Dave Andreychuk (1993-94 53G, 46A) |
| Most Points, Rookie Season | 66 | Peter Ihnacak (1982-83 28G, 38A) |
| Most Shutouts, Season | 13 | Harry Lumley 1953-54 |
| Most Goals, Game | 6 | Corb Denneny (Jan 26/1921) |
| Darryl Sittler (Feb 7/1976) | ||
| Most Assists, Game | 6 | Babe Pratt (Jan 8/1954) |
| Doug Gilmour (Feb 13/1993) | ||
| Most Points, Game | *10 | Darryl Sittler (Feb 7/1976 6G, 4A) |