1996 All-Star Game
| Charlie Hustle/Dick Allen | Hammerin' Hank/Shoeless Joe | ||||||
| . | |||||||
| Starters | Starters | ||||||
| C | Mike Piazza | Sting | C | Mickey Tettleton | Other Team | ||
| 1B | Eric Karros | Wildcats | 1B | Mo Vaughn | Lightning | ||
| 2B | Kirby Puckett | Grizzlies | 2B | Mark Lewis | Knights | ||
| 3B | Jim Thome | Homers | 3B | Bobby Bonilla | Knights | ||
| SS | Shawon Dunston | Bombers | SS | John Valentin | Giants | ||
| OF | Albert Belle | Scorpions | OF | Larry Walker | Other Team | ||
| OF | Dante Bichette | Scorpions | OF | Bernie Williams | Lightning | ||
| OF | Ray Lankford | Sting | OF | Raul Mondesi | Dodgers | ||
| DH | Harold Baines | Sting | DH | Edgar Martinez | Carcass | ||
| SP | David Cone | Grizzlies | SP | Hideo Nomo | Other Team | ||
| RP | Jose Mesa | Homers | RP | Mike Henneman | Other Team | ||
| . | |||||||
| . | |||||||
| Reserves | Reserves | ||||||
| C | Javy Lopez | Grizzlies | C | Benito Santiago | Comets | ||
| 1B | Tino Martinez | Homers | 1B | Mark Grace | Carcass | ||
| 2B | Chuck Knoblauch | Scorpions | 2B | Roberto Alomar | Caracss | ||
| 3B | Ken Caminiti | Grizzlies | 3B | Matt Williams | Giants | ||
| SS | Barry Larkin | Thunder | SS | Gary Disarcina | Dodgers | ||
| OF | Kenny Lofton | Bombers | OF | Steve Finley | Other Team | ||
| OF | Tim Salmon | Thunder | OF | Garret Anderson | Comets | ||
| OF | Jay Buhner | Wildcats | OF | Tony Gwynn | Carcass | ||
| DH | Jon VanderWal | Sting | DH | Eddie Murray | Other Team | ||
| SP | Jim Abbott | Thunder | SP | Pete Schourek | Knights | ||
| SP | Mike Hampton | Sting | SP | Randy Johnson | Lightning | ||
| RP | Trevor Hoffman | Bombers | RP | Paul Assenmacher | Dodgers | ||
| RP | Eric Plunk | Homers | RP | Jeff Nelson | Lightning | ||