editorial
As I write this editorial the totally unpredictable
Dunedin weather has just turned from wonderful warm sunshine to torrential
downpours and cool temperatures within the space of a day or two. Despite
being born and bred here, this feature of our weather is something that I
still find frustrating. But, even though winter is approaching, there’s
still plenty of things happening here in the LGBT/queer community to take
part in, experience and enjoy. For example, there are the regular
groups such as PFLAG, UniQ’s social support groups, Rainbow Families,
the Purple Passions women’s soccer team, Ascent and there’s now also
The L Club, a social group for lesbians over 45 (see Pages 4 and 5 and the
back page for more details). There are also several exhibitions taking
place over the next month or so that are of particular interest to our
community (see Page 10), and there’s the wonderful celebration that is
the Mid Winter Carnival in June too.
An important event happening very soon that I’d like to
bring to your attention is the AIDS Candlelight Memorial on Sunday May 21.
The cover features a national poster created by NZAF for this event and
there’s more information on Page 4. In this OGT we’ve printed a press
release from NZAF about the latest HIV .gures for gay and bisexual men in
New Zealand – and they’re higher than they’ve ever been! The AIDS
Candlelight Memorial provides the perfect opportunity not only to remember
all those who have been taken by this disease and those who live with it
currently, but also to think about how we can reduce the number of
diagnoses and save precious lives.
This issue of the paper includes tributes to Konrad
Kahuroa, together with some memories of Konrad from his mum. Konrad, who
was a well-known and enthusiastic member of the Dunedin gay community,
died suddenly and tragically at the end of last year at the age of 24.
From reading these pieces and talking to people I know that Konrad touched
the lives of many individuals in a very special way and that he is missed
tremendously. Long may his memory and his inspiration live on here
in Dunedin.
This issue of the OGT has had a bit of a rough road to
publication because around the time of copy deadline we found out that the
Oamaru Mail, which has printed the paper for many years now, is no longer
operating as a print site. Yikes! – what do we do now?! (This is the
printable version of what went through my mind when I learned this!) After
many phone calls (thanks Barb!) we finally found another place to print
the OGT although in a slightly smaller format than we’ve been used to.
So, please bear with us if there are some hiccups or teething problems
with this issue and, if this happens, we should be able to rectify them in
the following issue. I’d like to take this opportunity to thank the
Oamaru Mail for doing a wonderful printing job for us for many years, and
I’d especially like to mention Murray who provided me with a lot of
technical support particularly when we changed the programme that we use
to create the paper so that it can now all be sent through to the printers
electronically.
Enjoy the next few months and I hope you .nd lots of fun
ways to keep warm and dry!
Tor Devereux, Editor
KONRAD KAHUROA
02/09/1981 –
03/12/2005
Konrad Kahuroa was a much-loved member of the Dunedin gay
community. He died tragically, aged 24, in Auckland on 3 December
2005. Here we publish tributes to Konrad from friends and his mum talks
about his life.
MANAAKI KORERO
This column is in commemoration of Konrad Kahuroa (Ngai
Tuhoe, Ngati Raukawa, Ngati Kahungunu), co-founder of Pride Dunedin Youth
and total fashion star. His mother, Tangiwai Tahi, spoke about her son.
"He started school in Tuatapere, where he was born.
Konrad was always such a worker; he just loved his schoolwork, right from
when he started school. And the teachers were always so proud of him.
"We decided to move to Australia. And he did
really well there – he was just determined to do good,wherever and
whatever he did. He was the top student at Epping Boys’ High in
Sydney where he was from age 13 to 15. Then I decided to bring him back to
New Zealand. He struggled when he got back – he found the transition
quite difficult, and he just managed to pass school cert. But then in the
sixth form his marks qualified him to go to varsity. You had to get under
12 points, I think, and he had 8, so he was well and truly
qualifying. But because of his friends and his twin brother, they
decided to stay on at school for another year.
"Konrad started varsity studying health science, but
halfway through he decided that it wasn’t for him. And that totally blew
me, ‘cause as far as I was concerned my son was going to be my doctor!
Anyway, he decided to go do psychology and statistics. At the same
time, I spent a year at varsity. He and I were doing the same papers in
English. He was actually embarrassed that his mum was going to varsity at
the same time, and he said to me ‘Mum, if you ever see me at varsity, don’t
yell out to me.’ The bizarre
thing was, I never did, but all I would hear was ‘Muum!’ and it’s
Konrad screaming from way across some courtyard, yelling out ‘Mum’! He
was a real hard case, you know. The thing was, he actually enjoyed having
me at varsity – it was quite funny.
"During his time at Otago Boys High School he decided
to take up a modelling thing with Vanity Walk, and in the same period he
was an extra for Vertical
Limit. And that sorta led
him into his passion, as well as going to varsity and realising ‘Hey,
this isn’t me. My passion lies in the fashion industry.’
"In 2002, he ran the Schwarzkopf Professional Summer
Fashion Stage Show in the Glenroy, and that was a huge success. He did an
awesome job of that - I mean, it was a total blowaway. I was quite proud
of him. And then he did the second one, Selections, which was held at
Wrightson’s Woolstores. Konrad had quite a creative mind, you know? We’d
be driving along and he’d say to me, ‘Mum, let’s go for a drive!’
– and then Konrad would say, ‘Mum, stop the car!’ And he’d be
looking at some run-down old building, and his mind would be going at
100mph. We went to Cherry Farm once which used to be an old mental
institution. It was run down, but he was having this vision about having
this fashion show out there. And he’s got us climbing through cobwebs
and he’s saying, ‘Oh look it’s got a toilet here, we could do this
and this.’ It’s just a real totally run-down building, y’know. I
just couldn’t believe it! But Konrad, he wasn’t just a lateral
thinker, he had these huge, out-of-thisworld visions.
"His main objective with the first show was to get
employment, to create a job. He wasn’t just trying to promote himself.
He was also promoting the ones alongside of him. His passion was to
promote unknown artists, as well as to try to find employment for himself.
And he was trying to give people the opportunity to go to his show,
receive his full awe, his very best, and let them take inspiration from
that and share it.
If there were any profits made, it was going to charity
– nothing for him. And the second show I think went down the same track.
It was all about promoting everyone involved, but with all funds going to
Pride Dunedin Youth. And then Youthline as well.
"Initially, he thought Dunedin would have been an
ideal place to promote himself because it’s supposed to be the ‘fashion
city’. But, because nothing came of it, he went to Wellington.
Konrad and his friend Phil Rogers initiated a third fashion show there
under the name of Long Cloak Productions. Long Cloak is named after
Konrad, his Maori surname translated. And after that fashion show,
Auckland was going to be another step for Konrad.
"When he came out, aged 18, I have to be honest, it
threw me, like a lot of parents. But then my best girlfriend spoke to me
and said, ‘Wouldn’t you rather have a gay son than one who was in jail
or something?’ And Konrad started explaining to me, and got me to gay
parties – and it was great, I loved it! ‘Mum you’ll love it. There’ll
be somebody your age there,’ he’d say to me. Because Konrad was quite
a caring boy. Pretty outrageous, but that was, kinda, the only way
he could move ahead."
An acquaintance of only a few months was all it took for
Konrad to become set, in my mind, as the benchmark by which to measure the
gay experience. He lived honestly, he turned his sexuality into an
advantage rather than a disadvantage, and he was a fantastic success. He
could be bafflingly positive. For his first fashion show in 2002 he
decided he was going to get Schwarzkopf as a sponsor. I snorted at that.
But a few weeks later, Schwarzkopf was on board and a professional catwalk
co-ordinator had volunteered her services, to boot. Konrad showed me what
you can achieve if you believe in yourself. He remains the benchmark.
Anna Chinn
My little darling, Your sweet little
brother like hugs and warm
beaming smile will always be …
Thank you. Love Bethan
Dearest Konrad,
Somehow, years ago in my musical innocence, you got me on
stage singing to what seemed hundreds of strangers. Somehow every time
I saw you you made me feel beautiful. Your death shocked me to
the core. I had such trust in your ambition and strength. I’m sorry for
a world that can be so cruel. I’ve started wearing heels for you! I
promise to remember to be glam … if only sometimes. And I promise to
listen and care … always.
Much love, Doll face Pamela
Konrad,
You had massive ideas that you went through with and those
events were stunning! Thank you for including us in your amazing
productions. You will always be an inspiration to us. They were glam
darling ... just like you sweetie ... aside from being extremely good
looking [totally international].
Take care out there ... RASA Dance Company xx
I remember the night that Konrad first introduced himself
to me - it was the night that I won the "coveted" title of Mr
Pride Dunedin at ReFuel during the Pride Week Celebrations in 2002. After
the contest I was a bit blown away by my win, as take the piss as it was,
so was real keen to just "get on with it" with my $30 bar-tab
and celebrate with my friends. But Konrad, who would have been 20 at the
time, locked onto me as soon as I re-emerged from the back room and didn’t
disappear from my sight for the rest of the night. In fact, I have the
distinct recollection of feeling slightly suffocated by the way he was
constantly requiring my attention, which makes me laugh now as I recall
the sometimes diffcult journey we went through to becoming friends.
In the following weeks and months Konrad and I forged a
friendship to which we were both committed although it did require us to
work at it. I recall feelings of exhaustion that led me to question why I
was spending so much time with him. But I suppose I knew I was 100% Nathan
when I was with Konrad and I liked that. He always made me feel genuinely
appreciated and allowed me to flesh my opinions out to a receptive ear.
Konrad then quite naturally became an integral part of the
"gay-boy posse" that I was a part of and the period from 2002 to
the end of 2003 was a time characterised for me in large part by my
friendship with Konrad and I reflect on it fondly as a time of fun and
outrageous games. I also remember a defining coffee meeting with Konrad
when he announced his inspiration for a fashion show, and his realisation
that he just needed to get up and do it rather than wait for his life to
somehow happen… Many coffees, wines and get togethers followed as we
mapped out his vision for what he wanted to achieve. In the space of a
year Konrad had become actively involved in helping with Pride Dunedin
Youth and later FUNQ, both of which I was involved with.
So it was hardly surprising that in 2004 Konrad, in his
quest to progress towards the star-studded fashion career that he
envisioned, moved to Wellington. It was from that moment that we missed
the vibrancy and presence of Konrad on the Dunedin gay circuit. For
some his departure came with mixed feelings as they found his, at times,
cavalier approach a little testing if not downright rude. He
certainly made me cringe at times and he definitely rustled my feathers
quite frequently but because there was a heartfelt and yes, damn it,
beautiful person beneath it all with whom I felt connected, I came to
value and admire the forthright qualities he flaunted. So it is for this
reason that he will always remain an inspiration for me to never aim for
anything less than the best.
Nathan Brown
Konrad was an interesting vehicle owner who was a
favourite revenue earner for the City Council Parking coffers. I don’t
think he knew what a parking meter was for – nor what the role of a
petrol station was in running a car. The number of times I got called to
fix the car, only to find it was out of petrol and I had to tow him to the
service station to fill up was farcical.
He won the Weetbix Driver of the Year Award too. One night
he was taking a fellow bar manager to her home after a long shift and he
somehow decided the little red car was capable of 4-wheel driving. Talking
away to her, Konrad managed to steer the car across the traffic island in
the middle of the road, go flying through the air, and then drive on still
talking as though nothing unusual had happened. A shaken passenger
asked him if he had got his licence from the back of a Weetbix packet.
A few weeks later we had an awards ceremony and presented
Konrad with a framed Weetbix 4WD Car Test Pass Certificate to commemorate
that occasion!
Phil Rogers (Nga Mahu, Nga Kuia) -
Purple Passions
The Masters Games 2006, the
crowd is silent yet expectant, the Purple Passions are warming up on the
sidelines, and the opposition quake in their boots eyeing up those
gorgeous PP legs!!
In February 2006 seventeen Purple Passions women played
five games over a three day weekend. Fun, fancy and football were the
winners of the weekend. But to make sure we didn’t go home feeling like
we hadn’t won any games, a beautiful purple medal was awarded to all who
participated both on and off the field. Many thanks to Sue for making us
all feel like winners.
The Purple Passions, our lesbian social soccer team, has
been in existence for 20 years and the Masters Games highlighted, once
again, what a wonderful experience it is to be around a large group of
sporty, stroppy and sweaty women! Both young and old, experienced and
inexperienced (at soccer, that is!) came together to form a team who were
both passionate and determined to have a good time and participate at the
highest sporting level. Well, at least we achieved one of our goals!
Many thanks to everyone who supported the Purple Passions
Masters Games team. We are very thankful for the support that the gay and
lesbian community offered. Special thanks to Dykeworks, without your
support we would not look so "dyke delicious" on the field.
Turn now to April 2006 and the Purple Passions are on the
roam again - no, sorry, I meant to say that the Purple Passions are
playing the game again. Every Saturday morning at the Logan Park Sports
Grounds you can find the Purple Passions playing soccer. As always, the
team on the day is diverse in both experience and age. Basically if you
are keen to play then you pass the test as to whether you should play for
the team.
When we say anyone is welcome to play we really mean ALL
welcome. If you want to know more about the wonderful experience
that is the Purple Passions, feel free to contact Lisa Davis on 027-
479-5373 or 472-8677. The Purple Passions needs players and supporters, so
come along on Saturday mornings - we would love to see you.
aids candlelight
memorial
On Sunday 21 May, Dunedin will participate in the 23rd
International AIDS Candlelight Memorial. The event will be held at St Paul’s
Cathedral in the Octagon beginning at 7pm.
Dunedin will be one of the 4500 communities in 93
countries participating in this event which is a time to remember those we
have lost to HIV/AIDS, to show support for those living with the virus and
to mobilise community involvement in the .ght against HIV/AIDS. Despite
over 23 years of education, our community is more at risk than ever
before. Internationally AIDS has claimed more than 28 million lives, with
over 42 million now living with the virus. In New Zealand, the past three
years have seen a continued increase in new HIV infections with the
numbers now equating to one new HIV diagnosis every 4 days. This pattern
will continue if we do not stop ignoring the virus’ existence.
2006’s international theme - Lighting the Path to a
Brighter Future - encourages participants to take action beyond one night
a year by mobilising community action in the .ght against HIV/AIDS.
This year at the Candlelight Memorial remember those who have gone before,
but remember also that you have the power to stop it happening to someone
else you love or care for. Practise safer sex - wear a condom and help
stop the transmission of HIV/AIDS here in New Zealand.
Dunedin’s observance of the Candlelight Memorial at St
Paul’s Cathedral will include a non-religious service, speakers, song
and supper. Balloons will be released into the Octagon to commemorate the
occasion. Local AIDS Memorial Quilts will be on display. The event is
free, but donations are gratefully accepted and go towards the ongoing
work of Dunedin HIV/AIDS education, prevention and support groups
collectively called The Working Together Group.
HELP FOR PARENTS IN THE
CLOSET
by Sue Thompson
Coming out happens after a long process through denial to
final self acceptance, and telling the family can be a relief, even though
other problems sometimes follow. Even the most loving parents and families
often respond by going into the closet and have an experience similar to
that of their gay child. They need reliable information and support, and
often they have no idea where to turn. If you are planning to come out,
tell the people you love about PFLAG (Parents, Families and Friends of
Lesbians and Gays). They may not want to come to a meeting at first, but
we are willing to talk on the phone, email or meet individuals. Many
people prefer to find information from our website (details on the back
page of the OGT).
SOME PFLAG PARENTS’ REACTIONS TO PFLAG
Mother of a gay son "I felt as though I had come
home! All these ‘strangers’ were not strangers because we had a common
focus. We talked, we laughed, we listened. Sometimes in our small groups
we paused and revisited our individual grieving. Each person’s story was
the same but different. I attendedthe PFLAG meeting to educate myself and
our family about the social and support issues we need to know about. I
shall continue to go if for no other reason than the bonding experienced
there."
Parents of a 34-year old lesbian in a permanent
relationship "We both enjoyed the .rst meeting, and I think it helped
spur us on to tell more friends, neighbours and work colleagues that our
daughter is lesbian and expecting a baby. Since that meeting we’ve done
this on four occasions, and each time we were very happy about the
responses of our friends/neighbours/work colleagues who were all very
positive/supportive. We think the main value of PFLAG is to encourage
parents and friends of lesbians and gays to ‘come out’ to more and
more people they know and thereby help to lift the pro.le of lesbian and
gay people and issues, to educate and dispel ignorance."
Mother of a gay son I heard about PFLAG through my gay
son. My first meeting was great, friendly and no one had three eyes! I
found companionship, fun, support and education. The hardest things I have
had to deal with have been my own acceptance, telling friends and family,
and prejudice. Some of the best moments have been the way that my
relationship with my gay son has been enriched, that family and friends
have accepted him and that I have met many new people and had the
opportunity of making new friends and helping others. From attending PFLAG
I have gained in con.dence and learned not to care what other people
think, and that people with three eyes do not exist!
WORLD WATCH
World Watch acknowledges the source of these stories as
rainbownetwork.com and pinknews.co.uk
RACE FOR GAMES REGISTRATION Chicago
Organisers of the 2006 Gay Games have announced they now
have more than 10,000 participants from over 45 countries committed to
attending the event. "With just 100 days to go," said Brian
McGuinness, games executive director, "our registration rates remain
ahead of expectations with 12,000 participating athletes and artists
expected to march into the 15 July 2006 opening ceremony".
Registration for the most popular of the 30 sports, golf and sailing, has
closed. Badminton, soccer and ice hockey are nearly full, while tennis,
swimming, volleyball and basketball are running signi.cantly ahead of
projections. The week-long event will also include band, cheerleading and
colour guard performances, chorus, an ancillary arts festival and a series
of community-organised social events and parties.
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN BANNED
IN PRISON Massachusetts
A prison of.cer is facing a disciplinary hearing after
screening Brokeback
Mountain for his inmates. The
film was not on a list of approved video material because it violated
official policy of not showing sexual content. In contrast, a .lm like A
History of Violence, with much
graphic drug abuse and some violence, makes the approved list even after
the .lm was deemed unsuitable for some non-prison audiences in the state
and pulled from a theatre after a customer was shot dead in the lobby
following a screening.
HIV MAN FLEES HIS HOME Edinburgh
Scotland’s longest surviving man with HIV is moving to
London because of a lack of support and constant abuse. Mr Percy, 44, has
lived with HIV for 25 years. "I have been really annoyed by the lack
of support from the Scottish Parliament to improve services and reduce
stigma. I have had eggs thrown at me, people shouting at me in the street
calling me a gay paedophile. I just can’t take it any more. I am angry
that I am having to leave my own country because of this." Scottish
police confirmed there had been complaints from the campaigner about
verbal and physical assault, with some resulting in charges.
COUPLE FIGHT FOR BOTH NAMES ON BIRTH CERTIFICATE Monmouth
County
A superior court judge has denied a lesbian couple’s
request that both of their names be put on their baby son’s birth
certificate. An artificial insemination statute in the state enables a
husband to have his name on his wife’s child’s birth certi.cate if he
has consented to her artificial insemination by another man, though this
is the first time the statute has been tested with regards to gay couples.
The judge said adoption would be a good way to establish parental rights
for both women.
NIGERIA FACING CONDEMNATION Brussels
The Nigerian government is facing condemnation from the
European Parliament over plans to make homosexual marriage illegal and to
ban gay organisations. MEP Michael Cashman (UK), president of the
Intergroup on gay and lesbian rights, accused the government of supporting
a "homophobic" culture and threatening "the lives of
lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender citizens". Gay sex is already
illegal in Nigeria, with the justice minister calling homosexual unions
"unnatural and un-African".
ITALIAN TRANSGENDER LIKELY WINNER Rome
Transgender MP Vladimir Luxuria looks likely to win a seat
in the Italian parliament after the recent elections. A member of the
Refounded Communist Party standing in a staunchly communist constituency,
she had been confronted with homophobia throughout her election campaign.
In one instance 15 men, including former local councillors, pulled out a
banner that read "hammer and sickle yesterday, willy and sickle
today". She has promised to campaign for gay rights as well as
support the economically vulnerable so should be a firm ally of Romano
Prodi, the new Italian Prime Minister who supports gay unions.
NUMBER PLATE FINALLY BANNED London
The number plate H8 GAY (read "hate gay") has
been withdrawn by the British Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency after a
leading gay MP complained. The agency had refused to recall the plate
after a complaint by a member of the public, claiming it was not offensive
on the grounds of "political, racial or religious
sensitivities", but was ordered to reverse its decision by the
Transport Secretary. As one MP said: "If the DVLA sold H8 JEW or H8
WOG, there would rightly be a public outcry. Clearly this goes beyond the
realms of free speech and is a directly and deliberately offensive and
abusive statement."
GAY THEME PARK PLANNED Malaysia
Authorities in Malaysia have given permission for the
construction of "Tongziland", an adults-only theme and amusement
park aimed at affluent gay travellers. Preliminary designs for the park,
due to open at Johor Bahru in 2009, include an authentic Chinese dynastic
palace throne room inhabited by famous gay emperors, a transgender
kickboxing arena, an iron ladies volleyball court, Cinderfella’s
enchanted castle sauna, an old west themed lesbian round-up and a
10-storey tall tower of pride with rotating disco and lasers.
WHEN BEING QUEER MAKES A
DIFFERENCE
by Tor Devereux
Just when you think that life here in New Zealand is
pretty queer-friendly, suddenly little things happen or pop up that remind
us that life for those of us who identify as LGBT/queer isn’t always
quite the same as life for those who identify as straight. Sometimes these
things only impact on a select group within our community, but other
things impact on us all.
A few recent examples that I’ve been aware of are:
• The census form once again failed to collect important
data about our community - male or female were the only options to check
as far as sex was concerned and there was no question about sexual
orientation.
• It has come to light that fertility services
throughout the country do not accept gay men as sperm donors (see story
below for more details). • The negative response by some people to the
NZ AIDS Foundation’s recent poster campaign targeting Maori gay and
bisexual men (see Page 7 for thefull story).
• A Wellington film-maker, Andy Boreham, has been
finding it extremely difficult to secure actors for a NZ AIDS Foundation
advertising campaign (because the actors would be portraying someone who
is gay).
• Despite the Civil Union Act and the Relationships
(Statutory References) Act, same-sex couples are still not allowed to
adopt children. The Relationships Act didn’t include changes to any
legislation that was already being reviewed and, unfortunately, the
Adoption Act has been being reviewed for many years (although no progress
seems to be being made on it!).
• The straight media’s focus on what they regard as
the "low" number of Civil Unions that have taken place in New
Zealand during the first year they have been available and comments that
this suggests that the new legislation was neither needed nor wanted. But,
if there had been thousands of Civil Unions by same-sex couples then they
would be accusing us of entering into legal relationships too quickly and
without enough serious consideration!
So, while we have de.nitely made huge progress in terms of
LGBT/queer rights in this country, there’s still work that needs to be
done – and it’s not always about changing laws but sometimes it’s
more about changing people’s attitudes.
GAY SPERM DONORS
by Tor Devereux
Earlier this year the media revealed that the fertility
services throughout the country do not accept gay men as sperm donors
(according to Ministry of Health regulations). The reason given for this
position was that gay men are a high risk group for HIV and other
diseases. However, since all sperm donors are screened for a variety of
conditions, including HIV, why is it necessary or useful to exclude an
entire group of people, especially when there is a huge need for more
donors? Does this policy actually make sense from a medical or safety
perspective, or is it simply the result of a lack of understanding, fear
and prejudice? Given that within a month or so a nationwide policy change
was announced which would allow gay men to be sperm donors, it would seem
that it was the latter.
However, there are always some who don’t enjoy seeing
gay people being treated equally and fairly under the law and,
consequently, as soon as this policy change was made public there was
suddenly a whole lot of talk about how sperm from gay men would create
more gay children and therefore the recipients of sperm from gay men
should be told about the sexuality of their donor! Could they not come up
with something more original?! If gay people create gay children, then why
do so many of us have straight parents? And, scientists have not proved
anything about a "gay gene" to date. Apart from this obvious,
scientific flaw, there is also another reason why asking sperm donors
their sexuality and revealing that to the recipients is quite meaningless.
This is simply that people come to realise and/or acknowledge their
sexuality at different times in their lives so someone who claims to be
straight at one point in their life might actually come out as gay or
bisexual later on. Therefore, choosing or rejecting a donor on the basis
of sexual orientation is really a bit pointless. Fertility Associate’s
response to all of this was that a question about sexual orientation would
remain on the form that their donors complete, but like the various other
personal questions that are asked, donors are free not to answer it if
they’d prefer not to.
So, another policy that discriminated against LGBT/queer
people has been brought to people’s attention and, in this case,
resolved very quickly and in a positive, fair manner. (If only this was
always the way things worked out!) Well done to all those involved,
especially the gay man in Wellington who went public with this and alerted
us all to what was happening.
HIV Among Gay And Bi Men
Reaches New High
Press Release, NZ AIDS Foundation, 7 March 2006
HIV diagnoses among men-who-have-sex-with-men (MSM) in New
Zealand have hit an all time high, the New Zealand AIDS Foundation
reported today. Last year there were 89 new HIV diagnoses among MSM, the
highest number since the epidemic began and a 19% increase on the previous
highest figure in 2004. It means that in 2005 there was one new infection
among MSM every four days!
The rise is entirely due to an increase in men infected
within New Zealand. Out of the 89 new diagnoses, 66 (74%) were infected
within this country with almost all (94%) living in the North Island,
speci.cally the Auckland region where three out of every four new HIV
diagnoses were reported.
The figures are "deeply disturbing" says NZAF
Board Chair Hoani Jeremy Lambert, "and present a challenge to the
Foundation to ensure it keeps its focus sharply on HIV prevention for
men-who-have-sex-with-men." "However," he said,
"if we are to succeed in turning these figures around we need the
support of the leaders, business operators, community organisations and
individuals in the gay community. In the early days of the HIV epidemic it
was grassroots support for the safe sex message that produced the dramatic
successes in reducing HIV incidence among New Zealand MSM. If we are not
now to see that good work undone, we need to re-energise that community
support."
NZAF Executive Director Rachael Le Mesurier said it was
very worrying that the 2005 statistics pointed to an increase of
unprotected anal intercourse among MSM in spite of an abundance of
knowledge in this community about HIV and the consequences of unsafe sex.
"There is no other explanation for this increase," she said,
"other than the fact that more HIV positive men – whether they know
their status or not – are choosing to have unprotected anal intercourse
and more HIV negative men are choosing to have unsafe sex with men whose
HIV status they don’t know."
Ms Le Mesurier said that further analysis was needed but
it was highly likely that major factors in.uencing the increase would
include: the success of HIV treatments causing people to be less worried
about avoiding HIV, the growth of internet dating which is hugely
increasing the opportunities men have for sex, the integration of the gay
community into the "mainstream" making it harder to target HIV
prevention messages designed for MSM and the eroticisation of unsafe
sex."
"These present real challenges to the
Foundation," she said. "For instance, the diversification and
integration of MSM communities mean we are under pressure to develop a
wider range of very narrowly targeted resources which is hugely demanding
of staff time, resources and finances."
Ms Le Mesurier said the most effective thing that gay men
can do to help turn the HIV statistics around is to end what seems to be a
growing community tolerance of unprotected anal intercourse. "To
quote something I saw on a gay message board the other day – ‘People
need to stop seeing HIV infection as simply problematic. It is a
lifethreatening attack on happiness, health and lifestyle.’ It will
cause you to have to make major
compromises in how you live your life and it is still highly
likely to make you very sick and
kill you."
"‘No condom, no sex’ is a powerful message to
give to prospective sex partners," she said. "If everyone were
to use it, it wouldn’t take long for those who sometimes don’t use
condoms to get the message that people who demand unprotected sex will
always get less sex."
Maori Warriors For Safe
Sex
by Tor Devereux
At the end of February this year the NZ Aids Foundation
(NZAF) launched a new campaign, "Toa Takatapui", aimed at
takatapui tane (Maori men who identify as having same-sex attraction).
According to Eriata Peri, NZAF Hau Ora Takatapui team
leader, "Maori men who have sex with men (MSM) are part of the gay
and bisexual male communities in New Zealand that continue to be
over-represented in New Zealand’s HIV statistics … It is vital, as
takatapui tane, that we take a leadership role in our own communities to
try to turn these .gures around."
The word "toa" means a champion, a warrior or
having valour. Peri claims that "the practice of safe sex is
supported by self-pride, accepting that a warrior looks after himself and
the health of his lovers". But Peri points out that the campaign has
another message too. "It’s also about pride and combating
homophobia. Often, as takatapui tane, we can experience prejudice in the
form of not having our maleness acknowledged. We sometimes .nd that our
birthright, as men, to take male roles on the marae, in our whanau and
communities is challenged by people who don’t understand homosexuality
and the traditional place it had in pre-European Maori society. The use of
haka is a strong message to reinforce the fact that we have pride and
unity as takatapui tane and stand up to take our place as men."
NZAF has come up with many different campaigns over the
years, often targeting a specific group. Generally these campaigns are
provocative, eye-catching and demand our attention – otherwise there
wouldn’t be much point! However, these days they don’t usually create
much controversy or get noticed in the mainstream media. But, this was
exactly what the Toa Takatapui campaign did – and people like John
Tamihere, John Banks and Brian Tamaki decided to make public their
reactions to it.
Not long after the launch of this campaign, John Banks
interviewed Brian Tamaki on Radio Paci.c and asked him about it. Banks and
Tamaki then used the Toa Takatapui campaign as the catalyst to launch
forth on their views about not only about this campaign, but also NZAF and
queer people in general. Interestingly, Banks had as many – if not more
– negative, homophobic and, quite frankly, astounding things to say as
Tamaki. For instance, Banks asked the following: "Well, I .nd
it slightly offensive, as a white man, to see these once-proud warriors
humiliated in this way by the AIDS Foundation as part of their campaign.
Now listen, you and I understand that if these men want to do this, you
know, they need to practise safe sex. But why wouldn’t the AIDS
Foundations encourage them to join Destiny Church, .nd God and behave
themselves?"
During the interview both Banks and Tamaki talked about
their belief that gay men can never be happy in the following exchange:
BANKS: "Well, they can’t be happy, when I look at the sad faces of
all these Maori warriors on this homosexual ad, they can’t, they can’t
be happy getting around behaving in this way, can they?"
TAMAKI: "Well I don’t know how anybody, it doesn’t matter
what their race or colour is, if they’re involved in such practices, how
they can be happy, John, and I don’t think they are, to be quite
honest."
And in his comments just prior to the interview Banks had
these "choice" words to say about the men who are on the poster:
"I’ve never seen so many dead beat losers in one photograph in all
my life, that is outside a Labour Party conference, as these Maori
Warriors for Safe Sex."
Former MP John Tamihere (a self-proclaimed
"red-blooded heterosexual") announced that he was
"offended" by the Toa Takatapui poster. He claimed that the
poster is "an example of Maori culture being used by the gay
community to advance its own agenda" and he accused the gay community
of appropriating the word "takatapui" for its own purposes. For
Tamihere’s information, the campaign was created entirely by Maori men,
all those featured on the poster identify as takatapui tane and the word
"takatapui" means "intimate companion of the same sex"
and it has been used among LGBT Maori since the 1980s.
Obviously people are entitled to their own opinions and
beliefs, but it’s comments and attitudes like this that contribute
signi.cantly to creating a hostile environment for many LGBT/queer people
and their families, and this can have very serious and even disastrous
consequences, especially for those who are in the process of coming out
and/or who are struggling with their sexual or gender identity.
VISIBILITY
by Andrew Metcalfe
It’s meant to be spring, but it is still trying to
snow. After seeking refuge from the bitter cold in a coffee shop
(quite nice, but typical British chain of eateries that tries to look
Italian but still has a monolithic corporate feel) and then scuttling
towards home on Saturday lunchtime, there is a scene in front of me that
you don’t usually see around here. Two men, in the middle of the
pedestrianised High Street, are in a very intense embrace. One of
them is distressed and crying. His mate is holding on and comforting him,
trying to .nd words to say that might make things better. Being brought up
to feel that it’s rude to stare, I hurry by, pausing at the traffic
lights to look back. Still holding on, he is there for his mate for
however long it takes, despite the potential curiosity of passers-by.
It’s one of those scenarios where you would love to know
what was going on, but can only fall back onto imagination. Was it a lost
job, a messed up family encounter, a break up with a girlfriend …
or boyfriend? Who knows! But whatever it was, there was no
shame for them in giving and receiving what they needed for that moment.
Not a typical male (gay or straight) thing to do, I suspect.
It made me think more about a story a friend had told me
the night before at a wee gathering to celebrate a birthday. She had just
come back from San Francisco and had revelled in parts of that city where
diversity of all kinds was celebrated as a normal part of life. At one
stage in her street wanderings she stumbled on a large, impressive-looking
day centre for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people. Rather than
being tucked away on a back street (like it would be in Scotland), it was
visible in every sense of the word - large glass windowed frontages
proclaimed all that went on inside, which happened to be a gathering of
transsexuals/transvestites with the most amazing dresses, handbags and
wigs she had ever seen. They were obviously having a fabulous time. She
could not help but compare it with her neighbourhood in Dundee, where the
only place that a local transvestite could go dressed in all her finery
and not get hassled was the local park – in a nice part of town.
Maybe such things that might seem "out of place"
in the normal run of things are really important. Being man (or woman)
enough to be vulnerable and not hide it all because it’s not the done
thing to do. Being comfortable enough with who you are and what that means
even when it is not what is usually seen around the neighbourhood. I’m
due home soon brie.y in Dunedin after three years away, and I’ll look
with interest to see how much kiwis – especially males - are allowing
themselves to be openly visible. I suspect things may not have progressed
all that much, but who knows? If it can happen in a High Street in
Scotland, why not in the Octagon?
poetry
When The Lion Roars
by Jane E Libeau
When the lion roars
And the eagle soars
The heavens and earth unite
As wings draw near
If the beast does fear
The energies between
Earth and the cosmos .ght.
Where one belongs
Is where one must be
The lion walks the earth
The eagle .ies over the sea
One watches the other
They long to be seen
To know whom the other is
And where they have been.
With lions body
And eagles wings and claws
They .nd the space between
Heaven and earth’s cores.
They join together
Become as one
Land and sky
Are earth and sun.
The connection of these beings
Will satisfy their inner seeing
When one is one
And one the other
They are as close to being
In touch with each other.
As the eagle soars
And the lion roars
They acknowledge the
connection
And are bound to the other.
SARAH WATERS
Award-Winning English
Lesbian Author Visits New Zealand
Sarah Waters Runs Deep by
Anna Chinn
It had to be a phone interview - Sarah Waters was a busy
woman. She had cancelled her Dunedin faceto- face interview with the Otago
Gaily Times, and instead threw us the last small scrap of her time, from
her Auckland hotel room, after all the other media had had a go. It
was a snap decision on her part, but I had nothing better to do and was
ready with my old-fangled Teac micro cassette recorder.
Disappointingly she didn’t sound at all like Daffyd
Thomas, "the only gay in the village" in television’s Little
Britain. But the London-accented
author of Tipping the
Velvet, Af.nity
and Fingersmith
was born and raised in Wales, so
I asked if she’d ever considered setting one of her novels there.
"I haven’t actually. I’m still very connected to
Wales because my family all live there, but I feel very much like a
visitor … Y’know what, I’d .nd it hard to write authoritatively
about the culture now. I don’t know … London for me is such a big,
interesting place, so it’s not that I don’t want to write about Wales
but that I do want to write about London. So, yeah, I haven’t yet, but
you never know."
Where she has set her four novels is, indeed, London - the
first three in lesbian bodice-ripping Victorian times, and her latest, The
Night Watch, which she was here
to promote, in the warripped 1940s. Bodices and, to some extent, lesbians
had gone out of fashion by the 1940s, so this new tale is less of a romp
than her previous efforts.
"It’s a bit of a departure, obviously, from the
other books because of the change of period … It’s very much about
ordinary people living out their lives against the backdrop of war in
London, I suppose."
Not so much of a departure, though, that central
characters are not gay – and not so much that you won’t find her
Waters-marks throughout. "Certainly, people who’ve read it
can see preoccupations of mine. My interest is, well, for one thing, it’s
the physical detail of things, like design and texture, and I think I’ve
carried that over from the other books. And then, obviously, some of the
emotional themes, like betrayal and things that just seem to crop up –
imprisonment."
These are a few of her favourite things. Hmm. Why betrayal
and imprisonment? "I don’t know. Probably I’d need months
of psychoanalysis to pinpoint it exactly – ‘Ever since I was three,’
y’know. But I’m sure all it is, my mum must have locked me in a room
once for half an hour and I’ve turned it into the drama of my life.
[Laughs.] But no, I don’t know why those things keep coming up, except
that I think, for me, they must represent the worst sort of things. I
realised doing The Night
Watch about space – the awful
task of having to share spaces intimately with strangers, which I find
quite a horrible idea. So, I think imprisonment is just the idea that
somebody can lock you up inde.nitely like that. Similarly betrayal, you
know, I think making a real connection with another human being is the
best, best thing, and then betrayal is the absolute negation of
that."
Such universal themes were a clue, but still I had to ask.
Hadn’t Waters been surprised by the popular success of her novels?
"Uh-huh, yeah, I’ve been eminently surprised by how well they’ve
done. How far they’ve reached beyond the gay readership – because
something like Tipping the
Velvet, you know, it got picked
up by lesbian readers quite quickly, and I could understand that. But the
success of the TV adaptation and … I mean, last year a friend of mine
was in WH Smith, which is a big, big, utterly mainstream bookshop in the
UK, and there was a sign on the wall saying, ‘Fingersmith,
the perfect Mother’s Day gift’. I mean, it’s true, people’s
mothers love my books – it’s really weird, and I can’t quite account
for why."
It was time for Sarah Waters to leave New Zealand. She had
been a nice voice - exhausted but suppressing it, and yet thoughtful in
answering questions. She clearly hadn’t had time to rummage through our
tussocks or feel under our river banks for eels - she hadn’t had a
decent tourist experience at all, which I thought a pity. But from London
the world-famous author came, and that great metropolis, she had said, was
enough for her.
Of Closeted Skeletons In
Skeletal London
by Anna Chinn
A review of The
Night Watch by Sarah Waters
(London: Virago, 2006)
While being interviewed for this OGT,
Sarah Waters spoke of the "exhausted landscape" of postwar
London, in which Part One of The
Night Watch is set. And it was
the landscape, or context, of wartime and postwar London that really took
my attention while reading this novel. Rather than its four central
characters, that is. Although three of those four were queer, there was
not enough erotic goodness, shall we say, to nourish me as a "lesbian
reader". Instead, my approach quickly became that of someone
interested in London, history and politics – and voilà, this was a
fascinating read. Waters has done her research, and she details the 1940s
as robustly and assuredly as if she’d lived through them. (Impressive,
given that all the research she did for her previous novels, a trio of
Victorian pastiches, would have been useless for this her fourth project.)
Part One, set in 1947, introduces straight Viv, lesbian
Helen, lesbian Kay and (we suspect) gay Duncan, and hints at the skeletons
in their closets. Meanwhile, Waters gives us a panoramic view of
that exhausted postwar landscape - people are living in near-derelict or
else tiny homes, as if not trusting their arrangements to be permanent,
not expecting stability. Memories of the war inform conversations, and
fears of bombs disturb peacetime minds. This landscape has its own secret
history waiting to be unlocked – for most readers will only have a
passing idea of what London was like during World War 2.
Which brings us to Part Two, set back in time, in 1944 –
bang in the middle of a blitz. The closets of our heroes and heroines
creak open, and we get a good gawk at those skeletons mentioned earlier.
And quite grim – even ghastly – things they are, with litres of blood,
several .ery explosions and a lump of heartache swirling around them. The
landscape, in 1944, is well on its way to exhausted. I never realised just
how much of London was bombed to rubble during the war, nor how difficult
everyday life was made. Waters’ descriptions, with her usual attention
to detail, of hardships such as blackouts, censorship and rationing made
me so glad
to be living here and now instead.
Part Three is set in 1941, and serves simply to tie up the
loose ends. Any remaining queries we had for the author about those
skeletons get answered here. This novel might sound – and is –
quite a departure from Waters’ bodiceripping page-turners. It could
hardly be as bawdy - wartime sucks. And the characters seem to be there
less to entertain and amuse, than to be portals through which we might
enter this unfamiliar world. It is different, yes, but that winning Waters
writing remains.
An Evening With Sarah
Waters
by Barb Long
If only it could have been a whole evening … I could
have continued to listen to this author read more excerpts from her new
novel for quite some time. Sitting at school and being read to was never
so exciting - the teachers can’t have been as gorgeous as the engaging
Sarah Waters!
It was one of those damp misty nights with greying skies,
a reminder that daylight saving time was soon to end, when I joined a full
room at the University Staff Club to listen to an interview with Sarah
Waters. For me it was one of those moments where I experience a sense of
"coming home", that affirmative feeling of being in an
environment where there is a large component of the Dunedin lesbian
community in attendance.
The evening commenced with Sarah having a conversation on
the couch with Professor Jocelyn Harris. Jocelyn was interested in
exploring with her what stimulated the ideas for her novels and frequently
tried to engage her in dialogue about how her academic knowledge had made
an impact on her writing.
Sarah studied English Literature at the universities of
Kent and Lancaster and, after a break, she returned to postgraduate study.
She then gained a PhD in English Literature, her field of study being
lesbian and gay historical fiction. She has also had articles on gender,
sexuality and history published in a number of journals. She was short
listed in 2002 for both the Orange Prize and the Man Booker Prize.
While Jocelyn may have been interested in what Sarah
remembered from first year English, Sarah seemed more eager to tell the
audience about her passion for lesbian and gay literature, particularly
from the late nineteenth century, and how that led to her novels rather
than the structure of her writing.
The room was silent as Sarah read from her new novel The
Night Watch. The passages
she chose were about the ambulance crew and rescue workers travelling to
the scene of an air raid and attending to the family shattered by this
event. Her writing described with such knowingness the composure of Kay,
the strong and capable ambulance officer, and the anxiety of the other
woman worker. The brief glimpse of the novel that we got from this
reading implied that as the story progresses or in the preceding pages
there is a lesbian relationship between these two, or between Kay and
another female character. The passage also conveyed convincingly the
impact and tragedy of air raids. I anticipate that this will be a book I
don’t wish to put down yet will also disturb me in its description of
the horriifc consequences of war.
I can’t remember if the questions from the floor came
before or after the reading from her new novel. But, what clearly remains
with me is the feeling of inspiration that Sarah Waters evoked in me –
here was an author (who I thought was stunning!) who was openly out and
proud, successful, influencing the lives of others and travelling the
country speaking at various events.
"Black Milk":
No Tutus Here
Review by Terry
I doubt anyone would go to a Douglas Wright performance
expecting pretty eye-candy, but Black
Milk tested even the strongest
stomachs, and it was no surprise that several Dunedinites walked out. Yet
this work, born of an agonising year for the HIV-positive choreographer, is as powerful an artistic expression of
personal and political philosophy as they are ever likely to see.
Those who stayed were challenged by images of our world, domestic and global, which we would prefer to ignore.
Performance art took over from "pure" dance as the company
enacted powerfully symbolic scenes of birth, death and the horrors humans
inflict on each other. We were led on this remarkable journey by the
disturbing figures of a puppet master and his dummy – manifestations
perhaps of Douglas as man and child.
Dance is the most corporal of arts and we were invited to consider the human body stripped of its coverings –
first
as a superbly controlled and con.dent woman confronted us, with tossing
hair and flashing scissor blades, then later (and horribly) as the
company cowered through the degradation forced on naked prisoners
in a ghastly scenario all too reminiscent of recent coverage
from Baghdad – no tutus here!
Not that we were deprived of lyricism. There were some
beautiful sequences of fluid voluptuous movement, of impeccably
trained bodies twisting, falling and leaping with hypnotic grace. There
was humour, too, as the dummy squeakingly voiced the secret thoughts
of many of the less dance-literate: "Why are they running into a semi-circle? How can that girl fall and
get up so quickly? Why has the other girl joined her? Do they know each other? What will the
reviewers say?!?"
But the overpowering images, the ones that seared the eyeballs and burn on in the mind,
were the sickening depictions of torture and degradation, the brutalising effect on prisoner
and guard of the jails of Iraq. Artaud’s Theatre of Cruelty would recognise this theatre form. It
is disturbing, but the impact is undeniable.
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
Review by Tor Devereux
I hadn’t been to the movies for a couple of years (this can happen
easily when you’re a parent!), but I really wanted to see Brokeback
Mountain on
the big screen. It’s rare that Hollywood makes films with gay themes, and even more rare
that they are nominated for and win major mainstream awards. So, I knew that this was a "must see", even if just
to satisfy my curiosity. Consequently, with the kids well cared for, Barb and
I set off to the movies one Sunday afternoon. And, I’m happy to reportthat I wasn’t disappointed (although
I was somewhat taken aback by the price of the outing!).
After a movie people often ask the question, "Did you enjoy it?" My
answer to this question in regard to
Brokeback Mountain would
have to be a resounding "No". This doesn’t mean that the film isn’t beautifully
and insightfully created, or that it isn’t stunning visually, or that it doesn’t
sustain the viewer’s interest, or that it fails to tell an important story. Indeed,
Brokeback Mountain achieves
all of these – and more. I am very pleased that I went to see the film, I think it’s
wonderful that this story has been told in such a public and sensitive way and
it touched me very much emotionally – but definitely not in a way that I
would describe as "enjoyment".
I’m not going to write much about the plot of the .lm because I suspect
that most readers of the OGT will have been to see the .lm already or will have read about it elsewhere. I
thought that it was essential, though, to include some comment about it here
because of the impact and success this film has had, not only within our LGBT/queer community but within the
straight community as well.
So, why was Brokeback
Mountain
so important for our community? I believe that it was important because it tells some of our history, shows the
reality of gay love in that time and place, and highlights the strength of
true (gay) love despite an incredible number of odds. Brokeback
Mountain
has been dubbed the "gay cowboy movie" and indeed it is about the
relationship between two cowboys - Ennis Del Mar and Jack Twist - in Wyoming starting in the early 1960s.
The film then traces the relationship between Ennis and Jack over the next 20 years or so and we learn that
there is definitely no smooth course for this love, despite its intensity and
resilience. It is a love that is repressed and restricted because of its nature
and the culture and attitudes within which it exists.
The physical wilderness and the landscape in Brokeback
Mountain echo the relationship between Ennis and
Jack that brings so much hardship and pain, as well as being enriching and
enduring. Both the landscape and the love are epic and stunning, but also hard and uncompromising. Jack can
imagine a life together with Ennis, but Ennis believes with all his heart that
their feelings must remain a secret. He has seen firsthand what can happen
to gay men, and he feels that the only way to get through life is to subscribe
to the heterosexual paradigm, although he continues his relationship with Jack
in secret as they get together a few times each year when they go away on so-called
fishing trips. "Whoa, whoa, whoa. It ain’t goin a be that way. We can’t. I’m stuck with what I got, caught
in my own loop. Can’t get out of it. Jack, I don’t want a be like them guys
you see around sometimes. And I don’t want a be dead."
This love is certainly a tragic one, but at no point does the
film become sentimental. It is raw and real, with moments of humour. It reminds us how
far we’ve come in terms of acceptance of gay relationships in the last thirty
to forty years, but it also reminds us that people are still harassed, abused,
tortured and even killed because of who they are and who they love.
Brokeback Mountain the
film was adapted from the short story of the same name by Annie Proulx. The
movie follows the short story quite faithfully while fleshing out Proulx’s
rather stark yet vivid writing. What she captures in a page or two may take
up quite some time on the big screen, but both versions are intense, gripping
and moving for the reader or viewer. "One thing never changed: the brilliant
charge of their infrequent couplings darkened by the sense of time flying,
never enough time, never enough."
Brokeback Mountain was
nominated for numerous awards and ended up winning a decent number as well,
including the following:
• Golden Globes: Best Drama, Best Director, Best Screenplay and Best
Original Song
• Oscars: Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay and Best Score
• BAFTAs: Best Film, Best
Director, Best Supporting Actor and Best Adapted Screenplay
• 2005 Venice International Film Festival: First Prize
• The Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD) awarded top
honours to Brokeback
Mountain and its director, Ang Lee
In addition to winning three Oscars,
Brokeback Mountain was
nominated in a further five categories, including Best Picture which it was touted to win.
When it didn’t pick up the Oscar in this category some people speculated that
Hollywood simply wasn’t quite ready to give the ultimate Oscar to a gaythemed
film. I wasn’t surprised that the
film didn’t win Best Picture at the Oscars, but after seeing the film what
did surprise me (in a pleasant way, of course!) was how many awards it did
win. I suspect – or perhaps I should say hope – that this film has opened
doors in regard to movies that tell "gay stories" by showing that
they can be successful at the box office and win awards too.
CAPOTE - THE OTHER MOVIE
Review by Mike Wooliscroft
Over recent months the movie Brokeback
Mountain has
commanded a great deal of attention in all media: magazine and newspaper articles giving context to the
film rendition of Annie Proulx’s novella, television interviews with actors and commentators, list-serv discussions
doing the same and providing reflections on the experience of seeing the movie, reviews
and all manner of hype about the awards it might/might not receive and now Annie Proulx
expressing bitterly – sour grapes surely – her disappointment that Brokeback
Mountain did not receive more awards.
Through this time another masterful movie has been just a bit in the shade by comparison.
This is the movie Capote
which focuses on a major period in Truman Capote’s mature life
when he researched, investigated and analysed the brutal murder of a family in Kansas by two
mixed-up and impulsive young men – Perry Smith and Dick Hickock.
In writing about his investigation and research over a period of many years, Capote
produced a new kind of genre which he termed a "non-fiction novel" or, to put it another way,
literary non-fiction. What he meant by this was that he would bring a creative artist’s eye to the
selection of material to be included while using journalistic skills and producing the literary style
and structure of a fictional work.
The resulting book, In
Cold Blood, was an overnight critical and .nancial success and has
remained a high point of Capote’s career and still stands tall in this particular genre. John
Berendt’s masterful Midnight
in the Garden of Good and Evil,
which investigates another killing in Savannah, is another worthy example with gay
characters in major roles. It, too, was turned into a movie.
Capote the movie
has drawn heavily from Gerald Clarke’s .ne Capote:
A Biography (1988).
Clarke also more recently collected and edited
the letters of Truman Capote in Too
Brief A Treat
(2004) which allows us to venture into the fine wit (often biting) of this master of words and
insights into human behaviour – alas not often enough his own.
Philip Seymour Hoffman, who plays Capote, is not like Capote in a physical sense but in
the movie he has his mannerisms off-pat – his mincing, his particularly high-pitched voice
and spoken cadences so it is not too difficult to imagine we are seeing the real person playing
himself. Hoffman has well deserved his various awards for best actor.
The crux of the movie is the ethical dilemma Capote finds himself with when he falls at least
a bit in love with one of the murderers and provides support in gaining at least one appeal
and mentors the young man, but then as he progresses with his magnum opus on the killings
realises that it is only through the young men’s executions that he will be able to complete
his book. And so the seemingly supportive relationship becomes one of deceit. The tension
makes for compelling viewing.
Another film has recently been made of the mature phase in Capote’s life with the British
actor Toby Jones as Capote. Its release has been delayed until later this year so as not to compete
too fiercely with the movie being reviewed. And, as if this were not enough, there is also
a recent "graphic novel" by Ande Parks and Chris Samnee called Capote
In Kansas: A Drawn Novel. In addition, Capote’s previously
unpublished first novel,
Summer Crossing,
has just been published by Penguin so it is a real season of Capote.
If you have not yet seen
Capote I can
assure you it makes for rewarding viewing.
The Real Bennett
Review by Mike Wooliscroft
Alan Bennett - writer, playwright, satirist, essayist, comedian - for many years did not intend to write a
substantive volume of memoirs though in 2000 he read for the BBC ten snapshots from his childhood which were
subsequently published as Telling
Tales (2000).
Bennett’s inclination changed when he was diagnosed with cancer in 1997 and given a 50:50 chance
of recovery. Many of the pieces in this volume were written through the period of his convalescence. A few
years later, unhappy with his "somewhat
speculative" biography by Alexander Games, Backing
Into The Limelight: The Biography Of Alan Bennett (2001),
this intention was reinforced and led to his decision to open up rather more about his private and family life
in addition to reiterating his responses to many things in the fabric of British society and culture about which
he has informed and valued opinions – often deliciously expressed.
In Untold
Stories (London: Faber/Profile, 2005) Bennett writes
about his family with considerable candour and tenderness combined. His mother’s deterioration with
senile dementia is movingly and honestly told, including his own reactions and the
difficulties of visiting her during the particularly bad periods.
In Written
On The Body, the second section of this volume,
Bennett writes for the first time with some frankness about his sexuality – his schoolboy obsessions and (until now)
secret desires. He states, "I was generally in love, always unhappily, always with my own sex, and seldom
with any physical outcome." It is almost a relief
that he then tells us that in his 50s he connected with a loving partner Rupert, 30 years his junior. As he writes, "I
can’t quite boast that it’s an ordinary life, or, my parent’s ambition, a life like other people’s. But it does for
us."
Untold Stories provides
a selection of Bennett’s diaries from 1996 through 2004 which make entertaining
and thought-provoking reading,
including his comments on radio and television, art and architecture, theatre and
plays. Untold
Stories is a welcome addition to Writing
Home (first
published in 1994 and then republished in 2003) which contains similar miscellanies of Bennett’s
work.
Untold Stories is
probably a book best dipped into, sampling sections of particular interest to individual
readers, guided by chapter headings and the index, rather than being read through solidly over its
658 pages. However, throughout Bennett writes very well indeed and readers would miss much if they were to
skim through lightly.
|