Return to Back Issues

Issue 37: August-October 2003

Editorial

Letter to the Editor

Queer Quiz

Ruby's Rave

Letters from America

Queer History- Sappho

As I See It

PFLAG Report

Better To Bend Than Be Bent

Need a Lawyer?

Caledonian Reflections- Occasional Ramblings From Scotland

I Am What I Am!

NZAF South- Te Toka

Out To Lunch???

New Zealand Politics

Dunedin Rainbow Labour Branch- Update

Adoption By Same Sex Couples in New Zealand

Pride Week 2003 In Review

Pride Dunedin Youth- Where It's At

UniQ Otago

Rainbow Families

A Walk on the Queer Side

Are You Feeling Left Out?

PFLAG Office

Purple Passions 2003

Poetry

Book Reviews

Christchurch Lesbian Ball

Gay & Lesbian Archives

Out Takes 2003

The Word Out There

Queer Quiz Answers

 

Issue #32

This issue of the OGT was paid for by advertising from the following businesses:

 

The Last Footwear Company

9 George Street

Dunedin

477-4369

 

Global Pacific Distributors NZ Ltd (Vigorex)

PO Box 51-052

Pakuranga, Auckland

021-134-6132

[email protected]

 

R&R Sport

70 Stuart Street

Dunedin

474-1211

www.rrsport.co.nz

 

Nicola Brown, Psychology Associates

124 Musselburgh Rise

Dunedin

455-5622

[email protected]

 

Gray’s Studio

201 North Road

North East Valley, Dunedin

473-7774

[email protected]

 

Public Health South

57 Hanover Street, Dunedin

474-1700

 

Relationship Services

18 Princes Street, 3rd Floor

Dunedin

477-6766 or 0800 RELATE

 

Planet Pancake

134 Princes Street, Dunedin

471-7227

 

University Book Shop

378 Great King Street, Dunedin

477-6976

www.unibooks.co.nz

 

Bodyworks Club

284 Princes Street, Dunedin

477-8228

 

Presence

334 George Street, Dunedin

471-9000

www.dunedin-direct.co.nz/presence

 

The Break

1 Great King Street, Dunedin

477-2732

Editorial

by Victoria Devereux, Editor

 

Well, autumn has truly arrived in Dunedin and winter isn't far away now. However, that's no reason to hibernate away inside! As you'll see from this issue of the OGT there are plenty of things happening here in the south for the queer community. Indeed, the community seems to be quite buzzing at the moment with lots of energy, groups and planned events, so please support them and enjoy yourselves at the same time.

 

The material in this OGT illustrates very well, I think, the current situation for the queer community in New Zealand. On the one hand our country is a fairly laid back place and we as LGBT/queer people have access to our own culture and events. Locally the Out Takes gay and lesbian film festival is coming up soon in Dunedin and then next month there's Pride Week - not to mention all the regular activities that happen like FUNQ, Ascent social gatherings, UniQ and WAQD lunches, the queer walking group, etc. But, on the other hand, we've still got a long way to go to ensure that all members of our community can be safe just being who they are. For example, there's work to be done to make our schools safe places for both queer students and teachers (although the PPTA and individual schools have done a lot in this area). And, there are still a large number of laws in this country that blatantly discriminate against LGBT/queer people - for example the adoption act.

 

Some of the issues or areas that still need our attention may not affect or concern us directly as individuals, but it's important that we look wider than our own personal lives and consider these from the perspective of our community. Just because some people don't want to adopt a child or have their same-sex relationship legally recognised doesn't mean that they shouldn't have the right to do so, or that they shouldn't support others in the queer community being allowed to do this. It's all about the freedom to choose, being treated equally under the law and respecting each other and our differences.

 

The following quote is one that I've always found very powerful and it underlines the importance of supporting one another: "In Germany they came first for the Communists, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Communist. Then they came for the Jews, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Jew. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a trade unionist. Then they came for the Catholics, and I didn't speak up because I was a Protestant. Then they came for me, and by that time no one was left to speak up." (Martin Niemoeller)

 

So, over the next few months celebrate being LGBT/queer and enjoy the activities being offered to the community - but please don't get too complacent and think that all the battles have already been fought and won.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Queer Quiz

 

1. Who starred as a woman masquerading as a drag queen in "Victor/Victoria"?

2. What is the theme for FUNQ in June?

3. Who said: "Everyone is born naked and after that, everything is drag"?

4. Virginia Woolf's Orlando and Radclyffe Hall's Well of Loneliness were both published in which year?

5. Who are the presenters this year on "Queer Nation"?

Answers 

Top of the Page 

 

Ruby's Rave

by Miss Ruby

 

Feathers, sequins, sequins, feathers, feathers, sequins, seq………oh!!!

 

Hello Darlings

 

Sorry about that - I was in a Ruby Reverie. Well, this is the first of my raves and I’ll try to bore you all to diamonds. It’ll be a bit of this and a bit of that - whatever I’m in the mood for.

 

This little city of ours has got very exciting all of a sudden what with FUNQ (and isn’t it going off like an Italian Stallion - lots of kisses for Nathan and the team), COQ on Toast (sounds rather appealing doesn’t it), Rainbow Campers (well done to Cheryl and Alex) and the parties. Well, a girl can hardly keep up with it all, it’s either a flood or a drought here in the south. I’d rather have a flood myself, all that dryness isn’t good for one’s skin. So I hope you are all taking advantage of the ample opportunities to go out and let loose a bit of queer madness.

 

Warm fuzzies, Dunedin is just brimming over with them, everyone happy and getting along, lesbians and gays holding hands and skipping down Queerberry Lane, just fabulous. Not so in the rest of the country, so appreciate what we’ve got sweeties.

 

But there seems to be a lack of “Sisters of the Very Sequin” out there; hopefully Queen of the South in August will bring them out. Good to see Oceania at Pacific Paradise - well done girl - and where’s Lady Timara gone off to, get ya heels on girl! Any others wanting to be ordained into the sisterhood just come and see moi.

 

On the other foot, though, lots of “Kings” have sprung up to fill the gap, not to mention fab dance groups. I’m still feeling weak at the knees from watching the “Brown Family” shake their thing at Pacific Paradise. Great to see a variety on the stage and not just the some sad old queen shakin’ the same frock different song for the 10th time.

 

Talked to Missy and the Bag Lady the other day. They’re sunning it up in Keri Keri, growing swine and foul and having a raucous time. They’ve only been there two months and are already ingrained in the community and strutting their stuff.

 

Well darlings, that’s all from me this time. Do email me (at [email protected]) with any funny stories about our community that I could include in my rave. Stay happy, stay safe but most of all stay Fabulous until next time.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Out Takes Film Festival 2003

by Victoria Devereux

 

Out Takes is back … and it’s even bigger and better than before! This is the third year that Reel Queer (the Wellington-based organisation that organises Out Takes) has brought a selection of the Out Takes festival films to Dunedin. The success of the previous two mini-festivals down here has meant that Dunedin has continued to be included in the programme which is awesome.

 

This year Out Takes Dunedin includes 9 different screenings between Friday June 13 and Sunday June 15. The festival is being run at The Academy (50 Dundas St) and ticket prices are $10.50 adults and $8.50 concession. Tickets for Out Takes films can be purchased in advance from May 19 onwards. The Academy only seats 60 people, so booking in advance is probably a good idea if you don’t want to be disappointed. (Remember that in previous years many of the films have been sold out.)

 

Out Takes provides a wonderful opportunity for us to enjoy a wide range of queer cinema and indulge ourselves in a weekend of queer culture on the big screen. There’s quite a variety of material in the festival, so hopefully there’s at least one or two screenings that take your fancy! Mark your calendars now and make sure that all your friends know about Out Takes.

 

Here’s the schedule of films for Out Takes Dunedin followed by a brief outline of each of them. (A special thanks to Gavin, Kim and Simon of Reel Queer for all their work on the festival and for putting together these blurbs.)

 

Friday June 13

7:00pm

Ruthie and Connie (preceded by You 2)

77 mins

 

9:00pm

Nine Dead Gay Guys

90 mins

Saturday June 14

4:00pm

Reservoir Dykes (short films)

73 mins

 

6:00pm

Where The Boys Are (short films)

77 mins

 

8:00pm

Between Two Women

92 mins

 

10:00pm

The Sex Hour (short films)

71 mins

Sunday June 15

3:00pm

Dyke-u-mentaries (documentaries)

90 mins

 

5:00pm

Queen Of The Whole Wide World

82 mins

 

7:00pm

The Truth About Jane

87 mins

 

Ruthie and Connie (USA, 2002) - In 1959 Ruthie and Connie had been housewives and best friends for 18 years in a close-knit Jewish community in Brooklyn. Then the unthinkable happened - they fell in love. A major award-winner, this inspirational documentary traces the lives two feisty women who risked all for their love. This is a wonderful tale about two lively and inquisitive women who love life and each other – and who bicker like mad.

 

You 2 (The Netherlands, 2001) - The Surinamer culture is tolerant and laid back – all is fine and well as long as no one talks about it. In this fictional take on a very real dilemma, Sandra thinks she has a lot to lose by coming out to her mother and their close-knit community.

 

Nine Dead Gay Guys (UK, 2002) - Not for the politically correct, this outrageous caper is the story of Kenny and Byron, two rent boys from Belfast stumbling through London’s underground gay scene in search of gainful employment to subsidise their giros. When their principal source of income meets an untimely end, they are forced to look elsewhere. It is then that they hear of a stash of money that one of their clients, an orthodox Jew, keeps in his bed. Along the way they have to deal with an angry dwarf and several well-endowed African boys, among others – and all the while the dead gay bodies keep piling up …

 

Reservoir Dykes (a selection of short films) - Imagine if lesbians were in charge of Hollywood … Marilyn Monroe and Bette Davis would star in an elaborate Sapphic musical called Stealing Horses (USA, 1998, 4 mins). Medieval machinations would be between Eleanor and her mistress in The Strawberry Harvest (UK, 2001, 25 mins). The lesbo-erotic subtext of Disney fairytales would take centre stage as a Helpless Maiden Makes An I Statement (Canada, 2000, 6 mins) while handcuffed in a dungeon. Cinemas would screen From Queer To Eternity, Taxi Lesbian, Good Faigolas and Reservoir Dykes (USA, 2002, 8 mins). Fairytales would be wild and wacky as four Pretty Ladies (USA, 2002, 30 mins) let us indulge in their individual night time fantasies – where everyone gets their girl.

 

Where The Boys Are (a selection of short films) - This collection of boys shorts kicks off with three hysterical – and vicious – scene queens preparing for a night out in I Hate Faggy Fag Fag (USA, 2000, 10 mins), followed by a nerdy 12 year old’s ode Jan Michael Vincent Is My Muse (USA, 2002, 6 mins). A man confronts his childhood fears in the poignant and beautiful Contact (Australia, 2002, 17 mins), while Hung Frankenstein (USA, 2002, 16 mins) is a creature of inhuman proportions. During a weekend trip Mads has to deal with how Kristian loses his innocence in Summer Blues (Norway, 2002, 25 mins). And, finally, the cute young things in LTR (USA, 2002, 16 mins) have been together for two weeks … could this be the elusive Long Term Relationship?

 

Between Two Women (UK, 2001) - It is 1957. Ellen Hardy is unhappily married but is close to her ten year old son Victor. Suffocated by the working class mores of small town Huddersfield both Ellen and Victor focus their attentions on local schoolteacher Kathy, who is keen to encourage Victor’s art. As the friendship between the women grows, Ellen is torn between her duties as a wife and mother and a fear of admitting her own true feelings for Kathy. The burgeoning relationship between the two women marks the start of Ellen’s journey beyond a loveless marriage and the stifling conventions of Huddersfield.

 

The Sex Hour (a selection of films) - Hot Brazilian boys and cool nights on Hampstead Heath feature in this steamy collection for the boys. The Sex Hour (Brazil, 2001, 4 mins) is the best time of the day – when the boyfriend gets home from a hard day’s work and needs some relaxing. Leo is a hustler who steals from his pimp, getting himself into way too much trouble in Fake Vuitton (Brazil, 2002, 16 mins). And, finally, The Truth About Gay Sex (UK, 2001, 51 mins) is a comprehensive look at the ins and outs of everything gay men do to get off. Whatever your personal fetish or desire, it is likely explained here. Doctors, sex parlour owners and proficient practitioners use charts, diagrams, raw video footage and the odd watermelon to show how it’s all done.

 

Dyke-u-mentaries (a selection of documentaries)

Body: A Woman’s Definition (USA, 2002, 41 mins) – This surprisingly moving film follows eight lesbian body builders from their gyms in San Francisco to the 1998 Gay Games. As these striking women talk about how becoming increasingly muscular transformed their lives, it becomes clearer why they stick to the rigorous and sometimes contradictory discipline of women’s body building.

 

No Dumb Questions (USA, 2001, 24 mins) - A funny and heart-warming documentary in which three sisters (aged 6, 9 and 11) struggle to understand why and how their Uncle Bill is becoming Aunt Barbara.

 

Lesbian In Kautokeino (Norway, 2001, 25 mins) - Marjit Buljo was driven away from her village three years ago and courageously travels back to try and heal the wounds. A fascinating insight into the Sami culture in a remote part of Norway.

 

Queen Of The Whole Wide World (USA, 2001) - Warning! This film is highly contagious. This spirited drag-umentary follows the trials and tribulations of the seven semi-finalists competing for the Queen of the Whole Wide World title in Los Angeles, a send-up spoof of the Miss America pageant. No matter that Miss Antarctica is snow blind and needs a seeing-eye walrus, that Miss Saudi Arabia has to wear her swimsuit over her clothes or that Miss Norway is a black muscleman, the proceeds go to raise a bundle for people living with HIV and AIDS. Each queen pulls out all the stops in their quest to win the coveted title of Queen of the Whole Wide World.

 

The Truth About Jane (USA, 2000) - A close mother/daughter relationship goes haywire when daughter Jane comes out. Jane is an everyday, ordinary girl at high school and things are going fine. Then she meets the new-girl-on-the-block Taylor and slides headlong into confusion and love. An obscene phone call and an outrageous excuse later, Jane comes out, only to find it doesn’t end there. She discovers she also has to deal with the reaction of her mother, father and peers.

Top of the Page 

 

 

The Word Out There

 

The Word Out There is a column in the OGT that's all about finding out what different people in our community think about certain issues. In each issue of the OGT we ask a range of queer/GLBT individuals a question and print their answers.

 

QUESTION:  What issues do you think you will face as you age as a GLBT/queer person?

 

Barb, lesbian, 35 years old

The concept of ageing raises more questions than answers for me. It leads me to contemplate power of attorney papers, my health and mortality, and my place in the “community”. As I age will there be an increasing number of people who assume my sexuality to be straight? Will it take more energy to out myself as a 70 year old than as a 30 year old? Will the queer community include me in their ideology of lesbian? Financial planning for retirement is promoted, but where does one go for guidance about everything else associated with growing old and at what stage of my life will I accept this term?

 

Nathan, gay man, 23 years old

Ageing for me now means where I think I will be at 35. Once I get to that milestone, I expect that I will start to have ideas about what life might really be like when I start to age. In the meantime when retirement enters the conversation over a bottle of bubbly visions of lonely, wealthy, dirty, old men with gardener toy boys always seem to surface.

 

Wendy, lesbian, 52 years old

A bit thought provoking this one … Through each significant stage in my life I have gathered people and activities around me which support and nurture the changes and challenges of each new era. The issues for me, I would also see as significant for all women as they grow older. As a woman, menopause, lifestyle and body image adjustments are significant and will become interwoven into my understanding of myself as a lesbian woman.

But hey, I’m only 52, so I might be wrong!

 

Grant, gay man, 24 years old

The main issue for me is being single. As I get older singlehood becomes more of a hole you’re stuck in; the older you get the deeper the hole seems to get, especially as peers pair up around you. And, as a Drag Queen, people can find it hard to separate the person from the persona so never get to know the person. Another issue for me is the queer community as a whole; as I age and our community becomes more accepted and mainstream the need for “community” may become less and less. So, a commitment to the community as a fantastic entity that needs protecting from complacency and neglect is an issue for me, as I get older.

 

Sarah, lesbian, 18 years old

"Child" as I am, I can only really bear to look at this in terms of the next  decade or so. I suppose one issue that I see ahead is my hope for a gay/lesbian community which I can be involved in where a "party" culture isn't a given. Other than that is what the future holds in terms of "out"ness within the workplace - it would be nice if there could an environment unlike the frustrating "we know but we won't talk about it" attitude I found throughout secondary school.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Being Queer At Work

by Marie Metcalfe

 

Always the feeling, do I tell? Should I tell? What will it mean for me? To be out is to stop the lying, stop the hiding. But to be out is to risk being stared out, gossiped about, hassled. It’s a hard decision, and it depends a lot on the situation - company policy, co-workers’ expectations, informal norms … I have only come out in one workplace situation, and that was only after my co-worker came out to me! Somehow it made it a lot easier.

 

In other situations, I have just smiled and given my usual vague answer to the usual question, oh so do you have a boyfriend? I’ve ignored a lot of homophobic jokes, thinking the hassle is just not worth it. I’ve even ignored it when people hassled other co-workers for “looking” gay. By doing so, I kept myself safe, I never got hassled. But by ignoring these behaviours, I myself perpetuated the heterosexism, condoned the homophobia.

 

Sometimes I get so angry that it’s an issue, that I have to make this decision. We live in New Zealand already, theoretically, a pretty progressive society on queer issues. Our legislation’s not too bad, at least compared to other countries. Under the Human Rights Act it is illegal to discriminate on the grounds of sexual orientation, whereby sexual orientation is defined as heterosexual, homosexual, lesbian or bisexual orientation. This applies to the areas of employment, accommodation, provision of goods and services, access to public services and education. It is also illegal to sexually harass anyone, including harassment on the basis of sexual orientation. Sounds great, eh?! Well, except for all those people whose sexual identities don’t fit into those categories … the law does not ban discrimination against transgender and intersex people, as well as Maori and Pacific Island sexual and/or gender identities such as takataapui, fa’afafine, mahu and fakafafine.

 

So, does the reality of being queer at work reflect the legislation? Sometimes, sometimes not. For my dissertation proposal, I looked at queer women’s experiences at work. The research is pretty sparse, especially in relation to New Zealand, but they all agree on one thing: discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation in employment continues to exist in New Zealand.

Raven (1992) conducted interviews with 23 lesbians who were employed by the Department of Social Welfare The interviewees reported regular harassment related to their sexual identity, which included “complaints about unfeminine clothing appearances, discrediting of professional performance, the threat of allegations of sexual misconduct against clients, concerns about biased and “unprofessional” judgements, and sexual harassment”. In order to “survive” in the workplace, interviewees outlined two main coping strategies. Firstly, they could become “well-behaved” by adjusting their opinions and appearances. Alternatively, they could become high achievers for the organisation in an effort to make their sexual identity a secondary issue in the workplace.

 

Atmore (1990) investigated how six self-identified lesbians represented their workplace experiences, particularly in relation to their sexual, class and ethnic identities. None of the women were completely closeted in their current jobs, nor were any completely out. Their decision to come out depended on the perceived costs and benefits, which were dependent upon the work environment and the type of political beliefs they held. Some of the costs included harassment and being defined solely in terms of their sexual identity. As one respondent commented, “I’d have to be a full-time lesbian … the authority on matters lesbian, have a sense of humour but also have a firm jaw 24 hours of a working day”. Does this sound familiar to anyone?! The benefits included an improved situation, an alleviation of some of the costs of being closeted, not being seen as a potential romantic partner and being able to talk about their lives outside work.

 

Rankine’s survey (1997) is the most comprehensive account of lesbian and bisexual women’s experiences of discrimination in New Zealand. The results reveal that, in general, 75% of respondents had experienced verbal harassment because of their sexual identity. In addition, 8% of the women reported regular verbal abuse, 14% experienced physical assault, 32% had been threatened with violence and 62% feared for their safety at least once. Maori women were more likely to have experienced verbal abuse, assault and threats of violence than Pakeha or immigrant women.

 

With regards to employment, 63% of respondents have hidden their sexual identity at work in order to avoid workplace discrimination. Respondents used a range of tactics to hide their sexual identity, including dressing in “feminine” clothes, not bringing their partner to work functions, hiding or not displaying books, posters or domestic items related to lesbianism in their homes and avoiding discussing or defending homosexuality with heterosexual co-workers. Other tactics for avoiding discrimination included moving to a more tolerant locale and socialising mainly or exclusively with gay, lesbian and bisexual people (Rankine, 1997).

 

In terms of workplace discrimination, 9% reported being dismissed because of their sexual identity, 5% indicated that they had been refused a job, 8% had been denied promotion and 22% were harassed. In addition, 31% of respondents reported being treated differently than heterosexual co-workers and 40% were treated differently by heterosexual co-workers. Maori women were more likely to be dismissed from a job, denied a job or promotion and/or harassed because of their sexual identity than Pakeha and immigrant women (Rankine, 1997).

 

References:

Atmore, C. (1990). “Everything Isn’t For Everybody”: Some Experiences Of Being Lesbian In The Workplace. Victoria University: Wellington.

 

Rankine, J. (1997). The Great Late Lesbian And Bisexual Women’s Discrimination Survey. Discrimination Survey: Auckland.

 

Raven, A. (1992). “Lesbians And Equal Employment Policy In The State Sector”. In C. Briar, R. Munford, & M. Nash, Superwoman, Where Are You? Social Policy And Women’s Experience. Dunmore Press: Palmerston North.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Gay Queenstown

 

Recently a gay Queenstown web page has been set up to provide information about Queenstown to the gay community within New Zealand and overseas. Accommodation and activities can be booked from the web page and there’s other information there too about things such as dining out and shopping.

 

As the web page says, “With a name like Queenstown you should already feel at home and we even have streets with names such as Camp, Shotover and Man.” So, if you’re thinking about a trip away or know people who are travelling to Queenstown, then check out www.gayqueenstown.com

Top of the Page 

 

 

PFLAG Office

 

PFLAG (Parents, Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays) now has an office. Here are the details:

 

1st floor, 326 Moray Place, Dunedin (within the offices of the Dunedin Methodist Mission)

Office telephone: 477-2000

Help line: 025-686-9304

Email: [email protected]

Postal address: PO Box 5266, Dunedin

Hours: 10am to 2pm on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays

Top of the Page 

 

 

Coming Out As Transgender

 

The following is taken from the website of the Human Rights Campaign, a national American organisation that works for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender equal rights (www.hrc.org/ncop/).

 

Just as many gay, lesbian and bisexual people come out about their sexual orientations, some people examine, redefine and acknowledge their gender identities, or how they understand their gender as a man, woman or somewhere in between.

 

Some people say they have felt trapped in the wrong body for as long as they can remember and, at an early age, redefine their gender. Others don't come out until middle age and still others don't realize or aren't able to be honest with themselves until they are seniors. Whenever or however a person comes out, it is important to remember that gender varies and many people don't fit neatly into one narrow definition.

 

There are many different ways that transgender people identify themselves, including as a transsexual or simply as transgender. Transgender is an umbrella term that describes anyone expressing characteristics that don't correspond with those traditionally ascribed to the person's sex or presumed sex, as well as transsexual people and cross-dressers. It is not a sexual orientation. Unlike sex, which is biological and based on characteristics such as reproductive organs and chromosomes, gender is a social construct and can be displayed by appearance and behavior, including clothing, hairstyles, even the way a person walks. Society creates masculine and feminine gender roles that people are expected to follow. These roles are fairly set and most people notice when they are crossed.

 

Whether or not they identify as transgender, many gay, lesbian, bisexual and straight people transgress traditional gender roles. A straight female with short hair who is often called "sir" in public, a boyish-looking lesbian who is questioned in the women's bathroom, a gay teenager who is reprimanded for "not acting like a man" - all face bias based on preconceived notions of gender. The more people see how gender varies, the more people will embrace laws that treat people equally regardless of their gender exhibition.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Prostitution Reform Bill

by Victoria Devereux

 

The Prostitution Reform Bill is a Private Member's Bill sponsored by Tim Barnett MP. It aims to decriminalise prostitution and create a legal framework that:

safeguards the human rights of sex workers and protects them from exploitation

promotes the welfare and occupational health and safety of sex workers

is conducive to public health

enables the prevention of undue offence or nuisance from the location and conduct of prostitution

prohibits the use in prostitution of persons under 18 years of age

 

Key Dates:

- Introduction: 21 September 2000

- First Reading: 8 November 2000

(87 MPs voted for; 21 against)

- Select Committee Report: 29 November 2002

- Second Reading: 19 February 2003

(62 MPs voted for; 56 against)

 

The Prostitution Reform Bill is built on a decriminalisation model which rejects the position that prostitution itself needs to be or can be controlled. Instead the Bill focuses on controlling the genuine harms which can arise in association with prostitution. The Bill starts from the premise that, provided the people involved are of legal age, the act of selling one’s own body for sex is a legal activity in which the state will not intervene. The Bill identifies and outlaws specific harms which include under-age sex, coercion, unsafe sexual practices and poor health and safety practices.

 

Recently I put several questions to Tim Barnett about the Bill and its progress towards becoming law.

 

1. What changes will the Prostitution Reform Bill bring about?

 

The Prostitution Reform Bill will generate the following significant changes:

No prosecutions/convictions for prostitution related offences.

More coherent and accessible range of rights and protections for sex workers.

Detailed consideration (through a Review Committee) of how best to deter entry into and encourage exiting from the sex industry.

A move towards smaller worker-operated brothels.

A greater focus on contact with health and labour officials, and less on contact with the police.

 

2. Why are these changes important?

 

Because they reduce the risks faced by a significantly vulnerable section of our community, enabling those people to live more balanced lives.

Because they free police resources for more important things.

Because they remove an historic and significant gender bias in the law.

 

3. Are the changes being proposed based on models used in other countries?

 

The most significant decriminalisation model has been in New South Wales, Australia, where it has operated for the last 8 years. Aspects of decriminalisation operate in Belgium and the Netherlands, but only in certain zones. All indications are that the system works well in NSW.

 

4. Is the Prostitution Reform Bill supported by those who work in the sex industry?

 

It is supported by the New Zealand Prostitutes Collective and by operators of smaller brothels, including some which operate as escort agencies. Owners of larger brothels (massage parlours) support parts of the Bill but seek a clamp-down on smaller operators.

 

5. What are the main concerns of those who don't support the Bill?

 

Opponents of the Bill claim it will expand the sex industry and will worsen the existing risks in it. Some want to criminalise clients, while supporting the decriminalisation of workers; others want both to be criminalised.

 

6. What are these concerns based on?

 

The concerns are based (variously) on misinformation about the impact of decriminalisation in NSW, on base prejudice against sex workers and a deep dislike of the concept of prostitution, and on a feminist analysis of prostitution which believes that women's bodies should not be available for sale, even if the woman consents.

 

7. Why is it important that the queer community supports this Bill (or lobbies MPs to support it)?

For two reasons:

- This is the first significant debate on sex and sexuality-related matters in NZ since homosexual law reform. The conceptual parallels with homosexual law reform are strong, and have been raised frequently in debate on the Bill.

- The arrests for soliciting over the past five years have disproportionately been of men (50%+) and Maori (50%+). It is the Maori transgender workers who are the focus of most police pressure. This is a Rainbow issue.

 

8. How can we best support the Bill?

 

By contacting local MPs who are voting against the Bill (e.g. Bill English) and congratulating those who have supported it so far (David Benson-Pope, Pete Hodgson, David Parker, Mark Peck, Katherine Rich). Write to local papers giving your reasons for supporting the Bill.

 

9. Did you anticipate that the recent vote on the Bill's second reading would be so close? Why or why not?

 

I certainly thought it would be closer, since:

a) Some MPs happy to see a Select Committee look at an issue had no real intention of letting it go further.

b) The anti-lobby may have lost the intellectual argument, but won the numerical war. Most letters we have received were against the Bill.

c) The 2002 election, ironically, saw an increase in the number of morally conservative MPs, including two whole parties (NZ First and United Future) and a clear trend within National.

 

When it gets as close as 62:56, you're just grateful for every vote!

 

10. What is the process from here for the Bill?

 

The Bill will continue in its Committee Stage for as long as MPs keep talking - certainly through into May. There will be votes on (acceptable) amendments to certify operators, to give local bodies clarified powers over brothel location and to ensure that immigration laws are not evaded through decriminalisation. If all that happens okay, we move to the Third Reading. Then the Royal Assent, and that is that.

 

For more information about the Prostitution Reform Bill, visit Tim Barnett’s web page (www.timbarnett.org.nz).

Top of the Page 

 

 

Dunedin Rainbow Labour Branch

by Victoria Devereux

 

The Dunedin Rainbow Labour Branch has been busy recently working on our annual fundraising event for 2003 – a quiz night that was held on April 30. In addition to the quiz itself there were raffles throughout the evening. We were very excited about the wonderful support we received from businesses and individuals in regard to securing raffle prizes – and this provided an excellent opportunity to explain and promote the objectives of the Rainbow Labour Branches. In addition, the support we got from the community and friends on the night was awesome - the Shiel Hill Tavern was full and everyone seemed to have a good time.

 

The quiz night was an amazing success for the Dunedin Rainbow Labour Branch. A very big “thank you” to all the individuals, MPs, organisations and businesses who supported this event by donating raffle prizes, entering teams in the quiz and/or purchasing raffle tickets. And, a very big “thank you” to the members of the Branch who worked so hard to make this fundraiser happen in such a fabulous way.

 

On the political front the Dunedin Rainbow Labour Branch is still focusing on the issue of adoption and the need for the current law to change since it excludes all same-sex couples from adopting (both within New Zealand and internationally). As we’re finding out, a big part of bringing about change involves educating people about the current situation because so many people are surprised when they learn that the adoption laws in this country discriminate against same-sex couples. (There will be more information about this in the next issue of the OGT.)

 

Tim Barnett MP was scheduled to attend our meeting at the end of March, but unfortunately bad weather prevented him from getting to Dunedin on time. Tim has kindly rescheduled his visit, though, and will now attend our meeting on August 30. While at the meeting Tim will give us an update on the “Rainbow Agenda” (where things are at politically in New Zealand in regard to issues that affect the LGBT/queer community) and answer any questions that people have.

 

Anyone is welcome to join the Dunedin Rainbow Labour Branch and/or attend one of our meetings which are held on the last Saturday of the month at 2:30pm at Kirkland Chambers, 83 Moray Place, 2nd floor. Also, people can join the Branch and choose to be financial members only and not attend meetings, or only attend them from time to time. This includes people who live out of Dunedin. If anyone would like more information about the Dunedin Rainbow Labour Branch, then please email [email protected] or phone 453-1108.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Surrogacy Application Being Considered

 

The Government’s National Ethics Committee on Assisted Human Reproduction is currently considering an application for two gay men to have a surrogate baby. This is the first time that such an application has been made in New Zealand and so the committee’s decision will be an important one not only for the individuals involved but also for this country’s queer community in general.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Schools, Sexuality & Safety: What The PPTA Is Doing

by Judie Alison

 

As a union, the Post Primary Teachers Association (PPTA) has been working on issues for queer teachers and students since 1986, when an Annual Conference that year passed a series of resolutions calling on branches to work with their boards to ensure that their schools were safe for lesbian and gay staff and students. This was seven years before the Human Rights Act in 1993 made discrimination against people because of their sexual orientation illegal.

 

A Taskforce of lesbian and gay PPTA members began working in 1994 on developing materials and supporting research by Kathleen Quinlivan, Shane Town and Cynthia Shaw about queer students’ school experiences and ways to make schools welcoming places for queer students. That Taskforce went into recess for a time, but was re-established in 1999 after two PPTA members, Judie Alison and Susan Battye, went to the first ever international conference for queer trade unionists, in Amsterdam in 1998. On their return, funding was provided for workshops with lesbian and gay members to find out what the situation was like for queer teachers in secondary schools. The picture was grim. Homophobia was still rife, directed at teachers and students, and only a few boards or principals were acknowledging the problems and trying to address them.

 

Since then, work has been quietly proceeding. A pamphlet providing advice about "Making Schools Safe For People Of Every Sexuality" was supplied to branches early in 2001. A set of Guidelines for Boards of Trustees was produced, with help and endorsement from a number of groups including the Human Rights Commission, the Family Planning Association, the Youth Affairs Minister and the School Trustees Association. These Guidelines were issued to Boards of Trustees and PPTA branches late in 2001. Branches were also provided with a Kit to help them promote the Guidelines and begin education of teachers in their own schools. Multiple copies of two posters aimed particularly at students went out with the Guidelines and Kit.

 

In 2002, Judie Alison joined the national office staff of the PPTA as an Advisory Officer, with issues for queer teachers and students as part of her job description. Later in that year, Christchurch executive member Robin Duff, the current convenor of the Taskforce, and Judie attended the second conference for queer trade unionists in Sydney. As in 1998, the conference was organised to occur in the days leading up to the Gay Games to allow people to attend both.

 

Robin and Judie presented a workshop in which they reported on what the PPTA had done for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender members and students since the Amsterdam conference in 1998. They talked about the series of workshops held with members, the long process of producing the Guidelines, Kits, posters and leaflet, and what was left to be done. People were very impressed with the PPTA's materials.

 

As it happened, there was a workshop at the conference on the subject of "Coming Out as a Queer Teacher", presented by a Dutch group. They discussed the reasons why queer teachers might "come out":

- Visibility for students – seeing the reality of queer people, students learning appropriate social behaviour.

- For themselves - losing the fear of being outed, having to lie, etc. and its consequences in terms of burnout and stress.

 

They said that the second reason was a much more important reason, and would generally result in happier teachers which was better for the school too.

 

However, there were also some negatives:

- Being seen as "the gay of the school" – not just the physics teacher.

- Becoming the "expert" – you teach other people including students how to relate to queer people.

- Colleagues assuming that you are strong so you can cope with anything.

- The danger from hidden queer colleagues, for whom your coming out is a threat, making them subject to extra questioning.

- The issue of separating work and private life – where is the boundary?

 

In a very depressing presentation, Gerard Kelly of the UK National Association of Teachers in Further Education described what can happen in a context where there is no anti-discrimination legislation. He talked about two appalling cases:

1.  A lesbian accused of a sexual relationship with a student. The parents recanted their accusation but her institution persisted with action against her, saying that she was “a known lesbian” and therefore a danger to her students, and demoted her.

2.  A lesbian whose supervisor kept saying to her “We’ll get you into a skirt one day” and the like, leading to extreme depression. She finally capitulated and wore a skirt, and the next day she committed suicide.

 

The materials produced by the PPTA for schools and boards are based on a diversity model and place recognition of diversity of sexualities firmly within a wider diversity context. This is made clear in the terminology used in the Guidelines:

Schools are institutions where diversity is the norm, among the staff, the students and the community served by the school. Every Board and staff must ensure that their school not only recognises this diversity but affirms it, to ensure that everyone involved with the school feels welcome and valued.

 

The PPTA's Guidelines and Kit were re-issued early this year to school Guidance Counsellors, accompanied by a letter of commendation from the Chairperson of the NZ Association of Counsellors and the PPTA President. The Taskforce is considering rewriting some aspects of the material and re-issuing them to branches later this year. A page is to be set up on the PPTA website to provide resources for schools and for queer members. Work with teacher educators and health teachers is planned. The Taskforce will continue to put pressure on the government to live up to their manifesto promise to “Require educational institutions to ensure GLBT students are safe and face no barriers to being open about their sexuality, or gender identity” (Labour Rainbow Policy 2002).

 

The Sydney conference passed a final resolution which called on trade unions and their peak organisations to make further progress in addressing issues for queer workers. One on which the PPTA could feel it is making good progress was the following:

This conference calls on all unions to include in their education strategies and programs information and training on the elimination of discrimination based on sexual orientation, gender identity and gender expression.

 

While there is more that can be done, the PPTA has at least made a good start.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Pride Dunedin Youth

by Pamela Dwyer, Chairperson of Pride Dunedin Youth

 

So I think we all know and agree that there is a need in Dunedin, as in all cities and towns, for there to be support groups and safe social networks for youth that are same-sex-attracted or who are questioning their sexuality. We all deserve the right to come out and to be real and honest with ourselves and others without fear of negative reactions while we grow and discover who we are.

 

Pride Dunedin Youth, after a long haul of seemingly endless meetings and discussions, is now at the stage of developing these support groups and social networks in our very own Dunedin.

 

Personally, these planning meetings and discussions have helped me to feel more secure about my own sexual identity and what I really need to trust and accept about who I am. This proves to me the importance of being able to talk freely and comfortably about myself as a young gay woman involved with Pride Dunedin Youth. Therefore, I hope that Pride Dunedin Youth will be a place for other young people to feel free and accepted.

 

During Pride Week in July, we will be launching two facilitated group support programmes: Icebreakers for young men and Bloom for young women. Trained facilitators will follow a programme of information-based and social activities including discussions on issues such as coming out to your parents, public displays of affection and safe sex. We have got a lot of work to do and we're excited, but we also know that this is an important support needed in our community.

 

The makings of Pride Dunedin Youth owe dues to a lot of people; however, I'd especially like to thank Jan Hudson from Internal Affairs and Euan Thompson from PFLAG South for all their work and support. March 31st saw the launch of Pride Dunedin Youth's Draft Strategy Document at a community meeting in the Municipal Chambers. At this meeting the inaugural six member Management Team, consisting of 3 young men and 3 young women, was concretised with plans underway to develop a committed Advisory Group (the older ones!) that will meet with us every month to provide assistance and feedback.

 

The importance for us to get ourselves out there in environments that will reach young people, especially those who are under 18, is our immediate next step because what is the point of us existing if there are few to reap the benefits! So, School Counsellors and Sexual Health Workers can expect to hear from us in the near future.

 

And if anyone has any other ideas of ways to become known to the youth of Dunedin, please do not hesitate to email us ([email protected]).

Top of the Page 

 

 

NZAF South - Te Toka

 

NZAF South - Te Toka in Christchurch (formerly known as the Ettie Rout Centre) provides the following services:

- Information on HIV and AIDS.

- Free and anonymous counselling and HIV antibody testing for people who might be at risk of HIV infection.

- Individual counselling and support for people living with HIV and people living with AIDS.

- Support and counselling for families and friends of people living with HIV and AIDS.

- Assistance with maintaining safer sex and drug use.

- Sexual health counselling for men who have sex with men.

 

Appointments are recommended and are available Monday to Friday between 9am and 5pm, and Tuesday evenings between 5pm and 8pm.

 

CONTACT DETAILS:

NZAF South - Te Toka

269 Hereford Street, PO Box 13-618, Christchurch

Phone: 03-379-1953, Fax: 03-365-2477, E-mail: [email protected]

Top of the Page 

 

 

HIV Diagnoses Among Gay Men Increase To Almost One Per Week

 

The following is taken from a New Zealand AIDS Foundation press release issued earlier this year.

 

HIV diagnoses among men who have sex with men in 2002 were the highest in New Zealand since 1996. Fifty men who have sex with men (MSM) were found to be infected with HIV through antibody testing, a rise from a stable number of about 35 over each of the previous four years.

 

While cautioning that the numbers being diagnosed are still small in New Zealand, and therefore random numerical fluctuations from year to year can appear as a large percentage change, NZAF Executive Director Kevin Hague stated that the information is cause for concern.

 

The availability of new HIV treatments in the mid-1990s resulted in improvements in the health of many people with diagnosed HIV infection, particularly by limiting the progression of HIV on to an AIDS-defining illness. However, health promoters have feared for some time that the decreasing public visibility of AIDS might lead to heightened complacency about HIV. This could eventually lead many uninfected gay men into believing that HIV is no longer a significant personal threat.

 

Approaching the third decade of the AIDS epidemic, NZAF has been at pains to point out through its prevention campaigns that the risks associated with any one occasion of unprotected intercourse are actually increased in statistical terms.

 

This is because there are more HIV positive individuals in NZ than ever before. Many are aware of their infection because they have tested positive, but some are not. In western countries, it is estimated that about a third of people infected with HIV are not aware of it at any one point in time. It’s therefore important for people not to automatically assume that their sexual partner is HIV negative – it’s everyone’s responsibility to practise safe sex. This is particularly critical for gay men.

 

Fifty diagnoses over one year amounts to almost one diagnosis a week. Although it’s possible that some of these infections may have been acquired some time ago or that last year’s high number of diagnoses is an aberration, it means that gay men are still becoming infected with HIV in New Zealand. As much as some people might like to pretend HIV has gone away, it hasn’t.

Top of the Page 

 

 

A Final Celebration And Farewell - What Do You Need To Consider?

by Barb Long & Andrew Metcalfe

 

We all live with different expectations and assumptions about life, no one wants to talk about death and funerals unless forced to, we tend to avoid considering our own mortality and to contemplate the death of one’s partner is far too challenging.

 

Death is a complex event that balances many factors: spiritual requirements, emotional needs, “family dynamics” and financial realities. When faced with mortality we all react in different ways. Within the gay community the acceptance of our sexuality and relationships within our families of origin and wider society can have a significant impact on our ability to plan funerals and grieve for loved ones.

 

As morbid as it may seem, to save conflict within families and to have your wishes (and if in a relationship those of your partner as well) respected should you die, there are advantages in thinking ahead and discussing one’s funeral.

 

You can choose a funeral director in advance and it is important that they are supportive of your choice of service and non-judgmental in guiding you through the arrangements. Your wishes can be pre-recorded with a funeral director and/or lawyer so that they can be carried out accordingly. Preparing a will and power of attorney is another whole matter to discuss with your lawyer.

 

You need to check with individual funeral directors if pre-planning funerals obligate you to any cost and services from them. Many funeral directors offer pre-payment options where your money is invested in secure funds.

 

In contemplating your funeral consider the following;

Where would you like your service to be held

Do you have any particular requirements for clothing (personally Barb would hate to be clothed in a dress!)

Do you want to be buried or cremated

Do you have a particular casket choice

Who would you like to facilitate your service

In relation to your service, is there any particular music that you would like played or other requests (such as readings, hymns, etc.)

Would you like particular people to be pallbearers

Do you want donations to a particular organisation in lieu of flowers

 

It may be easier to initiate these thoughts and discussions if forced to due to ill health, terminal illness or personal bereavements. However, the gay community has a history of discrimination and we believe it is important to retain our dignity and honour ourselves by considering our wishes for when we die ahead of time.

 

You may also prefer to have a religious or spiritual component in the funeral service, and there are a variety of ways this can happen. Increasingly as people choose not to identify with organised religious groups, funeral celebrants are becoming more common. They offer a service for people who want to have the spiritual component of life and death recognised, but in a way that is tailored to their needs. Check out who is around and whether they have a good track record for being able to listen and design something that is right for people in the GLBT community. Your funeral director will be able to tell you the range of people who are available. Ask to see examples of services they have carried out and if they have worked with people in similar circumstances to you.

 

For those who do want support from a church community to say goodbye to a loved one, there are congregations and individuals in Dunedin and beyond who are supportive of the GLBT community. A good place to check out where these might be is the Association of Christian & Reconciling Congregations, Aotearoa New Zealand (ARCC). In Dunedin, Glenaven, Mornington and Broad Bay Methodist congregations are members of ARCC, as well as Knox Presbyterian. There are also a number of other people in other denominations who can offer sensitive support – it is worth while contacting GLBT Christian organisations such as “Ascent” to find out who is available.

 

Contacts:

 

Association of Christian and Reconciling Congregations: www.arcc.org.nz

Dunedin Methodist Parish: www.dunedinmethodist.org.nz

Knox Presbyterian: http://knox-dunedin.freeyellow.com/

Ascent: a Catholic-based gay and lesbian support group for those seeking to foster their spirituality. The Dunedin group is an ecumenical one with monthly religious services or social events. Write to PO Box 5328, Dunedin.

 

Thanks to Cheryl Cowden, Dignity With Sincerity Funeral Services (Christchurch), for her support with this article (www.dignitywithsincerity.co.nz).

Top of the Page 

 

 

Ascent Dunedin

 

Ascent Dunedin is a Catholic-based Christian group for gay men and lesbians. While there are Ascent groups also in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch, Ascent Dunedin has opened its doors to other denominations. So we can truly say we are a Catholic-based ecumenical group, and we are privileged to have a Catholic Chaplain appointed by the Bishop.

 

The last year or so has been particularly distressing for many of our members, who have felt alienated by the Church's response to the issue of sexual abuse of young people. Although sexual abuse of young people seems to be widely recognised by health professionals as a predominantly heterosexual power issue, the Church has seen fit to present it as the fault of those of us who acknowledge ourselves as homosexual. We believe the proposed changes put forward by the Church to combat the activities of sexual predators are aimed at the wrong group. If this is a demonstration of the degree of knowledge the Cardinals, Bishops and their advisers have about sexuality, it is a sad reflection of their willingness to truly come to grips with the issue.

 

Although Ascent was originally founded to support people in the exploration and growth of their spirituality, we have come to realise there is a need for such a group to be open to people who do not wish to attend religious services, but who nevertheless enjoy contact with others who share a similar philosophical basis for living.

 

Therefore, we have planned a provisional programme of activities for 2003 (which includes our popular Mid Winter Dinner), as well as some other social occasions, and people are very welcome to attend these. We realise there are a number of people who have been badly hurt in their contact with Churches of all denominations in the past, and Ascent aspires to provide a safe environment for all.

 

Those of us in the older age group remember very well the climate in the past when it was simply not safe to acknowledge our sexuality, and we can only be thankful to those who worked so hard to help make society a little safer for the younger ones coming out, who hopefully will never have to experience the difficulties of gay and lesbian people in past years. We are also appreciative of the individual Church congregations who not only support but affirm gay and lesbian members in their relationships; maybe it means the message is getting through that we are people, and that our sexual orientation is simply one facet of who we are.

 

Ascent Dunedin can be contacted via PO Box 5328, Dunedin.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Uncomfortable Emotions, Shame And Guilt

by Sue Thompson (PFLAG)

 

The paragraph below seems to make sense to me. It’s from the book Eternal Echoes: Exploring Our Hunger To Belong by Irish priest and poet John O’Donohue.

 

He writes about shame in this way:

“It is one of the most distressing and humiliating emotions … dignity is torn … we lose our esteem and reputation because of either something we have done, or incurred the disapproval of the community. Shame is a force intended to put one outside all belonging … conventions that shame are immensely powerful in a community.”

 

Stories we hear at PFLAG meetings suggest that many GLBT people and their families either have experiences like this, or fear it.

 

When parents of lesbians and gay men go through a “death” of heterosexual expectations for their son or daughter they experience grief. One of the emotions that can be part of grief is guilt.

 

Guilt is a feeling that you are somehow to blame for something. It is easy to understand why parents might feel this, given that they are coping with their belief that their family member will not now be acceptable in society or the church. Many parents feel guilty that they:

have been bad parents

have caused this pain and trouble for their child

may have previously hurt their child by their homophobic attitudes

are unable to just “get over it” instantly

 

Sometimes gay children feel guilty that they:

can’t fulfil their parents’ expectations

have caused their parents unhappiness

are the cause of family disharmony

 

Some people can carry this guilt throughout their whole life.

 

So, it’s important to recognise that shaming is a way that groups of people act to control behaviour, and it is often very unjust and unkind. Be proud of the person you are. Guilt accomplishes nothing and takes a lot of emotional energy. Better to try and move on through the challenges of examining the ideas that cause the guilt. If it seems possible, and when you can, try talking about these things in the family. You will need patience, understanding and willingness to speak about your true feelings. We wish you well.

Top of the Page 

 

 

A Walk On The Queer Side

by Tor & Barb

 

Winter might be approaching, but that's no reason to stay indoors! Here are the queer walks for the next three months - and, if you haven't come on one before, why not give it a go? We can promise you lots of fresh air, beautiful scenery and probably some interesting conversation as well! Children and dogs are very welcome.

 

If you have any questions or need a ride, then phone Barb and Tor on 453-1108. Also, if you know of any walks that are dog-friendly and that you think would be good for the queer walking group, then please let us know.

 

For all of the walks, meet at the duck pond at Woodhaugh Gardens (Duke Street) at 2:00pm.

 

Sunday May 25

Karitane and Huriawa Pa

After meeting at the duck pond we'll drive out to Karitane (about 40km from Dunedin) to start this walk. This walk includes shoreline, cliffs, blow holes and great scenery and should take about an hour or so.

 

Sunday June 22

Beach Walk at Island Park Recreation Reserve (between Blackhead Beach & Brighton)

We haven't done a beach walk before and someone at a queer walk recently suggested it and we thought that it was a great idea.  After a short walk to the sand from the car park we'll wander along the beach towards Blackhead for as long as people want!

(NOTE: This walk was meant to happen in March but was cancelled because of the rain!)

 

Sunday July 27

McGoun's Creek Walking Track

This is a track within the Ross Creek forest. It starts in Tanner Rd and joins up with the Pineapple Track, and provides a lovely scenic walk through the forest. So that we get in a good hour or so of walking, we'll go through a bit of Ross Creek first.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Rainbow Families

 

A Rainbow Families Group has recently been formed in Dunedin so those who have, want or are trying to have children can get together for support and social activities. The group meets on the first Saturday of each month. Below are listed the events that have been planned for June, July and August.

 

For more information about the Rainbow Families Group, contact Barb on [email protected] or 453-1108, or Jacinda on 471-9495.

 

Saturday June 7

Museum - we'll visit the different exhibitions and then there's the option of a cup of coffee and/or snack at the Museum Café afterwards. Meet in the foyer by the moa at 2:00pm.

 

Saturday July 5

Mid-winter (indoor) Picnic - starting at 12:30pm, venue to be confirmed. Bring indoor games and the smaller children can bring their favourite soft toy.

 

Saturday August 2

Moana Pool - there's the learner's pool, the wave pool, the regular pool and the hydro slide (so there should be something for everyone!). Meet in the foyer at the pool at 2:00pm - and we might like to head into town afterwards for a cuppa!

Top of the Page 

 

 

Pride Dunedin Inc.

by Stu Terry

 

Pride Dunedin Inc. has recently celebrated its first birthday. Our first year has been exciting, demanding, challenging, exhausting and totally rewarding. Everyone involved in Pride Dunedin was amazed at what was achieved in such a short period of time. The amount of voluntary time and effort people gave to ensure our whole community could proudly and publicly celebrate who we are and take our place in the community was awesome.

 

The start of 2003 has been slightly less frenetic than 2002. Pride Dunedin started 2003 by working on our foundations. All organisations that endure have solid foundations and we are no different. A lot of work has been undertaken behind the scenes as we develop our strategic and business plan. Our strategic plan is about the big picture goals between now and 2008. The business plan is about what we will be doing this year to achieve those goals. We are working slowly through this process and once a draft has been completed we want to talk to people in our community for their input. We have identified some big goals we want to pursue such as having a full-time paid coordinator who can advocate for our issues, support our communities and seek funding.

 

We have supported Pride Dunedin Youth which was officially launched at the end of March. Pride Dunedin Youth will operate as a semi-autonomous group within Pride Dunedin. We are all delighted that Pride Dunedin Youth has been formed to support young GLBT and questioning people in the city.

 

Planning is now well underway for Pride Week 2003 in July, “Unity In Our Community”. We have listened to feedback about Pride Week 2002 and this year’s week will feature a wide range of activities for everyone in our communities to participate in. A major change with Pride Week this year is how the events are being run. Last year Pride Dunedin organised and funded almost all of the events, whereas this year our role is focusing on facilitating and co-ordinating the events. A dedicated team of people are working hard to bring together a great week.

 

Communicating and keeping people informed about what is happening is one of our key goals. One way this is taking place, thanks to Grant, is the weekly “What’s On” email. I know the list of people it is sent to grows almost daily, and feedback has been very positive. To be added to this contact list just send an email to Grant ([email protected]).

 

It was interesting that following a request recently from the New Zealand Herald for people to talk about coming out in the workplace the article mainly featured Dunedin people. I believe this was a consequence of our strengthening communications. It was great to see Dunedin people being able to openly and freely talk about their experiences in the workplace. It was also good to read a balanced and well researched article on GLBT issues. Hopefully we can convince the Otago Daily Times to do the same.

 

Pride Dunedin values all feedback, input or views on our strategic and business plans, Pride Week and anything else. Please email us at [email protected] or write to us at PO Box 1382, Dunedin.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Poetry

 

One Million Eyes

by Jane E Libeau

 

I looked into one million eyes

Saw tears or sorrow

As the dust subsides

Unity has made them feel

They try to forgive

They try to heal

The destitute child

Who walks the ruins

Mother has gone

From fathers evil doings

The earth has shook

The shiver climbs our being

What have we done?

What are we seeing?

Throw back our thoughts

To greener grasses of home

Too late for wishful thinking

We have been left alone

The eyes look at me

I crumble and weep

We’ve destroyed ourselves

There’s nothing left to keep

Tomorrow is another day

Tomorrow we all shall pay

And the million eyes

Will be unforgiving

We took from them

Their right to living

Top of the Page 

 

 

Book Reviews

by Andrew Metcalfe

 

Worlds in Collision: The Gay Debate in New Zealand, 1960 - 1986

by Laurie Guy (Victoria University Press, 2002)

 

This book is based on a doctoral thesis by Laurie Guy, a lecturer in church history at Carey Baptist College, Auckland. As such, it is a fairly “academic” treatment of a fascinating and important part of our history by someone many would consider to be an “outsider”. This aside, the book is an interesting retrospective of what went on at this time, based on extensive interviews and other research. It begins by reminding the reader of what New Zealand was like in the 1960s and the evolution from the “decent obscurity” stance of the NZ Homosexual Law Reform Society through to the Gay Liberation movement of the 1970s - 80s.

 

Of particular interest is Guy’s discussion of what went on in church circles over homosexual law reform in the early eighties, plus the ensuing debate between hard-line fundamentalists and reformers. His analysis of how the conservative right made major tactical errors is of particular interest to those of us who got caught up in it all to a certain extent, but were often unaware of the bigger picture.

 

My main gripe with this book is that although Guy seeks to be an impartial raconteur of what happened over this period, there is an edge of bias that creeps in occasionally. Perhaps this is because I know some of the people he refers to and have a more intimate knowledge of some of what went on. Guy doesn’t appear to get it “quite right”. Like anything else of this genre, it is open to challenge, but it is still a significant work telling a story that was begging to be told. Hopefully it will spur some responses and recollections from others who were more directly involved.

 

 

The Comfort of Men

by Dennis Altman (William Heinemann, Australia, 1993)

 

This book could be “old hat” to many, but worth reminding people of as an offering from Australian author and academic Dennis Altman (see also Homosexual: Oppression and Liberation; Coming Out in the Seventies; Rehearsals for Change, The Homosexualization of America; AIDS and the New Puritanism; A Politics of Poetry; Paper Ambassadors). This is a novel that in some ways reads like a biography in the best sense of the genre. It revolves around Steven, a gay man in Tasmania in the 1960s - 70s, along with a variety of his male and female friends. The story moves around these characters as Steven recounts to his dying lover what made up who he was.

 

One “twist” of the book is that a central theme is the process of Tasmania gaining independence from Mainland Australia – told in such a way that it got me scratching my head and wondering if this had happened but I’d somehow missed it! The effect is to emphasise to what extent things could have gone if this island – renowned as being one of the most conservative states in the Commonwealth of Australia – had succeeded in creating a separate existence, which excluded anyone perceived to be “different”. What really inspired me (as any good novel should) was the way that the characters’ lives unfurled in such a way to connect with parts of my own journey. Perhaps it might for you as well! It is a beautifully told story, with some classic lines  - certainly worth adding to your reading list.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Dunedin's Pride Week 2003: Unity In Our Community

 

Pride Week 2003 is being facilitated and co-ordinated by Pride Dunedin Inc. and will take place July 11-20 (although a couple of events are happening earlier). A wide variety of events are planned so there should be something for everyone.

 

More details about events are available from Pride Dunedin (email [email protected] or write to PO Box 1382, Dunedin).

Top of the Page 

 

 

Lesbian Plays

 

In association with Pride Week

 

DEGREES OF SEPARATION

3 short plays about lesbians and their families, directed by Kari Morseth

 

- Conversation

A prologue to coming attractions.

 

- One Degree of Separation

The straight daughter of a lesbian couple lives in the "perfect" family until she discovers a shattering truth.

 

- Daughter of the Bride

The stresses of a lesbian relationship become more complicated when a mother gets involved.

 

Three performances only:

Thursday, Friday, Saturday, July 17, 18, 19

8.00 pm, Allen Hall, University of Otago

$10 waged; $7 unwaged

 

Auditions will be held in May for actors. Characters are three women, aged approximately 18-21, 25-35 and 40-50.

 

If you are interested, please email Kari Morseth at [email protected]

Top of the Page 

 

 

Are You Feeling Left Out?

 

Has coming out alienated you from your church family? If so you might feel at home at Glenaven.

 

Glenaven is a Methodist Church with an ecumenical congregation and a special ministry to the gay and lesbian community. Even if you don’t think of yourself as Christian you can belong and be valued. Theologically, Glenaven is at the cutting edge and our Sunday sermons are followed by some pretty lively dialogue. Be prepared to be challenged.

 

Try us out on Sunday mornings. We have coffee and cookies from 10:40am and our service is from 11am to 12pm. You’ll find Glenaven in Chambers Street, just two blocks along North Road from the Garden’s supermarket.

Top of the Page 

 

 

FUNQ!

 

On March 22 in Dunedin over 260 open-minded, happy go-lucky FUNQERS came along to the “New Arrivals” FUNQ queerdisco night at Refuel. A damn good night was had by all! Well it was hard not to with so many wild and wonderfully executed acts throughout the night.

 

FUNQ returned on April 12 for “Pacific Paradise”. Our very own Brendan Kydd choreographed a “pacific island dance troupe with bite” plus more fun!

 

Entry to FUNQ is $5 and we encourage everyone to come along for a bit of fun. There’s always a pool comp and excellent drink specials. We look forward to seeing you at Dunedin’s next queerdisco!!

Top of the Page 

 

 

UniQ

 

UniQ Working Party Established

The UniQ working party that emerged out of the Queer Students General Meeting that was held in late March has been meeting regularly to look at all the options of how UniQ may operate next year. The working party will present its recommendations at the next Queer Students General Meeting planned for May.

As the working party is only in the early stages of its thinking it is difficult to say anything definite other than that there are four broad options being considered at this stage: an advisory group to the coordinator, a committee that directs the coordinator and fronts UniQ, formalise the status quo, appoint a queer portfolio or queer officer on OUSA. Elements of each of these are interchangeable.

 

UniQ Lunches Are Back

Good old UniQ Lunches have finally returned and they got off to a modest but concerted start on Monday March 31st. The new venue is the ever-friendly and warm environs of Refuel. The lunches, which will take place in the performance room beside the bar area, are a time for any person – gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender – to come along, to hang out and be yourself. The lunches are on Mondays and start at 12pm and run through until 2pm so you can still come if you have a class at 12pm or 1pm.

 

Some meal specials are still to be worked out with Scotty, the bar manager, and because we are using that backspace he is kindly allowing us to bring a cut lunch from home if we prefer! We are also working out what UniQ can provide so come on down folks and be with your family for lunch on Mondays!

 

FUNQ

Just a little interior tweaking, carefully selected DJs and unparalleled live shows have transformed Refuel once a month into what can only described as Dunedin’s very own Studio 54, and is fast growing into the best queerdisco Dunedin has seen since the heydays of Powder at Fuel.

 

One of the greatest strengths of FUNQ is the priceless atmosphere of gay men and lesbian women celebrating being queer together like no other city in the country can do. This means that FUNQ is proving to be the perfect preamble to the theme of Pride Week 2003, “Unity In Our Community”, and is living proof of the commitment of Dunedin lgbt/queers to enjoy our differences and make them our strength.

 

“New Arrivals” on March 22 saw over 260 people bring Refuel (just inside campus) to life with colour and personalities, and on April 12 Brendan Kydd pulled together five other men and women to deliver what had to be one of the most ground shaking shows that FUNQ has seen so far - that’s if the applause was anything to go by! Our very own Rasa Dance Company have thrilled FUNQ audiences twice now and Lisa is choreographing a troupe of the Purple Passions for a special M*A*S*H edition of FUNQ on May 17.

 

“The decision made early on to start with a monthly event has proven successful. The focus is now on retaining the special celebratory atmosphere, and I think part of this comes from the deliberate move to not drown out the energy with mediocre drag shows like other centres do. FUNQ is pure energy for everybody,” said Nathan.

Top of the Page 

 

 

Relationship Riddles: Preserving Romance

by Relationship Services Whakawhanaungatanga

 

It's true. It's blind. It's romance. And it lasts about a minute and a half.

 

You want someone to love you. No question. But someone who spots your finer qualities, and loves them, can be depressingly elusive. As for stumbling on someone who appreciates you on a bad hair day, that can be a really tall order. So when you do find someone, it's your glossy best you aim to display. That's romance for you. The delightful blurring effect of the rose coloured lens. The candlelight feels delicious and cosy. It softens the distinctive features that make both of you the people you are.

 

After a while you start to feel this tension. Romance is yummy and you want to hold on to it. But there is more to you than is on show. When your unique, individual style gets a look in will it snuff out the candlelight? If you need to squash some bits of you to keep basking in that rosy glow, how good does the romance feel? What if your wonderful new lover wants you on the other side of the closet door? What happens when some of those warty bits slip the leash and make themselves startlingly obvious?

 

The pressure builds. It pushes you from romance to something else. You find your feet more often on the ground. Growing familiarity begins to replace novelty and excitement. Your focus becomes sharp and clear. Sometimes a good clear look is all it takes for a relationship to shut up shop. Sometimes the relationship was all about feeling the romantic buzz and when that goes so does the reason for the relationship. Sometimes romance lays great foundations for love. You just need to figure out how to build on them.

 

You wanted someone to love you. You thought this new partner was a real cracker, but now you wonder if they're a fizzer instead. If you feel square one getting closer you might want to ask yourself just how keen you are to really love someone else? Loving someone takes courage. The best dressed, best behaved self they show you first is relatively simple to enjoy. It might be a whole lot harder to keep your heart open when the face you see is scared or pompous or critical.

 

Daring to acknowledge and accept all that your partner offers moves you both into uncharted territory. You encourage them while they explore. Your support helps transform their inner map. They'll discover some of their buried treasures. Some of their scary "there be dragons" spots become less alarming and more known. You learn to be the kind of person who can support this particular partner really well. You discover talents in yourself you never knew you had. Some of your own dragons might just disappear or transform in the process.

 

This is when you get the best chance to really enjoy romance. When you've got the hang of being open with yourselves and each other, you don't have to hide or worry or impress. You trust each other. Your partner knows you stretch yourself when they need something hard for you to offer. You know that they dig deep for you as well.

 

Treasure that early flush of romance. Try to preserve it as it is, and you'll pickle it. Let it grow, and it will keep on sprouting when your relationship is due for a little spring.

 

If you would like help to build on your romance, contact Relationship Services on 0800 RELATE (0800-735-283) or your local office which is listed in the telephone directory. Or visit our web page at www.relate.org.nz/index.asp

Top of the Page 

 

 

Queer Quiz Answers

 

1. Julie Andrews

2. Slave Auction

3. Ru Paul

4. 1928

5. Andrew Whiteside, Rebecca Singh, Jonathan Marshall and Kelly Rice

Top of the Page 

 

 

What’s On

 

Out Takes Gay & Lesbian Film Festival, June 13-15, The Academy (50 Dundas St). See article for more details and the schedule of films. Additional information is available on the Out Takes web page (www.outtakes.org.nz).

 

Pride Week - "Unity In Our Community", July 11-20. See article on Pride Dunedin Inc. for for more details or contact Pride Dunedin on [email protected] or write to PO Box 1382, Dunedin.

 

A Walk on the Queer Side (See article for more details)

Sunday May 25 - Karitane and Huriawa Pa

Sunday June 22 - Beach Walk at Island Park Recreation Reserve

Sunday July 27 - McGoun's Creek Walking Track

For all of the walks, meet at the duck pond at Woodhaugh Gardens (Duke Street) at 2pm.

 

Rainbow Families (See article for more details)

Saturday June 7 - Museum

Saturday July 5 - Mid-winter (indoor) Picnic

Saturday August 2 - Moana Pool

 

Gay Ski Weeks, Queenstown, August 2-9 and September 6-13. See www.gayqueenstown.com for details.

Top of the Page 

 

 

 

 

Home

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1