II
Human development: from infant organism to adult person.
The Freudian view.
By
Olivier Charnoz
·
Structural development of the mental apparatus
·
Motivational development : transformation of drive organization
The earliest childhood :
birth to two
·
Motivational development : the primal
forms of the libidinal drive
· Motivational development : the primal form
of the aggressive drive
· Motivational development : the primal forms
of anxiety (the security drive)
· Cognitive
development : domination of the primary thought processes
The Oedipal period (two to
five)
·
Motivational development : the phallic stage and the shift from ego-libido to
object-libido
· The
emergence of gender identities.
· The
complete Oedipus complex and the Family complex
· The end
of the Oedipus complex and its developmental consequences
The 'latency' period an the
beginning of puberty : six to twelve
· Partial
aim inhibition and subsequent social development
·
Sublimation of aggressive drives
·
Development of moral and social signal anxieties
· A new
wave of libido re-cathectis infantile wishes
· The
challenge of libido reunification
One of the most fruitful insight of Freud's
psychology is its view of the individual as a developing being : everything is in motion, slowly
actualising its full potential. This developmental perspective - along with a psycho-biological and a
phenomenological one - informs every
Freudian concept.
It is crucial to stress that the
Freudian model of development is cumulative : in the general
motion towards adulthood, no previous
stage of development is wiped out. What is new never destroys what is old, but
merely dominates it. Indeed regression to less mature stages
is both a normal fact - daily expressed in sleep or in joking - and a major
pathological possibility. The Freudian road to adulthood is thus a bumpy and a
two-way one.
Understanding one's psychology
largely amounts to understanding one's specific history of development and its
relation to the general model. After having presented the its four
developmental lines, this paper proposes a chronological reconstruction of the
Freudian model along five periods : the earliest childhood (birth to two), the
famous 'Oedipal' period (two to five), the 'latency' period (six to twelve),
adolescence and adulthood.
Freud conceptualizes the human mental apparatus
in terms of phenomenological (Ucs/Pcs/Cs, and It/I/Over-I) and
psycho-biological structures (primary/secondary systems, and various ñ-systems). These structures are the cumulative
product of the individual's development.
The energies that activate these structures are
either systemic (such as vitality and
wakefulness) or motivational. Human
development was primarily studied by Freud through the changing forms of
motivations. The latter boil down to a mix of libidinal and aggressive
drives. A security drive is sometimes
implicitly assumed by Freud in his analysis of anxiety.
Though
fundamental and permanently active, these drives have no constant expression.
Their impetus (quantity of
excitation), their aim (specific
activity that would satisfy them), their object
(what is needed to pursue this activity) and their source (generally somatic) evolve over time. Thus, a specific drive organization characterizes
each step of human development.
Freud did not study the child cognitive
development as such, thus leaving a gap famously bridged by Jean Piaget.
However, he did study the functioning of thought, that is the way humans link
mental images. In his analysis of the 'dream work', Freud came up with a key
distinction between primary and secondary thought processes.
Primary thought processes are
present in the mental apparatus from the first and are intimately linked with
the primary system. Just as the latter, they are dominated by the
pleasure/unpleasure principle : connection of ideas is led by a search for
satisfaction. They operate through
pre-logical patterns such as condensation, displacement, compromises and
sensory associations.
Secondary thought processes connect
ideas logically and realistically (according to their
meaning and their real connection in the outer world) rather than according to
their sensory qualities. Just as the
pleasure/unpleasure principle dominates primary thinking the reality principle
dominates the secondary one. This mode of thinking is only possible insofar as
the mental apparatus is able to inhibit associations of the primary kind, which
connect ideas along the pleasure/unpleasure principle. This inhibiting capacity
draws on the energy of the secondary system, the correct functioning of which
is therefore required.
Thus according to Freud, our
original thought processes are wishful rather
than logical.
Social development only starts once the
motivational development overtakes the primal self-centred (narcissistic)
state. Freud then distinguishes two
basic modes to relate to people. Identification
is the most primitive one. In its earliest form, it is close to introjection whereby the ego
subjectively feels it is the other.
In later forms it is an emotional situation whereby the ego wants to be the other person. In both
cases, identification relies on a sense of being the other. On the other hand, object-choice (object-cathexis)
is a situation whereby the ego wants to have
the object.
On the basis of these concepts
(narcissism, identification and object-choice) Freud's model analyses the
social relationships humans are typically involved in, at each stage of their
development.
We will now study these four lines of
development simultaneously, so as to grasp how they relate to one another.
From the psycho-biological perspective, the
primary system (neural sensitivity to somatic processes) is present from the
first. The innate character of the pleasure/unpleasure polarity merely reflects
this innate sensitivity. The secondary system only unfolds later.
From the phenomenological
perspective, the primitive organism is an 'It' with no sense of 'I'. This
original organization of experience does not distinguish what is external from
what is internal. The differentiation process between the two is intimately
connected to the creation of the subjective agency 'I', and unfolds during the
first year of life.
Due to contact with the external
world, a portion of the Id undergoes a specific organization, so as to become
the Ego. More specifically, a tendency arises to separate from the ego
everything that can become a source of unpleasure (projection) and to incorporate everything that provides pleasure (introjection). The primal ego is
therefore a pure pleasure-ego
as opposed to an 'evil external world'. Further experiences eventually teach
that the outside world contains both pleasurable and unpleasurable objects :
the infant progressively sets up a valid reality testing procedure which is key
component of the secondary system.
Once the sense of self is firmly
established, the defence mechanism of projection turns into primal repression
(anticathectis). This is the birth of the dynamic Unconscious.
Just as Freud distinguished the psychical from the conscious, he famously separated the genital from the sexual,
widening the meaning of the latter so
as to encompass any pleasure-seeking behaviour. He stressed that from their
earliest childhood, humans seek pleasure for its own sake from zones of the
body : in that sense they have a sexual or libidinal life, which follows an
ordered course of development.
The
first organ to make a libidinal demand on the mind is the mouth. In
Freud's terminology, the primal libidinal source is thus the mouth, the
original aim is sucking and the original object is the mother's breast.
This oral phase is followed by the anal
one, whereby the infant gives himself pleasure through defecation in an
autonomous fashion, as he progressively controls his sphincter muscles. As we
see the two pre-genital stages are auto-erotic, as they have no need for any
external object : the infant gets pleasure from bodily functions.
The aggressive drives are primitively merged
with libidinal ones, in pleasure-seeking activities which are therefore of a sadistic nature. During the oral phase,
sadistic impulses occur sporadically along with the appearance of teeth and the
tendency to bite. In the anal phase, their extent is much greater, as the child
experience his first 'social power' to 'withhold the gift or making a big mess'.
As the child is taught to control his
excretory functions, he learns to repress immediate impulses. This opens up the
way for the reality principle to start developing. This latter principle is actually a later stage of development of
the pleasure/unpleasure principle, once the ego has learned that it is
sometimes necessary to renounce immediate satisfaction to obtain more pleasure
in the long term.
Anxiety is a reaction to a danger situation
that takes the form of a specific kind of unpleasure, accompanied by 'acts of
discharge' bringing partial relief. The tendency to avoid danger can be
referred to as a 'security drive', which is implicit in Freud's writings. Each
period of the individual's life has its characteristic definition of danger.
The danger of psychical helplessness, in the face of a growing
tension due to need against which the infant is helpless, is the most primitive
form. This primal anxiety is automatic and involuntary, due to the direct
confrontation with the danger situation.
Once the ego is more mature and able
to face its own psychical tension in a more ordered fashion, the danger becomes
the loss of a very specific object,
the mother, as she satisfies all the infant's needs. This second form
of anxiety is intentional, as it is used by the ego as a signal for the avoidance of a danger situation.
We have seen that the earliest mental life is
dominated by processes of projection and introjection. Once the innate Mnemic
systems are activated, the mental apparatus of the infant is dominated by the
primary thought processes that connect mental images according to the
pleasure/unpleasure principle.
The original state of affair of humans is
characterized by a total objective dependency and subjective self-absorption.
This "primary narcissism" parallels the lack of firm distinction
between the outer and the inner, which in turns parallels the lack of any
constituted ego : the primary narcissism therefore lacks a Narcissus.
After two years old, the baby enters the 'phallic
stage', whereby he discovers the pleasure potential of his genitals, long
before they acquire any reproductive significance. This discovery leads to
auto-stimulation. It is important to stress that the 'phallus' refers to the
external part of the genitals and therefore encompass the male penis and the
female clitoris.
This phallic phase radically differs
from the pre-genital phases, as it also pushes the child beyond mere
auto-eroticism : his libido becomes for the first time directed towards
other people. A sexual curiosity develops (childhood games) and
crystallizes on the parents. The little boy develops a sensual attachment to
his mother. The little girl, following the emergence of the 'penis envy' and
its transformation into a 'child envy', changes her object-choice from her
mother to her father. For Freud, there is no doubt about the sensual aim of
this affection.
Gendered identities progressively come into
play under the form of internalised social roles and norms. So far, the world
was merely divided into big and little people. The child learn to cathect
activities and objects that are socially relevant to his gender and to repress
those that are identified with the opposite gender. This learning process ends
up in the fundamental identification of the child with the parent of his own
gender.
As he identifies with his father, the little boy
develops a true sexual object-cathect towards his mother. The two currents
subsist side by side for a time without any mutual interference. In consequence
of the "irresistible advance towards a unification of mental life",
they eventually start conflicting with one another and the "normal"
Oedipus complex originates. The little boy feels that his father stands in his
way. His identification with him takes on a hostile colouring and "becomes
identical with the wish to replace his father in regard to his mother".
The emotional situation of the little girls is the exact anti-symmetric : she
identifies with her mother and sexually cathectes her father (thanks to the
'child envy'). These emotional elements form what Freud calls the positive (hetero-erotic) Oedipus
complex.
The issue is further complicated by
the innate bisexuality of humans. Indeed, boys also sexually cathexe
their father, and girls their mother. By the same token, they also identify
with the parent of the opposite gender. This is what Freud calls the negative
(homo-erotic) Oedipus complex. Together, the two Oedipus complexes form the Complete
Oedipus Complex which reflects humans' bisexuality.
When other children appear on the
scene the Oedipus complex is enlarged into a Family complex. New brothers
or sisters are received with repugnance and getting rid of them becomes a
central wish. This infantile kind of wish is often the basis of permanent
conflicts. Thus, the position of a child in the family order is of an extreme
importance.
Through the notion of 'castration complex', Freud proposes an experiential
explanation of the exit of boys from the Oedipus complex. Having seen the
female genitals, the little boy develops a new form of anxiety : the
fear of loss of the genitals, which have a high libidinal value to him. The
child consequently violently represses his aggressiveness towards his father,
by internalising the latter's authority through a new phenomenological agency :
the super-ego. Both the child's aggressiveness and love towards the father are
taken up by the super-ego. Its aggressive side is thereafter experienced as
guilt, its loving side as self-esteem. The dynamics Unconscious incorporates
the repressed wishes. As we can see, the castration complex triggers both
motivational (modification of the object of the aggressive drive : father ->
ego) and structural (creation of the super-ego) developments.
Girls slowly overcome the Oedipus
complex thanks to the permanent frustration they experience from their father.
The key factor here is sheer weariness and not a powerful fear as in the case
of boys. The female mode of repression has therefore not the cataclysmic
stature of the male one ; the female super-ego is consequently thought of by
Freud as structurally and significantly weaker than the male one.
Until the exit form the Oedipus
complex, repression of drives had always resulted form the fear of loss of love
from the external authority, that is of its aggression. With the setting up of
the super-ego the authority becomes internal.
This period marks a halt in the -so far- very rapid
sexual development of the child. Moreover, the majority of experiences and
impulses before the start of the latency period "fall victim to infantile
amnesia". This forgetting is in fact the outcome of a repression process
that follows the exit from the Oedipal complex and nourishes the dynamic
Unconscious.
Still, this period has a very
misleading name, as it suggests that development is frozen. If sexual
development undergoes a slowdown, still two very important steps are taken :
the development of partial aim inhibition with respect to sensual
feelings and sublimation.
The resolution of the Oedipus complex has split
up the libido into two distinct streams. The sensual feelings have been
deflected, as far as conscious life is concerned, from family members. This
sensual current has also undergone a stringent partial aim inhibition
experienced as warmth or closeness. These affectionate feelings partly
remain attached to family members and soon become directed towards same sex
people outside the family.
This is the time of formation of
close friendships in peer-groups (as opposed to individual
friendships in adolescence). These friendships are thus based on a latent homosexuality,
which is never fully satisfied. This is actually what make them last. These
groups also provide the context for new forms of identification as group
leaders strongly influence the ego-ideals of members.
The latency period is also a period
of strengthening of the 'incest taboo', which reinforces the split of the
libido and prepares itself to resist the fresh wave of sensual libido that
comes about at the time of puberty.
During the latency period the child learns to
direct its aggressive energy into socially approved activities. Work becomes the main area of
sublimation of these needs, in the forms of competition,
achievement and self-discipline.
In the aftermath of the Oedipal period, anxiety
takes the form of a fear of one's super-ego. Not breaking the rules is a way to
feel internally secure : this is moral anxiety. As the child moves into
the peer group, closer to adolescence, social anxiety comes about,
namely the fear of being isolated, of not belonging. These anxieties are signal-anxieties as they aim at avoiding
danger situations.
The crucial point is the maturation of the
secondary thought processes, that involves logical and realistic thinking. This
boils down to the progressive strengthening of the capacity to draw on the
energy of the secondary system so as to inhibit mental connections merely led
by the pleasure/unpleasure principle (primary thought processes).
Freud notes that the secondary
thought processes "unfold during the course of life" (Interpretation of Dreams, 640) but he
does not give a precise account of their chronological development. It is
Piaget's analysis of the child's cognitive development that helps us to roughly
locate their emergence around the age of five onwards (with the apparition of
concrete logical operation and logical thinking), that is during the latency
period. However, we have seen that some crucial elements of the secondary
thought processes, such as reality testing and the reality principle emerge
before the latency period.
At puberty, the maturation of the sexual
instinct launches new waves of libido. Drives become firmly organized under the
primacy of the genitals. The old familiar incestuous objects are unconsciously
taken up again and freshly cathected with libido, thus triggering an
unconscious struggle between infantile wishes and the sense of self which
internalised the Incest Taboo during the latency period.
The emotional challenge faced by adolescents
and young adults is the reunification of the two streams of libido, namely the
sensual and the affectionate currents. Deep emotional friendships provide an
occasion to merge these currents by sharing the intimate experiences. Love of
course as well. Freud distinguishes two kinds. The anaclitic love
(typically male) displays a 'sexual over-estimation' whereby the ego transfers
all its libido to the love-object. The narcissistic love (typically
female) is primarily a desire to be loved rather than to love.
The emotional freeing from the dependent
attachment to the parents is usually expressed through a period of rebellion.
Adulthood, in all its components, is a
cumulative product that carries alive every stage of the individual's
development.
The adult ego is the cumulative product
of its past identifications. As Freud puts it : " the character of
the ego is a precipitate of abandoned object-cathectis and contains the history
of those object-choices" (The Ego
and the Id, 24). The adult super-ego is the heir of the post-Oedipal
internalisation of the parental authority, later modified by a more mature
understanding of moral norms and autonomous choices of personal models and
ideals. The adult dynamic Unconscious is the cumulative product of early
pre-symbolized memories and repressed infantile wishes and traumata.
In Freud's view, the attitude of fond parents
towards their children has to be understood as a "revival of their own,
long since abandoned, narcissism". Thus, libidinaly speaking parenthood
operates a synthesis of narcissistic love and object-love which is made
possible by the identification
of the parents with the children, as a kind of extension of their selves.
"It may even be that the complete
domination [of the secondary thoughts processes] is not attained until the
prime of life" (Interpretation of
Dreams, 642). On the cognitive side, adulthood is therefore defined for
Freud by a clear domination of secondary thinking.
Adult life involves many normal forms of
regression to earlier stages of development. Sleep and dreams for instance show
features of structural, cognitive and motivational regression : blurring of the
boundary between the ego and the external world, primacy of primary thought
processes, and regression to infantile wishes. Jokes often involve cognitive
regression and the release of psychical tension from the secondary system,
discharged by laughing. Love or religious feelings can involve structural
regression through of weakening of the sense of self.
Many pathological mental phenomena
can be understood as regressions due to a libido fixation on earlier
stages. For instance perverse sexuality is "nothing else than a magnified
infantile sexuality" (Introductory,
385) The study of pathological regressions implies a study of the drives' economics,
that is of their quantitative relations.
It is hardly possible to overemphasize the
developmental perspective in Freud's work. This model of development provides
us with a rich view of human beings as carrying in themselves there many past
selves, which are never wiped out but at most drowsy.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Synthesis of the major
transformations humans undergo from childhood to adulthood
1) Structural development of
the mental apparatus
-
Simultaneous
differentiations Ego/Id and Inner/Outer
-
Differentiation
of the Super-Ego from the Ego
-
Cumulative
constitution of the dynamics Unconscious as a set of repressed infantile wishes
and traumatic experiences
2) Motivational development
-LIBIDO: from lack of drive organization to the
primacy of the genitals,
from ego-libido to object-libido
i.e. from bodily and narcissistic libidinal
satisfactions to love interests in
others
-AGGRESSIVENESS: from sadistic to masochist
forms, from outwards
to inwards aggressiveness (as
crystallized in the super-ego or sublimated
in work)
-ANXIETY: from object-loss to moral and social
anxieties
3) Cognitive development
-
From
primary to secondary thinking processes
4) Social development
-From primal narcissism to identification
-From identification to object-choice
-Socialization in peer groups
-Deep emotional adolescent friendships
-Male anaclitic love / female narcissistic love
-Fusion of identification and object-choice in parenthood:
emphatic helpers