 |
 |
 |
 |
| Miss Ohio Gay Pride 1998 Tara Richmond |
| Miss Ohio Gay Pride 1999 Krystal Stone |
| Miss Ohio Gay Pride 2000-2003 Alexis O'Hara |
| Miss Ohio Gay Pride 2004 Erica Martinez |
| Miss Ohio Gay Pride 2005 Kiarra Cartier-Fontaine |
| Miss Ohio Gay Pride Royalty |
 |
| Miss Ohio Gay Pride 2006 Danyel Vasquez |
 |
 |