Coastal
upwelling and the development of hypoxic dead zones are not removed from the
effects that climate change is having on the Earth’s dynamic climate
systems. In fact, it has become
increasingly evident that in light of climate change they may be inextricably
linked. The relevance of climate
change in considering the development and implications of hypoxic dead zones was
only first suggested in 1990 by Andrew Bakun. The important insight he made almost 20 years ago was that
the increase of atmospheric stocks of CO2 and other greenhouse gases
could lead to increased coastal upwelling. If increased greenhouse gas emissions forced increases in
temperature, the continents would warm, increasing the onshore-offshore
atmospheric pressure gradients.
This would then result in stronger winds and accelerated upwelling
(Bakun, 1990). Bakun even suggested that the cooling of the ocean
surface inherent in upwelling could couple with this process, creating a local
positive feedback by increasing atmospheric pressure gradients further (Bakun
1990). Intensified upwelling means
more nutrient rich deep-water coming up to the surface, which Bakun posited
would lead to increased primary production that would not by any necessity
contribute to greater populations of commercial fish. Instead “increased organic production might cause
large areas of these systems to become anoxic at depth,” (Bakun, 1990, p201).
Since then, the link between climate change and coastal upwelling (and thus, dead zones) is being more rigorously looked at. The nature of that link and its implications are clearer and more frightening.
Much of what Bakun and others has suspected has come to fruition, and some things are worse. Anoxia has not been limited to deeper waters. The increased rate of water renewal due to stronger upwelling prevents herbaceous zooplankton from maintaining populations. Phytoplankton populations, already benefiting from the nutrient-rich waters provided by the intensified upwelling systems, now grow unchecked by their traditional predator; herbaceous zooplankton (Bakun, 2004). This, as Bakun observed in the dead-zone along the Namib Desert, “provides an opportunity for massive buildup of phytoplankton biomass, much of which may sink unutilized onto the sea floor, resulting in thick accumulations of deposited unoxidized organic matter,” (Bakun, 2004, p1015-1016). Much of this ends up in anoxic deep waters, where this mass decomposes, producing H2S and CH4, which rise through the depths in the form of effervescent eruptions.
So
where’s the anoxia? Well, H2S,
aside from being extremely poisonous, has the “effect of stripping the
dissolved oxygen from the water column as it moves upward through it,” (Bakun,
2004, p1016). Anoxia caused by
such means is blamed for, “the loss of 80% of the regional stock of Cape hake
(Merluccius capensis), normally the basis for Namibia's most valuable fishery,”
(Bakun, 2004, p1016).
The diagram below illustrates the chemical and biological dynamics of a coastal upwelling zone under conditions of moderate and intensified upwelling (the diagram also illustrates a scenario stipulating a healthy sardine population; see Solutions):

The
upwelling region off of Namibia currently has the highest known rate of water
renewal of all of the world’s major upwelling regions. However, should climate change result
in a 15% increase in wind strength in these areas, which “seems not to be an
unreasonable projection”, water replacement rates in several other areas could
be pushed beyond the rate’s now experienced, causing massive ecological change,
as in Namibia (Bakun, 2004, p1018).
The below diagram from Andrew Bakun’s 2004 paper juxtaposes the current
water displacement rates of various upwelling zones, in terms of “fraction of
total upper layer volume replaced per day” with water replacement rates of the
same areas with a 15% increase in “upwelling favorable winds” (Bakun, 2004,
p1018):
