For years I've been annoyed at those reviewers who like to apply
the "worst filmmaker ever" label too liberally. Generally speaking, those
who do so have not seen enough movies to truly judge whether someone is
the worst filmmaker ever or not. For example, those who like to condemn
Uwe Boll as the "worst filmmaker ever" have probably never seen one of
Ed Wood's movies. Similarly, those who condemn Ed Wood as the "worst filmmaker
ever" have probably never seen a Bill Rebane picture; at least Wood' movies
tend to have a bizarrre sense of poetry and rhythm to them. This is not
the case in any Rebane picture I've seen so far.
I recently (and quite accidentially) subjected myself to a Bill Rebane mini-filmfest, and it was at that time that I decided that Mr. Rebane most definately deserves consideration as one of the worst filmmakers of all tine... just like the aforementioned Mr. Boll and Mr. Wood do. But the worst filmmaker of all time? Hardly. He's a guy you dont' even know, because his movies are so bad they exist only on a handful of videotapes given to cast and crew at the end of the production... and maybe behind the bookshelf at some distribution company where a copy fell before it was tossed in the trash.(How do I know this? Well, because I helped write the script for what is possibly the worst movie ever made. I'm relieved it never saw the light of day.
But, as far as the movies of Bill Rebane goes... since I've watched most of them at this point, I thought I'd honor them with a webpage. I understand that the man himself has been quite influential in encouraging filmmakers in the Midwest, and that he helped found the Wisconsin Filmboard. But his movies are still pretty awful. You can read my short reviews of them below. If you don't want to take my word for their "quality", you can get them cheap at Amazon.com, usually included in DVD mega-packs. (And that is the best way to get your Bill Rebane fix. You'll get to check out some truly bad movies, but there are bound to be some good movies in the set, too, so you'll get something worthwhile for your money. They can be purchased by following the links to the right of the reviews. A percentage of the money you spend after going to Amazon.com from those links goes to fund this website.)
The films here are rated on a Ten-Star scale, with Ten being a Damn
Great Movie and Zero being a Damnable Turd of a Movie. If you want to give
me your perspective on Bill Rebane films, please
email me. If I get enough interesting messages, I'll give them a special
webpage linked from here. (I will also be updating this page as I view
more Rebane movies... if I can find the strength to sit through them!)
| They (aka "Invasion from Inner Earth" and "Hell Fire")
Year of Release: 1974 Steve's Rating: One of Ten Stars Starring: Paul Bentzen, Debbie Pick, Nick Holt, Karl Wallace, and Robert Arkens Four men and one woman are in a remote wilderness when they hear reports of some strange calamity that has gripped the rest of the world. While trying to contain their own panic, they attempt to reestablish contact with the outside, but all they can raise on their shortwave radio is a strange, haunting voice. "They" is a movie that starts with a mystery and ends with a mystery. It never bothers to explain what's going on, although clearly SOMETHING is, because the filmmakers here don't understand the concept of P.O.V. and voice and they keep cutting away to show what's happening in nearby towns. Are aliens fumigating Earth in prepration for a takeover? Are people being "vanished" into the Inner Earth? Is this movie only watchable if you're really, REALLY stoned? None of these questions are answered. Although it did keep my interest to the point where I kept watching,
the film doesn't have a single good actor in it, the dialogue is lame,
the music soundtrack atrociously inconsistent and inappropriate for many
scenes, the special effects terrible, and the whole film ultimately pointless.
|
|
| The Alpha Incident (aka "Gift from the Red Planet")
Year of Release: 1977 Steve's Rating: One of Ten Stars Starring: Stafford Morgan, John Goff, Carol Irene Newell, George Flower, Paul Betzen, John Alderman, and Ralph Meeker After a dimwitted, clumsy railroad worker (Flower) breaks open the badly secured samples of a Martian virus being moved from one government lab to another, the agent escorting it (Morgan) must keep himself and a small group of local yokels at an isolated trainyard until a cure can be found. I should have stopped the DVD when the words "A Film by Bill Rebane" appeared on the screen, but. I didn't, and I witnessed a movie even worse, even more pointless than the other Bill Rebane films I've subjected myself to. While the acting is a little better here, the story goes nowhere, the characters never even rise to the level of figures they're so badly developed, neither the writer nor the director seem to have much of an ear for dialogue, or a sense of how to tell a good story. Whenever the film seems to start making a point--it repeatedly flirts with what stress and danger does to transform a person--it either backs off from it, or does it so ineptly the viewer (and just one viewer.., the person so wired on coffee and chocolate they've not been bored into a stupour, so they are still paying attention) must wonder if anyone involved with the production side has ever had any relationships with real people. The acting here is generally better than what might be witnessed in
the other Rebane opus I've seen, but the story is worse and even more pointless.
Its slow, and, like the train featured in it, seems to start a trip but
ultimately ends nowhere.
|
|
| The Cold (aka "The Game")
Year of Release: 1984 Steve's Rating: Three of Ten Stars Starring: Tom Blair, Stuart Obsorne, Donald Arthur, Debbie Martin,
and Carol Perry
Three bored millionaires (Arthur, Osborne, and Perry) invite a group of strangers to take part in a mysterious contest at a resort that is closed for the season. The winner will get one million dollars... if he or she survives! Until the final reel, this movie is a solid 4, which makes it one of the best Bill Rebane movies I've had the dubious pleasure of sit.ting through. The "game of fear" that the oldesters launch on their greedy guests is pretty juvenile, but tension starts to rise when it seems as though someone is playing for keeps... someone is eliminating players with extreme prejudice. However, as the movie comes to a close, it's as if everyone involved forgot what hade happened in the previous 70 minutes and some lame, unfounded twists get thrown in. Bill almost had a mediocre bad movie here, and then he blew it. Perhaps
he was going for a "third-wall" sort of effect, a situation where the game
being played by the characters in the film applies equally to the viewers.
If this was his intent, however, he blew the film even worse.
|
|
| The Demons of Ludlow
Year of Release: 1983 Steve's Rating: Four of Ten Stars Starring: Paul von Hausen, Stephanie Cushna, Carol Perry,
James R. Robinson, C. Dave Davis, and Angailica
A curse that's haunted a small New England town since its founding two hundred years ago is brought fully to horrible life when a piece of its secret history--a piano that sounds like a harpsichord (or is that a harpsichord that looks like an upright piano?)--resurfaces. Will the town preacher (Von Hausen) and a pair of young journalists (Cushna and Robinson) stop the curse, or will they fall victim to it? I have inadvertently subjected myself to a Bill Rebane mini-filmfest by watching two of his works in a row. I don't know wether my ability to tell crap from quality has finally started to erode, but "The Demons of Ludlow" was actually pretty good for a low-budget horror film. Compared to some of Rebane's other efforts, it's downright brilliant. Unfortunately, like another of his almost-good movies--"The Game" (aka "The Cold")--he and his writers simply can't seem to pull off the ending. Remember my question as to whether the preacher and the journalist escape the curse? That remains a question at the end of the movie, and it's not a question that hangs there in a good way. The ending is so abrupt that seems as though Rebane ran out of film and had no money to buy more. The film simply feels like the creators forgot the ending. If a little more care had been taken to construct a story with
a decent end, this could have ben a solid 5, or maybe even a low 6. The
soundtrack is decent, the acting is better than most of what you see in
films of this kind, and there are even some pretty scary scenes--the sequences
where the preacher's alcoholic wife is being tormented by the ghosts' of
Ludlow's past are particularly well done. But, again, Rebane screws up
the ending.
|
|
For more about Bill Rebane, check out this webpage for a biography and links to production details of his movies. And, although he's over 70 now, Rebane is keeping young. He's got himself a MySpace page that can be visited here.