AUTHOR: Kate M (also Kathryn Ravvin) E-MAIL: Enigma806@aol.com TITLE: "Every Rose Has Its Thorn" RATING: PG-13 (No drugs, no sex, rather mild gore...mainly for the one Russian Roulette scene.) I prefer to err on the side of caution...you don't get your butt sued that way! (I might throw in a little rock-'n'-roll... :-P) SUMMARY: On the most romantic day of the year, Mulder and Scully face the toughest moments of their lives. FEEDBACK: Yes! Yes! YES!!!!! It really does mean a lot to me. And I *do* respond. You have to understand, we authors...our egos require a lot of stroking...I accept constructive criticism, too. Flames will be saved for the purpose of burning my Euclidean geometry texts. If you want to use any or all of this story for something, contact me. ORGANIZATION: I'm a drifter... (I'd have said "FBI", but I don't need any legal trouble!) KEYWORDS (CATEGORY): Valentine's Day, MSR, major angst, torture (both M&S), Ratboy returns...whatever else you might want to read into it...(plus minor UST). DISCLAIMER: Chris Carter is god of anything and everything XF. I bow in humble subjection before him, 1013, and FOX. I'm not worthy. I'm taking their characters (not mine, I said, NOT MINE!--oh, that hurt...) out to play for a little while...I'm not making any money off this! I'll return them when I'm done. I promise. Except maybe Mulder. Just kidding, you can have him back too. And, much as I hate it, I'll even clean up. Deal? Okay! Good, then! Thanks! No infringement intended. Any songs mentioned here are also not mine, unless otherwise noted. DISCLAIMER 2: The poems quoted in here are by a friend of mine, Ryan Scott. I don't intend to take credit for 'em, although I wish I could. They're really good! ARCHIVE: Yes, please, definitely, but please tell me first, so I don't accidentally repost later. And feel free to pass this along, as long as my name stays attached. SPOILERS: Not really...unless you count one of Scully's speculations as a reference to "Closure". But you probably won't think anything of it unless you've seen the episode. Oh, wait, there's one for "Pusher" and "Anasazi". And a tiny one for "The End","Paper Hearts", and "731". The others are just "obscure references". SEASON NOTE: Really, this is supposed to be 7th season--it presumes that Valentine's Day was *before* "Sein Und Zeit", however. Otherwise, a lot of stuff would contrast continuity. AUTHOR'S NOTES: Hope you enjoy this...even if I'm still a little ticked over the fact that fictional characters are seeing more romance than I am! :-P It might get a little depressing, but things *do* work out, eventually...I promise. I don't write *too* many Valentine's Day stories of destruction... really! I swear it! Okay, fine, then, don't believe me. One other thing...in certain spots, I'm going for a sort of parallelism... *please* don't think of me as simply repetitive! Okay, 'nuff said, now on to the story! ************************************************************************ February 14 Annapolis, Maryland With a heavy sigh, Special Agent Fox Mulder got out of his car. He looked down at his attire. Black suit. Hmm. He could've sworn he'd put the *navy* one on this morning, but then again, it *had* been dark. He'd gotten up late, and had to hurry to work. Let's see...black suit, white shirt, black tie...he had his sunglasses on against the sun's glare...had he happened to have a black fedora on hand, he could've been one of the men in black (or one of the Blues Brothers, but that was another story altogether). He looked to his left, expecting his partner to be tagging along. It wasn't her. It was Skinner's secretary, Grace McDaniel. She was wearing a dark dress as well...it was a little dark to be grey, a little light to be black. He chuckled softly. So she was protesting Valentine's Day as well, as she'd threatened to earlier in the month. He didn't like Valentine's Day. Not because he had something personal against it, but rather because he had no one to share it with. The friendly "dates" that had become an annual tradition between himself and Scully didn't really count. If he only had the nerve to ask her out! Grace drew up beside him. "How're you holding up, Mulder?" "I'm fine," he replied. Okay, he didn't like the day, but it wasn't as though he were *depressed*.... Grace smiled at him--sympathetically, it seemed. "I wish I could lie half as well as you do." "Really, Grace," he insisted, "I'm fine. I'll just go home tonight, curl up with my video collection, and pretend like this whole day never happened." She took off her sunglasses as they approached the building, and he could see the very real hurt in her eyes--one that *didn't* come from the brightness of the sun. Maybe this was affecting her more than she was letting on. Maybe she...who knew? He hadn't spent excessive amounts of time with Grace, so he couldn't say for sure...hey, Skinner had just been complaining about not having anyone! Maybe Mulder could set his boss up with Grace...nah. It'd never work out. < he thought, < And where was Scully, anyway? She'd said she'd meet him there. With a sigh, he took off his own sunglasses, tucked them safely inside his suit jacket, and stepped inside the...cathedral? Huh? He could've sworn Scully had given him directions to the research facility she'd wanted to check out, but then again...she was...*Scully*. He couldn't even guess at the way her mind worked sometimes, but rather suspected the feeling was mutual. And she *was* Catholic... He and Grace exchanged a glance. "Here goes nothing," he sighed. "Or everything," she added. < And why was Grace even there in the first place? Oh, well...some questions might be best left unanswered...but he wanted some answers soon--forget conventional wisdom! XXXXXXXX Boston, Massachusetts Blowing a pesky strand of auburn hair out of her face, Dana Scully once again vowed her revenge on the smart aleck who had decided that the death of a martyr named St. Valentine was reason to make the day a romantic celebration. She'd purposely dressed in black, as Skinner's secretary had vowed to do...red may have been the color of the day, but she wasn't going to give anyone the pleasure. It surprised her that she was in such a mood over the day, though. Sure, being alone on Valentine's Day was no real treat, but she *did* have Mulder. And having a friend-- scratch that, best friend--was certainly better than nothing. She had to admit it, those alien-shaped chocolates he had given her last year *were* kind of cute...if not exactly something she'd have bought herself. At Mulder's request, she'd accompanied him to Massachusetts a week ago-- Chilmark, to be exact. He'd thought he'd found some more information on his sister Samantha's disappearance. He'd been called back to D.C. yesterday, but wanted her to follow up on one more lead for him. And she'd done it. Not out of duty or obligation...not because she felt she owed it to him...but because she'd *wanted* to. She was his friend. She wanted to find Samantha just as much as he did...although she was a bit more realistic about it than he was. But that was probably because he was so close to the case. Had it been one of her own siblings, she'd probably have been just as blind to the facts as he was. She'd intended to return to D.C. today and meet him at an Annapolis research facility, but she'd missed her plane. Just her luck, today of all days! At least it wasn't Friday the 13th or anything. That would have sent Mulder on a speech about the day that she'd have been hard-pressed to stop. Of course, Monday wasn't exactly her favorite day of the week, either. But that was only natural...right? She had decided to spend the time before she had to catch the next flight out (5 hours!) hanging around Boston. She'd never gotten much of a chance to see the city... and most of the time she and her partner had spent in the state had been in the Martha's Vineyard area--Chilmark, West Tisbury, the surrounding towns. But where was she now? Inside, that was for sure...but *where*? She couldn't believe she'd let her mind drift off *that* much. Fortunately, a man approached her. He seemed to know what was going on. "Miss Scully. You'll want to come this way, please." She smiled gratefully. "Thank you." "It's no trouble," he replied. "Are you all right?" "Sure," Scully answered. "I was just a little...distracted for a moment." He patted her hand in what she assumed was supposed to be a comforting manner. "Completely understandable. You've been through a lot." < Not that the last part of that would have been such a bad thing. He *was* sort of cute... XXXXXXXX Mulder and Grace were soon approached by the man they both worked for--each in their own way. And, of course, Grace was a little more likely not to tick the man off. But Mulder ticked a lot of people off, so that was something he was used to. The FBI's "most unwanted", the agency maverick...Fox Mulder would never be completely controlled. Not even by the certain female agent assigned to keep him in line and out of his superiors' hair. The man approaching was none other than Assistant Director Walter S. Skinner. He looked...well, Mulder wasn't entirely sure *how* he looked. Like his dog had run away or something. Okay, so maybe that wasn't a very apt comparison. But, then, Mulder didn't exactly specialize in apt comparisons (unless they somehow pertained to the extraterrestrial or otherwise strange). "Mulder," Skinner said simply. "How are you?" "I'm okay," Mulder answered. "Fortunately, this only has to be done once a year." Skinner nodded ruefully. "Unfortunately, in our line of work, that seems to be the case. God, I just wish it were someone else. I know that sounds awful, but I do." Mulder couldn't quite hold back a grin. "Believe me, sir...I know exactly how you feel." Skinner regarded him for a long moment. "You know, Fox, I honestly believe you do. You're probably one of the few that would." < Mulder wondered, slightly indignant. < Funny he should think of Scully's mother just then, because she was there too. She looked as though a terrible tragedy had recently occurred in her life. Mulder crossed over to her, wondering what the problem was and hoping he could help. The last time he'd seen Margaret this upset was right after Melissa died. Hey, maybe this was why Scully had wanted him there. Where *was* she?! Mulder walked over to Margaret. "Mrs. Scully?" She pulled him into a tight embrace. "Oh, Fox..." she sighed. "I don't know what to do..." "Hey," he soothed, pulling away, "it's going to be all right. We'll make it out of this just fine." Out of what, he hadn't a clue. But it seemed like a good thing to say. He looked into her eyes...eyes that held a world of pain and too much hurt. She was crying, and he brushed the tears away. Mulder had always had a soft spot for Margaret...she was like another mother to him. The personification, almost, of the ideal mother-- loving, patient, strong, and so much more. It tore at his heart to see her like this. Another man stood nearby, maybe a few years older than Mulder. The agent had never met him before, but felt as though he should've. The man regarded Mulder with a mixture of sympathy and respect. "You don't have to be so strong about this, you realize. I know how close you two were. Dana told me." With a quick glance around, all the pieces fell into place for Mulder. He mentally kicked himself. < But whose? Scully had given him directions...he assumed it had to be someone she knew as well. That was made all the more likely by Margaret's presence-and the fact that Skinner and Grace were there too. And he was apparently close to this person. A sense of dread filled him. Who? Who could it be? Who else had he lost to this foolish game? They'd already taken his sister, abducted Scully, murdered his father. Who else? Who now? Or *had* this death been due to his allegiance? Had it been natural? Had it been an accident? What was going on here? And why couldn't he remember? Too many questions. Way too many questions. And not enough answers to go around. XXXXXXXX Teena Mulder sat alone in the lobby, looking as lost (and depressed) as Scully felt. Scully was surprised to see her, but not precisely thunderstruck. After all, Boston wasn't that far from the Vineyard. And Teena still went up to the Vineyard fairly often, despite everything. "Mrs. Mulder?" Teena turned, and almost smiled--almost. "Miss Scully. I'm glad you could make it. I heard your flight left this morning." "I'm catching another one later," Scully replied, shrugging. "This hasn't really best the best of days for me." "I know how you feel, dear," Teena said, putting a hand on Scully's shoulder. "Truthfully, I do. I've seen this too many times in my life. But I'm still glad you're here. I know the two of you were very close." "Things *have* been a little strained lately," Scully admitted, correct in assuming that the older woman was alluding to the relationship between herself and Mulder, "but I never thought it was anything we couldn't work through. We *do* have our fights every now and then." "You're only human." Teena began to walk away, motioning for Scully to join her. "And with two such different personality types, the occasional argument...well, it was inevitable. Take my advice, Miss Scully. Don't beat yourself up over it. Don't torture yourself over all the things you might have done differently. I've spent too many years doing just that, and all it got me was a lot of sleepless nights. You were very special to him. You always have been." "He told you that?" Scully asked, her blue eyes widening. For as sweet and sensitive as he could be, verbally expressing his feelings was not one of Mulder's strengths. "Not in so many words," Teena answered, "but I could tell. A mother knows these things." They stepped into a room together, and Scully stopped short. There were a lot of people there...all dressed the same as they were. In black. A funeral? It certainly appeared that way, but whose? A fleeting look back at Teena confirmed that this was indeed the correct place. A tear slipped down Teena's cheek. Oh, God. Had they finally found Samantha--only to discover that she was dead? Was that why Mulder had left her here...because the truth was too painful for him to face? She fervently hoped not. Samantha couldn't be dead...she just couldn't. But if not Samantha, then who? Scully took another step inside, bracing herself for whatever was to come. XXXXXXXX Mulder approached the casket, Margaret by his side. His need to know prevailed over his apprehension about finding out. Margaret squeezed his hand. Mulder looked. Suddenly, all the breath rushed out of him, and he stumbled backward in a combination of shock and horror. Margaret helped him to sit, suddenly having become the comforter instead of the comforted. It was his worst nightmare come to life. The one thing he had hoped never in his life to have to face. It was Scully. XXXXXXXX Scully's surprise over finding herself at a funeral was only superseded by her surprise at also finding Walter Skinner there. "Sir?" she asked, hopelessly trying to make sense of it all. He hugged her. "I'm sorry. I really am. I know how tough this has to be for you." Teena had already wandered off by this time, so she wasn't going to be much help. While Scully was puzzling over this, Skinner continued talking. She forced herself to concentrate on what it was he was saying. "I've worked with a lot of people over the years, Dana..." < she wondered, amused. <