Also visit
"Where's the Math?"
a statewide nonpartisan grassroots organization advocating for world-class math standards and math choices for Washington State students.
MUST-SEE VIDEOS!

Unhappy with the current math curricula used in the North Kitsap schools? Join with other concerned parents, teachers and citizens through our Yahoo! email group to be notified of upcoming meetings and relevant school board business related to math curricula.

Click here to join NKMathWatchClick to join the NKMathWatch listserv

Contact Yes2Math

Get Informed!

You could spend days researching the current state of U.S. math education, reading expert reviews of K-12 curricula from math professionals around the country. Start with the Links below. Then visit wheresthemath.com, NYCHold, or Mathematically Correct for much, much more!

 

 


Math Curriculum Informational Links

for parents in Kitsap County, Washington
especially in the communities of Poulsbo, Kingston, Hansville, and elsewhere
in the North Kitsap School District

  • IN 2004, THE NORTH KITSAP SCHOOL DISTRICT ADOPTED "TERC/ INVESTIGATIONS" MATH CURRICULUM FOR GRADES K-5. Were they aware of the controversies surrounding this curriculum elsewhere around the U.S. when they adopted it? SEE LINKS BELOW.
  • IN 2005, THE DISTRICT ADOPTED "CONNECTED MATH" FOR GRADES 6-8. FOR MORE INFORMATION ON "CONNECTED MATH", FOLLOW THE LINKS BELOW.
  • IN 2006, THE DISTRICT ADOPTED "COLLEGE PREPARATORY MATH" (CPM) FOR HIGH SCHOOL. MORE BAD NEWS!! SEE LINKS BELOW.
  • IN 2007, THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION, FOLLOWING LEGISLATIVE ACTION, IS DIRECTING OSPI TO REVISE OUR STATE MATH STANDARDS to match world-class standards already adopted in California and other states. THESE THREE CURRICULA ARE NOT APPROVED FOR USE IN CALIFORNIA UNDER THESE REVISED STANDARDS. HOW WILL OUR DISTRICT RESPOND? WHAT ABOUT NEW SCHOOL BOARD CANDIDATES?

ABOUT THIS PAGE:

This page is being posted for parents who are looking for a one-stop hub for in-depth information about the mathematics curricula being used in our school district. "Yes2Math" site developers are NK district parents who are concerned that, through a legitimate desire to improve the quality of math instruction for all students, our school administrators are choosing all the wrong instructional materials and approaches for our kids. The sites below address specific issues related to curricula including "Investigations in Numbers, Data and Space", "Connected Math", "College Preparatory Math" and programs with a similar pedagogical approach. (ALSO SEE "WHY WE'RE CONCERNED")

We find it interesting to note that if you "drill down" through these links, you will find observers from many different political/ideological viewpoints coming together in agreement on the issue of math education. We recommend these links as a jumping-off place to your own "Investigations" into the objections to "Whole Math" / "Integrated Math" / "New-New Math" as presented by professionals and involved parents around the U.S.

We would like to hear from other parents, educators and community members in North Kitsap who share our concerns. Any contact information you provide on this site would only be shared (together with others' input) with the NK School Board, and then only with your permission. To join a related discussion forum, click on the Yahoo!Group link and become a group member.

Click here to join NKMathWatch
Click to visit or join NKMathWatch

One of our school board members was asked about his position on "Math Reform" and curriculum choices. Find out his response here.

ON THIS PAGE:

WHY WE'RE CONCERNED

THOUGHTS FROM A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER

AN OVERVIEW OF THE "MATH REFORM" CONTROVERSY

REVIEWS OF NKSD MATH CURRICULA

NATIONAL LINKS

WASHINGTON STATE LINKS

ON THE OTHER HAND...



HERE'S WHY WE'RE CONCERNED...

DOES THIS QUOTE BOTHER YOU? THIS IS WHAT THE WASHINGTON STATE OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTION (OSPI) PUBLISHED IN A DOCUMENT TITLED "TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS", DATED MARCH 2000. (Read for yourself! Go to Page 58.)

“Students exhibit four basic "dysfunctional" [author’s emphasis] mathematical beliefs (Borasi, 1990; based on a review of Buerk, 1981, 1985; Oaks, 1987; Schoenfeld, 1985a):
1. The goal of mathematical activity is to provide the correct answer to given problems, which always are well defined and have predetermined, exact solutions.
2. The nature of mathematical activity is to recall and apply algorithmic procedures appropriate to the solution of the given problems.
3. The nature of mathematical knowledge is that everything (facts, concepts, and procedures) is either right or wrong with no allowance for a gray area.
4. The origin of mathematical knowledge is irrelevant - mathematics has always existed as a finished product which students need to absorb as transmitted by teachers.”

EXACTLY WHAT IS "DYSFUNCTIONAL" HERE? PLEASE FOLLOW THE LINKS BELOW FOR MUCH, MUCH MORE....

Curriculum Reviews and Commentary:
 
TERC "Investigations in Number, Data and Space"
B. Braams (PhD): TERC "Investigations" review
Plus more LINKS from Dr. Braams

W.G. Quirk (PhD): TERC "Investigations" review
Plus more LINKS from Dr. Quirk

"Fuzzy Math" in Wisconsin (PDF)
Descriptive article of parents' experiences with Investigations

Wilfried Schmid (PhD): Harvard Prof Speaks Out
Harvard Math Prof. (and PARENT)'s letter to US House of Representatives

W.S. Wilson (PhD): Johns Hopkins Prof Speaks Out
Veteran JHU Math Prof writes an engaging letter to his son's elementary school...

"Do [TERC and similar] programs prepare students for calculus?" by S. Ocken, Math Prof. at CUNY: Well-reasoned presentation of the shortcomings of "Investigations" for college-prep math

Kids Do Count! Excellence in Math
Great place to start--comprehensive! Utah parents concerned about Investigations and Connected Math in their schools.

Teach Utah Kids
MORE Utah parents active re: Investigations & Connected Math

Connected Mathematics Project (Connected Math, CMP)
An Evaluation of CMP: R. James Milgram
R. James Milgram Ph.D rewrote the California Mathematics Standards for the California State Board of Education with colleagues at Stanford. With UC Berkeley Professor H. H. Wu, he helped write the California Mathematics Framework. He is a member of the National Board for Education Science and the NASA Advisory Council. He is also a Mathematics reviewer for the new NCTM Mathematics Guidelines.
ftp://math.stanford.edu/pub/papers/milgram/report-on-cmp.html

CMP Review by Mathematically Correct
"
Searching for content the reviewers find that there is little or no coverage of the properties of arithmetic; exponents, squares, and roots; fractions, decimals, and percents; and the book is devoid of algebraic manipulation. The only mathematical content that the reviewers find relates to Proportions and to Graphing. The reviewers write: 'There is very little mathematical content in this book. Students leaving this course will have no background in or facility with analytic or pre-algebra skills. [...] This book is completely dedicated to a constructivist philosophy of learning, with heavy emphasis on discovery exercises and rejection of whole class teacher directed instruction. [...] Students are busy, but they are not productively busy. Most of their time is directed away from true understanding and useful skills.' "
http://www.mathematicallycorrect.com/books7a.htm

CPM / College Preparatory Math
Content Review By Prof. Wayne Bishop of California Content Review Panel.
CPM WAS WITHDRAWN FOR CONSIDERATION AS AN APPROVED CURRICULUM IN CALIFORNIA.
http://www.mathematicallycorrect.com/cpmwb.htm

"Math Problems: Why the U.S. Department of Education's recommended math programs don't add up"
Search for CPM on this page: http://www.mathematicallycorrect.com/usnoadd.htm

Math method not working for some
http://www.press-enterprise.com/newsarchive/1998/04/26/893547127.html

Too Much PR
http://www.mathematicallycorrect.com/cpmpr.htm

 

An Overview...
A comprehensive history & analysis of the current "math reform" craze. Also discusses the political stalemate that is maintaining the "status quo".
In the News: (Many more recent news items available at wheresthemath.com)
Boston Globe Editorial on Boston teachers' feelings about TERC (Nov. 2004) "There's a new four-letter word among some elementary school teachers in Boston: "TERC."   Seattle Times Editorial by U.W. Atmospheric Sciences Professor (Nov. 2004) "Increasing numbers of our students have been forced to take remedial math courses prior to starting the normal college curriculum."
Seattle Times Editorial by Ballard High School Math Teacher  (March 2005). "As we direct our curriculum more and more toward skills that are reflected in the WASL, we harm our students' chances for success in college."    
National Links:    
MathematicallyCorrect
The granddaddy of them all! CA activists who organized and prevailed. Curriculum Reviews HERE.
  NYC HOLD
NYC math activists' site--heavy hitters here! Many links.
     
"Math Wars" Essay
What's going on in math education? David Ross, PhD, Kodak Labs Mathematician, explains
  American Enterprise Inst.
Lynne Cheney-moderated discussion with NCTM head and math reform opponents including "Mathematically Correct" founders
California's New Improved Math Standards
How would your Washington State student measure up? Practice Tests for each grade level HERE.
   
State/Local Links:    
Where's The Math? DOT-COM
Information about what's going on with math reform in Washington State--our own MathematicallyCorrect.com.
  "Math Instruction Needs Discussion" (MIND)Another concerned citizen's web site!
Parents for Math Matters (Spokane)
A parent's organization petitioning for change in Spokane
  Seattle Teacher's Testimony before the Seattle School Board
Bellevue School District
Parents' letter of concern
   
On The Other Hand:    
TERC Web Site
Developers of the "Investigations" curriculum make their case
   
     
Peripheral issues:    
Math classes & Gifted/Talented Students
"Age based tracking versus ability grouping in elementary school mathematics"
   

You are visitor #: Site Meter

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1