Battlefield Union Pacific
GE and EMD Compete in the Two Engine Locomotive Days
An illustration of a DD35 B-unit in its demonstrator scheme from my DD35 manual. The publication date for the manual is August of 1964.
      It is well known that Union Pacific has had most of the biggest locomotives ever built since the beginning of their exsistence. Union Pacific's answer to the demand for quick service on their rails over a  challenging geography was more horspower. During the Steam Era, Union Pacific was using 4-6-6-4
"Challangers" and 4-8-8-4 "Big Boys" to run long, heavy train loads over and through the mountains. The 4-6-6-4's were designed to produce at least 6000 HP and the 4-8-8-4's were designed to produce 7000 HP. In the late 1930's, Union Pacific and General Electric were working together on a steam turbine concept, but extensive testing of the new concept in motive power proved to be too difficult to maintain and was never palced in regular service.

       Although no railroad would believe you if you told them in the 1930's that the Steam Era would end after the war, the locomotive builders kept creating new, competitive, and alternative technology. Already having experience with gas turbine engines, General Electric decided to work with the American Locomotive Company (ALCO) to develop a gas turbine electric locomotive (GTEL) in the late 1940's. By the mid-1950's, Union Pacific had all 25 4500 HP GTEL's they ordered and placed a third order for 30 big 8500 HP GTEL's. During the same period of receiving their third order of GTEL's(1960's), Union Pacific went into the development of a coal-burning gas turbine. Unfortunately, this turbine was overwhelmed with operating problems and didn't last two years in service.

       As the 1960's rolled around, Union Pacific noticed that their gas turbine units needed to be replaced because the locomotives were heavily used. Having already experimented with mounting two diesel engines on the same chassis, the Union Pacific presented the concept of 5000 HP diesel electric locomotives with two engines on the same chassis to General Electric, EMD, and ALCO. GE was the first locomotive builder to respond with the U50. They used the proven technology of their U25-series locomotives and placed two 16-cylinder Model 7FDL-16 diesel engines on two U25 chassises, connected rear-end to rear-end (visualy, the radiators would be at the outer ends of the locomotive) with a new-styled cabs at one end. Also, the locomotive would ride on four sets of trucks with a  B+B-B+B arrangement just like their previous GTEL's. All in all, Union Pacific had a total of 23 of these U50s while Southern Pacific received three.

       EMD responded by introducing the DD35. Like GE, EMD used the technology of their GP35 locomotives and placed two 16-cylinder 567D3A diesel engines (on one huge new chassis), also connected rear-end to rear-end with bothof the cabs cut off. However, unlike GE which used trucks similar to their GTEL's, EMD designed huge four-axle D-type trucks to place under their DD35s (which can be seen below). A total of 30 locomotives were built, 27 of which were sent to the UP (including the 2 demonstrators) and 3 sent to the SP.
DD35 four-axle trucks from my DD35 manual.
UP's motive power chief David S Neuhart was determined to continue the experiment.  Perhaps most significant was the need to improve reliability beyond that conventionally experienced; the failure of one engine, with these dual-engine units, took two units' worth of power out of service and the overall economics of the locomotives were poor.  With that in mind, each manufacturer chose to resolve these issues in a different way. EMD built the DDA40X, which had a greater increase in horsepower and modularizred electrical locomotive equipment. GE built the U50C, with a massive decrease in weight, but had the same horsepower as its predecessor the U50. In both cases, the economics of the locomotives were theoretically better. As history has showed us, EMD's choice sparked a new electrical systems design, which was the heart of dash-2 locomotives. However, GE's U50C was a disaster and led them to forget everything about the U50C.
Pictures to the left is the control stand arrangement for the U50C. Ths is from my manual GEJ-3872
Pictured above is the controller for the U50C. This is from my manual GEJ-3872
An interesting fact about the U50C is that it was among the first GE locomotives to transition from 16-notch throttle to an 8-notch throttle. Also, the diesel engines operated on an advanced speed schedule. The engine speed will remain the same in notches 1 through 5 and increases in notches 6, 7, and 8. You can also see in the controller picture that the selector lever and reverse lever are in the same lever. This is known as the 2-lever controller.
Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1