| WINNER | DEFEATED | DATE | SITE | Taka Michinoku | Brian Christopher | 12/7/97 | Springfield, MA |
| Christian | Taka Michinoku | 10/18/98 | Chicago, IL |
| Duane Gill | Christian | 11/17/98 | Columbus, OH |
| Essa Rios | Duane Gill | 2/8/00 | Austin, TX |
| Dean Malenko | Essa Rios | 3/13/00 | N/A |
| Scotty Too Hotty | Dean Malenko | 4/17/00 | State College, PA |
| Dean Malenko (2) | Scotty Too Hotty | 4/25/00 | Charlotte, NC |
| Crash Holly | Dean Malenko | 3/12/01 | Anaheim, CA |
| Jerry Lynn | Crash Holly | 4/29/01 | Chicago, IL |
| Jeff Hardy | Jerry Lynn | 6/5/01 | Grand Folks, ND |
| X-Pac | Jeff Hardy | 6/25/01 | New York, NY |
| Tajiri | X-Pac | 8/6/01 | Anaheim, CA |
| X-Pac (2) | Tajiri | 8/19/01 | San Jose, CA |
| Tajiri (2) | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Billy Kidman | Tajiri | 4/2/02 | Rochester, NY |
| Tajiri (3) | Billy Kidman | 4/21/02 | Kansas City, MO |
| The Hurricane | Tajiri | 5/14/02 | Montreal, QU |
| Jamie Noble | The Hurricane | 6/23/02 | Columbus, OH |
| Billy Kidman (2) | Jamie Noble | 11/17/02 | New York, NY |
| Matt Hardy | Billy Kidman | 2/23/03 | Montreal, QU |
| Rey Mysterio | Matt Hardy | 6/3/03 | Anaheim, CA |
| Tajiri (4) | Rey Mysterio | 9/23/03 | Philadelphia, PA |
| Rey Mysterio (2) | Tajiri | 12/30/03 | Laredo, TX |
| Chavo Guerrero, Jr | Rey Mysterio | 2/15/04 | San Francisco, CA |
| Jacqueline | Chavo Guerrero, Jr | 5/4/04 | Tucson, AZ |
| Chavo Guerrero, Jr (2) | Jacqueline | 5/16/04 | Los Angeles, CA |
| Rey Mysterio, Jr (3) | Chavo Classic | 6/17/04 | Chicago, IL |
| Spike Dudley | Rey Mysterio, Jr. | 7/27/04 | Cincinnati, OH |
