A warehouse on Fifth Street purchased by John Dugan in
1820 became the first Catholic church and was called "Trinity Church and oftentimes
the "brick church". All catholics attended this church until 1842 when,
at that time, the German speaking catholics united and formed their own church.
As the congregation grew in the "brick church" a larger one soon became
necessary and the cornerstone was laid in March 1825 for a new one.
When it was dedicated in 1827 it was named St John's Roman Catholic Church.
The congregation continued to rapidly increase so it was decided in 1842
that another larger church was needed. The old church was demolished . The
cornerstone for the present church was laid in March 1842 on the same Fifth
Street site and was renamed St Thomas.
All catholics attended the fifth street catholic church until 1842 when
the German speaking members separated and united to form their own church
at the head of Main Street and Greenwood Avenue .It was named St Nicholas.
The present church was erected in 1898.
The "old" St Nicholas Cemetery was plotted on Wheeling Ave and
burials were made there thru 1921. The cemetery has not been maintained
and few legible stones remain. Even though the stones remain the bodies may
have been moved. When the "new" cemetery land was purchased a number of
the bodies were removed from Wheeling Avenue and re-interred
in Mt Olive- the name chosen for the "new" burial place. Mt Olive is located
on Rt 40 East at the top of the hill just beyond the Sunrise Shopping Center.
The St Thomas and St Nicholas cemetery transcriptions have
been read and copied by the Muskingum County Genealogical Society and can
be found in their library which is located on the second floor of the John
McIntire library on Fifth Street. Some St Thomas baptism and
interment records can be researched in the publication MUSKINGUM
COUNTY FOOTPRINTS which is also available.