| Round | Blind Sided Sacks | VFH | Blue Hens | Raider Nation | Da Don SP | Sophmore Slump? | Crystal Ballers | Your Mom | Rough Riders | The High Guys | |||
| 1 | Peyton Manning | Shaun Alexander | Ladanien Tomlinson | Priest Holmes | Daunte Culpepper | Willis McGahee | Edgerrin James | Randy Moss | Dominick Davis | Tiki Barber | |||
| 2 | Julius Jones | Tory Holt | Marvin Harrison | Chad Johnson | Clinton Portis | Jamal Lewis | Terrell Owens | Corry Dillon | Donovann McNabb | Duece McAllister | |||
| 3 | Curtis Martin | Rudi Johnson | Ahman Green | Kevin Jones | Javon Walker | Andre Johnson | Steven Jackson | Lamont Jordan | Nate Burleson | Joe Horn | |||
| 4 | Tony Gonzalez | Michael Clayton | Drew Bennett | Ashlie Lelie | Brian Westbrook | Jerry Porter | Steve Smith | Hines Ward | Tatum Bell | Reggie Wayne | |||
| 5 | Muhsin Muhammad | Antonio Gates | Darrell Jackson | Issac Bruce | Anquan Boldin | Laverneou Coles | Donald Driver | Roy Williams | Jimmy Smith | Chris Chambers | |||
| 6 | Derrick Mason | Deion Branch | Kerry Collins | Jake Plummer | Plaxico Burress | Jason Witten | Baltimore | Trent Green | Larry Fitzgerald | TJ Housmanzadeh | |||
| 7 | Eric Moulds | Marc Bulger | Alge Crumpler | Jermaine Wiggins | Pittsburgh | Chris Brown | Jake Delhomme | Fred Taylor | Jeromy Shockey | Dallas Clarke | |||
| 8 | David Akres | New England | Cadillac Williams | Carolina | Randy McMichael | Lee Evans | Eddie Kenison | Todd Heap | Philadelphia | Buffalo | |||
| 9 | Minnesota | Santana Moss | New York Jets | Warrick Dunn | Adam Vinatieri | Atlanta | Ronnie Brown | Brandon Stokley | Cedric Benson | Michael Bennett | |||
| 10 | Braylon Edwards | JJ Arrington | Duce Staley | DeShaun Foster | Keenan McCardell | Carson Palmer | Troy Williamson | Mike Anderson | Rod Smith | Larry Johnson | |||
| 11 | Jerome Bettis | Mike Vanderjadt | Keyshawn Johnson | Keary Colbert | Kevan Barlow | Mike Nugent | Brett Favre | Washington | Donte Stallworth | Aaron Brooks | |||
| 12 | Kurt Warner | Justin McCarriens | Matt Hasselback | Tom Brady | Peerless Price | Mike Vick | Charles Rogers | Joey Galloway | Jason Elam | Dallas | |||
| 13 | Bubba Franks | Drew Brees | Marcus Robinson | Seattle | David Carr | Lee Suggs | Cincinnati | LJ Smith | TJ Duckett | Shane Graham | |||
| 14 | Ike Hilliard | Jeb Putzier | Tampa Bay | Jeff Reed | Travis Taylor | Brandon Lloyd | Daniel Graham | Joey Harrington | Macus Pollard | Antwaan Randle El | |||
| 15 | Terry Glenn | Indianapolis | Eric Johnson | Chris Cooley | Arizona | Jacksonville | Sebastian Janikowski | Ryan Longwell | Chad Pennington | Steve McNair | |||
| 16 | Miami | Mewelde Moore | Josh Brown | Tyrone Calico | Matt Stover | Doug Jolley | Jeff Wilkens | Chicago | John Kasay | Dominic Rhodes | |||
| 17 | Nate Kaeding | Mike Williams | Reche Caldwell | Antonio Bryant | Dan Cambell | Lawrence Tynes | Thomas Jones | Stephen Davis | New York Giants | Corell Buckhalter | |||
| Quarterbacks | |||||||||||||
| Running Backs | |||||||||||||
| Wide Receivers | |||||||||||||
| Tight Ends | |||||||||||||
| Kickers | |||||||||||||
| Defenses | |||||||||||||