| First 5 rounds based on last years worst to first records. | ||||||
| After the 5th round it becomes a snake draft | ||||||
| Round 1 | Team | Player Picked | Round 2 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 1 | Edmonton Trappers | Bernie Williams | 13 | Edmonton Trappers | Jeff Cirillo | |
| 2 | Diamond Kings | Bartolo Colon | 14 | Diamond Kings | Fernando Tatis | |
| 3 | Tampico Stoogies | Raul Mondesi | 15 | Tampico Stoogies | Jeff D Amico | |
| 4 | Giddyaps | Trevor Hoffman | 16 | Lunatics (From Giddyaps) | Mike Sweeney | |
| 5 | Warriors | Jorge Posada | 17 | HOC (from Warriors) | Phil Nevin | |
| 6 | Mystery Machine | Tony Womack | 18 | Mystery Machine | Eric Young | |
| 7 | Dirty Dawgs | Daryl Kile | 19 | Dirty Dawgs | Charles Johnson | |
| 8 | DISTURBED | Ray Durham | 20 | DISTURBED | Kenny Lofton | |
| 9 | HOC | Curt Schilling | 21 | HOC | Shannon Stewart | |
| 10 | Auburn Tigers | Chan Ho Park | 22 | Auburn Tigers | Eric Chavez | |
| 11 | Lunatics | Geoff Jenkins | 23 | Lunatics | Luis Gonzalez | |
| 12 | Juggalos | Al Leiter | 24 | Juggalos | Billy Koch | |
| Round 3 | Team | Player Picked | Round 4 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 25 | Edmonton Trappers | Orlando Hernanez | 37 | Edmonton Trappers | Omar Vizquel | |
| 26 | Diamond Kings | Jim Edmonds | 38 | Diamond Kings | John Rocker | |
| 27 | Tampico Stoogies | Todd Hundley | 39 | Tampico Stoogies | Adrian Beltre | |
| 28 | Giddyaps | Pat Burrell | 40 | Giddyaps | Barry Zito | |
| 29 | Warriors | Joe Randa | 41 | Warriors | Carl Everett | |
| 30 | Mystery Machine | Darren Dreifort | 42 | Mystery Machine | Richie Sexson | |
| 31 | Dirty Dawgs | Craig Biggio | 43 | Dirty Dawgs | Roger Clemens | |
| 32 | DISTURBED | Barry Larkin | 44 | DISTURBED | Ryan Klesko | |
| 33 | Warriors (From HOC) | David Wells | 45 | HOC | Jose Valentin | |
| 34 | Auburn Tigers | Mike Lieberthal | 46 | Auburn Tigers | Kevin Millwood | |
| 35 | Lunatics | Darren Fletcher | 47 | Lunatics | Maksuto Sasaki | |
| 36 | Juggalos | Mike Cameron | 48 | Juggalos | Rich Aurilia | |
| Round 5 | Team | Player Picked | Round 6 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 49 | Edmonton Trappers | Keith Foulke | 61 | Juggalos | Roger Cedeno | |
| 50 | Diamond Kings | Jose Ortiz | 62 | Lunatics | Andy Pettitte | |
| 51 | Tampico Stoogies | Julio Lugo | 63 | Auburn Tigers | Ryan Dempster | |
| 52 | Giddyaps | Larry Walker | 64 | HOC | Paul Konerko | |
| 53 | Warriors | Troy Percival | 65 | DISTURBED | Livan Hernandez | |
| 54 | Mystery Machine | Ichiro Suzuki | 66 | Dirty Dawgs | Mike Hampton | |
| 55 | Dirty Dawgs | JD Drew | 67 | Mystery Machine | Antonio Alfonseca | |
| 56 | DISTURBED | Terrance Long | 68 | Warriors | David Veras | |
| 57 | HOC | Kris Benson | 69 | Giddyaps | Chuck Finley | |
| 58 | Auburn Tigers | Jeremy Burnitz | 70 | Tampico Stoogies | Rick Helling | |
| 59 | Lunatics | Freddy Garcia | 71 | Diamond Kings | Scott Elarton | |
| 60 | Juggalos | Kerry Wood | 72 | Edmonton Trappers | Mitch Melusky | |
| Round 7 | Team | Player Picked | Round 8 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 73 | Edmonton Trappers | Matt Mantei | 85 | Juggalos | Jay Bell | |
| 74 | Diamond Kings | Billy Wagner | 86 | Lunatics | Brad Fullmer | |
| 75 | Tampico Stoogies | Pokey Reese | 87 | Auburn Tigers | Tim Salmon | |
| 76 | Giddyaps | Jason Isringhausen | 88 | HOC | Roberto Hernandez | |
| 77 | Warriors | Bruce Chen | 89 | DISTURBED | Robin Ventura | |
| 78 | Mystery Machine | Matt Morris | 90 | Dirty Dawgs | Curtis Leskanic | |
| 79 | Dirty Dawgs | Mike Lowell | 91 | Mystery Machine | Matt Williams | |
| 80 | DISTURBED | Aaron Sele | 92 | Warriors | Neifi Perez | |
| 81 | HOC | Eric Milton | 93 | Giddyaps | Carlos Beltran | |
| 82 | Auburn Tigers | Todd Walker | 94 | Tampico Stoogies | Brad Radke | |
| 83 | Lunatics | Ben Greive | 95 | Diamond Kings | Carlos Lee | |
| 84 | Juggalos | Bob Wickman | 96 | Edmonton Trappers | Andy Ashby | |
| Round 9 | Team | Player Picked | Round 10 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 97 | Edmonton Trappers | Steve Finley | 109 | Juggalos | Pete Harnisch | |
| 98 | Diamond Kings | Jeff Shaw | 110 | Lunatics | Devi Cruz | |
| 99 | Tampico Stoogies | David Justice | 111 | Auburn Tigers | Kyan Kohlmeire | |
| 100 | Giddyaps | Dustin Hermansen | 112 | HOC | Dave Burba | |
| 101 | Warriors | Jon Leiber | 113 | DISTURBED | Aaron Boone | |
| 102 | Mystery Machine | Scott Williamson | 114 | Dirty Dawgs | Mark Kotsay | |
| 103 | Dirty Dawgs | Javier Vazquez | 115 | Mystery Machine | Juan Encarnacion | |
| 104 | DISTURBED | Dmitri Young | 116 | Warriors | Cliff Floyd | |
| 105 | HOC | Garrett Anderson | 117 | Giddyaps | Alfonso Soriano | |
| 106 | Auburn Tigers | Ugueth Urbina | 118 | Tampico Stoogies | Delino Desheilds | |
| 107 | Lunatics | Bobby Higginson | 119 | Diamond Kings | Ben Petrick | |
| 108 | Juggalos | Matt Lawton | 120 | Edmonton Trappers | John Smoltz | |
| Round 11 | Team | Player Picked | Round 12 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 121 | Edmonton Trappers | Tom Gordon | 133 | Juggalos | Bobby Esalella | |
| 122 | Diamond Kings | Mike Bordick | 134 | Lunatics | Tim Crabtree | |
| 123 | Tampico Stoogies | Latroy Hawkins | 135 | Auburn Tigers | Brook Fordyce | |
| 124 | Giddyaps | Jason Varitek | 136 | HOC | Dean Palmer | |
| 125 | Warriors | Travis Fryman | 137 | DISTURBED | Shawn Estes | |
| 126 | Mystery Machine | Brad Ausmus | 138 | Dirty Dawgs | Lance Berkman | |
| 127 | Dirty Dawgs | Royce Clayton | 139 | Mystery Machine | Mike Williams | |
| 128 | DISTURBED | Bret Boone | 140 | Warriors | Quilvio Veras | |
| 129 | HOC | Robert Person | 141 | Giddyaps | Russell Branyan | |
| 130 | Auburn Tigers | Eric Karros | 142 | Tampico Stoogies | Greg Vaughn | |
| 131 | Lunatics | Bengi Molina | 143 | Diamond Kings | Russ Ortiz | |
| 132 | Juggalos | Chris Stynes | 144 | Edmonton Trappers | Kevin Appier | |
| Round 13 | Team | Player Picked | Round 14 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 145 | Edmonton Trappers | Christian Guzman | 157 | Juggalos | Alex Gonzalez (Tor) | |
| 146 | Diamond Kings | Frank Castillo | 158 | Lunatics | Vinny Castilla | |
| 147 | Tampico Stoogies | Doug Glanville | 159 | Auburn Tigers | Jimmy Rollins | |
| 148 | Giddyaps | Steve Karsay | 160 | HOC | Derek Lee | |
| 149 | Warriors | Jose Jimenez | 161 | DISTURBED | Sandy Alomar Jr | |
| 150 | Mystery Machine | Kevin Young | 162 | Dirty Dawgs | Fernando Vina | |
| 151 | Dirty Dawgs | Corey Koskie | 163 | Mystery Machine | Orlando Cabrera | |
| 152 | DISTURBED | Tom Goodwin | 164 | Warriors | Ramon Hernandez | |
| 153 | HOC | Damian Miller | 165 | Giddyaps | Damian Jackson | |
| 154 | Auburn Tigers | Damion Easley | 166 | Tampico Stoogies | Tony Clark | |
| 155 | Lunatics | Jeff Weaver | 167 | Diamond Kings | Ken Caminiti | |
| 156 | Juggalos | Chuck Knoblauch | 168 | Edmonton Trappers | Adam Kennedy | |
| Round 15 | Team | Player Picked | Round 16 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 169 | Edmonton Trappers | Aramis Ramirez | 181 | Juggalos | Jeff Suppan | |
| 170 | Diamond Kings | Ben Sheets | 182 | Lunatics | Brent Abernathy | |
| 171 | Tampico Stoogies | Russ Davis | 183 | Auburn Tigers | Pat Hentgen | |
| 172 | Giddyaps | Andres Gallaraga | 184 | HOC | Gabe Kapler | |
| 173 | Warriors | Rick Reed | 185 | DISTURBED | Rob Bell | |
| 174 | Mystery Machine | Carlos Febles | 186 | Dirty Dawgs | Todd Zeile | |
| 175 | Dirty Dawgs | Mike Methany | 187 | Mystery Machine | Jose Cruz | |
| 176 | DISTURBED | Paul Oneal | 188 | Warriors | David Segui | |
| 177 | HOC | Ron Belliard | 189 | Giddyaps | Jacque Jones | |
| 178 | Auburn Tigers | Ellis Burks | 190 | Tampico Stoogies | Carlos Guillen | |
| 179 | Lunatics | Todd Hollandsworth | 191 | Diamond Kings | Luis Rivas | |
| 180 | Juggalos | Rondell White | 192 | Edmonton Trappers | John Olerud | |
| Round 17 | Team | Player Picked | Round 18 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 193 | Edmonton Trappers | Brian Jordan | 205 | Juggalos | Jeffrey Hammonds | |
| 194 | Diamond Kings | Brian Anderson | 206 | Lunatics | Dante Bichette | |
| 195 | Tampico Stoogies | Jason Larue | 207 | Auburn Tigers | Chris Truby | |
| 196 | Giddyaps | Ramon Ortiz | 208 | HOC | Rustry Greer | |
| 197 | Warriors | Marvin Bernard | 209 | DISTURBED | Scott Sullivan | |
| 198 | Mystery Machine | Chris Holt | 210 | Dirty Dawgs | Byun Hum Kim | |
| 199 | Dirty Dawgs | Jay Payton | 211 | Mystery Machine | Juan Pierre | |
| 200 | DISTURBED | Brady Anderson | 212 | Warriors | Herbert Perry | |
| 201 | HOC | Mark Loretta | 213 | Giddyaps | Rick Ankiel | |
| 202 | Auburn Tigers | Ruben Mateo | 214 | Tampico Stoogies | Mike Trombley | |
| 203 | Lunatics | Estaban Yan | 215 | Diamond Kings | Glendon Rusch | |
| 204 | Juggalos | Mark Quinn | 216 | Edmonton Trappers | Michael Barrett | |
| Round 19 | Team | Player Picked | Round 20 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 217 | Edmonton Trappers | Gerald Williams | 229 | Juggalos | JT Snow | |
| 218 | Diamond Kings | Ray Lankford | 230 | Lunatics | CC Sabithia | |
| 219 | Tampico Stoogies | Carl Pavano | 231 | Auburn Tigers | Adam Eaton | |
| 220 | Giddyaps | Randy Velarde | 232 | HOC | Trot Nixon | |
| 221 | Warriors | Eric Owens | 233 | DISTURBED | Jerry Hairston | |
| 222 | Mystery Machine | Ricky Bottalico | 234 | Dirty Dawgs | Corey Patterson | |
| 223 | Dirty Dawgs | Gil Heredia | 235 | Mystery Machine | Jose Silva | |
| 224 | DISTURBED | Woody Williams | 236 | Warriors | John Vander Wal | |
| 225 | HOC | Jose Mesa | 237 | Giddyaps | Ben Davis | |
| 226 | Auburn Tigers | Melvin Mora | 238 | Tampico Stoogies | Alex Gonzalez (FLA) | |
| 227 | Lunatics | Chris Richard | 239 | Diamond Kings | Ricky Guiterrez | |
| 228 | Juggalos | Jose Offerman | 240 | Edmonton Trappers | Ron Gant | |
| Round 21 | Team | Player Picked | Round 22 | Team | Player Picked | |
| Overall # | Name | Overall # | Name | |||
| 241 | Edmonton Trappers | Bill Mueller | 253 | Juggalos | Brad Penny | |
| 242 | Diamond Kings | Reggie Sanders | 254 | Lunatics | John Halama | |
| 243 | Tampico Stoogies | BJ Surhoff | 255 | Auburn Tigers | Homer Bush | |
| 244 | Giddyaps | Josh Hamilton | 256 | HOC | Scott Brosius | |
| 245 | Warriors | Rey Sanchez | 257 | DISTURBED | Cal Ripken | |
| 246 | Mystery Machine | Mark Mulder | 258 | Dirty Dawgs | Placido Palonco | |
| 247 | Dirty Dawgs | Jeff Nelson | 259 | Mystery Machine | Matt Stairs | |
| 248 | DISTURBED | Paul Abbott | 260 | Warriors | James Baldwin | |
| 249 | HOC | Kenny Rogers | 261 | Giddyaps | Tomo Ohka | |
| 250 | Auburn Tigers | Erubio Durazo | 262 | Tampico Stoogies | Gabe White | |
| 251 | Lunatics | Aubrey Huff | 263 | Diamond Kings | Benito Santiago | |
| 252 | Juggalos | Jeff Zimmerman | 264 | Edmonton Trappers | Felix Rodriguez | |
| Round 23 | Team | Player Picked | ||||
| Overall # | Name | |||||
| 265 | Edmonton Trappers | Craig Paquette | ||||
| 266 | Diamond Kings | Estaban Loiaza | ||||
| 267 | Tampico Stoogies | Rolando Arrojo | ||||
| 268 | Giddyaps | Vernon Wells | ||||
| 269 | Warriors | Frank Catalonatto | ||||
| 270 | Mystery Machine | Osvaldo Fernandez | ||||
| 271 | Dirty Dawgs | Chad Hutchinson | ||||
| 272 | DISTURBED | Fred McGriff | ||||
| 273 | HOC | Travis Lee | ||||
| 274 | Auburn Tigers | Eddie Taubensee | ||||
| 275 | Giddyaps (From Lunatics) | Timo Perez | ||||
| 276 | Juggalos | John Flaherty | ||||