The cast was as follows:

Mother (Grace): Susan Selvey

Father (Bob): David Koehler

Beth: Sarah Sauer

Charlie: Brandon Burkey

Imogene Herdman: Amanda Hungerford

Leroy Herdman: Scott Harvey

Ralph Herdman: Jerod Post

Olli Herdman: Jackie Willmes

Gladys Herdman: Hannah Calkins

Hobie Clark: Jared Burkey

Danielle: Logan Cannon

Mrs. Armstrong: Gina Cannon

Mrs. McCarthy: Melissa Saito

Mrs. Slocum: Carol Hungerford

Reverend Hopkins: Carol Hungerford

Beverly: Astrid Munn

Carol: Jessica ?

Maxine: Katie Eitzman

Janet: Roxanne Miller

Elmer Hopkins: Kyle ?

Fireman: David Koehler

Barbara: Chelsea

?: Roxanne

?: Sarah Harvey

?: Constance Bode

?: Kathleen Bode