| Bob Horner League Awards | ||||||
| AMERICAN LEAGUE | ||||||
| 1950 | 1951 | 1952 | 1953 | 1954 | ||
| MVP | Andy Delahanty, KC | Rob Floyd, CHA | Andy Delahanty, KC | Rob Floyd, CHA | George Mabry, BAL | |
| Cy Young | Marty Sandusky, BAL | Dutch Schultz, CLE | Marty Sandusky, CHA | Marty Sandusky, CHA | Marty Sandusky, WAS | |
| Fireman | Elvio Moss, DET | Gene Dickshot, CHA | Gene Dickshot, CHA | Gene Dickshot, CHA | Gene Dickshot, CHA | |
| ROY | George Mabry, BAL | Gene Dickshot, CHA | Michael Sagmoen, BAL | Spike Grba, BAL | (None) | |
| 1955 | 1956 | 1957 | 1958 | 1959 | ||
| MVP | George Mabry, BAL | George Mabry, BAL | George Mabry, BAL | George Mabry, BAL | George Mabry, BAL | |
| Cy Young | Marty Sandusky, NYA | Marty Sandusky, NYA | Cly Monteleone, NYA | Frank Levrault, CHA | Cly Monteleone, NYA | |
| Fireman | Gene Dickshot, CHA | Gene Jorgensen, KC | Gene Jorgensen, KC | Gene Jorgensen, KC | Dick Cabell, KC | |
| ROY | Ernie Judy, CLE | Bill Torre, BOS | John Bridges, KC | Dan Sutter, CHA | Greg Taylor, KC | |
| 1960 | 1961 | 1962 | 1963 | 1964 | ||
| MVP | George Mabry, BAL | George Mabry, BAL | George Mabry, BAL | Jay Sisti, CHA | ||
| Cy Young | Frank Levrault, CHA | Rick Baumgartner, BOS | Frank Levrault, CHA | Rick Baumgartner, BOS | ||
| Fireman | Gene Jorgensen, CHA | Frenchy Bernazard, DET | Gene Jorgensen, CHA | Bruce Hershberger, CHA | ||
| ROY | Jack Jones, DET | Art Ryerson, BOS | Rocky Pippen, WAS | Dave Moore, KC | ||
| 1965 | 1966 | 1967 | 1968 | 1969 | ||
| MVP | ||||||
| Cy Young | ||||||
| Fireman | ||||||
| ROY | ||||||
| NATIONAL LEAGUE | ||||||
| 1950 | 1951 | 1952 | 1953 | 1954 | ||
| MVP | Ricky Chipman, PHI | Luther Whitt, STL | Herb Peterson, PHI | Alex Sugden, STL | Mickey Spence, PHI | |
| Cy Young | Dutch Schultz, NYN | Drummond Santiago, STL | Drummond Santiago, STL | Drummond Santiago, STL | Drummond Santiago, STL | |
| Fireman | Peaches Kelso, NYN | Shad Salkeld, CIN | Al Giordano, STL | Al Giordano, STL | Bruce Hershberger, PIT | |
| ROY | D. Hargesheimer, CHN | Shad Salkeld, CIN | Johnny Gowell, PHI | Sean Campbell, STL | Howie Martin, CHN | |
| 1955 | 1956 | 1957 | 1958 | 1959 | ||
| MVP | Luther Whitt, STL | Luther Whitt, STL | Garry Somerville, CIN | Sean Campbell, STL | Garry Somerville, CIN | |
| Cy Young | Drummond Santiago, STL | Drummond Santiago, STL | Alan Jeffcoat, CIN | Jake Riss, STL | Jake Riss, STL | |
| Fireman | Harry Fisher, MIL | Doug Branch, NYN | Doug Branch, NYN | Frank Nied, MIL | John Oster, CHN | |
| ROY | Colonel Glockson, CHN | Frank Nied, MIL | Kevin Martini, NYN | Steve Menechino, NYN | Patsy Welch, NYN | |
| 1960 | 1961 | 1962 | 1963 | 1964 | ||
| MVP | Garry Somerville, CIN | Garry Somerville, CIN | Tim McDonnell, CHN | Colonel Glockson, CHN | ||
| Cy Young | Billy Kiely, CIN | Jake Riss, STL | Otto Midkiff, MIL | Otto Midkiff, MIL | ||
| Fireman | Frank Nied, MIL | John Oster, CHN | John Oster, CHN | John Oster, CHN | ||
| ROY | Tom Erickson, CHN | Tim Riggs, BRO | Harry Mulcahy, CIN | Sam Gizmo, PIT | ||
| 1965 | 1966 | 1967 | 1968 | 1969 | ||
| MVP | ||||||
| Cy Young | ||||||
| Fireman | ||||||
| ROY | ||||||