Cetacean Unit
(Whales)
Suitable for 5th grade: with modifications may be used for 4th
grades through High School Biology.
Objectives:
- SWAT: Distinquish between cetaceans and other marine mammals
and marine life
- SWAT: Define a sea mammal and define the characteristics they
ALL share
- SWAT: Distinquish between baleen and toothed whales
- SWAT: Find facts on the Internet, AND in the Library enough to
do a written and oral report on their assigned cetacean. Quality
art work is encouraged.
- SWAT: As a group, collect a "scrap book" of whales and
dolphins, from interesting articles on the nets and in the
newspapers. Articles must have references and dates. Quality art
work is encouraged.
- SWAT: Give the Latin (scientific) name for "their whale" and
use correct format for scientific names (and will understand that
all organisms have these). Note: current popular novel series,
"Harry Potter" makes liberal use of Latin, and this is an
excellent tie-in for students.
Things needed to help us along in this lesson plan:
- · Tapes and books on whales (see bibliography: there are
libraries of references on dolphins and whales readily available)
- · Stereo/telly to run the tapes of whale song
- · Access to a computer with the Internet
- · Art paper, art supplies
Vocabulary: Orca, dolphin, baleen, cetacean, vestigal, canine
teeth, cachelot, pod, echolocation, radar, sonar, fluke, dorsal fin,
melon, blow hole, toxins, predator, prey, lobtail, spyhop, breach
Day One Introduction (all other
lessons more or less follow in a non-linear fashion, as this is a
"research" workshop)
- · Introduction is to "capture the imagination" by
playing CDs and tapes of whale song, or showing videos of various
whales in their nature habitat. Ideally we could take everyone on
a whale cruise, but it is not practical of course.
- · Discuss how modern composers actually use whale song
in orchestral compositions (Pines of Rome, used in Fantasia 2000).
- · Discuss types of sounds made by whales, used for a)
communication between each other, as they are social creatures and
b) for echolocation to navigate, or to hunt "stun" fish with their
pings (and there is always c) maybe they are reciting poetry!)
Following days:
- · Mythology: discuss Greek tie-in of dolphins (sacred to
Apollo), story of how sailors turned into dolphins by Dionysius,
children being pushed to shore by dolphins (just recently! Little
Ilia from Cuba claimed dolphins helped him to shore!) and also tie
in Moby Dick, and Free Willy. Discuss reality vs
mythology.
- · Discuss DNA relatedness to cows J (see attached, ref
National Geographic "Mammals" April 2003)
- · Revisit ecosystems, and where each cetacean fits into
this food chain (ie Orcas at the top, Gray Whales being prey)
- · Social Structure: pods (not herds!) Discuss that orcas
seem to have two societies, a) transient pods, which eats anyone,
whales, dolphins, seals (tipping ice bergs) people, etc. While b)
the pods close to shore eat mostly Chinook salmon, and have
identifiable families and maternal groups.
- · Discuss clans, the J,K,L pods combine in the summer
and hang out, and split up in the winter. This group in Puget
Sound is very intensely studied, and very well known to
researchers. It might be dangerous to generalize the group
structure of J, K, L to all orcas, but it's all we have to go on.
- · History: Baleen used in corsets, ambergris used in
perfumes, blubber rendered for lamp oil (prior to electricity),
currently used in dog food, and a delicacy in Asian food market.
Discuss Makah issues (might even be a good topic for a persuasive
essay). Also discuss modern whaling issues, and tell about the
history of "dolphin safe tuna"
- · Discuss shortage of fish and excess of toxins, and how
this impacts the orca populations
- · Discuss come-back of gray whale species, and discuss
as much as possible the other populations of cetaceans and if they
have declined, increased, and why? (a research point for each
report). Discuss Exxon Valdez disaster
- · Discuss toxins in blubber of dead orcas, and how they
are the top of the food chain, how they are "indicators" or
"canaries" for our own world.
- · Discuss impact/implications of noise pollution and US
Navy sonar tests, as well as submarine ULF.
- · Discuss captive orcas, such as Keiko, Springer and the
resolution of their interactions with humans.
- · Age: at least one female "Granny" is documented to be
around 80 years old, here in Puget Sound! WOW!
- · Discuss/research the distance boats can get to wild
whales, legalities in both Canada and US waters
- · Discuss behavior (spyhopping, breaching, lobtailing,
rock scratching, logging etc, use overheads). One behavior not
well documented involves what happened at Sea World about 10 years
ago, one of the orcas "took out" another whale, by doing some sort
of attack from underneath, an attack run upside down. I can't find
my research, but it was competitive behavior, and deadly for one
of them. Also discuss attacks of captive orcas on their trainers,
also poorly documented but it has happened.
- · Research point: shape of spouts (ref: Moby Dick, Whale
Adventure) The old-time whalers could ID the species from a long
distance by the shape of the spouts.
- · Discuss ID of individuals (nicks on flukes, and dorsal
fins, marks on saddles)
Notes from the field June 21, 2003: An Orca cruise: I got
seasick of course, and the Skipper was kind enough to give me a
device he was field testing, which changed its pitch depending on the
roll of the ship! (Somehow was picking up signals from the inertials
in the ship). Fed White Noise to me in one ear. It was kinda cool,
and may have been some sort of expectancy effect, or hypnosis. But it
did help a bit. The Dramamine I took sure didn't! BLUGH someone
actually ate tuna next to me and I almost tossed on them!
Managed to come around long enough to see the whales, which
were a delight! We apparently had come around the outside of the San
Juans in the open ocean (which accounted for the rough seas!) but
that was the only way to ensure we would encounter the pod. We
stopped near Henry Island, next to a rookery of pelagic cormorants
(which was exciting, as I had just been observing our identical
colony that lives in my home town, under the Wheaton Way bridge). We
drifted with the tide, and were in the right place at the right time,
as the whales continued toward us, busy with their own agenda I have
no doubt.
I do know, yes we are supposed to remain totally objective in
our observations. But to ME it appeared that the mothers and calves
went by us first, in a "sub pod". There was then a break, and behind
them came a great group of frolicking (it looked like to me) females,
and possibly younger males (I suppose the difference is only
important to another whale!). I personally could only identify one
mature male, he was VERY hard to miss, as his dorsal fin looked like
it was about two stories tall! I also noticed he did no breaching or
spy hopping!
With the exception of the male, there was a good deal of spy
hopping at a distance from the ship, as well as breaching and leaping
out of the water for the sheer fun of it, for all I could tell. Maybe
they were trying to impress each other. As they got closer to us, and
I also thought there was more of this the closer the animals were to
the male orca, AND to our boat, there was a lot of lob-tailing, which
is a "warning" thing (apparently this causes a good deal of
percussion under water, sends out a warning). I got the impression
some of the whales were a bit hesitant, and milled a bit before they
passed our boat. Some appeared to deliberately pass to the outboard
of us, while others passed between us and the boat, turning over a
bit against the rocks (maybe scratching). I wonder how much of OUR
human noises THEY could hear, we were pretty noisy tourists, much
OooOing and AHH ing with each splash. (No bird watchers here!!!! A
noisy excitable lot!) I wish we had an underwater microphone
along!
In the spaces we were quiet we were able to hear them breathing
through their blowholes, and I think I heard some very high pitched
squeaks, rather like baby birds (I don't think it was the
cormorants). I couldn't help but feel that spot was a regular
cruising place for the whales, maybe hoping to nab a stray bird.
Apparently we were passed by the majority of the combined J, K,
and L pod, which has grouped up for the summer. I couldn't help but
think that bunch around the big male were doing a huge singles party,
and I hope they were enjoying themselves! J According to our
instructor, orcas do not have a "harem" society (that is one male,
and a lot of females) but rather, males appear to be on the decline
in general. Research has not answered this issue yet. As we are
unable to observe the transient pods, the research is very
incomplete, and it is difficult to draw conclusions.
One small note, one of my fellow classmates said he had found
some brachypods on the North Shore of Whidbey, near Deception Pass.
These are a very ancient order of shellfish which I need to research,
but it was a rather exciting off-topic note in the day's activity.
Assessment:
1) Test, the "usual" involving matching for vocabulary words,
multiple choice, fill in the blanks, no essay questions. Consult
EALRs to align objectives as needed.
2) Written report, length of written material to be determined by
age and relative ability of the class as a whole.
3) Short oral report "share your whale" encourage story boards,
art work, and outlines. No more than 5 minutes.
4) Rubric to include the objectives, and how well they handled
this for "their whale"
Bibliography (for fun and serious
research, to use as needed):
- · "Farewell to Tarwathi" by Judy Collins (Whales and
Nightingales album)
- · Any one of many CDs and tapes on the market with whale
song (I have several)
- · Any one of many Discovery Channel videos, or NOVA,
etc. Lots to chose from out there.
- · Fantasia 2000
- · Star Trek IV (movie)
- · Free Willy
- · Moby Dick (both the Patrick Stewart and Ray Bradbury
version) would limit showings of this to just "portions" depending
on the class. Also look for passages from the book pertaining to
whale natural history
- · Flipper
- · Pinocchio (discuss fallacies, and mythology?)
- · Willy the Operatic Whale (old Disney cartoon, from
Make Mine Music)
- · Dolphin Island by Arthur C. Clarke
- · City Beneath the Sea (young adult novel)
- · Whale Adventure by Willard Price (young adult)
- · Startide Rising by David Brin (adult)
- · The works of Dr. Lilly (as appropriate)
- · Day of the Dolphin movie with George C. Scott (again,
as appropriate)
- · www.whalemuseum.org
(Friday Harbor U of W research group)