| Who Won it: | Won From: | Date: | Where: |
| Mitch Paradise | K-Train (Title Was Vacant) | 10/30/99 | Waverly, MN |
| Lenny Lane | Mitch Paradise | 4/28/01 | St. Cloud, MN |
| Chi-Town Thug | Magnus Maximus (Lenny Lane dropped the title) | 9/15/01 | Fridley, MN |
| Mitch Paradise | Chi-Town Thug | 1/26/02 | Anoka, MN |
| JR the Punisher | JR the Punisher & Chi-Town Thug vs. Mitch Paradise & K-Train. (The title was on the line in this tag match and JR the Punisher pinned Mitch Paradise to win the MIW Heavy Weight title!) | 12/14/02 | Fridley, MN |
| JB Trask | Title Tournament pinned Jason Vaine | 9/20/03 | Big Lake, MN | Mitch Paradise | JB Trask | 1/17/04 | Big Lake, MN |
| JB Trask | Mitch Paradise | 3/20/04 | Big Lake, MN |
| Mason Quinn | JB Trask | 6/26/04 | South St. Paul, MN |
| "Playboy" Pete Huge | Mason Quinn | 9/24/04 | Montrose, MN |
| Remy Rainz | "Playboy" Pete Huge | 2/26/05 | Shakopee, MN |
| "Playboy" Pete Huge | Remy Rainz | 6/04/05 | Big Lake, MN |
| Big Daddy Hoofer | BATTLE FOR THE BELT: The Genuine Article, Shimdog, Joey Envy, & Johny Parks | 03/03/07 | Clearwater, MN |
| Playboy Pete Huge | Big Brody Hoofer | 01/19/08 | Chanhassen, MN |
| Big Daddy Hoofer | Playboy Pete Huge | 01/19/08 | Chanhassen, MN |
| Mitch Paradise | Big Brody Hoofer | 03/07/09 | Chanhassen, MN |
Top 15 Contenders (03/09/09):