| Who Won it: | Won From: | Date: | Where: |
| "Playboy" Pete Huge | ???(The title was vacant) | 3/4/00 | Waverly, MN |
| Robbie Thunder | Helmut Von Strauss (The title was vacant) | 11/11/00 | Lynd, MN |
| Soul Brother #1 | Robbie Thunder | 9/15/01 | Fridley, MN |
| Robbie Thunder (He vacated the title right after the match) | Soul Brother #1 | 11/10/01 | Fridley, MN |
| Austin Aries | Justin Lee (Tournament Finals) | 2/9/02 | Fridley, MN |
| Justin Lee | Austin Aries | 12/14/02 | Fridley, MN |
| Play Boy Pete Huge | Justin Lee | 9/20/03 | Big Lake,MN |
| Justin Lee | Playboy Pete Huge | 11/22/03 | Montrose,MN |
| The Title is Vacant | Justin Lee Moved to LA | 4/01/04 | xxx |
| "The Punisher" Rob James | Ben Sailer (Tournament Finals) | 6/18/04 | Big Lake,MN |
| Genuine Article Chris Jordin | "The Punisher" Rob James | 9/24/04 | Montrose,MN |
| "Live Wire" Johnny Parks | Genuine Article Chris Jordin | 12/18/04 | Montrose,MN |
Top 5 Contenders (12`/18/04):