Hot Gimmick

 

“I loved the original story “Hot Gimmick”, and I love this story. The way u changed the characters around and added your own idea without ruining the plot is great. This is one of the few ones that is actually works without copying the original work word by word. I LOVE IT. Can’t wait till the next chapter”- heaven, ff.net (HG, ch 1)

 

*-*

Hahaha Ok, I love it! I was laughing so hard at the end of it. I really like Ginny's attitude towards Draco. Haha and the whole Master Draco thing. I can't wait to see how long that lasts! Great job! Please post soon!!!” –Dracosbaby7, portkey.org (HG, ch 1)

 

*-*

 

“Absolutely iridescent. Amazing and well put together. The plot thickens with great mystery and interest. To be one of the best. Brings together the real feelings and characteristics of everyone mentioned. Please keep writing.” –Anonymous, (HG, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job good job”laila on portkey.org (HG, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

"Even though you might not actually like a person, you could still really like kissing them." I COMPLETELY KNOW WHAT YOU MEANT WHEN YOU SAID THAT. Very good story! I'm liking it so far, and the Neville and Ginny thing...that's just too weird to happen I think. Why is Harry going after Ginny!? NO SHE IS MEANT FOR DRACO. They will do the cliché thing and fall in love right? Cause that would be so cute. And who would've thought that Draco could actually be nice and not take a girls virginity? From the hints you are dropping it seems as if Draco already does love her, he just isn't quite sure of it or is mistaking it for lust, and Ginny has basically no idea what is going on, and dear lord I’m so sorry for rambling!! GREAT STORY!”MalfoyLittleGirl, Portkey.org (HG, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

Oh My God! I love Hot Gimmick! And this is so much more frickin cooler! I would probably even offer to do a banner with all the HG cast (anime ones) too, but oh well! So cool! Keep it up!”luckistars of hpff.com (HG, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

Bloody hell this is brilliant! Haha!
Comedy, Er-Some-what Dramatic, And totally rad!
Continue PLEASE!”
a_fire_inside on ff.net (HG, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

Nice story... it has a lot of promise. I'm curious to see what Neville is up to. Whatever it is, it can't be good.

As for the D/G, it also has a lot of promise. I like this characterization of Draco. I think he's very capable of being charming one minute and an ass the next. So it works well for him. I hope that he does begin to treat Pansy like a human, just so Ginny will dump Harry for him. I'm looking forward to more.”
-smprsgrrl, Portkey.org (HG, ch 3)

 

 “Damn. Neville is turning out to be quite an asshole. Then again he might be I dunno....your the one writing this. Right now I hate him, but...you being the writer might completely change it around and almost make me feel sympathy for him...As for respect for what he did. Well, plot out really. Wasn’t a bad plan. Cruel, evil despicable, but not half bad. Oh and the bit about Malfoy reading Machiavelli's The Prince, I loved it. So.. eloquent. (i really do hope I’m using that word right) Anyway it's befitting. hah, but I am a little nerd who seems to know more than she should anyway....Okay, I’m babbling. Great chappie, update soon.”MexiChick, Portkey.org (HG, ch 4)

*-*

 

“Hey, MeiQueen! I would like to say, first and foremost, that I would never have thought of doing a fanfiction off a manga- I think that it is totally creative! I have a question, though... In Hot Gimmick, the character that Draco is now playing is actually a virgin... how will that play into this story? Is Draco a virgin? He doesn't quite come across as one, but you never know...And also, I think it was cool how Ginny told him to be nicer to Pansy! Girlpower!! So yeah, great fanfic! Thanx for writing. I also, by the way, appreciate that your fic doesn't have the obvious grammatical errors that other authors at times appear to be too lazy to sort out.”-silverclaw_firefly, Portkey.org (HG, ch 4)

 

*-*

“Wow! That was a very dark chapter. Wonderfully done, though. OMG I could just murder Neville right now. It's probably the wrong coincidence because i just saw HP4 (I live in Australia so it only just came out) and I was really loving the weird Neville in it (he's so adorably weird) and there was that scene where he's dancing with Ginny that was sweet. But now in your fic I want to like kick him really hard in the balls. Lol. Update soon so i can find out what the hell is up with Neville!!!! It was a terrible thing that happened to Ginny. But yay for Draco saving her. I'm getting warm and fuzzy feelings. He really cares! Who would have thought! And I really like Pansy. Karma actually works. Anyway, eagerly awaiting your next wonderful chapter! Update soon!”  -RoseB on hpff.com (HG, ch 4)

 

*-*

 

excellent...awesome. Really cool. I really like it. Some people, when they write a story with sex in it tend to not have storyline, just the sex, but yours is good. Write soon ok” aphrodesia on ff.net (HG, ch 4)

 

*-*

 

“Sweet!                                                                         
Neville gets his just desserts + Draco and Ginny are happy + and the other Slytherin boys are all scared of Draco=GREAT FIC! I love it! You’ve done so well with it!”
–Keeper of the Pine Needles on ff.net (HG, ch 4)

 

*-*

 

this really is an excellent story, and I believe that in the next six or seven chapters, that this story will go much deeper then just a silly schooldays romance, and I think that you proved that exceptionally with the attempted rape. Now, true Draco is out of character, but with your plotline, it's acceptable and works well. As far as advice, it was a little confusing in Chapter 3, I don't know why but it was, other then that, it's very well written, a major problem with most writers on is that their descriptions are either too randomized, detailed, or not detailed enough. But you pretty much have it down, should you keep writing I believe that you would be up with the authors on the net such as Dracademented, and GD-7, (the latter I'm not a huge fan of, but she is an awesome writer) Your not there yet, but with time I am sure that you will be. Keep writing, and keep reading as well, the only way that you can improve your writing is by seeing other writers present dos and do nots in their own story, and being an outside writer, not a friend or relative, you can see what works and what doesn't work. That's all that I have to say, it's a remarkable story, and I really hope that you keep up with it.

The only other thing that I would suggest altering is your summary and title. Now, it depends on what plot you have in your mind for the story (if you have a detailed one in mind) …the present title makes the story seem more trashy then it actually is. If you do change that, and prove on a first impression that this is a more serious story, I can guarantee that you will have more reviewers.

Keep updating and make me happy, and I shall speak to you when you next update.”
Elvra, ff.net (HG, ch 4)

 

*-*

 

“Great chapter, I can't wait until you update again. And I love the way you write Draco’s character, it's a perfect balance of his character”kinky_lover on hpff.com (HG, ch 4)

 

*-*

 

I really like *grins*. It's good. I like how you have Draco. Usually when Draco is relatively sweet it ends up all wrong and it is a chore to read it (but of course I do lol I'm too addicted.). It doesn't seem so wrong in this one though. Myself, I like to write it where Draco is a complete prat and yet Ginny still likes him. It's so hard yet fun. Hehehe. I really like this thought. It's really interesting. Especially with Neville. Neville is really awesome in this. I like it how he's evil but nice y'know? It's . . . prettiful *giggle* hehe. Lovely just lovely. Also, I think flames are awesome. I mean it is so cool how someone can say stuff so mean about one thing. hehehe. I hope when I finish my things and start getting them up, I get tons and tons of flames *evil laugh* . . .
Sorry, kinda off topic (if there was one.) I really like it . . .” –
OnerousOrangutang, ff.net (HG, ch 5)

 

*-*

 

This is a fantastic story. I'm really curious about the book it was based on, though. I don't usually like the whole concept of cartoon stories, anime, or manga shows, but I might reconsider and have a look at the book. I'll add this to my alert list and continue to review. It's lovely.” Mellia Black, ff.net (HG, ch 5)

 

*-*

 

“Egyptian cotton sheets...she blushed thinking about what he wanted to do with them...he wanted to shag her senseless underneath them! lol I love it! Please update soon.” HarryPotterFreakEver, ff.net (HG, ch 5)

 

*-*

Great! Great great great! That was just really.......great. I'm glad you [finally] updated! And it is such a nice update, too.” –Swim17, Portkey.org (HG, ch 5)

 

*-*

 

“So glad you are back...definitely another wonderful chapter. Worth the wait but just hope the others don't take quite as long. Love how you made Pansy and Draco be friends rather than the jealous spurned woman. Excellently done!”jchaser, Portkey.org (HG, ch 5)

 

*-*

 

AHHH, OMG where the HECK is the NEXT CHAPTER?! lol. cute story (in a way) so far... you know, once you get past the "Draco’s 'best friends'" part and all that other good stuff. I find myself not being able to wait until Ginny tells Harry that she's, uh, NOT going to the ball with him *gasp*! Ron is seriously going to blow his top, I think, (but he hasn't been around much... that's intriguing in itself... hold it, *WHAT* did the test say for Luna? I’d almost forgotten about that!) And I think it's nice that Ginny let Neville off... though I would have turned him in like that (well, *maybe*)... I was kind of wondering about that, going "she's THAT nice?" (I hope you know what I mean... not saying she's evil but... yeah) then she mentioned to Draco that she was going for revenge (Neville had better watch out, because Ginny was none-too-happy about feeling helpless and doubtful of herself, ESPECIALLY for a week!) can't wait until you continue, this is great! This especially makes me want to read hot gimmick (lol) which I haven't gotten to yet (but that's beside the point! lol) I really can't wait until you continue!!!!!” –Sailor Universe, Portkey.org (HG, ch 5)

 

 

 

 

 

Steal My Kisses

 

“It's great and THANK YOU for saying You-Know-Who. Most people are only making Voldemort be rising in their stories when he was supposed to be around for quiet awhile and that bugs me. Anyway, I loved it and am eagerly waiting for more. :D”  Radcliffe_PotterFan319 on hpff.com (SMK, ch 1)

 

*-*

 

This, as another reviewer said, has some clear potential! It’s great! Please continue! I want to see how Lily will manage to break down with Grant, poor guy! lolhmtc on ff.net (SMK, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“This is really good so far. I especially love your summary: 'Lily Evans is an average girl who makes mistakes.' So many authors turn Lily into a perfect person, and the only thing wrong with her is that she never stops yelling at James. You've made her seem so much more real, like someone who the reader can actually identify with. Its okay that this isn't a lot of action yet, I'm sure it will be soon. Can't wait for the next chapter!”Occhio di Lince, ff.net (SMK, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“Amazingly written! It was actually surprisingly deep, which is more than rare in a fanfic! PLEASE update! Soon? ;)” –vivphy05, ff.net (SMK, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“OH! I like this story! It's really good! Lily's so confused! Poor girl. I can relate to her confusion. Heads tellin' you one thing while your hearts tellin' you another. So confusing!! I look forward to your update!! …” –Sweet Southerner, ff.net (SMK, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“Amazing cliffie! Mean... but amazing!! I can't wait for an update... I had completely forgotten about this story (I had added it to story alert after just the prologue...) but I’m glad you didn't abandon it! PLEASE please please update, because this story is REALLY getting good!” –vivphy05, ff.net (SMK, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“THIS IS AWESOME! PLEASE UPDATE SOON OR I THINK I MIGHT CRY!!!!! I’M SMILING FROM EAR-TO-EAR, I CAN’T WAIT TO FIND OUT WHAT HAPPENS! PLEASE UPDATE SOON!!!”-TriwizardChamp, Portkey.org (SMK, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

OOH!! MORE MORE MORE MORE!!!!!! I love this as much as your other fics!!!!!! And I think we're twins!! I'm from California (not born there, but does growing up there from the age of four count?) And I hate all those things except maybe red peppers, and I practically have a worship center (sorry-- not big on the vocabulary right now) for the Gilmore Girls. THAT'S SCARY. Keep writing!!!!” –Mischief Managed, Portkey.org (SMK, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“Wow. I'm stunned.

But completely satisfied. I love it! This is a really good fic; I really like the way you write. James's last line is especially... breath-taking. *giggles* I really do want them to be together, but then again, I hope it's a longer fic because I like it so. Keep it up!” –
ItsLily2U, Portkey.org (SMK, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“Wow, this is one of the best fics I have ever read! Write more!” tygeye, Portkey.org (SMK, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“AAHHHH!!!!! I'm literally HYPERVENTILATING here!!!!!! CUTE!! CUTE!!! That was so cute!!!! Awww... I LOVED the ending... it was so cute!!!

Update!!!

Miss Mady... who's still hyperventilating...”
–Miss Mady, Portkey.org (SMK, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“Oh you finally updated this story. I have to say good job on this chapter! I just wish you could update sooner because it's such a great story and I absolutely love reading it. Don't take too long to update if possible.” –loonymoony8, Portkey.org (SMK, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“Wow! This story is magnificent! I love how Lily makes mistakes and is confused... it's so not the mary sue Lily that we all know and hate. But Lily is just trying to do the right thing to her boyfriend, isn't she... It must be hard to break up with a nice boy who really likes you.

And I love how you've portrayed Sirius; he still has that casual elegance that I've always associated with him. James is such a sweetheart! He just seems so nice and down to earth.

Anyway, enough of my rambling... I look forward to more chapters posted on this story (and unwritten)!”
–Lauren Dawnie, Portkey.org (SMK, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“WOW! *jaw drops*

Update soon, or I will be forced to explode or implode, whichever is cheaper...”
–Sarah Kavanagh, Portkey.org (SMK, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“You are the master of fluff, I must say. I've been waiting for this chapter since my previous birth. You finally updated! Thank you for being so merciful.
Dr. Fawkes”
–Dr. Fawkes, Portkey.org (SMK, ch 3)

 

 

Reflections

 

“You have to keep going with this storyline. It's amazing! I can't wait to read more! Please hurry!” IndescribablyBee, ff.net (R, ch 1)

 

*-*

 

“It's good. Thanks for the warning about Remus/Lily thing. I can totally relate to Lily's 'experience'. well not directly but i think we all dread it. Still not over the whole Rico Suave thing!” Ariane, Portkey.org (R, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“I really like where this is going! It's nicely written and I like the characters' personalities. I have a couple of questions, though: Is the story going to skip ahead to when they're older, or is it going to progress year by year? Is Lily liking Remus going to be a major factor, like a love triangle? I don't know if I could stomach that, but I'll try. I noticed that you keep putting an emphasis on Sirius and James, is there any particular reason? That's all. Now, feel free to tell me to shut up because I'll find out when I find out, as long as I do find out eventually. Again, I really like what you've written and I hope you post more soon. Bye!”angelicbabie on ff.net (R, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“Really nice story so far! I love the way Lily's eleven year old self is sarcastic and witty. I always liked the Remus/Lily pairing, but can't stay away from Lily/James. Anyway, I said I was going to read this story and I did. You were right. Excellent! I still hope that you'll keep up with Bad Company, though.”Incendia, Portkey.org (R, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“EAK love this story!! I know you’re probably tired of hearing from me but you will just have to deal!!! Once again, I love how you have got the characters just right!! I love how you write, and how they have got the lil crushes and all that good stuff!! UPDATE!

Lots of love
Kat Black(MINE MINE MINE *hugs Sirius to her* MINE!!)”
kat black, Portkey.org (R, ch 4)

 

*-*

 

Aww... I've never seen a fic before where Lily likes Remus... but this is sweet. There were parts (like that about Lily's purple jumper) that made me laugh out loud... I think you've done a fantastic job.” –ItsLily2U, Portkey.org (R, ch 4)

 

*-*

 

“Awesomeness. You should definitely keep writing. This was a story that made me think it was the real deal. Not many do that, so thanks!” –Anonymous, Portkey.org (R, ch 5)

 

*-*

 

“NO!!!! It can't be over!! Please, please, PLEASE write quickly! (Suspense might kill me otherwise). Oh, and did I mention PLEASE!?” –Anonymous, Portkey.org (R, ch 5)

 

 

Unwritten

 

“I really like the Lily you've created so far, and James and the other characters appear pretty "in character" so far as J.K. Rowling intended. I think this fic will definitely be interesting and funny, so please do continue it! It's so nice to have a Lily/James fic that isn't absolutely contrived and purely physical. :)” –Abigail, ff.net (U, ch 1)

 

*-*

 

“What a good beginning! I adore the song "Unwritten" and was really excited when I found this story. The beginning is really strong. Can't wait to read more!” –PotterChick958, Portkey.org (U, ch 1)

 

*-*

 

ok.. This is really good and I’m really enjoying the story. I can't wait to see where it's gonna go. Lily's honesty is very good… the weight thing definitely goes against Mary-Sue so congrats. The only thing I noticed that you might think about changing (although if you don't agree that’s cool too) is the when you said her parents didn't understand how big a deal headship is. I'm from England and headship is a big deal. Yes, there are prefects and heads and at least at my school it's an honor to get headship. Prefect is also an honor to achieve. If her parents are English they'd probably know this. Other than that I thought you did a great job and keep up with the updates!” –moo moo mr. cow, Portkey.org (U, ch 1)

 

*-*

 

“I really liked it. The best I’ve ever read and I’ve read a lot, lol” –Anonymous, Portkey.org (U, ch 1)

 

*-*

 

“It's loverly wonderly. I will be happy for the rest of my life because of reading this *sigh* Also, there's this tiny error (at least I think) don't hate me for this in why Petunia hates Lily. In the book it says Petunia hates Lily because she is so much better, prettier, smarter and everything than Petunia so Petunia is jealous. :) hehehe Sorry you don't have to change it it's just I read your summary and it said all that stuff about how some people got the right thing and all that stuff and that is totally awesome so I just decided to . . . say that you know?

I love the thing with James by the way :D
OnerousOrangutang, ff.net (U, ch 1)

 

*-*

 

“Yes, like is definitely a word I would use. Although it seems a little understated, I'm sure I can come up with some more apt ones: adored, eagerly awaited, was absolutely riveted by, for example (incidentally, the 'eagerly awaited' ran from when I first got an alert in my mailbox, I always loved your Lily/James, and another definitely put a smile on my face!). I can't wait for the next installment, and I especially loved Lily's speech about You-Know-Who, it makes everything seem a little more real, a little more dark, if you get my meaning.

Anyway, waffle over, and looking forward to the next ultra incredible chapter!

xFaithx
–Faith Kingsley, ff.net (U, ch 1)

 

*-*

 

“This was really good!! I like its accuracy and I absolutely love her parents! They remind me of mine! Can’t wait for more chapters! And I like that peter isn't seen as a helpless nothing or anything.” –lily, ff.net (U, ch 1)

 

*-*

 

“That... was an EXTREMELY eventful day! Head students, missing meetings, Remus not knowing anything - INCLUDING his name ("why does it feel like the floor is moving?" honestly! rotfl) James jumping on his bed -after a freakishly long password!- and then Hogwarts no longer being safe... I would ask if there was something else that I forgot, but my brain just might go into overload! lol j/k! Can’t wait until you continue, awesome job (oh yeah, and a new Herbology teacher)” –Sailor Universe, Portkey.org (U, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“Well then you better update quick! I would like to read more. It's awesome!!! You're doing a really good job. But no, you don't have to update that fast. I was just kidding, but if you do, I would really much appreciate it.

xoxoLuna
loonymoony8, Portkey.org (U, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“Yeah, it'll do...

No, I'm joking!!! I really liked it, loved it, if I were to be honest... Its wicked to see a fic that is not only interesting and refreshing, but is grammatically correct and has proper spelling... you know how bad grammar and spelling can really ruin a fic..

And the best thing about it??

James was jumping on his bed!!!!”
–Sarah Kavanagh, Portkey.org (U, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“I'm so happy with this chapter; you've really kept your work, so to say, up to scratch. And I love the idea of Lily loosening her grip on the Marauders pranks/bullying of Snape...And James bouncing on the bed was very cute.

Anyway, I'm happy that you've made Lily have flaws, like being a nervous eater. Too many stories make out that she is perfect and uptight, which I think is total bollocks... anyway, I could rant and rave about that for ages.

But anyway, great work and an interesting storyline, as usual.”
–Lauren Dawnie, Portkey.org (U, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

Hm. Veeeery interesting. Dumbledore's comment is very interesting. He obviously knows something about the students.

I like how Lily is loosening up and not nitpicking the Marauders. And I like how your Lily isn't the normal "OMGWTFIHATEJAMESANDIWANTTOCASTERATEHIM" Lily that we normally see.

Keep on writing!”
–PotterChick958, Portkey.org (U, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“Absolutely brilliant, wonderful fic. I hope you keep updating because I love this story. I'm adding this to my Alerts list. I love it because it seems so real and interesting, keep up the good work.

Also something I wanted to point out: James looked like a "bobble head". I don't know why but I thought that was hilarious, I don't usually laugh out loud while reading, but this time I did and my brother thought that I went crazy for a bit.”
–lolipop5551, ff.net (U, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“I LOVED IT! You are a really good authoress, I love that word! Write more write more write more” –amethyst-baby, ff.net (U, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“First off I must point out that I love the Sugar Plum Fairy joke (being a dancer & all). I laughed really hard. I’m not sure I like the Head Dorm, but I’ve seen some people pull it off and I’ve read alot of your works. I have totally faith that you'll make it work. I love how u had to change retards to prats (being a Cali girl myself). Can’t wait for the rest. You’ve got me HOOKED! Looking forward to the rest. Still laughing about Remus' solo. Hope I helped you out (even though I probably didn’t)... basically I like it so far.”-Ariane, Portkey.org (U, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“Well, huh. I got an 'honourable mention'! Hell yeah! I liked this, you seem to contrast the beginning of term buzz with the dark shadow of Voldemort pretty well, and all is not good in Hogwarts, no matter how much reassurance the first years are given. I also like how James and Lily are civil, they just don't really know each other (those fics where they begin hating each other for no reason whatsoever are really frustrating), and her begrudgingly admiring the marauders was a nice touch. Keep it up, girl!
xFaithx
–Faith Kingsley, ff.net (U, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“I liked this chapter very much! It was brilliant. :D

Hugs,

GoddessoftheMaaN” –
GoddessoftheMaaN, ff.net (U, ch 2)

 

*-*

 

“Great chapter! I really enjoyed it, although I think that Lily and James may have acted a little bit too nice to each other. To me it seems like it would be awfully hard, for Lily at least, to get used to the idea of having to work with James for a year. That's just my opinion though, so feel free to completely disregard that comment. Anyway, great job, I can't wait to read more!” imber de caelum, Portkey.org (U, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“Oh good, that way you'll update quicker and then we could all read your new chapter. Awesome-ness! I love this story!!! You're a great writer. Keep up the good work! And update as soon as possible.

-Luna”
–loonymoony8, Portkey.org (U, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“Oh my God! This is so hilarious! Keep up the very great work and write a whole lot more very soon!” Harryluvr, Portkey.org (U, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“Awesome chapter. I hope u update soon. I like the part when James explains y he took some many points from Slytherin. I think its a good chapter. And the next chapter should be hilarious seeing the little hint. I can't wait to see what explanation James is going to give her.” –wizardchick292, Portkey.org (U, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“WOW! Great update! I love the "stuck on the stairs" thingy! That was so funny! Hope you update soon!” –Francesca, Portkey.org (U, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“James and Lily's relationship has progressed so well in this chapter, James was right when he thought "I think I'm growing on her"

...and I loved the "a few choice fantasies were playing out in his head about it; actually" when Lily leaned remarkably close to him >>*snickers madly*”
–Lauren Dawnie, Portkey.org (U, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“I LOVE IT!” –Ginny-and-Draco-fan, ff.net (U, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“I really like James at the end of the chapter though I like the rest too. It's really good and I like the rant of Lily. Fear me . . . fear me. hehehe. I like it. It's cool. :D I like Lily too. She's nice :)” OnerousOrangutang, ff.net (U, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

heh. James makes me laugh, making Lily think about being with him. I was wondering why they didn't think to look for troublemakers too. But this was much funnier.

I can totally see the spark between Lily and James. Poor Lily won't know what hit her in a few months.

This was a very amusing chapter. Keep up all the wonderful work!”
–PotterChick958, Portkey.org (U, ch 3)

 

*-*

 

“I have read all three chapters of this story. I have to say, it shows a higher level of vocabulary, understanding (natural habits of people), and (believe it or not) HARRY POTTER BOOKS. I hate how some stories are completely unrealistic and have no sense of normal attitude. But, there is something i must point out, some dialogue that James says is NOT the James described in the books. Such as when she fell on her bum, he was too polite and gentleman-like...he wasn't like that in the books. Oh and Lily kept on repeating the days events and EXAGGERATED the bum story...I mean, that really could've been talked about less. She made it such a big deal. All I’m saying is that this story is turning out very well and you are just my kind of author, but you overdo it. I understand that there are times when you think the chapters are getting too short...DON'T WORRY. Just update the next chapter sooner. It avoids the rambling.

I know...if you read a story of mine after this, you'll be saying I’m a huge hypocrite. I'm not the best at writing, I’ll admit, but I’m not too shabby at editing.

Hope you took the time to read my review. It's pretty short...I usually write much more, but there isn't more to it.”
–madhu893, Portkey.org (U, ch 3)

 

 

 

*-*

 

“I loved it! I especially liked 'James was looking at her in awe. That was flawless. That was one of the most fantastic lies he’d ever seen. She was amazing'. That was classic!
Also, 'Could’ve been a worse reaction… I think I’m growing on her'. I think I just like James' thoughts, he's so infallible...
xFaithx
–Faith Kingsley, ff.net (U, ch 3)

 

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1