| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Huh & Cheesecake (The Eccentrics) | Jay Crowe & Dusty Schneble (The Pyro Twins)* | Dayton, OH | 5/14/04 |
| 2. | The Pyro Twins | The Eccentrics | Dayton, OH | 7/6/04 |
| 3. | Alan Mayse & Austin Lee | The Pyro Twins | Nashville, TN | 12/28/04 |
*When the Pyro Twins declared themselves the first FPPVW Tag Team Champions, Jon Z instituted a tournament for an Ohio Tag Team Championship, which the Eccentrics won. This was the unification match to determine the first true tag champs.
Title Defenses:
1. The Eccentrics 2. The Pyro Twins 3. Alan Mayse & Austin Lee
---pinned Johnny Kashmere & Chris Stylez, Foundation: 6/22/04
---pinned Cynric & Kevin Stone, Breakout: 7/24/04
---pinned Swinger & Aki Mann, Firestorm: 8/28/04
---pinned Aaron Bowman & Dru Stoke, Homecoming Hell: 10/23/04
---pinned Cynric & Kevin Stone, November Pain: 11/27/04
---pinned Ronin Fox & Cynric, This Week in RCW: 1/7/05
---pinned Johnny Kashmere & Chris Stylez, This Week in RCW: 1/21/05