| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Alan Mayse | Trent Acid* | Dayton, OH | 4/29/06 |
| 2. | Joey Sprinklers | Alan Mayse | Los Angeles, CA | 2/10/07 |
| 3. | Low Ki | Joey Sprinklers | Dayton, OH | 5/16/07 |
| 4. | Cynric | Low Ki | Richmond, VA | 7/25/07 |
| 5. | The Wild Wolf | Cynric | Nashville, TN | 10/27/07 |
| 6. | Eddie Crowe | The Wild Wolf | Louisville, KY | 2/6/08 |
| 7. | Alan Mayse | Eddie Crowe | Trenton, NJ | 5/31/08 |
| 8. | Delirious | Alan Mayse | Philadelphia, PA | 6/4/08 |
| 9. | Alan Mayse | Delirious | Las Vegas, NV | 8/30/08 |
*This was the final match of the Toughman Tourney to crown the first champion.
Title Defenses:
1. Alan Mayse
---pinned Matt Sydal, Go Time: 5/3/06
---beat Trent Acid in a First Blood Match, Punked Out: 5/27/06
---pinned Kevin Stone, Rundown: 6/6/06
---pinned the Wild Wolf, Go Time: 6/14/06
---knocked out Huh, Go Time: 6/28/06
---pinned Andy Nathans, Rundown: 7/18/06
---pinned Cheesecake, Liberty or Death: 7/29/06
---submitted Jamie Chan, Rundown: 8/8/06
---DDQ against Kevin Stone, Summertime Showdown: 8/26/06
---submitted Jack Fletcher, Go Time: 9/6/06
---beat Kevin Stone in a No Holds Barred Match, Go Time: 9/13/06
---pinned Bryan Danielson, Go Time: 10/18/06
---pinned Masato Tanaka, Scared Stiff: 10/25/06
---knocked out Ronin Fox, Go Time: 11/8/06
---pinned Johnny Kashmere, Go Time: 12/20/06
---beat Kishi Fatu by DQ, New Year's Knockout: 12/30/06
---pinned the Wild Wolf, Snowed In: 1/13/07
---double pin against Eddie Crowe, Go Time - Night of Champions: 1/31/07
2. Joey Sprinklers
---beat Matt Sydal by DQ, Go Time: 2/28/07
---pinned Matt Stryker, Melee: 3/17/07
---pinned John Walters, Go Time: 3/28/07
---pinned Matt Sydal, Go Time: 4/11/07
---pinned Alan Mayse, the MECCA Challenge III: 4/28/07
3. Low Ki
---no contest against Kevin Stone, Go Time: 6/6/07
---knocked out Huh, Go Time: 6/13/07
---pinned Cynric, Punked Out: 6/30/07
---submitted the Human Tornado, Rundown: 7/8/07
---submitted Trent Acid, Rundown: 7/15/07
4. Cynric
---knocked out Tristan Lee, Go Time: 8/8/07
---knocked out Andy Nathans, Go Time: 8/22/07
---knocked out the Human Tornado, Rundown: 9/7/07
---knocked out Ryan Andrews, Rundown: 9/21/07
---pinned Matt Sydal, At Your Own Risk: 9/29/07
---lost to Anubis by DQ, Go Time: 10/3/07
---beat Anubis in a No DQ Match, Go Time: 10/10/07
5. The Wild Wolf
---submitted Jack Fletcher, Rundown: 11/2/07
---pinned Joey Sprinklers, Go Time: 11/14/07
---pinned Jamie Chan, No Regrets: 11/24/07
---pinned Matt Stryker, Go Time: 12/5/07
---submitted John Walters, End of the Line: 12/15/07
---beat Alan Mayse and Anubis in a Triangle Match, Ignition: 1/19/08
---beat Alan Mayse, Ronin Fox and Bryan Danielson in a Four Corners Match, Rundown: 2/1/08
6. Eddie Crowe
---knocked out Joey Sprinklers, Go Time: 2/13/08
---pinned the Wild Wolf, Rundown: 3/7/08
---no contest against Alan Mayse, Go Time: 3/12/08
---submitted Ryan, Go Time: 4/16/08
---pinned Alan Mayse, the MECCA Challenge IV: 4/26/08
---submitted Cubby, Go Time: 4/30/08
---submitted John Walters, Rundown: 5/9/08
---pinned Matt Sydal, Go Time: 5/21/08
7. Alan Mayse
---N/A
8. Delirious
---knocked out Gary, Go Time: 6/25/08
---pinned Alan Mayse, Punked Out: 6/28/08
---knocked out Dusty Schneble, Go Time: 7/9/08
---beat Alan Mayse in a Last Man Standing Match, Liberty or Death: 7/19/08
---beat Omar, Dusty Schneble and the Wild Wolf in a Four Corners Match, Rundown: 7/25/08
---pinned Huh, Rundown: 8/15/08