CHAPTER 6
PSYCHOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES
CRIMINOLOGY 3310
I. Psychological Perspectives:
A. History:
Demonology : individuals were possessed by evil spirits.
Trephiny:
Exorcism:
1. Gabriel Tarde (1843-1904) people learned
from each other by imitating.
- Laws of imitation:
- people imitate those they are most intimate with
- imitation spreads from the top down:
- intensity and frequency impact imitation
B. Modern Psychological Theories
psychodynamic
moral development
social cognition
personality traits
1. Psychoanalytic
Theory (p.87)
Sigmund Freud: Austrian physician (1856-1939)
a. Components
of the Human Personality:
- id: the unrestrained,
primitive, biological pleasure-seeking drives with which each child is born.
- ego:
develops through the reality of living in the world.
- super
ego: location of conscience and the internalization of societies morals.
b. Developmental Stages:
Eros or sex drive.
-
oral stage: new born--sucking and biting
-
anal stage: Urinary and bowel movements are a source of pleasure
-
phallic stage: children derive pleasure from fondling their genitals. Males
have sexual feelings toward their mother (Oedipus complex) and Females toward
their father (Electra complex)
-
Latency Stage: Children repress sexual pleasure
Any trauma or conflict that occurs in these early developmental stages may
have a lasting effect on the child
c. Relationship to Criminal Behavior
All behavior is an expression of the subconscious drives.
-
Many criminals are ID dominated.
-
Criminal behavior may be attributed to underdeveloped superego : psychopaths
-
Weak egos are associated with immaturity, poor social skills and easily led
into crime
Parents are responsible for the healthy development of the three components
2. MORAL DEVELOPMENT THEORY (p.88)
Lawrence Kohlberg: People travel through 6 stages of moral development.
STAGES OF MORAL DEVELOPMENT
LEVEL 1—PRECONVENTIONAL MORALITY
(do’s and don’ts to
avoid punishment)
Stages:
One: Right is the obedience to authority and avoiding punishment
Two: You obey rules because it is beneficial to you, let others
take care of themselves
“If I steal, what are my chances of getting caught?”
People stuck in this level will choose not to commit crimes based on their
fear of punishment.
LEVEL 2—CONVENTIONAL MORALITY
Stages:
Three: Right means having good motives, concern for and
having the respect of others (care about what others think of
you)
Four: Right is maintaining and conforming to
the rules of society and serving the welfare of the group.
“It is illegal to steal under any circumstances”
People in this stage are deterred from crime because they fear the reaction
from family and friends
LEVEL THREE—POST CONVENTIONAL MORALITY
(duty to mankind)
Stages
Five: Right is based on recognized individual rights with a society
with agreed upon rules—a social contract
Six: Right is an assumed obligation to principles applying
to all humankind—principles of justice, equality and respect for human
life.
“I won’t steal because it is unjust and violates universal ethical
principles
and the world will not survive unless we follow these principals"
People at this stage don't commit crimes because they have a duty to others
and to universal rights of mankind.
Level One: "I don't do drugs because I fear getting caught and
punished"
Level Two: " I don't do drugs because I am concerned that those
about what others think of me and the law must be obeyed"
Level Three: "I don't do drugs because I have a duty to God and to mankind
to maintain a keen mind to help this world be more healthy, safe and productive."
3. SOCIAL COGNITION
PREMISE: The way people think, the way people perceive the world mentally
and the way in which they solve their problems can be associated with delinquency.
When people make decisions they go through several stages:
-
interpret the data and search for a proper response
4. SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY
Learn behavior in three ways:
observation
direct experience
differential reinforcement
-
Observation: Behavioral Modeling (Imitation)(Albert Bandura)
Criminal behavior is learned through behavior modeling which is based
on three sources:
-
environmental experiences:
-
Direct Experience: Behavior Modification. (operant conditioning
We learn through positive and negative reinforcers, which behaviors are acceptable
and which are not.
-
Differential Reinforcement:
Ernest Burgess and Ronald Akers (1965) Differential Reinforcement Theory
Direct Experience:
Direction of reinforcement depends upon the group you are attracted to
5. Personality Traits
Personality can be defined as reasonably stable patterns of behavior including
thoughts and emotions that distinguish one person from another.
Two early researchers studied a large number of delinquents in the 1930's.
A) Sheldon and Eleanor Glueck identified 17 characteristics associated
with criminal behavior.
self assertiveness sadism
defiance
lack of concern for others
extraversion
feeling unappreciated
ambivalence
distrust of authority
impulsiveness
poor personal skills
narcissism
mental instability
suspicion
hostility
destructiveness resentment
B) Testing personality types:
Personality Inventory: self administered questionnaire
(500 questions) MMPI (Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory)
Personality inventories have not been proved effective at predicting criminal
behavior.
II. MENTAL DISORDERS
A. Psychopaths/anti social personality disorder:
The American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic Manual included psychopath
until 1980 when it was replaced with the Anti social personality disorder
diagnosis
B. Anti Social Personality Traits:
-
lack of remorse, empathy, shame, guilt
C. The major differences between a psychopath and those with anti social
personality disorder are:
-
psychopaths are more violent
-
violent acts are motivated by vengeance, retribution, sadism and money
-
psychopaths are more involved in sexual sadism
-
psychopaths are more likely to recidivate
-
psychopaths start their criminal careers earlier and commit more types of
offenses and at a higher rate
-
psychopaths are less amenable to treatment
-
psychopaths are unable to learn from their experiences
All psychopaths have anti-social personality disorder but not all who have
ASPD are psychopaths