CHAPTER 3 and Chapter 4
SCHOOLS THOUGHT THROUGHOUT HISTORY
Middle Ages
People committed crimes because:
1. demon possessed
2. feeble minded
3. morally destitute
CLASSICAL SCHOOL OF CRIMINOLOGY
Cesare Becarria: (1738-1794) An essay on
Crimes and Punishment (1764) Italian philosopher
Jeremy Bentham (1748-1833) English philosopher:
An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1780):
coined the term Utilitarianism
BASIC ELEMENTS:
1) Human behavior is a matter of choice.
People have free will to
choose criminal or non criminal behavior.
2) Punishment should be based on pleasure
pain principle
3) Whether people will commit crimes is in
part determined by their fear of the punishment
4) Punishment should fit the crime
5 The more certain and swift the punishment, the better able it is to control criminal behavior. However, punishment should be no more than is necessary to deter the offense.
6 The law must be applied equally
to all persons and there is no defense for criminal acts.
IMPACT OF CLASSICAL SCHOOL:
Many governments used Becarria's ideas as a model for their criminal law.
1) Prisons began to be used for
punishment
2) Sentences were geared proportionately to the seriousness of the
crime
3) Capital punishment was used less often for minor offenses.
4) Gave rise to the choice school of criminology, which dominated
peoples thinking about crime for the next 100
years.
CRITICISMS:
1) Too harsh and rigid.
Did not allow for discretion on the part of judges.
2) Too simplistic
NEOCLASSICAL SCHOOL:
punishment should
fit the individual.
There were exceptions to
the doctrine of free will and it could no longer stand alone as the sole
cause of crime.
POSITIVE SCHOOL:
Advocated scientific
method
Auguste Comte
(1798-1857) French philosopher. Coined the term sociology..
ELEMENTS
OF THE POSITIVE SCHOOL
1)
human behavior is function of external forces beyond the control of the individual.
2) use of scientific method to solve problems.
BIOLOGICAL DETERMINISM:
Giambasttista della Porta (1535-1615) Italian physician founded school
of human physiognomy. Study of facial features and their relation to
human behavior.
J.K. Lavater (1741-1801): revived Porta's.
Franz Joseph Gall ( 1758- 1828) : Developed the science of Phrenology:
Study of the shape of skulls and bumps on the head
Cesare
Lombroso:
( 1835-1909) Italian doctor. Father of modern criminality.
PREMISE:
People are born criminal.
developed the theory of Criminal Atavism. Atavistic Stigmata’s
(physical features in an earlier stage of development)
"Criminal Man" in 1876.
Enrico Ferri: (1856-1929) Lawyer, editor of a newspaper, member of parliament.
Raffaele Garofalo (1852-1934): Professor of law, magistrate, senator.
Crime was committed by people who lacked moral constraints. And that these
deficiencies had a biological basis.
Charles Buckman Goring (1870-1919). refuted Lombroso's ideas.
PSYCHOLOGICAL DETERMINISM:
Isaac Ray (1807-1881): first forensic psychiatrist. Primary
contribution was his writings on moral insanity.
SOCIOLOGICAL DETERMINISM:
Europe was experiencing a major evolution it its social structure during
the 18th and early 19th centuries.
1) Population explosion that began in 1650.
2) Industrial revolution was in full swing. Feudal system broke down
3) People were moving to the cities to work in the industries.
L.A.J. Quetelet (Adolph). (1796- 1874) Belgium
astronomer and mathematician (first social criminologist) and
André Michael Guerry: (1802-1866) French Lawyer: (first
work in scientific criminology.
Founders of the study of moral statistics and the cartographic school of
criminology
Suicide Studies:
Three patterns emerged:
1) Rates were very stable from year to year
.
2 Rates varied greatly from region to region.
3) Suicide rates were steadily rising through the century.
Later studies also found that crime rates varied greatly
Gabriel Tarde: (1843-1904) developed one of the first sociological
theories of crime.
laws of imitation People will emulate others behavior just like
they would imitate how another may dress.
Principles associated with this law
1) Individuals imitate others in proportion to the intensity and frequency
of their contacts.
2) inferiors will imitate superiors
Emile Durkheim ( 1858-1917) Founder of sociology in France
Crime is normal, functional and necessary.
Durkheim also coined the term Anomie.
CHICAGO SCHOOL OF SOCIOLOGY:
Robert Park (1864-1944) and Ernest Burgess ( 1886-1966) were founders
of the Sociology department at the University of Chicago. The first
sociology department in the U.S.
Social Ecology: Study of the relationship of individuals
and their social environment. Crime is a function of where on lives
as opposed to individual choice
CRIMINOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES
CONSENSUS:
1. Crimes are behaviors that are harmful to society
2. The law reflects a consensus on the values of society
3. Law applies to everyone equally
CONFLICT VIEW
Karl Marx (1818- 1883) German philosopher
bourgeoisie: The owners of the
means of production
proletariat: The workers
Crimes are defined by those groups who hold political, social and/or
economic power
INTEGRATED DEFINITION OF CRIME: (P. 19)
Crime is a violation of societal rules of behavior as interpreted and expressed
by a criminal legal code created by people holding social and political power.
Individuals who violate these rules are subject to sanctions by state authority,
social stigma and loss of status.