What if is a list of things that I wonder, and others, what would have happened if it came true in the Lord of the Rings books.
1) What if Isildur threw the Ring into the fire???
2) What if Elrond killed Isidur and then put the ring into the fire......or what if he ran off with the Ring?
3) What if Bilbo never found the Ring?
4) What if Gandalf was killed by Saruman?
5) What if Frodo wasnt realated to Bilbo?
6) What if Gandalf really did turn Sam into something unnatural?
7) What if Arwen didnt love Aragorn....or Aragorn didnt love Arwen??
8) What if Boromir did steal the Ring?
9) What if Aragorn stole the Ring?
10) What if J.R.R. Tolkien never wrote the books?
11) This one has nothing really to do with the books but o0owell ----What if J.R.R. Tolkien was still alive and he sued J.K. Rowling because she copied some things from his book????
12) What if Legolas turned out to be a girl?--That one is for my brother, he always says that he is a girl.
13) What if Wormtounge didnt kill Saruman?
14) What if the Nazgul did kill Eowyn and Merry?
15) What if Theoden and Boromir never died?
16) What if Bill the Pony stayed with Sam the whole time?
17)What if Aragorn did like Eowyn?
18) What if Faramir didnt like Eowyn, what if he liked Arwen?
19) What if Elrond never decided to have the Fellowship?
20) What if Gandalf never met Bilbo in the Hobbit, would they be friends in LOTR?
21) What if the entire fellowship was formed of FEMALES? I am sure some males would freak at the thought of that. Thanks to Aranndil for this one.
22) What if Galadriel took the One Ring?
23) What if Gandalf didnt get taken by the Balrog?
24) What if Peter Jackson didnt make the movie or get the rights?
Thanks to Allicat for 22 + 23 + 24
25) What if Middle Earth had cars? Thanks to mel_ryan87
26) What if Lord of the Rings didn't exist? Thanks to Haldir!
27) What If you or I were an actor/actress in the movies?
Your turn...if you would like to add anything please fill out the form