Luke Woods

Eng 328

 

Online Community Discourse and Style

 

 

            Internet chat rooms and message boards have gained massive popularity in the past five years or so.  One can find online communities that discuss anything and everything: from music groups to gardening to quantum physics.  However, any observer of one of these communities can testify that the subject of conversation often deviates, often quite dramatically, from the topic that the group is known for.

            People who participate in online discussion arenas do so for a variety of reasons and needs.  They may be lonely and too shy to interact with others face to face.  They may be confined to their home for some reason and a discussion group may be one of their only outlets for communication.  They may want to use the Internet as a mask so they can pretend to be whomever they want and say whatever they feel without any real negative consequences.  Or they may just be hunting down the latest news or rumors on their area of choice. 

            For the past few weeks, I have been observing an online newsgroup through the Google search engine called rec.music.phish.  Phish is a four-piece improvisational rock band from Vermont, who maintained rigorous touring schedules and obtained a colossal fan base between 1983 and 2000.  In 2000, they decided to take a break from touring with one another and each member pursued his own side projects.  In August of 2002, the band announced they would return from hiatus for a performance on New Year’s Eve in New York, follow that up with three concerts in Virginia and then begin to tour regularly once again some time in February 2003.

            This came as life changing news for many Phish fans that used to schedule their lives around tour dates, living on the road, following the band from city to city.  Over the years these fans developed a sort of underground society with its own language and rules, a cultural microcosm.  This identity is somewhat projected onto rec.music.phish. 

            One special quality of this culture is that Phish, along with many other bands in the same genre of music, allows fans to record their live shows.  Fans, in turn, use their computers to process the audio or data they record and make copies of it by using a compact disc burner.  Fans then trade these discs or offer up a “b + p.”  A “b + p” stands for blanks and postage.  One fan mails blank compact discs to another, along with a self-addressed, stamped envelope so the goods may be returned.  Trading and b + p offers are prevalent on rec.music.phish.  Applicable thread titles include: “TAB [Trey Anastasio Band] 10-28-02 Trades/B&P” and “It's B&P Day!!!.”     

               Many Phish fans follow the band as if it is a religious cult because of their unique approach to live performance.  The band is known for playing a different song list every night.  They often segue from one song into the next while jamming in between.  During these jams, Phish sometimes incorporates “teases.”  Teases are brief, instrumental allusions to a particular song, usually the main theme or melody, played during improvisation.  So the audience is, in a sense, “teased” into thinking a certain song will be played, but then it is not. 
        Avid fans study things such as setlists, segues, and teases, using their recorded copies of live performances as reference.  Then these folks convene in communities such as rec.music.phish to discuss quirky details.  For example Will Scanlan posted:
                    What are everyone's favorite teases that they have 
        heard be it either live or  recording?  One of my 
        all time favorites is the Barracuda tease from the 
        7/16/94 show during Chalkdust!
               
               Fan obsession does not stop with concert statistics.  Posters on rec.music.phish try to find out personal information about the band members as in the thread “What kind of car do you think phish drives.”  That one is pretty tame, but other exhibitions of mania are not so innocent.  
               For many fans there is a lot of emotion tied to whether or not they get into Phish’s first four performances when they return this winter.  In a thread titled “Phone sex for your Hamptons,” Raj offers a unique payment for tickets to any of the three  upcoming concerts in Hampton, Virginia:
        I will copulate with a phone of your choice for 
        Hamptons Xtras.  Cellular preferred (Ericssons are 
        nice and small), cordless also desirable, will even 
        do one of those ancient black rotary deals, although 
        I'll need some time to lube up.  Would like to be the 
        pitcher if possible.  Phone booths are out, I'm afraid.
 
There is undoubtedly humor implied here, but it does make one wonder what some fans may endure to see their favorite band in person after a lengthy hiatus.
               Humor is used extensively on rec.music.phish.  A large portion of threads are posted solely for entertainment purposes, either to amuse the poster or those that read the initial post.  Examples of such threads include: “Best frozen pizza?,” “Is it okay to pee in the shower?,” and “I’m starting my own sovereign nation.”
               Occasionally people post things that are accidentally entertaining.  It is remarkable how quickly subjects and tones can change in this medium.  It’s almost like a real conversation.  Note the dialogue between these two posters, who seem to know one another offline:
               Ash: Hey hey... So this weekend I started going to
        a unitarian universalist church with my friend, Rhea, 
        and I went to their service on Sunday night called 
        soulfull sundown.  At the start, a few people were on
        stage with drums and it was really fuckin amazin and I 
        just wanted to dance...  Then, this women who is a 
        famous local solo artist was there and she did alot 
        of songs for the service.  She was so amazin and
        everyone really enjoyed it and were dancing in their 
        seats which I loved!  The whole thing was just alot of 
        fun and I really enjoy the church.  They are all very 
        open and nice and I think im gonna start going more often.  
        Just thought Id share and if you are interested, check out 
        Amy Sterling.  She has a few cds and I got one and have
        really enjoyed it.  peace love and good vibes
 
               Mike h: hey bitch shut up, no one cares what you got to 
        say round these parts, and hey, give me my shit back.
 
               Ash: mike mike, dont be a cunt just cuz you fuckin have 
        issues with me??? Your shit?  You have alot of my shit 
  too!  Not to mention, yourbrother owes me a god damn 100
 dollars.  And, shit, i owe you nothing, you broke the god 
 damn pipe you fuckin asshole.  THat is what i think of you,    
 please just fuckin dont talk to me, i dont wanna know you, 
 i detest you and regret having dated you for 6 fuckin months 
 so leave me fuckin alone?  okay?
 
               Another form of unintentional comedy on rec.music.phish are random advertisement threads.  Each one offers a tempting spiel, promoting their product of choice, then provides a link for probable consumers to make a purchase or subscription.  The ads are easy to pick out since they are posted by those using their e-mail addresses as their online name, a characteristic which is quite uncommon among normal posters.  “Married but flirting people are looking for a chance to…” and  “become a millionaire” are examples of these.  Here is one titled “Increase your penis size by ¼ inch in one week”:
               INCREASE YOUR PENIS SIZE BY 1/4 INCH IN ONE WEEK!
 
        Guaranteed!!!!!!
 
 
        OUR DOCTOR APPROVED TABLET WILL ENLARGE YOUR PENIS 
        UP TO 3 INCHES.
 
        NO PRESCRIPTION NECESSARY! YOU CAN HAVE REALISTIC 
        GAINS IN JUST A FEW WEEKS. Over 100,000 Satisfied 
        Customers! Complete PENIS Enlargement System! 
        Laboratory Tested, Doctor Approved! Do you want a 
        bigger PENIS? Do you want to pleasure your partner 
        every time? Do you want your PENIS to be HARD as a 
        ROCK all the time? If you are serious about ENLARGING, 
        strengthening and developing your PENIS, then you have 
        finally found what you are looking for. With over 35 
        years of research behind our product, we can guarantee 
  results. Our prorietary exercises when used with the DHG  
 supplements will give you results! We guarantee it!
 
Although threads aimed to entertain dominate this site, there are plenty of
legitimate discussions relating to matters concerning Phish, current events, movies, video games, television, and other musical acts.  Hot recent subjects have been rumors surrounding Phish’s newest album, “Round Room.” which is supposed to be released on December 10th, and dates and locations of a pending tour starting in February.  All of these threads receive mixed responses.  Brian Kelly started a thread concerning rumored tour dates that he found on Maximtickets.com:  
               They say these cities Phish will play....
 
        Phish Spring Tour!! Phish will be announcing their 
        confirmed tour in the coming weeks but for right 
        now the dates and venues are not confirmed. We do 
        know the cities that they are planning on stopping 
        in but Phish plans to add to the list. Phish will 
        be hitting most of the major cities along with a
        few smaller ones. There are a few 2 night stops 
        and one 3 night stint in Las Vegas. We will also be 
        pre-selling tickets to all of the Phish Spring Tour 
        concerts as we did for the Madison Square Garden and
        Hampton Coliseum concerts. Keep checking back for 
        more news updates on Phish and ticket availability 
        for these concerts.
 
       Boston
       Cleveland
       Cinncinatti
       Indianapolis
       Chicago
       St. Louis
       Atlanta
       Miami
       Orlando
       Washington D.C.
       Philadelphia
       Portland
       San Francisco
       Los Angeles
       San Diego
       Phoenix
       Dallas
       Denver
       Kansas City
       New Orleans
       Las Vegas
        
        Those fuckers better not turn this into a pain in 
        the ass again !!! If i don't get tickets to every 
        fucking show i want, i will be touring the ticketing 
        agencys with an AK-47 !!!
        Bastards!!!!
               
               It is evident from posts like this that Phish fans on rec.music.phish can be quite passionate.  Whether they are discussing Phish history or statistics, the latest box office hit, or having sexual intercourse with a phone, their discourse is constantly informal and bold.  The community seems to possess a collective tongue-in-cheek attitude, one of their main focuses being to make one another laugh by being silly, bawdy, or outrageous.  The site also fulfills its role as a vehicle for news.  However, the accuracy of the news is, at times, questionable.  rec.music.phish is a laid-back, no-rules message board where fans of the band log on to satisfy their needs for information, entertainment, and communication.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Works Cited
 
1.       Ash.  “Drum circles @ church.” Newsgroup posting. 10-28-02.
   http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-  
   8&group=rec.music.phish.  11-1-02.
 
2.      Brian Kelly.  “Cities for Spring Tour on Maximtickets.com.”  Newsgroup posting.  11-9-02.  http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&group=rec.music.phish.  11-9-02.
 
3.      Raj.  “Phone sex for Hamptons.”  Newsgroup posting.  10-5-02  http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&group=rec.music.phish.  10-27-02.
 
4.      [email protected].  “Increase your penis size by ¼ inch in one week.” Newsgroup posting.  11-1-02.  http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&group=rec.music.phish.  11-2-02.
 
5.      Will Scanlan.  “All time favorite Phish teases.”  Newsgroup posting.  10-30-02.  http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&group=rec.music.phish.  11-1-02.
Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1