| Round | Pick | LSFBL Team | Pos | Player | MLB Team |
| 1.01 | 1 | Thunder Chickens | 1B | Albert Pujols | STL |
| 1.02 | 2 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | 3B | David Wright | NYM |
| 1.03 | 3 | Dahlonega Disastros | SS | Jose Reyes | NYM |
| 1.04 | 4 | Quisenberries | 1B | Miguel Cabrera | DET |
| 1.05 | 5 | Georgia Cy Clones | 2B | Chase Utley | PHI |
| 1.06 | 6 | Yellowfin Tuna | OF | Ryan Braun | MIL |
| 1.07 | 7 | Las Vegas Strippers | SP | C.C. Sabathia | NYY |
| 1.08 | 8 | Out Of My League | SS | Jimmy Rollins | PHI |
| 1.09 | 9 | Martial Monkeys | 2B | Ian Kinsler | TEX |
| 1.10 | 10 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Johan Santana | NYM |
| 1.11 | 11 | Mystery Hill | OF | Manny Ramirez | LAD |
| 2.01 | 12 | Mystery Hill | OF | Carlos Beltran | NYM |
| 2.02 | 13 | Hollerin' Hokies | 1B | Ryan Howard | PHI |
| 2.03 | 14 | Martial Monkeys | OF | Grady Sizemore | CLE |
| 2.04 | 15 | Out Of My League | SP | Tim Lincecum | SF |
| 2.05 | 16 | Las Vegas Strippers | 1B | Mark Teixeira | NYY |
| 2.06 | 17 | Yellowfin Tuna | 1B | Lance Berkman | HOU |
| 2.07 | 18 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Roy Halladay | TOR |
| 2.08 | 19 | Quisenberries | 3B | Garrett Atkins | COL |
| 2.09 | 20 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Brandon Webb | ARI |
| 2.10 | 21 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Dan Haren | ARI |
| 2.11 | 22 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Jake Peavy | SD |
| 3.01 | 23 | Thunder Chickens | OF | Nick Markakis | BAL |
| 3.02 | 24 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | OF | Nate McLouth | PIT |
| 3.03 | 25 | Dahlonega Disastros | OF | Carlos Lee | HOU |
| 3.04 | 26 | Quisenberries | SS | Derek Jeter | NYY |
| 3.05 | 27 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Carlos Zambrano | CHC |
| 3.06 | 28 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | Roy Oswalt | HOU |
| 3.07 | 29 | Las Vegas Strippers | OF | Alfonso Soriano | CHC |
| 3.08 | 30 | Out Of My League | SP | Josh Beckett | BOS |
| 3.09 | 31 | Martial Monkeys | SP | Jon Lester | BOS |
| 3.10 | 32 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | James Shields | TB |
| 3.11 | 33 | Mystery Hill | 2B | Brandon Phillips | CIN |
| 4.01 | 34 | Mystery Hill | 3B | Alex Rodriguez | NYY |
| 4.02 | 35 | Hollerin' Hokies | OF | Matt Holliday | OAK |
| 4.03 | 36 | Martial Monkeys | 3B | Evan Longoria | TB |
| 4.04 | 37 | Out Of My League | 3B | Aramis Ramirez | CHC |
| 4.05 | 38 | Las Vegas Strippers | OF | Vladimir Guerrero | LAA |
| 4.06 | 39 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | A.J. Burnett | NYY |
| 4.07 | 40 | Georgia Cy Clones | 1B | Kevin Youkilis | BOS |
| 4.08 | 41 | Quisenberries | SP | Javier Vazquez | ATL |
| 4.09 | 42 | Dahlonega Disastros | OF | Ichiro Suzuki | SEA |
| 4.10 | 43 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | 2B | Brian Roberts | BAL |
| 4.11 | 44 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Matt Cain | SF |
| 5.01 | 45 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Yovani Gallardo | MIL |
| 5.02 | 46 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SS | Michael Young | TEX |
| 5.03 | 47 | Dahlonega Disastros | C | Geovany Soto | CHC |
| 5.04 | 48 | Quisenberries | 2B | Robinson Cano | NYY |
| 5.05 | 49 | Georgia Cy Clones | C | Victor Martinez | CLE |
| 5.06 | 50 | Yellowfin Tuna | DH | David Ortiz | BOS |
| 5.07 | 51 | Las Vegas Strippers | 3B | Chone Figgins | LAA |
| 5.08 | 52 | Out Of My League | OF | Carl Crawford | TB |
| 5.09 | 53 | Martial Monkeys | OF | Curtis Granderson | DET |
| 5.10 | 54 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Ted Lilly | CHC |
| 5.11 | 55 | Mystery Hill | OF | Jason Bay | BOS |
| 6.01 | 56 | Mystery Hill | C | Joe Mauer | MIN |
| 6.02 | 57 | Hollerin' Hokies | 2B | Dan Uggla | FLA |
| 6.03 | 58 | Martial Monkeys | SP | Rich Harden | CHC |
| 6.04 | 59 | Out Of My League | SP | Zack Greinke | KC |
| 6.05 | 60 | Las Vegas Strippers | SP | Hiroki Kuroda | LAD |
| 6.06 | 61 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | Adam Wainwright | STL |
| 6.07 | 62 | Georgia Cy Clones | OF | Magglio Ordonez | DET |
| 6.08 | 63 | Quisenberries | OF | Bobby Abreu | LAA |
| 6.09 | 64 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | John Danks | CHW |
| 6.10 | 65 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Derek Lowe | ATL |
| 6.11 | 66 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Scott Baker | MIN |
| 7.01 | 67 | Thunder Chickens | RP | Francisco Rodriguez | NYM |
| 7.02 | 68 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Aaron Harang | CIN |
| 7.03 | 69 | Dahlonega Disastros | 3B | Chipper Jones | ATL |
| 7.04 | 70 | Quisenberries | OF | Raul Ibanez | PHI |
| 7.05 | 71 | Georgia Cy Clones | SS | Stephen Drew | ARI |
| 7.06 | 72 | Yellowfin Tuna | 3B | Ryan Zimmerman | WAS |
| 7.07 | 73 | Las Vegas Strippers | SP | Mark Buehrle | CHW |
| 7.08 | 74 | Out Of My League | SP | Kevin Slowey | MIN |
| 7.09 | 75 | Martial Monkeys | SS | J.J. Hardy | MIL |
| 7.10 | 76 | Hollerin' Hokies | SS | Jhonny Peralta | CLE |
| 7.11 | 77 | Mystery Hill | RP | Jonathan Papelbon | BOS |
| 8.01 | 78 | Mystery Hill | 1B | Prince Fielder | MIL |
| 8.02 | 79 | Hollerin' Hokies | RP | Joe Nathan | MIN |
| 8.03 | 80 | Martial Monkeys | RP | Brad Lidge | PHI |
| 8.04 | 81 | Out Of My League | 2B | Kelly Johnson | ATL |
| 8.05 | 82 | Las Vegas Strippers | C | Jorge Posada | NYY |
| 8.06 | 83 | Yellowfin Tuna | 2B | Mark DeRosa | CLE |
| 8.07 | 84 | Georgia Cy Clones | OF | Hunter Pence | HOU |
| 8.08 | 85 | Quisenberries | DH | Johnny Damon | NYY |
| 8.09 | 86 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Joe Saunders | LAA |
| 8.10 | 87 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Kenshin Kawakami | ATL |
| 8.11 | 88 | Thunder Chickens | 2B | Jose Lopez | SEA |
| 9.01 | 89 | Thunder Chickens | C | Chris Iannetta | COL |
| 9.02 | 90 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | 1B | Carlos Pena | TB |
| 9.03 | 91 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Andy Sonnanstine | TB |
| 9.04 | 92 | Quisenberries | C | Bengie Molina | SF |
| 9.05 | 93 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Brett Myers | PHI |
| 9.06 | 94 | Yellowfin Tuna | OF | Matt Kemp | LAD |
| 9.07 | 95 | Las Vegas Strippers | SP | Andy Pettitte | NYY |
| 9.08 | 96 | Out Of My League | 1B | Justin Morneau | MIN |
| 9.09 | 97 | Martial Monkeys | SP | John Maine | NYM |
| 9.10 | 98 | Hollerin' Hokies | 1B | Chris Davis | TEX |
| 9.11 | 99 | Mystery Hill | SP | John Lackey | LAA |
| 10.01 | 100 | Mystery Hill | SP | Erik Bedard | SEA |
| 10.02 | 101 | Hollerin' Hokies | OF | Andre Ethier | LAD |
| 10.03 | 102 | Martial Monkeys | 1B | Joey Votto | CIN |
| 10.04 | 103 | Out Of My League | C | Chris Snyder | ARI |
| 10.05 | 104 | Las Vegas Strippers | 2B | Dustin Pedroia | BOS |
| 10.06 | 105 | Yellowfin Tuna | C | Kelly Shoppach | CLE |
| 10.07 | 106 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Brandon Morrow | SEA |
| 10.08 | 107 | Quisenberries | OF | Chris Young | ARI |
| 10.09 | 108 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Gavin Floyd | CHW |
| 10.10 | 109 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | OF | Shin-Soo Choo | CLE |
| 10.11 | 110 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Gil Meche | KC |
| 11.01 | 111 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Johnny Cueto | CIN |
| 11.02 | 112 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Matt Garza | TB |
| 11.03 | 113 | Dahlonega Disastros | RP | Mariano Rivera | NYY |
| 11.04 | 114 | Quisenberries | SP | Felix Hernandez | SEA |
| 11.05 | 115 | Georgia Cy Clones | OF | Conor Jackson | ARI |
| 11.06 | 116 | Yellowfin Tuna | OF | Jermaine Dye | CHW |
| 11.07 | 117 | Las Vegas Strippers | RP | Brian Fuentes | LAA |
| 11.08 | 118 | Out Of My League | SP | Manny Parra | MIL |
| 11.09 | 119 | Martial Monkeys | OF | Josh Hamilton | TEX |
| 11.10 | 120 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Jair Jurrjens | ATL |
| 11.11 | 121 | Mystery Hill | SP | Oliver Perez | NYM |
| 12.01 | 122 | Mystery Hill | SP | Armando Galarraga | DET |
| 12.02 | 123 | Hollerin' Hokies | 3B | Adrian Beltre | SEA |
| 12.03 | 124 | Martial Monkeys | SP | Fausto Carmona | CLE |
| 12.04 | 125 | Out Of My League | OF | Jacoby Ellsbury | BOS |
| 12.05 | 126 | Las Vegas Strippers | SP | Randy Johnson | SF |
| 12.06 | 127 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | Chris Young | SD |
| 12.07 | 128 | Georgia Cy Clones | RP | B.J. Ryan | TOR |
| 12.08 | 129 | Quisenberries | SP | Ubaldo Jimenez | COL |
| 12.09 | 130 | Dahlonega Disastros | DH | Hideki Matsui | NYY |
| 12.10 | 131 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | 1B | James Loney | LAD |
| 12.11 | 132 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Jeremy Guthrie | BAL |
| 13.01 | 133 | Thunder Chickens | 3B | Alex Gordon | KC |
| 13.02 | 134 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | OF | Torii Hunter | LAA |
| 13.03 | 135 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Ervin Santana | LAA |
| 13.04 | 136 | Quisenberries | SP | Bronson Arroyo | CIN |
| 13.05 | 137 | Georgia Cy Clones | 3B | Carlos Guillen | DET |
| 13.06 | 138 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | Wandy Rodriguez | HOU |
| 13.07 | 139 | Las Vegas Strippers | OF | Jay Bruce | CIN |
| 13.08 | 140 | Out Of My League | RP | Jose Valverde | HOU |
| 13.09 | 141 | Martial Monkeys | SP | Paul Maholm | PIT |
| 13.10 | 142 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Jamie Moyer | PHI |
| 13.11 | 143 | Mystery Hill | SP | Mike Pelfrey | NYM |
| 14.01 | 144 | Mystery Hill | SP | Aaron Cook | COL |
| 14.02 | 145 | Hollerin' Hokies | OF | David DeJesus | KC |
| 14.03 | 146 | Martial Monkeys | OF | Jayson Werth | PHI |
| 14.04 | 147 | Out Of My League | SS | Mike Aviles | KC |
| 14.05 | 148 | Las Vegas Strippers | SS | Rafael Furcal | LAD |
| 14.06 | 149 | Yellowfin Tuna | SS | Orlando Cabrera | OAK |
| 14.07 | 150 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Brad Penny | BOS |
| 14.08 | 151 | Quisenberries | OF | Vernon Wells | TOR |
| 14.09 | 152 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Tim Wakefield | BOS |
| 14.10 | 153 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Jon Garland | ARI |
| 14.11 | 154 | Thunder Chickens | OF | Adam Dunn | WAS |
| 15.01 | 155 | Thunder Chickens | SS | Yunel Escobar | ATL |
| 15.02 | 156 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Joe Blanton | PHI |
| 15.03 | 157 | Dahlonega Disastros | OF | Nelson Cruz | TEX |
| 15.04 | 158 | Quisenberries | 1B | Pablo Sandoval | SF |
| 15.05 | 159 | Georgia Cy Clones | 2B | Howie Kendrick | LAA |
| 15.06 | 160 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | Kelvim Escobar | LAA |
| 15.07 | 161 | Las Vegas Strippers | SP | Randy Wolf | LAD |
| 15.08 | 162 | Out Of My League | SP | Vicente Padilla | TEX |
| 15.09 | 163 | Martial Monkeys | SS | Ryan Theriot | CHC |
| 15.10 | 164 | Hollerin' Hokies | C | Mike Napoli | LAA |
| 15.11 | 165 | Mystery Hill | SP | Kyle Lohse | STL |
| 16.01 | 166 | Mystery Hill | 3B | Kevin Kouzmanoff | SD |
| 16.02 | 167 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Daniel Cabrera | WAS |
| 16.03 | 168 | Martial Monkeys | SP | Scott Kazmir | TB |
| 16.04 | 169 | Out Of My League | 1B | Casey Kotchman | ATL |
| 16.05 | 170 | Las Vegas Strippers | RP | Jonathan Broxton | LAD |
| 16.06 | 171 | Yellowfin Tuna | RP | Bobby Jenks | CHW |
| 16.07 | 172 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Cliff Lee | CLE |
| 16.08 | 173 | Quisenberries | OF | Delmon Young | MIN |
| 16.09 | 174 | Dahlonega Disastros | 1B | Carlos Delgado | NYM |
| 16.10 | 175 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | C | Brian McCann | ATL |
| 16.11 | 176 | Thunder Chickens | 1B | Derrek Lee | CHC |
| 17.01 | 177 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Jonathan Sanchez | SF |
| 17.02 | 178 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | RP | Mike Gonzalez | ATL |
| 17.03 | 179 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Edwin Jackson | DET |
| 17.04 | 180 | Quisenberries | SS | Miguel Tejada | HOU |
| 17.05 | 181 | Georgia Cy Clones | 2B | Rickie Weeks | MIL |
| 17.06 | 182 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | John Smoltz | BOS |
| 17.07 | 183 | Las Vegas Strippers | SP | Koji Uehara | BAL |
| 17.08 | 184 | Out Of My League | 2B | Placido Polanco | DET |
| 17.09 | 185 | Martial Monkeys | SP | John Lannan | WAS |
| 17.10 | 186 | Hollerin' Hokies | 2B | Alexi Casilla | MIN |
| 17.11 | 187 | Mystery Hill | SP | Jeremy Bonderman | DET |
| 18.01 | 188 | Mystery Hill | OF | Brad Hawpe | COL |
| 18.02 | 189 | Hollerin' Hokies | 3B | Troy Glaus | STL |
| 18.03 | 190 | Martial Monkeys | C | A.J. Pierzynski | CHW |
| 18.04 | 191 | Out Of My League | 3B | Edwin Encarnacion | CIN |
| 18.05 | 192 | Las Vegas Strippers | C | Yadier Molina | STL |
| 18.06 | 193 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | Mike Hampton | HOU |
| 18.07 | 194 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Justin Duchscherer | OAK |
| 18.08 | 195 | Quisenberries | SP | Kevin Millwood | TEX |
| 18.09 | 196 | Dahlonega Disastros | 3B | Mike Lowell | BOS |
| 18.10 | 197 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | OF | Jeff Francoeur | ATL |
| 18.11 | 198 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Chris Carpenter | STL |
| 19.01 | 199 | Thunder Chickens | 2B | Asdrubal Cabrera | CLE |
| 19.02 | 200 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Barry Zito | SF |
| 19.03 | 201 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Ian Snell | PIT |
| 19.04 | 202 | Quisenberries | SP | Justin Verlander | DET |
| 19.05 | 203 | Georgia Cy Clones | DH | Billy Butler | KC |
| 19.06 | 204 | Yellowfin Tuna | 1B | Paul Konerko | CHW |
| 19.07 | 205 | Las Vegas Strippers | RP | Carlos Marmol | CHC |
| 19.08 | 206 | Out Of My League | SP | Sean Gallagher | OAK |
| 19.09 | 207 | Martial Monkeys | SP | Jeff Suppan | MIL |
| 19.10 | 208 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Andrew Miller | FLA |
| 19.11 | 209 | Mystery Hill | SS | Hanley Ramirez | FLA |
| 20.01 | 210 | Mystery Hill | C | Ramon Hernandez | CIN |
| 20.02 | 211 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Doug Davis | ARI |
| 20.03 | 212 | Martial Monkeys | 3B | Ian Stewart | COL |
| 20.04 | 213 | Out Of My League | OF | Xavier Nady | NYY |
| 20.05 | 214 | Las Vegas Strippers | 2B | Akinori Iwamura | TB |
| 20.06 | 215 | Yellowfin Tuna | 2B | Orlando Hudson | LAD |
| 20.07 | 216 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Edinson Volquez | CIN |
| 20.08 | 217 | Quisenberries | 2B | Mark Ellis | OAK |
| 20.09 | 218 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Dustin McGowan | TOR |
| 20.10 | 219 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | 2B | Felipe Lopez | ARI |
| 20.11 | 220 | Thunder Chickens | C | Jarrod Saltalamacchia | TEX |
| 21.01 | 221 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Clay Buchholz | BOS |
| 21.02 | 222 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Cole Hamels | PHI |
| 21.03 | 223 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Jose Contreras | CHW |
| 21.04 | 224 | Quisenberries | RP | Brian Wilson | SF |
| 21.05 | 225 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Sean Marshall | CHC |
| 21.06 | 226 | Yellowfin Tuna | C | Ivan Rodriguez | HOU |
| 21.07 | 227 | Las Vegas Strippers | SP | Chien-Ming Wang | NYY |
| 21.08 | 228 | Out Of My League | RP | Kerry Wood | CLE |
| 21.09 | 229 | Martial Monkeys | OF | Pat Burrell | TB |
| 21.10 | 230 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Dana Eveland | OAK |
| 21.11 | 231 | Mystery Hill | SP | Francisco Liriano | MIN |
| 22.01 | 232 | Mystery Hill | SP | Glen Perkins | MIN |
| 22.02 | 233 | Hollerin' Hokies | SS | Yuniesky Betancourt | SEA |
| 22.03 | 234 | Martial Monkeys | RP | Matt Capps | PIT |
| 22.04 | 235 | Out Of My League | SP | Zach Duke | PIT |
| 22.05 | 236 | Las Vegas Strippers | 1B | Jason Giambi | OAK |
| 22.06 | 237 | Yellowfin Tuna | 3B | Casey Blake | LAD |
| 22.07 | 238 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Brandon McCarthy | TEX |
| 22.08 | 239 | Quisenberries | SP | Aaron Laffey | CLE |
| 22.09 | 240 | Dahlonega Disastros | OF | Corey Hart | MIL |
| 22.10 | 241 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | RP | Francisco Cordero | CIN |
| 22.11 | 242 | Thunder Chickens | SP | Anthony Reyes | CLE |
| 23.01 | 243 | Thunder Chickens | OF | Adam Jones | BAL |
| 23.02 | 244 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Jason Marquis | COL |
| 23.03 | 245 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Tommy Hanson | ATL |
| 23.04 | 246 | Quisenberries | C | Brandon Inge | DET |
| 23.05 | 247 | Georgia Cy Clones | SS | Khalil Greene | STL |
| 23.06 | 248 | Yellowfin Tuna | OF | Rick Ankiel | STL |
| 23.07 | 249 | Las Vegas Strippers | SS | Bobby Crosby | OAK |
| 23.08 | 250 | Out Of My League | OF | David Murphy | TEX |
| 23.09 | 251 | Martial Monkeys | 2B | Jeff Baker | COL |
| 23.10 | 252 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | David Purcey | TOR |
| 23.11 | 253 | Mystery Hill | 1B | Adam LaRoche | PIT |
| 24.01 | 254 | Mystery Hill | RP | Heath Bell | SD |
| 24.02 | 255 | Hollerin' Hokies | OF | Shane Victorino | PHI |
| 24.03 | 256 | Martial Monkeys | C | Dioner Navarro | TB |
| 24.04 | 257 | Out Of My League | C | Kurt Suzuki | OAK |
| 24.05 | 258 | Las Vegas Strippers | SS | David Eckstein | SD |
| 24.06 | 259 | Yellowfin Tuna | RP | Joey Devine | OAK |
| 24.07 | 260 | Georgia Cy Clones | 3B | Brandon Wood | LAA |
| 24.08 | 261 | Quisenberries | 1B | Chris Carter | BOS |
| 24.09 | 262 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Ryan Dempster | CHC |
| 24.10 | 263 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Chad Billingsley | LAD |
| 24.11 | 264 | Thunder Chickens | SS | Troy Tulowitzki | COL |
| 25.01 | 265 | Thunder Chickens | DH | Jim Thome | CHW |
| 25.02 | 266 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | C | Kenji Johjima | SEA |
| 25.03 | 267 | Dahlonega Disastros | 2B | Freddy Sanchez | PIT |
| 25.04 | 268 | Quisenberries | SP | Jesse Litsch | TOR |
| 25.05 | 269 | Georgia Cy Clones | OF | Alex Rios | TOR |
| 25.06 | 270 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | James McDonald | LAD |
| 25.07 | 271 | Las Vegas Strippers | SP | Jered Weaver | LAA |
| 25.08 | 272 | Out Of My League | 3B | Mark Reynolds | ARI |
| 25.09 | 273 | Martial Monkeys | 1B | Adrian Gonzalez | SD |
| 25.10 | 274 | Hollerin' Hokies | C | Russell Martin | LAD |
| 25.11 | 275 | Mystery Hill | OF | Elijah Dukes | WAS |
| 26.01 | 276 | Mystery Hill | SS | Marco Scutaro | TOR |
| 26.02 | 277 | Hollerin' Hokies | RP | Chad Qualls | ARI |
| 26.03 | 278 | Martial Monkeys | 3B | Andy LaRoche | PIT |
| 26.04 | 279 | Out Of My League | RP | Matt Lindstrom | FLA |
| 26.05 | 280 | Las Vegas Strippers | 3B | Bill Hall | MIL |
| 26.06 | 281 | Yellowfin Tuna | OF | Milton Bradley | CHC |
| 26.07 | 282 | Georgia Cy Clones | OF | Jeremy Hermida | FLA |
| 26.08 | 283 | Quisenberries | OF | Nick Swisher | NYY |
| 26.09 | 284 | Dahlonega Disastros | RP | Frank Francisco | TEX |
| 26.10 | 285 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | 3B | Russell Branyan | SEA |
| 26.11 | 286 | Thunder Chickens | 3B | Josh Fields | CHW |
| 27.01 | 287 | Thunder Chickens | OF | Colby Rasmus | STL |
| 27.02 | 288 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | OF | Cameron Maybin | FLA |
| 27.03 | 289 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | Matt Harrison | TEX |
| 27.04 | 290 | Quisenberries | OF | Felix Pie | BAL |
| 27.05 | 291 | Georgia Cy Clones | C | Jason Kendall | MIL |
| 27.06 | 292 | Yellowfin Tuna | SS | Cristian Guzman | WAS |
| 27.07 | 293 | Las Vegas Strippers | 3B | Ty Wigginton | BAL |
| 27.08 | 294 | Out Of My League | SP | Yu Darvish | Japan |
| 27.09 | 295 | Martial Monkeys | SP | Carlos Silva | SEA |
| 27.10 | 296 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Carl Pavano | CLE |
| 27.11 | 297 | Mystery Hill | OF | Travis Snider | TOR |
| 28.01 | 298 | Mystery Hill | SP | Joba Chamberlain | NYY |
| 28.02 | 299 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | David Bush | MIL |
| 28.03 | 300 | Martial Monkeys | SP | Scott Lewis | CLE |
| 28.04 | 301 | Out Of My League | OF | Ryan Ludwick | STL |
| 28.05 | 302 | Las Vegas Strippers | OF | B.J. Upton | TB |
| 28.06 | 303 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | Braden Looper | MIL |
| 28.07 | 304 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Daisuke Matsuzaka | BOS |
| 28.08 | 305 | Quisenberries | SP | Kyle Davies | KC |
| 28.09 | 306 | Dahlonega Disastros | DH | Aubrey Huff | BAL |
| 28.10 | 307 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Phil Hughes | NYY |
| 28.11 | 308 | Thunder Chickens | OF | Justin Upton | ARI |
| 29.01 | 309 | Thunder Chickens | 3B | Jorge Cantu | FLA |
| 29.02 | 310 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SP | Mark Prior | SD |
| 29.03 | 311 | Dahlonega Disastros | 2B | Alexei Ramirez | CHW |
| 29.04 | 312 | Quisenberries | SP | Ricky Nolasco | FLA |
| 29.05 | 313 | Georgia Cy Clones | OF | Adam Lind | TOR |
| 29.06 | 314 | Yellowfin Tuna | SP | Nick Blackburn | MIN |
| 29.07 | 315 | Las Vegas Strippers | C | John Baker | FLA |
| 29.08 | 316 | Out Of My League | OF | Lastings Milledge | WAS |
| 29.09 | 317 | Martial Monkeys | SP | Dustin Moseley | LAA |
| 29.10 | 318 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Todd Wellemeyer | STL |
| 29.11 | 319 | Mystery Hill | SP | Luke Hochevar | KC |
| 30.01 | 320 | Mystery Hill | SP | Tom Glavine | ATL |
| 30.02 | 321 | Hollerin' Hokies | SP | Chris Volstad | FLA |
| 30.03 | 322 | Martial Monkeys | SP | Max Scherzer | ARI |
| 30.04 | 323 | Out Of My League | SP | Josh Johnson | FLA |
| 30.05 | 324 | Las Vegas Strippers | C | Ryan Doumit | PIT |
| 30.06 | 325 | Yellowfin Tuna | OF | Carlos Gomez | MIN |
| 30.07 | 326 | Georgia Cy Clones | SP | Clayton Kershaw | LAD |
| 30.08 | 327 | Quisenberries | RP | Joakim Soria | KC |
| 30.09 | 328 | Dahlonega Disastros | SP | David Price | TB |
| 30.10 | 329 | Hog Mountain Mudslingers | SS | Jed Lowrie | BOS |
| 30.11 | 330 | Thunder Chickens | OF | Carlos Quentin | CHW |