| Criteria | Points Received | Total Points |
| Focus (22) | ||
| -Well-developed and precise thesis | / 8 | |
| -Support theses have strong connection to the main thesis | / 7 | |
| -Maintains point throughout the writing | / 7 | |
| Organization (19) | ||
| -Good sequencing of points/paragraphs | / 7 | |
| -Presents examples in logical manner within body paragraphs | / 6 | |
| -Smooth transitions | / 6 | |
| Conventions (20) | ||
| -No spelling errors | / 3 | |
| -No grammar mistakes | / 5 | |
| -Correct word usages/choice including homophones | / 12 | |
| Elaboration (23) | ||
| -Supports ideas and theses with pertinent examples | / 8 | |
| -Thorough analysis of examples/quotes/paraphrases | / 15 | |
| Style (16) | ||
| -Fluidity | / 5 | |
| -Recognizes audience and masters content | / 6 | |
| -Distinction/Individuality | / 5 | |
| Total Points | / 100 | |