Matt
Brew

(2)
(0)
Jim
(1)
Blake
Brendan
Larry
Neal
Chris, Jon
(6)
Issues Page
Vote to Change the Scoring System, Pending the Formulation of a Value Replacement Draft.
STATED ISSUE:
FINAL RULING:
The League rules IN FAVOR.
VOTING TALLY:
"Yes" = a vote in favor of the proposal
"No" = a vote not in favor of the proposal
"Impartial" = a voiced indecision on the proposal (Uncounted towards final percentage of votes entered)
"No Vote" = an unvoiced indecision on the proposal (Uncounted towards final percentage of votes entered)
YES:
NO:
IMPARTIAL:
NO VOTE:
Percentage to Overturn = 86% (6/7)
ISSUE RAISED BY:
BLAKE
INITIAL POST:
Calling a Vote (1 of 3) - Change of Scoring
by:  ** COMMISSIONER ** (** COMMISSIONER **)
Jul 21 12:28pm

I call a vote to change the Scoring System:

R-.75
Rbi-.75
1B-.33
2B-.6
3B-.9
HR-1.2
SH-.25
SF-.25
BB-.3
SB-.33
CS-(-.3)
K-(-.03)
GIDP-(-.3)

...to...

R- .35
RBI- .35
1B- .55
2B- 1
3B- 1.5
HR- 1.65
BB- .5
SB- .55
CS- (-.5)
K- (-.05)
GIDP- (-.5)

Change the scoring system for Pitchers from:

IP- 2.1 (.7 per out)
W- 1.2
L- (-0.6)
CG- 3
SV- 4.2
SVOP- (-1.2)
HLD- 1.8
H- (-.5)
ER- (-1.2)
BB- (-.3)
HBP- (-.3)
K- .12)

...TO...

IP- 1.95 (.65 per out)
W- 1.25
CG- 2.75
SV- 4
SVOP- (-1.25)
HLD- 1.4
H- (-.45)
ER- (-1.1)
BB- (-.25)
HBP- (-.25)
K- .12

APPENDIX:
This part was added in all the other proposals for changing the scoring system, but I forgot to copy and paste it here - but there is one stipulation to changing the scoring system that has always been included in a called vote for changing the scoring system.

A change can only be made if teams are allowed to replace value lost by the change

For example - there was suggested my Value Replacement Draft. Another solution was a complete Re-Draft of the League. Either way, the only way this change can be made is if teams value is evened out for the teams.

Any votes on the points should take this into consideration.
BLAKE
Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1