| Author |
Topic  |
|
Adambown
United Kingdom 9
Posts |
Posted - 22 Jan 2002 : 12:34:31
quote:
I am also studying at Teesside university
Why doesn't anyone mention Abertay university in Scotland. It was
detailed in both of Edge's university guides. So why does no one
talk about it. Is it any good? Ive had an offer form them and
Teeside and everyone seems to prefer Teeside. Any recommendations.
Thanks. Adam Bown.

|
Mchugh
United Kingdom 194 Posts |
Posted - 22 Jan 2002 : 13:46:17
sorry, i've not visited this forum for ages (no particular
reason)
i think it was 'gakkari suru' that asked about industry placement
- at teesside, you are given the option as soon as you start the
course - they even find the placement for you (i've not heard
anything about mine yet).
in response to the abertay question, i would perhaps have
preferred to goto dundee, from what i hear the course is top rate.
however, because i did not do maths at A level, they would not let
me even apply. teesside is a great university and the computer games
programming course (hey, i got the name of my course changed now
too, yay) is really getting good (the first year seems a little
easy, at at times irrelavant, but its worth sticking with it to get
to the second year). teesside is also a lot geographically closer to
where i live.
good luck with all your applications guys, i was just about to
say i might be seeing some of you in september, but then i
remembered, its placement year, so i should be working for Rareware
or something (yeah right, i wish).

|
Tommo
United Kingdom 437 Posts |
Posted - 22 Jan 2002 : 21:58:15
Adam, I think with Abertay, there's two reasons why I
personally wasn't interested. Firstly it's in SCOTLAND! Teeside is
already pushing it distance wise for me, let alone full blown
scotland!
Secondly it's got that 'oxford' karma about it. I mean I didn't
even bother, because I just *knew* about 5 million people would
apply, and well I haven't got that much cofindence in myself. 
Well, I know it's abit late now, but I'm going to the open day
tomorrow. Will post my impressions, if anyone's interested tomorrow
night.
UK Nintendo site you ask? http://www.uknside.com/ |
unclesomeone
United Kingdom 2654 Posts |
Posted - 23 Jan 2002 : 06:10:08
Those with Middlesex offers:
I'm a 3rd year student here, and I feel strongly obliged to put
you off coming. Several things have happened to the course in the
last few years:
1: The degree is now BCS Accredited which, whilst sounding good,
means that you'll have to do useless and patronising modules in
subjects like ethics / professionalism that genuinely detract and
even replace the more useful games / graphics based modules.
2: There has been a major shift to Java, and you'll be unlikely
to do any C++ until late in the 2nd year / early in the 3rd year.
When you are trying to make your first game (in the 3rd year) you
don't want to be learning C++ at the same time, trust me.
3: I can honestly say that none of the lecturers here know the
first thing about games, and certainly don't play them. The marking
schemes are barely concerned with gameplay; yet if you have
implemented a clever programming technique in a dire game you will
do well.
4: The course used to be sponsored by Sony using the Yaroze
consoles. This has now been dropped, the Yarozes are quite literally
broken and gathering dust whilst stuck in red-tape limbo, and for at
least the next 2 years students will be making games with a buggy
student-made wrapper around DirectX technology. So when you leave
you won't even know DirectX.
5: If you choose to do a joint degree with what you see as
another compatible subject, there will be no communication between
the different departments, and you'll spend 3 years being shunted
between the two in ways you daren't imagine, whilst wishing you had
the promised personal tutor.
6: Statistically, around 10% of those that start the course will
get any degree at the end of it. Middlesex is primarily a business
designed to attract as many students as possible to enroll in order
to determine their funding. Instead of starting the course at a
suitably high difficulty level in the 1st year (with the inevitable
drop-off), courses are kept easy until the 3rd year when they reach
what should be a normal difficulty. So, you learn little for 2
years, then drop out in the 3rd after re-enrollment due to
disillusionment, depression or simple failure. Since September last
year my course has been truly decimated.
7: Last year the engineering department was shut down without
warning; students in the first and second years had to change
universities as a result. Rumours of cuts in other departments
persist, along with publicly-declared closures of key
facilities.
I trust this information is enough to help you in your decisions.
For what it's worth, I'm on the Board of Studies for my course
representing students to the university authorities, so I have
experienced all the above (and all the excuses for them) first
hand.
The only good points I can think of are that you can do joint
degrees in almost any 2 or 3 subjects, and also that you can delay
your specialisation until the 2nd and 3rd years and, eventually,
you'll get to make at least 2 games.
That guy in the grey top with the red griffin on it
frightens me!
|
Adambown
United Kingdom 9
Posts |
Posted - 23 Jan 2002 : 13:45:24
Thanks for the advice with my previous post. However, there's
something i really would like some help with. Iv'e applied to both
Abertay in Scotland and Teeside. Iv'e had offers from both. I live
in Kent so i have to travel whether i like it or not. Which one
should i choose? Do developers prefer one university to another, is
one course better than the other? If someone could please offer me
advice on what to do, i would be most grateful. Thanks. Adam Bown. |
Tommo
United Kingdom 437 Posts |
Posted - 24 Jan 2002 : 21:05:39
Unclesomeone, thanks for the 'inside' info.
Well, I went Teeside yesterday (woke up at half 4, yes HALF FOUR,
in the morning to get there!). And I must say I ha... loved it. . In
my own personnal experience, it seemed that Teeside was about 3
times better than Lincoln(Hull). Teeside seemed like a place that
was actually cared about, but Lincoln(Hull), with it being gotten
rid of in less than two years, was run down to be honest.
Teeside's facilities are bigger and seemed better. Also, although
it was exam week, so it's probably not that good to base a
comparison on (people would have been on study leave or whatever),
but how can I say this without offending... basically the people who
were around didn't look like geeks who hadn't ever been exposed to
the sun. (No offence intended). So a plus for Teeside then.
Also what I loved is, the fairly good town centre which was
actually visible from the main entrance of the uni. That means
whenever you need a shop, you could easily (within 2 minutes) walk
there.
I've got two gripes with it. One, it's 5 and a half hours drive
from where I live, two it's rather industrial. Where's all the
green?
Despite all that though, it's still my first choice, and pending
anything only Mystic Meg could predict, I'll be there next
September, AND I'm actually looking forward to it.
UK Nintendo site you ask? http://www.uknside.com/ |
Mchugh
United Kingdom 194 Posts |
Posted - 24 Jan 2002 : 22:48:07
i'm
glad you liked Teesside
if you're after a bit of greenery you can goto North Yorkshire
(apparently, i've never been myself)
the five and a half hours is no big deal - you wont do it that
often

|
Adambown
United Kingdom 9
Posts |
Posted - 28 Jan 2002 : 15:24:17
I
would be really grateful if you could offer even the tiniest bit of
information as i am about to make a huge decision that will affect
the rest of my life. Thanks. Adam Bown.

|
Kelso
United Kingdom 73
Posts |
Posted - 31 Jan 2002 : 13:32:57
Damn! UCAS site down, so, another day
of waiting.
does nebody know how many places are 'up for grabs' on the
teesside games programming course?
------------------------- Signiture's are soo 'last topic' |
Azure
United Kingdom 231 Posts |
Posted - 31 Jan 2002 : 15:13:23
Adambown, although I am a Teesside student and do enjoy my
course I would recommend you to take the place at Abertay. I haven't
been there but it's reputation is second to none, and that is often
what counts when you've got your degree and are looking for a job.
Anyway, it's up to you.
Did he design the games? No - he executes them. |
Mchugh
United Kingdom 194 Posts |
Posted - 31 Jan 2002 : 22:55:05
just to let you know, the university is going to be putting
my name forward for a place at SCi! (makers of Carmaggedon, in
London). Even though chances of me getting there are still slim, its
a chance nonetheless, and has installed some confidence in me
relating to the uni's placement finding prowess.
i'll keep you posted.
that was a very badly worded post. my apologies!

|
Kelso
United Kingdom 73
Posts |
Posted - 01 Feb 2002 : 09:06:38
quote:
Damn! UCAS site down, so, another day of waiting.
same today.
------------------------- Signiture's are soo 'last topic' |
Tommo
United Kingdom 437 Posts |
Posted - 01 Feb 2002 : 09:50:26
quote:
just to let you know, the university is going to be putting my
name forward for a place at SCi! (makers of Carmaggedon, in
London). Even though chances of me getting there are still slim,
its a chance nonetheless, and has installed some confidence in me
relating to the uni's placement finding prowess.
Wow, good luck Mchugh! Hope you get in.
UK Nintendo site you ask? http://www.uknside.com/ |
Kelso
United Kingdom 73
Posts |
Posted - 05 Feb 2002 : 15:35:09
I've applied for the Paisley - 'Computer Games Technology'
course, and apparently, they give students details to nearby devcos.
DMA? oh, and i read in the prospectus, that they give u a laptop
for the first year. any truth in that?
------------------------- Signiture's are soo 'last topic' |
Mchugh
United Kingdom 194 Posts |
Posted - 06 Feb 2002 : 12:34:50
quote:
I've applied for the Paisley - 'Computer Games Technology'
course, and apparently, they give students details to nearby
devcos. DMA? oh, and i read in the prospectus, that they give
u a laptop for the first year. any truth in that?
i've never even heard of this course, but it sounds too good to
be true, whatever! let me know if the laptop thing is true...

|