| Mel | Wade Richey | Tom Brady | Drew Bledsoe | Kerry Collins | Jason Sehorn |
| Cindy | Wade Richey | Kerry Collins | Tom Brady | Drew Bledsoe | Jason Sehorn |
| Jade | Wade Richey | Drew Bledsoe | Tom Brady | Kerry Collins | Jason Sehorn |
Okay, so we unanimously agree that Richey is the most appealing of the five and Sehorn, the least appealing. We have relatively similar tastes in this category.Looking at the Top 3 of each person's choice, the Inductees should therefore be Richey and Brady.
Martin Brodeur . Sergei Fedorov . Patrice Brisebois . Richard Matvichuk . Joe Nieuwendyk
| Mel | Patrice Brisebois | Richard Matvichuk | Sergei Fedorov | Joe Nieuwendyk | Martin Brodeur |
| Cindy | Marty Brodeur | Sergei Fedorov | Patrice Brisebois | Joe Nieuwendyk | Richard Matvichuk |
| Jade | Joe Nieuwendyk | Patrice Brisebois | Richard Matvichuk | Marty Brodeur | Sergei Fedorov |
Now this category is the most interesting one. The tastes vary. But it is fairly easy to see that Brisebois appeals to us all since he appears in everyone's Top 3. It's a tie between Fedorov and Matvichuk but I take it upon myself to induct Matvichuk and Brisebois into my version of the Hall of Fame.
Mark Grudzielanek . Alex Gonzalez . Shawn Green . J.T. Snow . Mike Mussina
| Mel | Alex Gonzalez | J.T. Snow | Mark Grudzielanek | Mike Mussina | Shawn Green |
| Cindy | Alex Gonzalez | Shawn Green | Mike Mussina | J.T. Snow | Mark Grudzielanek |
| Jade | Mike Mussina | Shawn Green | Alex Gonzalez | J.T. Snow | Mark Grudzielanek |
Now Mel, I seriously think you should 'revise your "I don't fancy Hispanics" option' ('baseball speak') because you definitely think Gonzalez is hot. And so does Cindy; I place him as third so he's through. Now second place either goes to Mussina or Green. Both are attractive in their own right - Italian, shy and smart or tall, lean and charming. Hmmm...hard choice to make so we look to Mel's vote as deciding factor. Mussina it is then.
*****
~Thanks for taking the time~