We are told in the Urantia Papers (92:5.3) that Marduk was a Babylonian perpetuation of the Adamic legends. The following quote is from the "Epic of Erra," one of the most ancient Akkadian epics in existence. It was found last century, written on clay tablets:
'I shall cut off the life of the righteous man who acts as intercessor. The evil man, who cut throats, him I shall put in the highest place. I shall so change men's hearts that father will not listen to son and daughter will talk to mother with hatred. I shall cause them to speak ill and they will forget their god and speak blasphemy to their goddess. I shall quench the glory of the beams of Samas. To the king of the gods I shall say 'Dwell in Esagila' [the underworld]. I shall destroy the cities and turn them into barren landÉI shall get into the house of the gods, there where the evil man has no access. At the abode of princes I shall let the rogue dwell."
Erra was another name for "Nergal," and Nergal
is described by Sumerian texts to be (from:
Nergal: Also pronounced Erakal, "Lord of Erkalla (the great city)" Chief god of the Underworld, consort of Ereshkigal (and of Mammetum; see Ninhursag). Assimilated with Erra and called Hercules in Greek. Patron god of Kutha and Tarbisu. Temple Emeslam. Partly assimilated with Gilgamesh as judge of the Underworld and with Ninurta.
So Nergal was pronounced Erakal. The rest should
be clear to the FER student, and I'll leave it as such. The following is
from
"The Poem of Erra, one of the most remarkable
documents which has come down to us from ancient times, was discovered
in the nineteenth century and to judge by its diffusion throughout the
ancient Near East one of the most popular poems of antiquity.2
The subject of the poem is Erra's attack upon
Marduk, king of the gods, and his oppression of Suanna, the celestial city
of Marduk.3
Later on in the poem Erra makes good on his threat.
Erra's revolt not only causes Marduk to rise from his seat, but to abdicate
his throne for a brief period. As a direct result of Erra's oppression
of the Oriental Olympus, Marduk is enfeebled and the world temporarily
thrown out of kilter and plunged into darkness.5
We are not the first to raise the possibility
that the Poem of Erra was concerned with celestial events. De Santillana
and von Dechend drew a similar conclusion in Hamlet's Mill: "It is evident
that the events of the Flood in the Era Epic, however vivid their language,
apply unmistakably to events in the astral heavens and to nothing else."2
A few excerpts from the poem confirm this opinion.
Thus Marduk is made to announce, with apparent reference to an earlier
cataclysm, that should he rise from his seat flood and dissolution of the
government of heaven would result:
"I rose from my seat, and the government of heaven
and earth dissolved. And the sky, lo!, it shook: the stations of the stars
in the sky were altered, and I did not bring (them) back to their (former)
positions."3
Here Gossman's translation may be more accurate:
"When I stood up from my seat and let the flood break in, then the judgement
of Earth and Heaven went out of joint. The gods, which trembled, the stars
of heaven their position changed, and I did not bring them back."4
A straight-forward reading of this passage finds
that as a result of Erra's assault Marduk rose from his seat, thereby changing
the order of the solar system. Here de Santillana and von Dechend remark
that this passage forms "the clearest statement ever uttered by men or
gods concerning the Precession
This interpretation, however, while
Thus Erra is made to announce: "I want to annihilate
the brilliance of Sulpae [an epithet of Marduk]. I want to attain the seat
of the king of the gods so that his counsel be not forthcoming."7 In an
analogous passage Erra is made to state:
"I shall quench the glory of the beams of SamasÉTo
the king of the gods I shall say 'Dwell in Esagila' [the underworld] "8
The cataclysmic nature of Erra's assault finds
ample proof in the imagery of the poem. To make our case it is necessary
to review a few of the basic elements of Babylonian cosmology. To the ancient
Mesopotamians, for example, heaven was compared to a bull led by a nose-rope.1
In accordance with this conception, the rulership of heaven could be symbolized
by the king of the gods holding the nose-rope of heaven.
In the Poem of Erra, it is related that Erra held
the nose-rope of heaven, an implication, presumably, that he had wrested
this distinction from the deposed Marduk.2 There Erra's reign of power
is presented as being both far-reaching and oppressive: "Hero Erra, you
are holding the nose-rope of heaven. You
Marduk's fall from power is alluded to throughout
the poem. One passage makes Erra address Marduk as follows: "Until you
enter that house, prince Marduk, and Girra purifies your garment, and you
return to your place, Till then I shall rule in your stead and keep strong
the government of heaven and earth."4
The welfare of the world is elsewhere said to
be dependent upon the state of the bond of heaven Dimkurkurra a euphemism
for the heavenly kingdom of the gods, considered to be the "knot" of the
universe and center of the world. In the Poem of Erra it is said: "It is
you, hero Erra, who did not fear prince Marduk's name! You have undone
the bond of Dimkurkurra, the city of the king of the gods, the bond of
all the countries."2
Yet another barometer of the state of heavenly
affairs, according to Mesopotamian conceptions, was the health and well-being
of the World Tree. In Akkadian tradition this tree was known as the Mesu
tree, described in the following manner: "The flesh of the gods, the ornament
of the king of the universe, that pure tree, whose roots reached as deep
down as the bottom of the underworld, whose top reached as high as the
sky of Anum."3
In the Poem of Erra it is related that as a consequence
of Marduk's discomfiture the Mesu Tree became disturbed. Indeed it is stated
that the tree became permanently relocated.4
In summary, the consistent message of the imagery
of the Poem of Erra indicates that Erra's uprising posed a severe threat
to the kingship of the gods. The throne was wrested from Marduk; the bond
of heaven the city of the king of the gods was disfigured; the crown of
kingship was obscured (or cast down); and the tree of heaven, a visible
sign of the god's Creation, was disturbed. The cataclysmic import of such
imagery much of which strikes at the very heart of ancient conceptions
of kingship has yet to be recognized.
A careful reading of the Poem of Erra will find
that virtually every one of these motives is met by Erra's assault. Erra
usurps Marduk's throne; the people, incited by Erra's presence, gather
about the hero who has assumed the powers befitting the king of the gods;
the government of heaven is dissolved; customary religious practices are
suspended; and, finally, under Erra's rule a dark pall hangs over the land,
the land itself becoming barren.5
The following passage is indicative of this state
of affairs:
I shall cut off the life of the righteous man
who acts as intercessor. The evil man, who cut throats, him I shall put
in the highest place. I shall so change men's hearts that father will not
listen to son and daughter will talk to mother with hatred. I shall cause
them to speak ill and they will forget their god and speak blasphemy to
their goddess.1
A passage quoted earlier is in a similar vein:
Surveying the destruction wrought by Erra, Marduk
laments: Of all the countries what is there left steady? He has taken the
crown of his lordship: kings and princes forget their ordinances, the bond
between god and man is undone: difficult it is to knot again.3
Erra's identification with Nergal points the way.
Thus both Cagni and Roberts have called attention to the resemblance between
the two gods. They share the same consort (Mami); the same residence (Meslam);
and an association with the same natural phenomena: war, pestilence, fire,
etc.1
Neither scholar, however, considered the possibility
that Erra might bear a relationship to the planet Mars, Nergal's identification
with Mars being well- known. This is hardly to be wondered at as most scholars
consider the identification of Nergal with the red planet to be entirely
arbitrary in nature, a product of Oriental astrological speculation. It
has been our purpose in this series of essays, however, to show that the
cult of Nergal cannot be understood apart from his identification with
Mars, the planetary aspect of the god actually determining the god's distinctive
characteristics.2
That Erra-like characteristics were associated
with the planet Mars in Mesopotamian thought is undeniable, the forbidding
nature of the red planet being everywhere apparent. Oriental skywatchers
regarded Mars as the "disaster bringer," the star of rebellion, the star
of misfortune.3
Consistently associated with the phenomena of
war, Mars was the warrior-planet par excellence.4 And in light of Roberts'
suggestion that the name of Erra derives from a root meaning "scorcher,"
it is significant to note that Mars was the fiery planet par excellence
in ancient astrological thought.
Indeed, a name of Nergal/Mars in Babylonian texts
was sarrapu, "scorcher."1 A Hellenistic name for Mars Pyroeis, "Fiery Star"
indicates that similar conceptions prevailed among the Greeks.2
Names applied to the red planet likewise testify
to its evil reputation amongst these earliest of astronomers. Consider
the name harabu, meaning "to ravage, devastate, lay waste."3 This term
is not only consistent with the ancient traditions associated with the
planet Mars, it almost certainly traces to the Semitic root *hrr, "to scorch,"
that regarded by Roberts as the root in Erra.
The Assyrian word mutanu, signifying "death,"
"plague," "pestilence," was also applied as a name of the planet Mars.4
Kugler translates this name as "he who brings an abundance of death by
plague."5
Certain omens associated with the planet Mars
in Babylonian texts are also reminiscent of the deeds ascribed to Erra.
Mars is directly associated with the usurpation of the king's throne, for
example: "If the Sun goes down (by a Darkness/Eclipse) and Mars stands
in its place, there will be an usurpator."6
Significant here is the mention of the untimely
going down of the sun, with Mars in attendance, not unlike the references
in the Poem of Erra to Erra's role in the eclipse of Shamash/Marduk.7
With this passage we might compare a passage from
the Poem of Erra: "The hero reached Mount Hehe. He raised his hand and
levelled the mountain. He destroyed the cities and turned them into deserts.
He devastated reed and rush thickets and burned them like fire."1
At this point it may be relevant to reflect upon
the personality of Erra as described in the Poem of Erra. There he is represented
as a terrible, impetuous warrior, an appropriate adjective of which would
be "fiery-tempered or hot-tempered." Students of comparative mythology
will recognize that this is precisely the personality typically ascribed
to Martian heroes throughout the ancient world, the Biblical Samson being
perhaps the most famous example of the impetuous berserker.2 Is it not
possible that the "fiery-tempered" Erra owes his bellicose personality
to the fiery appearance of the red planet?
Emeslam is just as precisely defined. It is the
underworld residence of Erra, literally the region beneath Saturn's cosmos.
According to the reconstruction offered by Talbott and myself, this region
necessarily included the pillar-
...A common interpretation of the celestial pillar
envisaged it as the World Tree, said to unite heaven, earth and the underworld.
In Mesopotamia, as we have seen, this tree was known as the Mesu, a word
cognate with Meslam. It is within this tree-like pillar that the residence
of Erra is to be located, and it was from there that he rose to imperil
the kingdom of the gods."
Erra's dire intentions are made known early on
in the poem: "I will make prince Marduk wrathful: I will cause him to rise
from his seat and I will fell the men."4
[i.e. the precession of the equinoxes]."5
on the right track, is precluded by other events
attending Erra's revolt. As noted earlier, for example, the world was plunged
into darkness during Erra's assault, and Marduk was forced to descend to
the Netherworld, the darkness and Marduk's displacement apparently being
related.6
Here it is scarcely necessary to observe that
the precession of the equinoxes does not involve a darkening of the heavens.
Raids by nomadic renegades like the Sutians are not likely to precipitate
such events either. To interpret the Poem of Erra in this fashion is to
misinterpret it and renders meaningless the carefully chosen imagery. Difficult
as it is to accept, the clear meaning of the poem is that the heavens were
disturbed and the planet-gods rearranged during Erra's assault.
dominate the whole earth. You lord it over the
country. You convulse the sea, you destroy the mountainsÉYou control
Suanna. You gather all the divine powers to yourself. The gods fear you."3
I shall quench the glory of the beams of SamasÉTo
the king of the gods I shall say 'Dwell in Esagila' [the underworld] I
shall destroy the cities and turn them into barren land. I shall get into
the house of the gods, there where the evil man has no access. At the abode
of princes I shall let the rogue dwell.2
In Mesopotamia it is Nergal who is the preeminent
"hero-warrior." Astandard epithet of Nergal was ur-sag: "hero."8 The following
passage from the epilogue of Hammurabi's Law Code is typical of his veneration:
"May Nergal, the strong one among the gods, the fighter without peer, who
achieves victory for me, burn his [i.e., the enemy's] people in his great
power, like the raging fire of swamp-reeds!"9
It is such passages as the foregoing which have
led scholars to emphasize the fiery, destructive power of Erra.
like apparition associated with Saturn.3 That
such a pillar played a prominent role in ancient conceptions of the underworld
has been thoroughly documented by Eliade and other modern scholars.4