To compete in the Evaluation Contest
the contestant needs to be a Lake Oswego Toastmasters Club Member in good
standing.
In the Evaluation Contest, a “target”
speaker gives a speech. At the conclusion
of the speech, all the evaluation contestants are given five minutes to analyze
the speech and summarize their findings.
After the five minutes all of the contestants
notes are collected.
The timing on the evaluation contest is two to three
minutes. That means the contestant is
within time if the speech is between
Then the contestants are brought back
into the room one at a time and each one gives their evaluation of the target
speaker. As in other speech contests,
the judges give numerical rankings to the contestants. The numerical rankings for the Evaluation
Contest are based on the following criteria.
Judging Items
|
Excellent |
Very Good |
Good |
Fair |
Analytical Quality
Clear,
focused |
40 |
28-39 |
17-27 |
0-16 |
Recommendations
Positive,
specific, helpful |
30 |
22-29 |
13-21 |
0-12 |
Technique
Sympathetic,
sensitive, motivational |
15 |
11-14 |
6-10 |
0-5 |
Summation
Concise,
encouraging |
15 |
11-14 |
6-10 |
0-5 |