| Questions on Religion | |
| Sir Mavalankar uwach | |
| Dear Friends, Last couple of days I have been thinking about religion. What is religion? Why do most of the religious groups tend to be fundamentalists? Why is there so much violence in the name of religion? Does being religious mean going back in time? Can one go to heaven by brutally terrorizing fellow human beings? Why is Hindu religion so diverse? Does it mean our forefathers were more tolerant, learned and liberal in their thinking? Does going to temple, church, pagoda, agar or a mosque makes one more religious? Does one have to believe in God to be religious? Why are rituals performed? Do rituals lead us to salvation? What does religion mean? Why should we be religious? Why is there some much hatred between various religious groups? Does any religion in the world command its followers to kill humane beings in the name of religion? Why should there be so many different religions in this world? May be it God's trick to keep human population at reasonable levels? What would have been the population of the this earth had we not had so many religious was and campaigns? Could God have achieved the same result by making Human Beings less fecund and less fertile? |
|
| Cantfake comments | |
| 1. Right approach - ask lots of questions
first, before attempting to answer them. In my language proceed
breadth-first, and not depth-first. Why do you think humans so
genetically close to champanzee can do so much in sophisticated
computation? Because we can skip-read, and unlike mathematics, the real
linguistic world is breadth-first!
2. Be a skeptic. Always be on the look out for inconsistent inobjective incomprehensible repetitionary answers. Specially those that sound scholarly and reference a lot of authorities. 3. Let me not pretend to be wise enough to answer those on your list, nevertheless I am willing to take lumps for my answers. |
|
| The Mavlankar questions | |
| What is religion?
The set of rules we use by default to address any new problem not encountered before.
Practicing-religionists tend to be fundamenalists because they need to conform to something and be true to something!
Because historically violence is a good way to expropriate some one else's property or to stop some one from complaining. One has to surround violence with religion in order to solve THE oldest human problem, why wont he do the same to me (my term analogy-prevention? Loyalty, religion, skin color, culture are some of the rationale of the violent analogy-preventers. Does being religious mean going back in time? Being fundamentalist certainly does. Can one go to heaven by brutally terrorizing fellow human beings? Posits heaven which I deny. Why is Hindu religion so diverse? Because we use the label Hindu on many diverse beliefs. It really matters not what the beliefs of so labelled aree, the real question only is whether majority of existing hindus consider the person a hindu.. Does it mean our forefathers were more tolerant, learned and liberal in their thinking. Or perhaps more cowardly, backward, incapable, ... Does going to temple, church, pagoda, agar or a mosque makes one more religious? Depends on the agent you ask to - fudamentalist yes, me a bigger time waster, you don't know.. Does one have to believe in God to be religious? Yes Why are rituals performed? Conformity (that is how it is done) temporal consistency (that is how it it was) moronic-complexity (that is the way to do it - Sir/lady moron), ...
Nope.
Why should we be religious? Why is there some much hatred between various religious groups? Does any religion in the world command its followers to kill
humane beings in the name of religion? Why should there be so many different religions in this world? May be it God's trick to keep human population at reasonable
levels? What would have been the population of the this earth had we not
had so many religious was and campaigns? Could God have achieved the same result by making Human Beings
less fecund and less fertile? |
|