Dr. Ambedkar’s formula for abolition of caste system: (picked out from his summary of speeches)
1.Emancipation of the mind and soul in respect of caste consciousness etc., shattering religious notions of the same, bringing about free intercourse.
2.Getting into employment of all fields overcoming restrictions and taking part in their management as well as ownership
3.Change over to other religions
4.Inter-marriages causing blood bond
5.Maximum political representation
6.Development of individual capacities to the point of competency.
7.Recognizing only the division of Touchable and Untouchable
8.Acquiring benefits of fundamental rights and provisions for the protection of minorities plus special safeguards including reservations in all fields of human endeavor
9.Finally to establish a Society based upon Liberty, Equality and Fraternity. (These are only guidelines picked out from his speeches)
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Writings and Speeches Vol.1 (Work of an Editorial Board inclusive of the w/o Dr. Ambedkar)
Introduction on Dr.Ambedkarji:
Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar, being a crusader against caste system, a valiant fighter for the cause of downtrodden in India, also an elder statesman and national leader who almost single handedly produced the Constitution for India is cherished forever by all Indians. In fact, his fight for human rights and as an emancipator of all those enslaved in the world gave him international recognition as a liberator of humanity from political social and economic injustice, said Maharastra Chief Minister Sharad Pawar commenting on the publication of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Writings and Speeches Vol.1.
Pandit Jawarlal Nehru paid a glowing tribute to Dr. Ambedkar while moving a condolence resolution upon his death, in the parliament as follows: Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar was a symbol of revolt against all oppressive features of the Hindu Society.
Substance:
Dr. Ambedkar observes that superimposition of endogamy over exogamy is the main cause of formation of caste groups, in a lecture on Castes in India: Their mechanism, Genesis and development. As long as castes exist in India, Hindus will hardly intermarry or have social intercourse with outsiders and if Hindus migrate to other regions on earth, Indian caste system would become a world problem.
Indian population in India is a mixture of Aryans, Dravidians, Mongolians and Scythians. Caste in India means and artificial chopping off the population into fixed and definite units, each one prevented from fusing into another through the custom of endogamy. Endogamy is the only characteristic that is peculiar to caste
Dictionary meaning of Endogamy is : marriage within the limits of community, clan or tribe and exogamy means marrying outside the community, clan or tribe.
With the growth of history, however, exogamy lost its efficacy. Originally the endogamy was foreign to India. Various Gotras of India were exogamous. Exogamy was strictly observed and there were rigorous penalties for violating exogamy than violating endogamy
Touching upon technicalities of caste maintenance he says that it is absolutely necessary to keep the numerical equality between marriageable units of the two sexes to prevent any surplus woman or man outstanding partnerless constituting menace to the caste system by way of their moving out of the circle to find partners and import foreign offspring into it.
There were methods found out to get rid of the surplus men and woman in order to maintain the purity or prevent pollution, one being Sati where the wife of the dead husband is sacrificed into the funeral pyre and widowers are encouraged to take Sanyas (priesthood).
Nasified says ‘job and job alone’ was the foundation upon which whole system of caste was built in India. Brhamins closing the door to the rest of the community made others in varied divisions of employment to keep them closed to the rest of the population.
In other words, restriction of employment and endogamy are the pillars on which the caste system stands.
One occasion, Ambedkar says Real remedy for breaking caste is intermarriage causing blood bond. But in deviation, on another occasion he said: “Breaking up the caste system cannot be brought about by inter-caste dinners and inter-caste marriages but by destroying religious notions on which the castes were founded.
It is true that caste rests on belief. And it is almost impossible to be sustained. Firstly there was one caste and classes became castes by imitation and excommunication
Unless ceaseless effort is carried out to eliminate caste system and caste consciousness India cannot reach the necessary efficiency to achieve progress in every field of human endeavor.
Under the rules of Peshwas in Maratha country, the untouchable was not allowed to use the public streets if a Hindu was coming along, in order that he may pollute Hindu by his shadow. The untouchable was required to wear black thread either on his wrist or in his neck. Some wanted others not to wear in the way Brahmins did so that non-Brahmin would not be taken to be Brahmins who went to the extent of enforcing that.
Ambedkar also said Brahmins in Northern and Central India are only cooks and water carriers while Brahmins in other parts occupies high social position. (Page 67)
Damn your safeguards, we don’t want to be ruled by you under any term said the Ulstermen talking of the Irish rule.
Emancipation of the mind and the soul is a necessary preliminary for the political expansion of the people. Civilized society undoubtedly needs division of labor. But in no civilized society, division of labor is accompanied by unnatural division of laborers into water-tight compartments. In no other country, division of labor is accompanied by gradation of laborers, unlike India.
Social and individual efficiency requires us to develop individual capacities to a point of competency to choose and make his own career. This principle is violated in the caste system, in so far as it involves an attempt to appoint tasks to individuals in advance., selected not on the basis of trained original capacities but on that of the social status of the parents. Industry is never static. It undergoes rapid an abrupt changes. With such changes an individual must be free to change his occupation. Caste system would not allow Hindu to take occupations where they are wanted if they do not belong to them by heredity. By not permitting readjustment of occupation, caste system become a direct cause for much of the unemployment found in the country. Caste system has disorganized and demoralized Hindus because of separate caste units that cankers into each other in particular and Indian Hindu society in general.
Hindu society being a collection of castes, each caste being a close corporation, there is no place for a convert to be in it. Though there are castes among Mohammedans and Sikhs, the idea of excommunication is foreign to Sikhs and Muslims. Unlike Muslims, no Hindu regards other Hindu to be his brother. Among Hindus there is no brotherhood. There is some unity when there is a Hindu Muslim clash. . Ambedkar’s ideology explains that the society must be based upon Liberty, Equality and Fraternity.
Even Varna system has its weak points and the strict adherence to the Varna make the growth of society difficult. Abolition of sub castes coming under Varnas allowing only the four Varnas (Brahmin, Kshatriyas, Vaisya, Sudra) to exist does not solve the problem. It could worsen and aggravate it, he said
How to bring reform to the Hindu social order How to abolish caste? This a question of supreme importance, he said
He divided the Hindu community to two classes i.e. touchable and untouchables; distinction more pronounced and unmistakable and more convenient than castes. He also recognized the distinction between Brahmins and non-Brahmins but this was of less importance. He did not think that there was any necessity for communal electorate for non-Brahmins.
The untouchables are usually regarded as objects of pity but they are ignored in any political scheme. The socio religious disabilities have dehumanized the untouchables and their interests and their interests are at stake. The word untouchable is an epitome of ills and sufferings . Untouchable is not even a citizen in all practicality. Because a citizen has bundle of rights 1. personal liberty 2. personal security 3. Right to hold private property 4. Equality before law 5. Liberty or conscience 6. Freedom of opinion or speech 7. Right of assembly 8. Right of representation in a country’s government.
Real social divisions in India are:
1. Touchable Hindu,
2.Untouchable Hindu
3.Mohammedans
4.Christians
5.Parses
6.Jews
Will a Hindu political candidate represent a Mohammedan interest. He suggests two methods to meet this difficult situation. To reserve seats in plural constituencies for those minorities that cannot otherwise secure personal representation or grant communal electorate. Both have there usefulness.
The congress has denied communal representation except in the case of Mohammedans and it also denies the extensive use of nomination. For congressmen who are by design political radicals and social conservatives. For them, ‘political’ and ‘social’ are two suits and can be worn one at a time as season demands. As congress is non-national and anti national body, its views on communal electorate are worthy of no serious consideration. Some Congressman suggested appointment of one or two untouchable representatives but that is as good as having none, he said
World war yielded a principle of self-determination for governing international relations which embodied in its 1917 pronouncement saying that every people must be free to determine the conditions under which it is to live. It is not right to restrict that concept only to international relations because discord does not exist between nations alone but there is also discord between classes within the nation
Scheduled caste are more than a minority and that any protection given to the citizens and the minorities will not be adequate for the scheduled castes. And in other words it means their social economic and educational conditions are so much worse than that of the citizens and other minorities. Scheduled castes would require special safeguards against the tyranny and discrimination of the majority. Other interpretation is that scheduled castes differ from a minority and therefore protection given to minority is not enough for scheduled castes.
Ambedkar demanded for the scheduled castes, all the benefits of fundamental rights of citizens, all the benefits of provisions for the protection of minorities plus special safeguards.
1.Emancipation of the mind and soul in respect of caste consciousness etc., shattering religious notions of the same, bringing about free intercourse.
2.Getting into employment of all fields overcoming restrictions and taking part in their management as well as ownership
3.Change over to other religions
4.Inter-marriages causing blood bond
5.Maximum political representation
6.Development of individual capacities to the point of competency.
7.Recognizing only the division of Touchable and Untouchable
8.Acquiring benefits of fundamental rights and provisions for the protection of minorities plus special safeguards including reservations in all fields of human endeavor
9.Finally to establish a Society based upon Liberty, Equality and Fraternity. (These are only guidelines picked out from his speeches)
Political representation and the right to hold office under the state are the two most important rights, he said on one occasion
Nehru:Caste System, Minorities and Social Justice (1989) By Attar Chand (Independent Publishing Company - New Delhi)
Nehru argued that that the caste system once provided important benefits to India, but over centuries it became rigid citadel for the exploitation of the masses developing an aristocratic approach that was wholly opposed to modern conditions and the democratic ideal.
Inequality and injustice has to be removed through constitutional means especially when the Untouchables are doctrinally deemed extremely low and even dangerous.
Equality of Opportunity, according to Nehru had three meanings namely: A. dismantling and abolition of caste system B. reward based upon ability and hard work C. inequalities of caste system to be replaced by inequalities of capitalism which will be shared by all alike except the entrepreneur class. But Nehru was not eager of the third because of identifying himself as a socialist.
Nehrus’s strategy laid special emphasis on programs for bringing scheduled castes and other backward classes to the level of the rest of the humanity.
His three strategies to promote equality of opportunity are: 1) to bar the discrimination against the Untouchables 2) to reserve concrete opportunities in Education and employment for them 3) To make them geared to the industrialization taking place in India.
Under his guidance and approval, the Indian constitution abolished Untouchability. According to Article 17, practice of Untouchability in any form was forbidden. The Untouchabulity Act of 1955, made it punishable under the law to refuse services or deny Untouchables their rights. However these policies met with mixed success in the cities and in the countryside made little progress.
As the untouchables and other scheduled caste members would still carry the legacy of unequal treatment that existed for two millenniums at least, Nehru held not only the equal opportunities be given to all, but special opportunities for educational economic and cultural growth be given to the backward groups so as to enable them to catch up with those who are ahead of them. But the courts thwarted these efforts declaring them to be contrary to the equal treatment of all Indians as embodied in the Artcles 15 and 29 .
Nehru and his government plus the education Institutions for untouchables were hindered in their advancement by the caste system. Caste is a mighty power even in the villages today.
Statutory provisions providing reservation in legislatures for ten years and then it was extended. Minority commissions are appointed entrusted with the task of:
A) Evaluating the various safeguards provided in the Constitution
B) Making recommendation to ensure effective implementation of the safeguards.
C) Reviewing implementation of the policies pursued by the Union and State governments
D) Looking into specific complaints regarding the deprivation of rights and safeguards guaranteed to the minorities.
E) Undertaking surveys and research
F) Suggesting welfare measures and submitting reports as per constitution.
Indira Gandhi’s 15 point program broadly cover the following (Page 23)
A) Prevention of Communal violence and promotion of communal harmony
B) Giving special consideration to minorities in the matter of recruitment to services in the central and state police forces, national banks, public sector undertakings including railways etc. and appointing a selection committee representative for the above purpose.
C) Laying special emphasis on the education needs of the minorities
D) Measures for ensuring fair and adequate share of the benefits of the development programs including 20 point program to the minorities
E) Provision for expeditious action for redressal of minority grievances and institutionalized arrangements for dealing with the problem of minorities on a continuing basis
Scheduled castes and scheduled tribes have been living a miserable life for almost 2000 years. Black community in USA had lived under privileged and miserable conditions for 200 years. The same is not true for Muslim community of this country.
Being true Gandhian , Nehru tried to wipe off every tear from every eye. With his qualities of his head and heart, Nehru endeared himself to the humblest and poorest of Indians. He was even concerned with the lot of the Muslims.
Not only does the poor consumer have less money to spend but also his discretionary power, freedom of time, place, quality and amount and method
of purchase are severely restricted. Since he has little choice about the place, quality, amount and method of purchase. The poor have to pay extra for every item he buys. Like the economic costs of poverty, the poor and the backward community of the society, have to bear heavy educational costs as compared to their affluent counterparts.
Communalism of the majority community was on the offensive. The greatest casualty of this was the Father of the Nation – Mahatma Gandhi who was murdered by them.
Nehru believed that under colonial rule, all Indians were untouchables and slaves. We are all untouchables because the present government has reduced us to a political slavery and made us powerless. Nehru believed that Judiciary was essentially conservative an undemocratic organ and it was usually unresponsive to the dynamics of social change. The magnificent constitution we framed had been kidnapped and usurped by the lawyers. Nothing can be worse for the world than the deprivation of the human freedom. Therefore no Individual is trivial, he added
I have been associated with the National Planning committee for so long gaining conviction in me that it is not possible to solve any major problem separately by itself, they all hang together depending greatly upon economic structure.
Never before have we felt the absence of Gandhi and Nehru including Indira Gandhi so much as we do to day, when some of their policies and ideas have been steadily diluted and distorted. When those who profess to follow the ideology of socialism, secularism, democracy are doing everything to the contrary. If Gandhi and Nehru were alive to day, they would be shocked at the violation and mutilation of their cherished principles and policies by their so-called followers.( page 90)
In the shadow of the Mahatma
Bishop V.S.Azariah and the Travails of Christianity in British India (by Susan Billington Harper)
Birth of Azariah
Vedanayagam Samuel Azariah was born August 17, 1874, in the church rectory and was baptized on October 4. He had his final education at Madras Christian College.
Although Christianity opposed to the caste system in general, caste divisions were existed in congregations. Christian Brotherhood Association which he organized , opposed caste system in order to promote Christianity.
Azariah and YMCA
YMCA, being ecumenical from its inception, was formed for the benefit of the wandering Chrisitan journeymen in the 19th century as an inter-denominational organization.
World alliance of YMCAs were formed in 1855 in Paris. Number of associations grew from 338 in 1855 to 2043 in 1876. It was International Ecumenical movement of young men representing neither single Christian denomination nor single nationality.
V.S. Azariah whose vision was beyond nationalism, was the first Christian Bishop of India, agreed to join the Madras YMCA 1985 as an assistant secretary and work for converting Indians to Christianity.
In 1907, World Student Christian Federation and Fifth National Convention of YMCA was held in Tokyo and the YMCA conference elected Azariah as a vice president and discussed strategies for evangelization in Japan., China and India. He was by then the General Secretary of the Indian YMCA.
Azariah never accepted the charge that his efforts were not intrinsically unpatriotic. But his personal letters en route from Ceylon to China 1907 almost guilelessly linked British power to divine power. Christians and Muslims were disturbed by the symbolic association of Hinduism with the nationalist cause.
Azriah struggled during his pre Episcopal career to reconcile his Indian Christian identity with communal, national and transnational loyalties of other Christians in YMCA and elsewhere.
By January 1890, YMCA headquarters were located in Madras which successfully evangelized its own members both Christian and non-Christian. In 1910 -15 out of 20 YMCA secretaries in India were graduates.
The conversion of Mr. Ramanujam Chetty (high caste Komati caused a great uproar which resulted in establishing Young Men’s Hindu Association (YMHA).
In the restaurant of Young Men’s Christian Association in Madras, men of Highest caste had to sit men of other castes and eat food prepared by a cook who is an outcaste, as far back as 1896.
Within the walls of the Association, all are equal without distinction of caste or creed whether he was a Brahmin, Sudra ,churchman or a dissenter. All stood on one platform with feeling of fellowship and equality fostered between all members.
Whatever the forum, Azariah never compromised his Christian evangelism in the face of resistance.
At the age of 21, he was placed in charge of YMCA headquarters in Madurai.. He traveled extensively visiting YMCA branches helping to indigenize the YMCA by adjusting its activities to the needs of the smaller towns and villages where western influence was less pronounced.
He put before the Christian students the duty of evangelization of India. Azariah argued that conversion to Christianity promised national as well as individual salvation.
Indian Missionary Society in Tinnevelly was formed in 1903 and National Missionary Society in 1905.
Azariah wrote in 1906 to John Mott of the YMCA who won Nobel prize that India was in great need of literature that used to rouse up missionary interest of the church. We have to study your methods and adapt them to India. Running a totally Indian church was something which was discouraged by the Western missionaries. However Azariah managed to establish IMS (Indian Missionary Society) as far back as 1903.
Even their models for indigenization were taken from the western based Christian organization rather than from Hindu based Indian one. IMS has been established in complete isolation from Indian nationalism.
The NMS restricted the membership to Indian Christians and forbade solicitation of funds from outside India.. National Missionary Society wanted to evangelize the hitherto untouched parts of the country through Indian men and women supported by Indian money.
Many of its founders were generally sympathetic to the national movement. They were members of a relatively small and elite, western educated group.
The NMS later adopted a radically indigenous approach contributing to its decline rather than to any greater acceptance in India. The European Advisory Board was dismissed in1920 and the society assumed a vernacular name: “Bharat Kristya Sevak Samaj.” But many Indian churches were alienated by its call for radical indigenization and they had a few new converts reason being that it was made a nationalist movement.
Meanwhile Azariah thought NMS’ growing liberal nationalistic profile would detract it from its original evangelistic mission. He said that the missionary cause has taken his entire heart.
In spite of being not strongly convinced of the society’s new orientations, I am called upon to defend it, to speak for it, to support it, of which I feel doubtful in private. Hence, I feel miserable in this business, said Azariah.
Travails of Christianity and Azariah
In 1912 Azariah was consecrated the first Indian Bishop who belonged to Anglican Church, it being the most significant event in his personal a life more than all the evangelical movement of India.
Only Syrian Church appointed Bishops from the 16th century on wards. The Roman Catholic Church appointed three Goan Brahmins as Bishops in the 17th century. But they did not appoint native Indian Bishops again until 1923. Catholic and Syrian churches used liturgical languages of Latin and Syriac respectively in their priestly duties. Methodist Episcopal Church appointed a Indian Bishop only in 1931. Lutheran Church lingered until 1955.
The first indigenous Anglican bishops Were consecrated in China in 1918, Japan 1923, Uganda 1947 and Iran in 1961. Thus the appointment of Azariah was a path breaking step, not only for the Anglican Church globally but also for all Christian denominations in India.
The church in India confronted variety of frustrating state-imposed obstacles on its path of growth. This situation of civil and ecclesiastical discord belied the widely accepted notion that church participated in a semi official imperial system of mutual support and promotion.
Queen Victoria in 1858 ordered non-interference with the religious belief or worship of any of the subjects on pain of her highest displeasure.
But this policy of non-intervention was difficult to enforce. Evangelicals such as Charles Grnt (1746 – 1823) and Willian Wilberforce (1759- 1833) successfully pressured the government into allowing the Anglican Church and missionary societies fuller access in India. Meanwhile East India Company administered revenues to Hindu temples and propitiated Hindu gods.
However the Parliament approved the extension of Anglican episcopate to India in 1813. 1823 appointed a new Bishop of Culcutta being the first Anglican Bishop east of Suez with three new archdeacons assisting him in the presidency capitals.
Culcutta Bishop Herber, during his short tenure, ordained a Tamil convert Christian David and Muslim Convert Abdil Masih to Anglican orders. Although Christianity may have benefited in early times from its close association with the prestigious British Empire in India, its state connection became serious liability with the adventure of the national independence movement.
Anglican Bishops generally came to regret their church connection with sate, well before the advent of popular Indian nationalism in the early 20th century.
Azariah lamented that the Anglican Church in India was unable to create new dioceses and also to subdivide old ones or to consecrate new bishops without government approval.
The Hindus knew that Her Majesty has proclaimed strict neutrality in the matters concerning the religion of the peoples of India. The Church saw the sate connection as a legal and cultural hindrance to the Church’s growth and development.
From 1813 1929 number of Bishoporics in India, Burma and Ceylon increased from one to fourteen. Untouchable groups in Soutern Andra Pradesh of over a million people converted into Christian faith during the last three decades of 19th century.
Bishop of Madras Henry Whitehead recognized the need for assistance in overseeing the expanding Telugu Churches and identified Azariah as the man for the job.
Whitehead was sorry as the progress of conversion was slow. But it continued to spread at a rapid pace among untouchables and low castes in India. Christian Missionaries were the first people to treat India’s outcastes as human beings.
When Azariah joined the mission formally, there were approximately 30,000 Indian Christians associated with the Indo Anglican Church in the Telugu region. In 1925 alone there were over 17,000 converts.
Newspaper accounts of Azariah’s appointment in early 1912 generated rumors which caused concern in both London and Madras. Controversies
erupted in Parliament in 23 April 1912 and Undersecretary of State for India Edwin Montagu had assured the House of Commons through his spokesman En King issuing Royal license to Archbishop of Canterbury empowering him to commission the bishops in India to consecrate Azariah as Assistant Bishop in the Madras diocese. Some British Anglicans did not like his low cast background not representing westernized Indian professional elite.
As a Nadar from Tinnevely, Azariah represented formerly low caste and untouchable groups who rejected High class Hindu domination, which conveniently reinforced British Empire’s own policy of resisting the increasingly troublesome Indian Congress (page 130). He was not a High Caste English educated Indian. In spite of criticisms, Azariah rose to become competent bishop running a diocese roughly the size of England.
Heads of Church of India were government servants supported out of government funds Consequently the church in India actively engaged in propagating Christianity among the people of India whose responsible heads are government officers. So, it was simply impossible for the government to maintain its pledge of religious neutrality as ordered by Queen Victoria.
“The Hindu” only made a passing comment on the appointment of an Indian as Bishop and had he been from a elite background The Hindu would have gone to town with it.
However the non-Christian elite were unconcerned with this appointment because the Anglican Church was considered Home for the British rulers and Indian outcastes. Marginalization of Azariah’s ministry by the Indian elites was begun with the very date of his consecration.
However Nizam administration was pleased to have a church working among poor people in the remote Dornakal area that it donated 300 acres of land to the diocese free of charge as an act of charity. Nizam being a Muslim Maharajah, gave Azria free first class railway passage throughout the state and also requested Azariah to talk with him when he was passing through Dornaka in a rain.
Meanwhile, Indian Christians castigated Azariah for allegedly lacking experience, sanctity advanced university or theological education, high
social position or reputation among Hindus. Even at Tinnevelly those who belonged to different castes sent petitions against Azariah In letter to Archibishop of Cantabury , Whitehead argued that protests were inspired by unworthy motives, race, prejudice, caste feelings, party spirit and jealousy.
Azariah was promoted by liberal westerners against the wishes of many less liberal westerners and Indians. His appointment opened up rifts within the established church., within British, Indian and Madras governments, within and between various missionary societies and within factions of Indian Christianity itself.
Azariah himself faced enormous personal and professional challenges. He was worried as to how his wife would rise up to the occasion of his being a bishop, to dine with the bishop, to lead in all big meetings, to be introduced to the governor. It is difficult to behave in such way that the people will look up to. And yet God can give you the grace and I am praying that He who led us so far, will even now lead us on.
English bishops at that time make dresses costing 500 pounds Sterling amounting to Rs.7500 rupees with which Azariah and his wife could have bought a three to four bed-room house. At the Edinburg conference of missionaries Azriah said that we ought to be wiling to learn from one another and help one another.
The next two Indians elevated to th episcopate were appointed only as assistants to Europena Bishops (SK Traffidar for Cucuta in 19 35 and and JSC Banergea for Lahore in 1937) and this trend was followed in China Japan and Africa too.
Indian professional elites filled positions of Indian Civil Service while those mostly from outcastes and low caste back grounds, became Christians out of whom bishop being appointed, Consequently, Britons became further prejudiced against them.
Whitehead hoped that Azariah’s appointment would both mollify the Indian community and challenge those westerners who believed that the White races should never be under the authority of non-white races. British missionaries were placed under Azariah’s Jurisdiction in the new Dorankal
diocese. No other Indian was made diocesan bishops during Azariah’s life time.
Of the 34 appointed to Anglican dioceses in India, Burma and Ceylon from 1912 to 1945, all were Europeans except Azariah and and C.K.Jecob, an Indian who was consecrated bishop of Travancore and Cochin after Azaia’s death in 1945. Of course there were two assistant bishops appointed one to Calcutta in 1935 and to Lahore in 1937 of which earlier reference was made.
Azariah generally appointed Englishmen rather than Indians to important positions in the Dornakal diocese; three European Archdeacons and one European Assistant Bishop shouldered much of the responsibility for his diocesan administration.
Azariah declined to comment on the absence of other Indian diocesan bishops for most of his career being more cautious than his mentors about taking a chance on an Indian appointee.
India’s total Christian population of 1,862,634 in 1881 which rose to 6,290, 292 in 1931. Conversions to Christianity in Andra Pradesh grew faster than other territories in the entire South Asian region during Azariah’s administration. By 1933, roughly 80 per cent India’s Protestant Christian Converts were from depressed class backgrounds and no Brahmins.
Shepherding the conversion of depressed classes, tribals and non-brahmin castes through direct evangelism, teaching and grass roots humanitarian aid was the central occupation of Azariah’s life. Azariah who performed baptisms in the river keeping his
body in water up to waist, used to get up at 5.00 and spend at least 02 to 03 hours for bible study and prayer.
Most notable aspect of IMS mission strategy under Azariah leadership was the encouragement of group conversions in order to minimize the social dislocation of converts after baptism and to provide the strength of group solidarity in the face of hostility from non-Christians.
He emphasized during the conversion questioning as to the use of worshipping idols. Forgetting the creator, you are worshipping the creation, he said.
IMS and Azariah regarded evangelism as their first duty. Second was training teachers and pastors to look after fast proliferating village congregations. Dornakal Divinity school was founded in 1920 to train ordination candidates.
Azariah shared Gandhiji’s interest of woman upliftment and was responsible for training widows as Bible women to teach villagers, promoting women as village elders, deaconesses at the same time he also went from village to village and spoke of the importance of tithing in order to keep the Church self-sufficient.
Azariah’s wife Anbu served as President of Mothers’ Union in Dornakal which maintained branches throughout the diocese. By 1931, the mothers union had 688 branches and 5,480 members. He enjoin seminarians to get on their knees to thank Lord for their wives.
Azariah changed the Lord’s prayer thus:
“Oh Father who art in heaven, You are our Father, We are Your children. Keep us all well. Heal my rheumatism and my child’s boil. Keep us from wild animals and the tiger, Forgive us our sins, our quarrels, angry words, all that we have done since morning. Make us good. Bring all the castes to kneel down to you and call you Father. By 1940, 157 out of 168 ordained workers were listed a indigenous and only 11 as foreign.
Azariah’s dedication to the cause of unity was prompted by several interrelated facts. A) His commitment to evangelism 2) his quest for united Church of India, were to promote authentically Indigenous Church. He was for universal ecumenical vision for being distressed to find younger Christians felt more resentment than gratitude towards the work of the western missionaries.
Azariah’s second major challenge was to overcome the constant friction between local Andra culture and the transformative agenda of the Christianity. He insisted all beliefs and rituals, practices, cultural manifestations of Hinduism that the church judged to be evil be renounced at Baptism. Chief among the evils were the caste system with dehumanizing conceptualization like pollution and Untouchability throwing
some one fifth of the society to perpetual thralldom. He argued for complete repudiation of caste loyalties in order to achieve successful brotherhood.
Stronghold of caste system is being very badly shaken by the assault of Christian message of salvation for all. Hindu men women were asked to remove the caste marks. Rejection of traditional authority represented not just repudiation of old idols but also a challenge to the social order . It was done by the long suppressed lower classes. But they could not eradicate all the caste practices.
The bishop also talked of the importance of giving up the animosities between Malas and Madigars. (both were outcaste groups in Andra) and to soften the negative feelings of Sudras towards untouchables.
Converts from different caste back grounds were required to attend the same chapels, drink from the same communion cup, to send children to the same school (Where they could receive training in occupations reserved traditionally for their own or for rival castes. When assistant pastor of Madiga origin attempted to preside at wedding in a predominantly Mala congregation, riot erupted. Finally entire congregation temporarily defected to the Roman Catholic Church. Denominationalism pander to the class hatred often, having to run two different chapels to different communities in the same village. (This would never happen in any other country).
Azariah wrote in 1941: Mixed marriages are wrong according to Christian ideals and it is duty of the church by ecclesiastical action to give clear guidance to their ministers and uphold the Christian standards by Christian discipline, also calling for abolition of dowry system and bargain marriages.
Successfully introduction of marriage rights and celebrations free of alcohol consumption were done.
One of the main factors associated with the Untouchability was meat eating. Chicken, fish and mutton are considered less polluting. Bats, cats, rats dogs crows and snakes considered tobe very much more polluting. Beef and pork considered by higher caste particularly defiling because the former came from most sacred of all animals- the cow and the latter came from swine which ate excrement.
Both western missionaries and caste neighbors disapproved of carrion eating but for different reasons. Depressed classes eating carrion was condemned because they came from animals which died of disease, old age and starvation resulting in their meat being dangerously unsanitary. Madigas and Yerukulas decided to abstain from eating beef and pork voluntarily. In 1928 Church reported that Christians in Pastorate headquarters had given up pork (page 275)
Voluntary commitment to giving up drinking beef eating thievery and falsehood improved their cleanliness in the eyes of Village Zamindars who as a result abandoned the spatial distance requirement.
Azariah had hostile relationship with Gandhiji. Whitehead and Azariah met Gandhi for the first time in February 1916. Mahatma Gandhi arrived by slow train, 3rd class and immediately struck Whitehead as delightful person, very simple in his life, very warm-hearted and affectionate and most responsive to the appeals on poverty and suffering.
There was big rift because the Christians were considered anti-national and unpatriotic, Azariah and Gandhi both opposed to British plans to divide the growing Indian electorate along communal lines.
In a much publicized declaration at the Yola Conference of October, 1935, Ambedkar announced that he would lead those belonging to depressed classes out of Hinduism into a religion committed to social equality. On that Azariah wrote: “Religion is not a matter that can be adopted or changed by fifty million people at the behest of a leader, however influential he may be.
Mahatma’s popular and carefully cultivated political image as a champion of the depressed classes was jealously observed by leaders like Ambedkar.
By 1935 Dornakal diocease had 250 ordained Indian clergy and more than 2000 village teachers and extensive network of schools and medical dispensaries, co-operative societies, banks, printing presses, agricultural settlements and industrial projects in addition to leading the worship and providing pastoral service for over 218, 879 Anglicans.
Gandhi accused Azariah for inflating figures of conversion. Gandhi advise them to confine to areas of ameliorating the social and economic conditions instead of converting people into Christianity. But this is something which could give enough practical difficulties.
The conflict between Gandhi and Christian missionary forces and Azariah personally over depressed class conversions threatened to worsen the atmosphere of intercommoned distrust. Agatha Harrison who liaise between and Nationalist leaders and the Briish government said that conflict between missionaries and Hindu reformers in the religious field was serious enough to aggravate the conflict between Briton and India in the political field.
Gandhi’s position was that it was better for the depressed classes to suffer in Hinduism than to be converted into Christianity. He refused to admit those who were converted into Christianity were improved.
Bishop Azariah, Hodge and Pickett had an interview with Gandhi who told him if they convert depressed classes, he would wean away the educated other classes from Christianity. Gandhi had also threatened them with legislation to discourage conversion not to prohibit them.
However, Azariah’s continued activity of supporting mass conversions had placed him in collision course with Gandhi well before 1937. Gandhi being formidable opponent, by 1938 Azariah was simply unwilling to take on a major battle with him.
C. Rajagopachari called upom Hindus to wake up and give up their social inequalities in order that the depressed classes may not be driven away from Hinduism.
Azariah called upon the religious leaders to respect the religious liberties of the Christians in the interest of the national unity.(340).
Azariah rejected Gandhi's view that all religions are merely different paths to the same truth. The bishop also said that the government or party (Congress) has no right to call itself national if it allies to a one particular religion out of many professed. However he said that Hindus and Christians could work to make a joint electorates.
Persecution of Christians in an Independent India is not unlikely. Our forefathers who wanted to become Christians were often deprived of their homes, their property, yet sometimes their lives had been threatened . In 1944 Bishop Azariah forcefully said Christians must have the right to preach and baptize in the Independent India. He urged that in no circumstances, should any penalties be inflicted on those who honestly and sincerely desire to change their religion.
His work among depressed class groups in Andra also convinced him that many Indians preferred British rule to Congress-led Independent government. In 1942 at the Episcopal Synod, Azariah reported that the depressed classes felt that they owed everything to the British and were afraid of Congress gaining control.
He spent last part of his life traveling on village roads by bullock carts to visit the remote Parkel area. When the people were asked whether they are Chrisitans and they so said “no” adding that no one has told us about it. How shall they believe in Him of whom they have not heard putting the blame back to him and the evangelical effort. Having served as a Bishop of Dornakal for thirty two years, Azariah died on the new year day of 1945 at the age of 70.
After Azariah’s death in 1945, many Christians in the Dornakal campaigned vigorously for an European Bishop. “Not tainted like the treacherous late Tamilian bishop,” many of them said. There are persons who preferred an Indian Bishop but vast majority wanted a European bishop.
Cultivator's Whipcord (Collected works of Mahatma Jotirao Phule)
"Without knowledge, the intelligence was lost. Without intelligence, morality was lost. Without morality, dynamism lost. Without dynamism money lost and without money Shudras sank to the lowest depth " said Phule
His active role in women's equality of status can hardly be surpassed even by more educated and more recent men of 20th century.
During the life time of Phule from April 11, 1827 to November 28, 1890, social injustice, inequality, casteism, exploitation of the farmers and under privileged strata of the society, untouchability and the suppression of the women were at its maximum. In order to defeat these social aberrations, Mahatma Phule battled with every ounce of his energy managing to bring about Justice to a greater number of people..
At the age of 21, Jotirao completed his education which included studying the life of Buddha, Basaweshwar, Jain Tirtankara and such classics as Vedas. He also studied the works of the great saints such as Namdeo, Tukaram, Kabir and trends of politics.
Conceptualization came to him that all men are born equal and that all are God's children. Every one should have equal opportunity and be treated with fair play and justice. It was a time, seeing a widow's face in the early morning being considered inauspicious. Phule decided to fight against all these misconceptions, as well as the so-called god-ordained caste system.
He started a first school for girls in India in 1848 in Poona because women too are subject to severe discrimination in addition to being obliged to sacrifice themselves in the funeral pyre of the husband in an act known as Sati. His wife Savatribai taught in the school facing innumerable obstacles and hardships, born out of vicious campaign being launched by orthodox upper castes as it was an act against established laws of Hinduism.
Accordingly it was a Sudra Phule who took the initiative to emancipate high class women from the clutches of their own men. To find money to run the school, he became a part time English teacher in a missionary school. and also functioned as a Building contractor. Three years later, in 1851 a first school for untouchables in India was founded followed by a network of schools in Poona.
His personality was so great that he was even able to control and convert hirelings who set upon to murder him, who in turn became his ardent disciples. Only the sages were reportedly able to do these kind of acts.
In 1860 He organized a first widow remarriage program receiving massive support from his wife. Also in a meeting of barbers, convened by him, attended by some 500, it was agreed to refuse solidly to tonsure widowed women. The husband and wife, together, fought against child marriage, superstition and untouchability.
Home for the orphaned children was also started and the couple adopted a Brahmin child as they were childless. Being given a good education, their adopted child managed to become a medical doctor who often attended free for the sick and needy. Appreciating his work for social upliftment, at the early age of 25, Phule was felicitated by the governor of Bombay.
His other projects were a night school for the laborers. Working for the benefit of the farmers by representing their plight to the government, he managed to get the land lords to reduce the rent for the land they worked upon plus other concessions. During the famine of 1876 -77 the Savitribai Phule and Jotirao phule fed and cared for about 2000 children.
For his extremely liberal modern views as well as fearless work for the upliftment of the downtrodden, in 1888, in Bombay, there held a meeting to felicitate Jotirao Phule and to confer on him a title of Mahatma.
Belonging to Sudra class, Phule opened up a well for everybody including untouchables when they were refused elsewhere. Phule also had the experience of being insulted by Brahmins at the beginning of his life.
To propagate his thoughts, Jotirao founded an organization called Satya Shodak Samaj. Gradually, its branches spread throughout Maharastra.. He said there is only one God who fills the whole universe being in the nature of truth. All human beings are God's children. Persons superiority does not depend on birth but on the stage of his personality development. He further said that to behave truthfully means to behave morally.
The way the Barhmin priests cheated Sudras and Athisudras are innumerable and varied going to the extent of manipulating horoscopes to threaten the gullible Sudras into parting money etc. etc..
When Sudras and Athisudras embraced the Christian faith in order to achieve human status, it resulted in priest Brahmins being thrown out of livelihood compelling them to engage in manual labor which was a job of Sudras and Ahtisudras. Oppression of the farmers were also attributed to the religion. Law was enforced that Brahmins should not give any knowledge to the Shudras in addition, the Brahmin priests enforced hard and fast, the law of not accepting Sudra children in their Sanskrit schools in order to prevent them from getting any indepth knowledge of Hinduism.
That apart, singing of Vedas should not be heard by Sudras.Original law was that even intelligent capable Sudras should not accumulate wealth. In short, Sudras and Athi Sudras were not allowed to stand on their feet reducing them to the state lower than animals.
However the Governor General of Bombay gave the right of vote to Sudras and Athisudras to the dismay of Brahmins.
But the top white rulers steeped luxury so much, that they did not know what was taking place in the country while Brahmins who held other vital posts in all government departments controlled and manipulated the administration cankering into the life of the down trodden..
Willy-nilly underhand operations of the Brahmin government officials by way of taxtation etc.,caused so much sufferings to the Sudra and Athisudra farmers that they did not even get enough food to eat or clothing to cover their nakedness. Often having no enough land to cultivate, they were reduced to virtual starvation, making them trudge to long distant jungles to eat wild fruits to appease the hunger.
Aryan Brahmins came to India originally from Iran who destroyed and killed all the original inhabitants branding them as astiks and rakshashas. Those who surrendered to them were made slaves (Dasas) Aryans made two classes of out of them namely: A) Sudras (Dasa) Athisudras (Anudasas)
Only some centuries ago, Mohammedan government took pity on them and forcibly converted lakhs and lakhs of Sudras into Islam. That apart, Portugese government also converted by force thousands of Sudras and Athisudras to Roman Catholicism, so did other Christian missionaries. Phule thanked them profusely for contributing their emanicipation.
Jyotirao Phule blamed the British government for spending huge amounts of funds from state revenue on the education of the higher classes which resulted in Brahmin monopoly of all higher offices under the British Raj. The dedicated couple were all out to break the Brahminical monopoly in order to equip the down-trodden to struggle for equal rights to lead a life of dignity in their own mother land.
Phule requested the government to treat all alike and give the same knowledge and information to all farmers alike as is given to European farmers as far back in the latter half of 19th century.
Book Summaries
1. Dr. Babasheb Ambedkar's writings and speeches (378 pages) 4
B. Ambedkar's formula for abolition of caste system 1
2. Nehru: Caste Syste, Minorities and Social Justice (1989) - 3
3. In the Shadow of Mahatma (Biography of Azaria) (366 pages) - 12 By Susan Billington Harper
4.Cultivator's Whip Cord, (Collected Works of Mahatma Jotirao Phule) (129 pages) 3
5. Nehru by Judith Brown (345 pages) 6 pages
6. India unbound By Gurucharna Das (364 pages) -12
78.Christian Conversion
9.The Gift of pain