TITLE: Hearts and Other Strangers II/ A Whole Person AUTHOR:Kestabrook E-MAIL: Kestabrook@aol.com DISTRIBUTION: Archive if you'd like. Please let me know where. SPOILERS: "Milagro" and slight mention of "Never Again" RATING: PG-13 CONTENT: MSR; S/A CLASSIFICATION: V SUMMARY: The original "Hearts..." focused on Mulder's interpretation of the events of "Milagro." This sequel immediately follows that and focuses on Scully-- will she allow Mulder to persuade her to let her heart be opened? DISCLAIMER: These characters belong to Chris Carter and the X-Files' gang. If they were mine, I could buy a cruel green dress and more Kraft dinners. Right, BNL? DEDICATION: For LAAdolf, Nicola, Lyra, RavenL4, Laine, Clarissa, and Red Tyger for great friendship, helpful feedback, and super support. Also, for Catbird for the same and for letting me use the borrowed T-shirt!! AUTHOR'S NOTES: To read the original "Hearts..." please go to Xemplary or to http://members.xoom.com/PaperDreams (and click on "Visions"). FEEDBACK: Oh yes, please!! But only if it's positive or helpful. Hearts and Other Strangers II/A Whole Person by Kestabrook Loneliness is a choice. Born of independence and dedication, it becomes a woman's reality, a woman's vulnerability. It isolates her being; it imprisons her heart. It strengthens her yet leads her to believe in a fallacy--a fallacy that happiness can be achieved by one, and that that choice--that loneliness--is a mere glitch in an otherwise fulfilling life. And loneliness had led Dana Scully to this point. She stood in Fox Mulder's bathroom, her shaking fingers absently wringing out a washcloth, her gaze shyly raising to meet itself in the mirror over the sink. And what she saw didn't please her. Make-up streaked her face, and blood, smeared and drying, covered her neck and chest and stained her white blouse. Images of the bodies she'd seen, the victims of Padgett's Stranger, flooded her mind, but the faces of each had now been replaced by her own. And she shuddered. Phillip Padgett was dead; Mulder had said so. And she knew it to be true, or she would have been dead instead. The Stranger conjured up by the young author had also tried to kill her by reaching into her body to extract her heart, but he had disappeared before completing her murder. And she'd fainted, waking to find her partner staring down at her, grief overwhelming his eyes as he thought her dead. Her partner, Fox Mulder, who, in days previous, had warned her, had insisted that somehow Padgett and his character were committing psychic surgery. But she hadn't believed it. Nope. Not her. But tonight the Stranger had proven it to her empirically--just the way she'd want it to be proven. "Oh yes, Dana," she now thought angrily to herself. "Thank God your need for evidence, for tangible proof, proved Mulder's theory to be right again. What would he do without you?" She'd stopped shaking, though her knees could still vie with any jello in a bowl. And she'd willed an end to her tears. This was not the first time in her career that she'd been attacked. And Dana Scully was a proud woman, a strong woman. Not a woman who'd gotten a medical degree and a career as a Special Agent with the FBI by being emotional, by being--a real woman. And when Mulder returned from briefing the D.C. cops in the cellar of his building about the death of Phillip Padgett, he would see the Scully he knew--the Scully who could weather an attack--not the one who'd clutched him to her as if his very presence would save her from death and evil. Her breath caught in her throat as a leftover sob escaped. She'd been close to death before--probably closer than most people had. But the terror of this attacker--one inside of whom bullets wouldn't lodge, wouldn't stop, wouldn't even slow--continued to chill her. After Mulder had left for the cellar, she'd absently packed up the surveillance equipment they had used to keep watch on Phillip Padgett. She'd hoped that being busy would take her mind off the attack, but it hadn't. She'd played over and over in her mind what she could have done differently, what she could have done to thwart the Stranger. And yet--how did one fight an illusion--an illusion that could tear the heart from a person's chest? Scully removed her blouse and noted that magically no blood had touched her black lace bra. That undergarment sickened her at the moment. Padgett's novel had given a detailed, sensual account of its removal and of his hands and mouth exploring her breasts. The thought of him that close to her now made her stomach lurch. She shamefully had to admit that she *had* fantasized about someone seductively removing the garment, but the remover in her dreams hadn't been Phillip Padgett. No, the remover had been someone she knew very well, someone she lov-- someone she respected. Someone with whom she worked. Padgett had told her and Mulder that "Agent Scully is already in love," and fight the idea as she tried, she now wondered if it might be true. When she'd woke and found Mulder staring at her--his fear nearly tangible and his presence so necessary to her--she'd hugged him. She'd so melded into his wonderful embrace that she'd wanted him to hold her forever. Well, one part of her had wanted that. The personal side. But the professional side had taken over as it always did, and she'd released him. There was a case to be closed, after all. And the last thing she needed was to have her partner feeling sorry for her, feeling her too weak to be an agent. As he'd left his apartment, she'd tried to close off her mind to her personal feelings toward him--to close off her heart. She'd done that for six years, but it was becoming more difficult. Mulder had told her she needed to let the stranger out of herself, but she was nearly as afraid of that stranger as she was of Padgett's creation. Feelings got in the way--would get in the way. To allow the woman to take control of the agent would be a mistake. But she loved Fox Mulder. Scully stared open-mouthed into the mirror. Could that be true? She quickly soaped the washcloth and hurriedly rubbed it over the dried blood on her chest, and she rinsed as fast. She examined her skin and found it flawlessly intact. And except for the after-shocks of nearly being killed, her heart was fine, untouched. Unopened--because she'd chosen loneliness. "Scully?" She gasped and turned toward the now open bathroom door. "Mulder!" she panted, trying to cover her half-naked torso with her hands. He'd whispered her name, and she'd been totally unaware of him easing the door open. "You scared me. I didn't know you were back." Despite her resolve to be professional, and her hopes that she'd put the Stranger's attack further back in her mind, she felt tears again sliding down her cheeks. Seeing blood on his sweatshirt--her blood--brought it all back. "I'm sorry, Scully," he told her quietly. "I called to you, but when you didn't answer--I--I didn't know if you were okay." She nodded, biting her lower lip as further emotions threatened to spill. She saw him reach out, and she gratefully allowed him to pull her to his body again, to hold her close, her skin feeling his warmth and the smooth fabric of his sweatshirt. And his hands on the bareness of her lower back and shoulders as she willingly accepted his comfort. Where had her professional side gone? She clutched his shirt over his shoulder blades and sobbed into his chest, unable to stop the undoing of her strength. "Aw, Scully," he whispered into her hair. She felt him kiss the top of her head lightly and slowly, and she tightened her grasp. "I'm sorry, Mulder. I'm such a wimp tonight." She heard him chuckle. "I love wimps." Scully smiled in spite of her tears. "You do?" "Yeah." Again his lips brushed her hair. "I--" Why was it so difficult to respond after he said such a thing? While he held and kissed her? In her fantasies, she'd said lots of things to him--as his hands had wandered over her skin, his lips following. But the man holding her now was her partner, not her fantasy lover. "Padgett's dead. For certain. The Stranger won't be back." She squeezed her eyes closed. "I know." "You're okay, Scully, right?" "I'm just--just a bit unnerved, I guess." She swallowed hard. "I'll get it back together, Mulder." "I know you will." "It was the attack--" "No. Not just the attack, Scully." She leaned back to search his eyes. She could tell he was upset from the evening, but something else lurked behind his expression. She had seen his jealousy since Padgett's slide into their lives. She'd found it both touching and mad- dening. She had to admit that Padgett's attention had flattered her, had made her feel desirable. To find that the author had written of sex with her made her blush even now. To be wanted--even by Padgett--was a thrill rarely known to her. And Mulder's jealousy of that gave her a certain arrogance. But maybe he hadn't felt jealousy. It could have been protectiveness--Mulder, the older brother, still trying to save his sister vicariously by protecting Scully. She knew he always endeavored to keep her safe, and though she cherished that, she felt disheartened now if that was all his attitude of the last few days reflected. "Not just the attack? I don't know what you mean," she finally told him. "Something else is upsetting you." "Are you my psychologist now, Mulder?" She watched as he almost winced at the accusation. He suddenly pulled away from her. "C'mon. Come with me." "Um--" she hesitated, again trying to cover the tops of her breasts. He shook his head and smiled at his own ignorance. "Sorry." Opening a cupboard behind her, he hauled out a grey T-shirt. "This'll work." He shook out the folds and then held the bottom open for her. Scully wiped away more tears and allowed him to help her put on the shirt. And she realized that on any other night than this, she'd have felt sheer delight when his palms grazed her bra as he pulled the shirt's tail down and over her stomach. "You need a coat?" "A coat? In here?" "No," he said, heading from the bathroom. "We're going for a walk." "What? Mulder, I'm in no shape to go out." She was incredulous at his words. Why go out? A man had died. She'd been attacked... "You're in *great* shape--unless--you said you weren't injured physically, right? You--you looked fine to me." Scully struggled for a reason other than "I'm too shaken." That wouldn't sound good for a strong FBI woman. "I've no make-up on." That sounded *much* better; she groaned at herself. "So? Be natural, Scully." He grinned. "I'm not wearing any either." "Well, thank God for that." "Besides, it's dark. Nobody'll see you, and nobody will care." Scully pulled the long T-shirt tail and tied it around her waist. "And to where are we walking?" "Wherever we want. C'mon." He took her hand, leading her toward the dining room. She felt a wave of nausea and paused as she gazed at the floor where she'd been attacked. But her concentration was interrupted when Mulder put a black hooded sweater around her shoulders. She stiffened. "Naciamento...he wore a hooded sweater." Mulder shrugged. "So do millions of other people. And I can almost guarantee you that most of them have never ripped out anyone's heart." She nodded and tried to purge the image of the Stranger's grey hood from her mind. Mulder was ignoring, downplaying her reluctance. "It's a little big on you, but you'll be warmer." "'Big'?" she chided, trying to get ahold of herself and noticing the hooded sweater's tail nearly reached her knees. "Okay, over-sized." She shook her head, unable to stop a smile. She wasn't thrilled about going outside, yet she couldn't stay here with that spot which now radiated terror. Maybe--for once--Mulder was right. Scully slid her arms into the sleeves of, then zipped the hooded sweater. "Too bad it's not purple. I could look like a walking grape." She caught Mulder's grin and saw it relieve a little of his tension, but still something lingered in his eyes. She followed him into the hallway and to the elevator, and then they headed down. She waited for her partner to speak, to tell her what was on his mind, but when he didn't, she asked him, "Mulder, why a walk? You're not tricking me into meeting with the D.C. police, are you?" "No." His face had returned to seriousness. "I told them I'd bring your statement in tomorrow." "*You're* not a suspect are you? You were the last to see Padgett alive." "No, Scully. It's okay." He allowed his fingers to pull at his bottom lip. "Padgett burned most of his novel...and his heart was out--in his hand." She stared at him. "What?" "He made a sacrifice--destroyed himself. For you, I guess. To save you." Scully looked away, regretting the young author's passing, his literal giving of his heart for her. As the elevator's doors opened, she and Mulder exited it and moved down the stairs of the building's entrance. Mulder held the door for her as she asked, "What'd you tell the cops?" "Told them my theory. They didn't buy the psychic surgery idea, but that's no surprise, is it?" She shook her head, soothed by the night's cool air. "Something they'd have to see to believe. I know the feeling." "You'll have to tell them that--they'll believe it if it comes from you." "Yeah, right." Scully moved along the sidewalk and looked up at her partner. "Yeah, no doubt they'd believe 'Mrs. Spooky'." "Huh?" Mulder stopped and turned toward her under the streetlight. His eyes narrowed in concern. "What'd you call yourself?" "'Mrs. Spooky'." She saw the utter surprise on his face which changed to disappointment when she told him, "You know that's what they call me, don't you?" "At the Bureau, you mean?" "Where else?" She searched his face. "My God, you *didn't* know that?" "Scully, I'm sor--" "Don't worry about it, Mulder. It doesn't bother me." "But I'll bet it did." "Once maybe. But no more. I--I've kind of...grown to like it." She inhaled quickly, saw the flicker of surprise in his eyes, and turned away from him, her hand covering her mouth as she moved onto the darkened sidewalk and started walking up the street. She felt totally out of control. The attack had laid bare all her emotions. And even though the skin was intact over it, the attack had laid bare her heart as well. Her words to Mulder revealed that; they would never have escaped her lips otherwise. She hoped he'd not heard her. But she knew he had. She suddenly felt him gently pulling at her arm, and she allowed her hand to come away from her mouth and to fit snugly-- yet stiffly--into his as he walked beside her. Theirs was a slow pace, but they fell into step easily. She began to relish the feel of her hand surrounded by his, and she let it soften and conform to his grip. She felt herself start to calm in the warmth of his hooded sweater, the warmth of his presence. And she realized what a good idea this walk was. Out on the dimly lit sidewalk, hand-in-hand with the man she... It was helpful. She could forget Phillip Padgett; she could almost forget being atta--no, she could not forget that terror. She intertwined her fingers with Mulder's, and she felt his hand squeeze hers. She returned the action. "I'm sorry about tonight, Scully." His voice was quiet, sullen. She glanced over at him. The lights of slowly passing cars illumined lines of worry streaking his features. "I should have been there with you. I should have seen it coming. I could have--" "No, Mulder. Don't do this to yourself." "I shouldn't have left you alone--" "No," she told him firmly, aware that he would beat himself up with guilt over her attack. "No, you had to--you had no other choice. And I had more than enough warning. But I had to be so damned bull- headed--" "It's my fault, Scully. You had a lot of mixed messages. How were you to know--" "I'm an FBI agent, Mulder. That's how." She felt the urge to pull her hand away. She *was* an agent when she was with him, wasn't she? Not someone who should be holding his hand while dressed in his clothes. What *was* she doing? "Yeah, and you're a woman, too. A woman who has to have feelings. You're no ice queen, Scully. A tough, hard-as-nails FBI agent, yes. But there's more to you than that." "No--" "Yes." She felt him stop and turn her toward him. His warm, free hand tilted her chin till her gaze was forced to meet his. And even in the dim light, she could see the tenderness in his eyes, as well as his shyness and dread over what he was about to say. "Scully, last summer I said some things to you. I said you make me a whole person. I meant that. Before you--before you, I was nothing. Just an agent. My work was all I cared about, all I wanted, or so I thought." Scully stared up at him as his voice became husky. "You changed all that. I've learned to-- care again. Because of you. And *for* you." He swallowed hard, his eyes now filling. "I've come so--so close to losing you so many times. I've realized that would be as bad--as losing Samantha was. Scully, probably even worse." She let her jaw drop at his words, her heart twist with his words. Worse than losing Samantha? "I'm a whole person, Scully. Because of you. You--you have to also let yourself be a whole person." She nearly gasped as he pressed his hand over her heart. "Padgett left this here for you to use. He gave you the chance to love that he didn't have. You have to bring this heart out, Scully. You have to open it." He looked away from her, as if finding the courage to say his next words. His eyes shyly returned to hers. His hand remained pressed against her chest. "Let me in, Scully." She looked at their still-joined hands. She bit her lip and then whispered, "But Mulder, you're already there." His hand moved to gently caress her cheek, to rest there and to again raise her face and, thereby, her eyes. She saw relief cross his features, concern quickly replacing it. "Now that you've admitted that to me, you've got to admit it to yourself." Leaving her hand in his, she started to walk again. Even with the lateness of the hour, cars continued to pass them, but she didn't notice. Her heart felt nothing more now than heavy. "I think I've done that, Mulder." "No, you haven't," he replied softly. "If you had, then you'd not be so flattered when somebody like Padgett looks at you." Though she wanted to dispute that logic, she refrained. To argue this point could open doors that needed to stay shut. Sarcastically, she said, "Okay, then tell me, Mulder; how do I *admit* to myself that you're in my heart?" He laughed lightly at her rebelliousness. "Same way *you* do everything else, Scully. Look at the evidence. Prove it to yourself." Her eyes closed. The faces of Padgett and Naciamento floated in her mind. As did her sweet relief of seeing Mulder when she'd woken from the attack. "I don't want--I can't think tonight." "Yes, you can." "No--" "Then let me help you." He'd fallen into step with her again. "Do you trust me?" She wished he'd forget this for now. Maybe forever. What was the sense? She'd told him, hadn't she? "Mulder, you know--" "No, I don't. Not until you say it. Do you trust me?" "Yes, of course. More than I could trust anyone else." After a few steps, he asked, "Do you like...being with me?" "Probably." She sighed heavily, then told him, "Unless you're being a pain in the ass--like you are right now." He chuckled mildly. "I'll take that as a 'yes,' then. I've noticed that you're not running away from this 'pain in the ass'." "Not yet. I'm just trying to be polite." "Well, there's a first." "Don't make me hurt you, Mulder." "Do you want to hurt me, Scully?" She was stunned by his change in tone, his voice suddenly naked. "No," she replied quietly. "Never." //Not again,// she wanted to say. Some of the time she'd spent with other men *had* hurt Mulder, she knew. She'd seen the fleeting glimpses of dejection or disappointment in his gaze when she'd mentioned them or had to refer to them. Just days ago, after the visit to the church which housed a painting of the flaming heart also present on the milagro charm Padgett had given her, she'd seen Mulder's face when telling him she did have a "secret admirer"--Padgett--who'd waited for her there. She'd seen his face when he'd found her and Padgett seated on the young author's bed--when he'd first told her Padgett had written of doing the "naked pretzel" with her. Mulder *had* been hurt, yet he'd been there to hold her, to comfort her. She vowed not to be responsible for hurting him again. Their footsteps against the concrete sidewalk echoed in the night air. She hoped he was finished with his questions. She just wanted to relax. "Do you care for me?" She stopped, tears coming to her eyes again. Why was he forcing this on her tonight? How many more attacks could she take? The first had been physical and had taken its emotional toll. But Mulder was exacting that toll again. She wanted him to leave her alone--to get out of her heart; it had been hurt too much for one night. "Scully?" "I don't want to talk about this now." "Do you care for me--about me?" "Of course I do. I think I've shown that. Let's go back now." "I know you have. Give me examples." "What? Why?" "I want you to admit it to yourself." She turned and started back toward his building, shoving her hands into the pockets of his hooded sweater. "Scully, c'mon. Don't shut yourself off like this." "I need to." "No, you don't." "Yes--" "No!" He caught up to her in a few quick, long strides. His hands on her shoulders stopped her. His eyes pleaded for her to listen to him. "On the last page of his novel, Padgett said--I read it tonight before he burned it--Padgett said you were trying to get my attention and didn't realize it. That's what your being with him in the bedroom was all about. That's what Ed Jerse was all about. You've got my attention now, Scully. You've always had it. Tell me why you wanted it." "How--" "Give me examples. Show me if what Padgett said is theory or fact." She'd had enough. She sighed heavily, her anger and confusion frying behind her eyes. "I won't. It's redundant." Mulder's gaze seemed to burn into her. "You're escaping. Why can't you admit to yourself how you feel?" "I have." "No, Scully. No, you haven't. You do things and then--you're like a computer. You file all your feelings under some little icon, and they only come up if you click on it." She felt her throat constrict. How else could she operate at the FBI? How else could she have gotten where she was in a man's world? Men didn't respect an emotional woman as a colleague. "I have feelings, Mulder." "I know that. Just--just tell me what you feel...for me." She looked him in the eyes, saw his pleading, saw the same fear she'd seen when she'd woken to find him instead of the Stranger. "This is stupid," she managed. He heaved a sigh. "If you can't tell me, I'll do it for you." His voice tried to maintain patience; his gaze wouldn't allow hers to look away. "You've always been there to help me or to save me. That has to mean something, doesn't it? You were there after John Lee Roche--I'll never forget that, Scully. You were the only light for me then. You were there after the fire. The office--*our* office. My whole life--gone with the flames. My whole life--except for you. The only thing I could feel then was you--touching me, letting me know you were there. You got me through that night." He leaned toward her, kept his voice soft. "How about six years of partnership? You've stayed with me through all of it. You've never given up. You've never told me to shove it. You've never--you've never even applied for a transfer. You *stay* with me, Scully. Doesn't that show you something about your heart?" She covered her face with her hands. God, yes, she cared for him. She'd seen him near death and felt so hopeless, dying already inside if he perished. She'd craved, welcomed, cherished his presence when she'd been so sick. And tonight, she'd held him so tightly--he was the only person she'd have wanted near her, the only person she'd have allowed near her. "Mulder," she hoarsely confessed, "I *do* care about you. You know that." "Yes, I do. Do you?" She closed her tear-filled eyes and nodded. "Yes." "Do you love--me--Scully?" She continued to nod as she stepped into his embrace. He gently pulled her head to his shoulder. And he whispered, "I love you, too." She once more enjoyed the feel of his arms around her, of his strength. She breathed in the scent of his clothing, of his body, and she reveled in the sound of his heart as she lay her head against his chest. Another heart that was no longer a stranger to her. She remembered other embraces--after Donnie Pfaster, after Melissa's death. Mulder's presence had always strengthened her. She could depend on him. She could love him. And Phillip Padgett could fade into the background as could her attack-- when she was wrapped in Mulder's arms. She eventually felt him steer her back toward his apartment, his arm around her shoulders, her body tucked snugly and comfortably against his. In the elevator, she snuggled closer to him, abandoning all controls, abandoning the FBI agent and letting the woman come forward. Her own stranger coming forward to have a look at this new idea. And Mulder guided her to number forty- two and inside, quietly. Once there, he turned her toward himself, calmly unzipped the sweater she wore, and carefully slid his hands inside it, wrapping around her T-shirted torso, as his lips slowly descended toward hers. Slowly. Giving her time to refuse if she wanted. But she couldn't. Wouldn't. Padgett had been correct. She was already in love. And she did want her partner's attention. She tilted her mouth upward and met Mulder's lips, finding their caress respectful, tantalizing, needy, and promising. A light touch, but one in which she reveled. She put her arms on his shoulders, her fingers lightly clawing at his sweatshirt as they had earlier that evening. He pulled back slowly, his mouth coming away from hers gradually. "Enough evidence?" She allowed a small smile. "For now." She saw his hand come up to caress her cheek, and she leaned her head against his palm. "You hungry? Need anything?" She met his eyes. "No...thanks, Mulder." "Feel--better?" "Yes, I'm getting there." His fingertips lightly traced her jawline. "It's been quite a night. You need to rest. I'll take the couch, and you can use the waterbed." Scully shook her head. It suddenly occurred to her that they were standing on the spot where Naciamento had attacked her. She made a decision. "I don't want to be...alone." As he gave her a small, knowing smile, she found her hand in his again, and he led her to the couch. She sat and then watched as he turned out all but one light. Nervously, she crossed her arms. Had he misinterpreted her actions? Her words? Did he want more than she could--or would--give him tonight? But no. She knew better--she knew him better. Mulder joined her on the couch, but he sat so that his torso was supported by its back and arm. His features held mixed concern, relief, and--happiness? He gave her a slight, reassuring smile. Scully felt his hand gently pulling her until her head again rested on his chest. As she lay against him, she felt overwhelming exhaustion--and contentment. He gently tugged the hooded sweater to cover and keep her warm, and then his arms settled around her. And her senses rippled as he lightly kissed her forehead. Feeling cozy, as relaxed as she could this night, safe, and protected, she raised her head long enough to taste his kiss--to meet his lips again, to enjoy, to cherish that touch. As she once more lay her head on his chest, and as security and drowsiness conquered her fears, she felt at peace with her feelings for this partner: with the trust, care, and love she had for him. Maybe someday he'd be more than a fantasy lover, but for now, it was enough to have his attention, to have his heart. And to have opened her own. Loneliness is a choice. Born of independence and dedication, it becomes a woman's reality, a woman's captor, unless and until the decision to let someone in is made. Scully realized she could be a complete person. And the glitch of loneliness, like Phillip Padgett, vanished from her fulfilling life. ************************** End "Hearts and Other Strangers II/ A Whole Person"