The Main Page | 2005-01-20 35 exonerated in
Suryanelli case A two-member division bench consisting of Justice K.A. Abdul Gafoor and Justice R. Basanth pronounced the verdict in the infamous Suryanelli sex case in which a 16-year-old girl of Idukki district was sexually exploited by several people in 1996.
The bench said the prosecution had failed miserably to prove the conspiracy of the accused. Regarding the allegation of rape, the court ruled that it could not be said that there was no consent on the girl's part. The first accused S.S. Dharmarajan was sentenced to five years imprisonment and a fine of Rs.25,000 imposed by the court. Dharmarajan was sentenced under Section 366A and 372 of the Indian Penal Code on charges of procuring a minor girl and selling a minor for prostitution. Reacting to the verdict, women activist K. Ajitha said that the verdict was a shocking one and this could have far-reaching social implications. "The verdict is going to become a tool for all those who are involved in the sex mafia. It is really shocking", said Ajitha. The court ordered that the fine would be handed over to the victim and, if not paid, he would have to undergo an extra year of imprisonment. In 1999, three years after the incident took place, the then chief minister E.K. Nayanar had set up the state's first-ever special court to deal with the case. The inquiry had found out that 36 people were involved and brought the culprits to book. On Sep 6, 2000, the special court sentenced the 36 people to rigorous imprisonment for varying terms. Soon after the sentence, the accused were let off on bail by the high court. The accused then filed separate appeals against the special court verdict on which the division bench gave the verdict Thursday, letting all but one go. o¥j¬¨c¿¢:
35 ±dY¢J¨q ¨ls¤¨Y l¢¶¤ ±dY¢Jw¨´Y¢¨j O¤h·¢i¢j¤¼ fk¡vo«L«, Y¶¢¨´¡Ù¤©d¡Jv, L¥W¡©k¡Oc Y¤T¹¢i J¤×¹w ¨Yq¢i¢´¡c¡i¢¶¢¨¿¼® O¥Ù¢´¡¶¢i¡X® Qo®×¢o¤h¡j¡i ¨J.F. Af®a¤wLe¥t, Bt. foÉ® F¼¢ljT¹¤¼ V¢l¢nu fÕ¢¨Ê l¢b¢.
F¼¡v, ¨dxl¡X¢g©´o¢¨k ±db¡c ±dY¢i¤« o¥±Yb¡jc¤h¡i AV§. F. Fo®. bt½j¡Qc® Cɬu m¢È¡c¢ih·¢¨k 372, 366 (F) lJ¤¸¤Jw ±dJ¡j« AÕ¤ltn« l£Y« JU¢cYTl¤« AjkÈ« j¥d d¢ri¤« l¢b¢µ¢¶¤Ù®. ±d¡id¥t·¢i¡J¡· ¨dxJ¤¶¢¨i ©lm¬¡l¦·¢´¡i¢ lm£Jj¢µ¤¨J¡Ù¤©d¡J¤J, ±d¡id¥t·¢i¡J¡· ¨dxJ¤¶¢¨i Hj¢T·¤c¢¼® h¨×¡j¢T©·´® ¨¨k«L¢Jl¦·¢´¡i¢ ¨J¡Ù¤©d¡l¤J F¼£ J¤×J¦Y¬¹w bt½j¡Qu ¨Oi®Y¢¶¤¨Ù¼¡X® V¢l¢nu fÕ® J¨Ù·¢i¢¶¤¾Y®. bt½j¡Qu YTl¤m¢È
H¼¢µc¤gl¢µ¡v (AÕ¤ltn«) hY¢¨i¼¤ ©J¡TY¢
l¬J®Yh¡´¢. d¢r ATi®´¤¼¢¨¿Æ¢v jÙ¤ltn«
JU¢cYTl¤J¥T¢ Ac¤gl¢´X«. d¢r ATµ¡v o«K¬
d£Vc·¢c¢ji¡i ¨dxJ¤¶¢´¤ cvJX«. 2002 Q¥k¡i®
12 c® ©J¡¶i¨· ±d©Y¬J ©J¡TY¢ QV®Q¢ l¢.
O±z©mKjd¢¾ bt½j¡Qc® Q£ldj¬É« YTl¤m¢Èi¡X®
l¢b¢µ¢j¤¼Y®. CY¤l¨j jÙ¤ltnl¤« 92 a¢lol¤«
Qi¢k¢v Jr¢º bt½j¡Qu AÕ¤ltn·¢v ©mn¢´¤¼
J¡k« h¡±Y« Qi¢k¢v Jr¢º¡v hY¢i¡J¤«. ©Jo¢v ±dY¢©Ot´¨¸¶¢j¤¼ CT¤´¢ ¨J¡¼·T¢ d¤Y¤µ¢si¢v j¡Q¤ (32), O¢s´Tl® ¨Y©´·¤hk ¨J¡¶¡T¢´¤©¼v Dn (35), O¢s´Tl® d¤Y¤¸sØ¢v d¢.¨J. Qh¡v (34), d¡k¡ J¤s¢µ¢i¢v ¨Os¢i¡µu (50), O¢s´Tl® lT©´´j DX墴¦n®Xu c¡it (35), ¨J¡r¤lc¡v ¨cT¤«YJ¢T¢i¢v ©Q¡o® (41), O¢¹lc« lk¢idsØ¢v ±m£J¤h¡t (44), J¤q·¤©½v ¨J¡¿¡¶¤h¤s¢ h¡Øs·k j¡©Q±zu c¡it (38), Ahi¼¥t h¡©lk¢v ©Q´f® o®×£eu (50), J¢r©´´j ©lki®´¡T® AQ¢ (34), ¨d¡uJ¤¼« hº¡l¢v ©J¡qc¢ l¶´¡l¤Æv oY£mu (37), h¡s¡T¢ j¡hh«Lk« ©d¶ J¤r¢´Ù·¢v Ak¢i¡t (30), B©l¡k¢ j¡hh«Lk« J¤r¢¨·¡¶¢i¢v h¤p½a® i¥oe® (41), h¡s¡T¢ j¡hh«Lk« DX塸¢¾¢ dT¢º¡©sl¶·® d¤·ud¤ji¢v a¡l¥a® (32), Fj¤©hk¢ d¤Õliv Jd®q¢i¢v Y¤qo£bju c¡it (45), ¨d¡uJ¤¼« dÉ¢j¤©lk¢v h¡Y¬¤ ©Q¡oe® (45), O¢s´Tl® ¨Y´i¢v ±m£J¤h¡t (43), d¤k¢i¼¥t dT¢º¡×¢uJj Jj¤¸¥´¤©¼v oXå¢ ©Q¡tQ® (40), J£r®YT¢i¥t J¡c¡¶¤d¡s C¿¢h¥¶¢v Q¢Q¢ (34), Fk¢´¤q« AÕ¡«¨¨hv O£j«J¤r¢ ©Q¡oe® (41), O¢s´Tl® lT´¤«g¡L« CT·¤dsØ® d¢Xhs¤J¢v o¡f¤ (39), J¤¼·¤c¡T® j¡hh«Lk« hXk¢´¤r¢i¢v ltL£o® (49), l¡r¥t d¤q¢´´lk ¨Y¼©mj¢v ©Q¡tQ® ¨Os¢i¡u (42), Y¢j¤l¿ ©Y¡¶¸¤r©mãj¢ ¨F´j l¢QiJ¤h¡t (49), ¨Y©´·® Jlk ¨J¡¶¡T¢´¤©¼v ©h¡pcu (38), h¡s¡T¢ j¡hh«Lk·® d¤·ud¤ji¢v Anse® (39), Cq¹¤q« J¤r¢´¡¶¤Y¡¨r BÊX¢ (40), j¡hh«Lk« dT¢º¡¨s¨l¶·® d¤·ul£¶¢v n¡Q¢ (34), h¡s¡T¢ Bc¢´¡T® d¤·u©Y¡¸¢v Ac¢v(43), J¤Ti·¥t J¥l¸¾¢ d¤q¢i¡Æ¤©¼v f¡f¤ h¡Y¬¤ (40), J¥l¸¾¢ hXå¡s´i« ©Y¡T¢´Tl¢v ¨J. YƸu (45), J¤sl¢k¹¡T® J¤¼·¤l£¶¢v ©hj¢ (40), J¶¸c l¾¢i¡Æ¤T¢ l¢r¢´¸¡s l£¶¢v c¢¼® hb¤j Q¢¿i¢¨k JÙh¿¥t c¡T¡t ¨Yj¤l¢v Y¡ho¢´¤¼ l¢k¡o¢c¢ (33) F¼¢l¨ji¡X® ¨Yq¢l¤Jq¤¨T Ag¡l·¢v ¨¨p©´¡TY¢ ¨ls¤¨Y l¢¶Y®. ©Jo¢¨k ±dY¢i¡i¢j¤¼
¨sQ¢ (41) A¸£v ptQ¢i¢v ¨¨p©´¡TY¢i¢v l¡a«
cT¼¤¨J¡Ù¢j¢¨´ BY®hpY¬ ¨Oi®Y¢j¤¼¤.
©Jo¢¨k h¨×¡j¤ ±dY¢i¡i F¨¨k×® ©alo¢
C©¸¡r¤« Hq¢l¢k¡X®. |
|||
c¢ih«
l¡X¢g·¢¨us lr¢´®
h¡b¬h¹q¤« ¨d¡Y¤Qcl¤¨h¿« c£jo« ±dJT¢¸¢´¤¨h¼® As¢i¡h¡i¢y¢¶¤« ±dm Y¢Jµ¤« c¢iha¦n鬡h¡±Y« dj¢©m¡b¢µ¤; ¨¨lJ¡j¢JYi¢v c¢¼¤« Y¢Jµ¤« l¢h¤Çh¡i oh£dc« o§£Jj¢µ¤ ~ o¥j¬¨c¿¢©´o¢¨us l¢b¢¨i AY¢c¡v F±YY¨¼ Ag¢cz¢µ¡k¤« hY¢i¡J¢¿. C½¡Y¢j¢ ©Jo¤Jq¤h¡i¢ cT´¤lt´¤¾ Hy h¤¼s¢i¢¸¡X® CY®. o¥j¬¨c¿¢©´o¢¨us ©dj¢v h¤¸·Õ¤©d¨ji¡X® h¡b¬h¹q¤« j¡±né£i´¡y¨h¿¡« AdJ£t·¢¨¸T¤·¢iY®, ©l¶i¡T¢iY®. Alt´® ©h¡Oc« cvJ¢i ¨¨p©´¡TY¢ QV®Q¢h¡¨j F±YY¨¼ Ag¢cz¢µ¡k¤« AYb¢Jh¿. ©Jjq·¢¨c¼¿, ©k¡J·¢c¤ Y¨¼ h¡Y¦Ji¡X® Cª l¢b¢... ©Jjq ¨¨p©´¡TY¢i¢¨k o£c¢it Ag¢g¡nJu ©L¡l¢z® ¨J gjY® B©lml¤« Bczl¤« AT´¡c¡J¡¨Y J·¢´is¢iY® GY¡Ù® ©hv©Ot· h¶¢k¡X®. l¢b¢ l¼ a¢lo« j¡±Y¢ Hy ±dh¤KO¡ck¢¨us c¬¥o® Als¢v A©Àp« ±dY¬È¨¸T¤Ji¡i¢y¼¤. o¥j¬¨c¿¢©´o¢¨k ¨¨p©´¡TY¢ l¢b¢©i¡¨T c¡T® jȨ¸¨¶¼® ©Y¡¼¢´¤« l´£k¢¨us g¡l« JÙ¡v. l´£k¡J¤©Ø¡w ©k¡ ©d¡i¢us¤Ù¡J¤«; i¤Ç¢i¤Ù¡J¤«. Cª ©Jo¢k¤« c¬¥o® Als¢v ±dY¬È¨¸¶ l´£k¢c® G¨s ©d¡i¢us¤Jq¤Ù®! ©J¡TY¢l¢b¢ ©Jw´¡·Y¤¨J¡Ù®, J¡X¡·Y¤¨J¡Ù® o¡b¡jX´¡t´® A©Y´¤s¢µ® o§¡LYh¡i¢ ±dY¢Jj¢´¡u ©d¡k¤« là. d©È, c¬¥o® Als¢¨k l´£k¢¨us S¡i¨·¸×¢ ±dY¢Jj¢´¡u By¨Ti¤« m£¶® ©l©X¡. GY® c¢jÈjJ¤È¢´¤« o§É« c¢ki®´® ±dY¢Jj¢´¡«. l´£k¢¨us S¡i¹¨q¨É¡¨´i¡X® ~ 40a¢lo« ©Jjq·¢k©¹¡qh¢©¹¡ql¤« d¤s·¤« 4000 J¢©k¡h£×©s¡q« ¨d¡Y¤l¡pc¹q¢k¤« hפh¡i¢ o¥j¬¨c¿¢ ¨dxJ¤¶¢ oÕj¢µ¢¶¤Ù®. ¨¨k«L¢Jh¡i¢ Dd©i¡L¢µlt (Cc¢ A¹¨c©i dsº¤J¥T¥!) ¨´¡¸«C¹¨c oÕj¢µ¢¶¤« B ¨dxJ¤¶¢ jȨ¸T¡u ©c¡´¢i©Yi¢¿; B¨jÆ¢k¤« JÍV¢i¢k¡´¢¨´¡Ù¤ ©d¡J¤Ji¡i¢yÆ¢v, g£nX¢¨¸T¤·¢ ¨J¡Ù¤©d¡J¤Ji¡i¢yÆ¢v B ¨dxJ¤¶¢´® l¡pc·¢vc¢¼® Cs¹¢ H¡T¢´¥T¡i¢y©¼¡, l¢q¢µ® J¥l¢´¥T¡i¢y©¼¡ F¼¡X® l´£k¢¨us ©O¡a¬«. l´£v C´¡j¬« ©O¡a¢µY® Qc©·¡T® ©cj¢¶¡X®. F±Y i¤Ç¢i¤Çh¡i ©O¡a¬«. 40a¢lo·¢cJ« 4000 J¢©k¡h£×©s¡q« oÕj¢µ® h¤¸·¢©k¨s©¸¨j o§£Jj¢µ (o§£Jj¢µ¤ F¼ l¡´¡X® l´£v Dd©i¡L¢µY®) B ¨dxJ¤¶¢ jȨ¸T¡u Alojh¤Ù¡i¢y¼¢¶¤« AY® ¨Oií¢¿! AY¢vc¢¼® F·¡l¤¼ c¢Lhc¨hÉ¡X® ~ ¨dxJ¤¶¢ 40 a¢lol¤« o§É« Cné¡c¤ojX« Jr¢i¤Ji¡i¢y¼¤; Q¡jÁ¡t´® Alw lr¹¢iY® o§É« Cné±dJ¡jh¡i¢y¼¤; ¨¨k«L¢JfÜ« cT·¤Y¢c¡i¢ Alw o§©hbi¡ 40a¢lo« 4000 J¢©k¡h£×t H¡T¤Ji¡i¢y¼¤ ~ AY¢v fÜ« cT·¢i d¤ynÁ¡t Fɤ d¢rµ¤? CY¡X® ©k¡©d¡i¢Ê®... dY¢c¡s® lioæ® Y¢Ji¤« h¤Ø¡i¢y¼¤ o«gl¨hÆ¢v ©Jo¢c® Ao¡j« c¢kc¢vd¤Ù¡J¤h¡i¢y¼¤. d©È, 16 Y¢Jº DT¨ci©¿ ¨dxJ¤¶¢ 40a¢lo« 4000J¢©k¡h£×t... d¢¨¼É® l¡X¢g«, d¢¨¼É® fk¡Ë«L«, d¢¨¼É® d£Vc« ~ GY¡c¤« Br®OJw´® h¤Ø¡i¢yÆ¢v Yj©´T¢¿¡i¢y¼¤. djoçj o½Y©·¡¨Ti¨¿Æ¢v g¡j¬~gt·¦ ¨¨k«L¢J©lr®O©d¡k¤« fk¡Ë«L·¢¨us dj¢b¢i¢v ly¨h¼¡X® d¡hjÁ¡t hcoæ¢k¡´¢i¢¶¤¾Y®. Y¨us o½Y©·¡¨Ti¿¡¨Y 40 a¢lo« h¤¸·¢©k¨s©¸t d£V¢¸¢µ® Almi¤« ©j¡L¢i¤h¡´¢ F¼® ¨dxJ¤¶¢ dj¡Y¢¨¸¶¢¶® ~ A©Y´¤s¢µ¡X® c½¤¨T l´£v O¡ck¢v Jis¢c¢¼® dsi¤¼Y® ~ o½Y©·¡¨Ti¡X®, lioæ® 16 Jr¢º¤, fk¡o«Lh¿, ¨ls¤¨Y ±dY¢J¨q AdJ£t·¢¨¸T¤·¤Ji¤« d£V¢¸¢´¤Ji¤h¡i¢y¼¤. Y£t¸¡i¢´r¢º Ì¢Y¢´® Hy ±dmî« Al©mn¢´¤Ji¡X® ~ JZ¡d¤ync¡i l´£v Y¨¼ g«L¬É©jX AY¤it·¤Ji¤Ù¡i¢ ~ ©J¡TY¢ l¢¨¶Æ¢k¤« Al¨j¸×¢ Qc« Fɤ JyY¤«, FÉ® ±dY¢P¡ii¡i¢j¢´¤« Alt´®? ltn¹q¡i¢ h©c¡d£Vc« Ac¤gl¢´¤¼lt, AdJ£t·¢´¢ji¡ilt, Hyd¡T® cné¹w o«gl¢µlt, ±d©Y¬J ©J¡TY¢ m¢È¢µY¢c¡v Qi¢k¢v Jr¢©iÙ¢ l¼lt ~ Alt´® ot´¡y« F¿¡«©Ot¼¤¨J¡Ù® cné« lJ¨lµ¤¨J¡T¤©´ÙY©¿? C±Yi¤« dsºY¢v ©J¡TY¢i¤h¡i¢ fܨ¸¶® H¼¤h¢¿. C´¡j¬·¢v c¢ih« h¡±Yh¡X® ©J¡TY¢ ©c¡©´ÙY®. AY¢k¸¤s« ©d¡JyY®. A¹¨c¨iÆ¢v l¬g¢O¡j·¢c®, ©lm¬¡l¦·¢´® Hy ©Jo® o§©hbi¡ O¡tQ® ¨Oà¡u lJ¤¸¢©¿? |