| Matt | ||
| QB | Derek Anderson | CLE |
| WR | Larry Fitzgerald | ARI |
| WR | Braylon Edwards | CLE |
| WR | Santonio Holmes | PIT |
| WR | Greg Jennings | GB |
| WR | Andre Johnson | HOU |
| RB | Shaun Alexander | SEA |
| RB | Jamal Lewis | CLE |
| RB | LenDale White | TEN |
| RB | Ronnie Brown | MIA |
| RB | Jerious Norwood | ATL |
| RB | DeAngelo Williams | CAR |
| RB | Deuce McAllister | NO |
| TE | Vernon Davis | SF |
| K | Stephen Gostkowski | NE |
| DEF | TEN | TEN |