| Joe | ||
| QB | Jay Cutler | DEN |
| QB | Vince Young | TEN |
| WR | Randy Moss | NE |
| WR | Reggie Williams | JAX |
| WR | Plaxico Burress | NYG |
| WR | Derrick Mason | BAL |
| WR | Anquan Boldin | ARI |
| WR | Ike Hilliard | TB |
| RB | Steven Jackson | STL |
| RB | Fred Taylor | JAX |
| RB | Brandon Jacobs | NYG |
| TE | Todd Heap | BAL |
| TE | Owen Daniels | HOU |
| K | Rob Bironas | TEN |
| DEF | JAX | JAX |
| DEF | SD | SD |