| Eddie | ||
| C | K. Johjima | SEA |
| 1B/OF | C. Duncan | STL |
| 2B | R. Durham | SF |
| 2B | R. Cano | NYY |
| 3B | A. Rodriguez | NYY |
| SS | D. Jeter | NYY |
| OF/2B | A. Soriano | WAS |
| OF | N. Markakis | BAL |
| OF | J. Rivera | LAA |
| OF | D.DeJesus | KC |
| DH | T. Hafner | CLE |
| P | C. Hamels | PHI |
| P | E. Loaiza | OAK |
| P | C. Cordero | WAS |
| P | H. Street | OAK |
| P | D. Haren | OAK |
| P | Jer. Weaver | LAA |
| P | J. Bonderman | DET |
| P | F. Hernandez | SEA |
| P | M. Mussina | NYY |
| P | C. Billingsley | LAD |